Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel that I'm being treated unfairly at work?

166 replies

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 08:40

I'll try to keep a long story short and just the facts - trying to be as objective as possible.

Recently returned to work from 10 months maternity leave - been back 6 weeks now. I have struggled with my mental health whilst on maternity leave quite significantly - I spent some time admitted to a mother and baby unit when my baby was born, and have struggled on and off with anxiety and low mood throughout my maternity leave. I have been seen regularly for therapy by a perinatal mental health team, who are fabulous and have helped me lots.

Part of my struggles relate to separation from my baby, which sends my anxiety into overdrive. Hence the return to work has been extremely hard indeed, to put it mildly. But I've put a brave face on and tried to just get on with it thus far.

I submitted a request for flexible working / reduced hours to my manager. I wanted to go from FT (37 hours a week) to PT (33 hours a week). So in effect I'm asking for a reduction of just 4 hours per week. It's been declined. On the basis that it cannot be justified in the current for climate of severe staff shortages and the service being at crisis point as a result of Covid (I am in a large public sector organisation).

However, I know for a fact that some other colleagues work flexibly and have reduced hours, for their own reasons. So in effect I am being treated differently because of the work climate at the moment.

I honestly feel as though I will end up on long term sick if I have to continue to work FT hours. I am asking for a small bit of flexibility to enable me to keep working and to meet my health needs.

Am I being unreasonable? Any advice on how to proceed with this? I'm really lost. Thanks.

OP posts:
careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 10:13

Hence the proposed reduction to 33 hours - it's the most hours I can fit into 4 days, allowing for childcare arrangements.

OP posts:
SD1978 · 10/02/2022 10:13

As well as 4 hours less though, you're also requesting one day less- it may be the company doesn't currently have capacity for facilitating you to have a 4 day work week, when the business requires a 5 day work week? That's not discrimination, and if they can't afford to run on a 4 day week, then they aren't obliged to supply that

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 10:12

@RunningFromInsanity

So you don’t really want to reduce hours for your MH, it’s actually because of childcare arrangements?

No. I want to reduce my hours for MH reasons to allow me a full day off per week. Ideally this would be FT hrs over 4 days (this way I'd also not lose any money). However, I can't work FT hours over 4 days because my childcare provider doesn't work past 5.30pm, and it's 30 min drive to her house from work, so there's no way I can leave work later than 5pm on those days.

OP posts:
konasana · 10/02/2022 10:09

How about a normal compressed hours and arrange for your DH to collect your little one from childcare?

PAFMO · 10/02/2022 10:06

So, they've already been flexible in allowing you to compress those hours into 4 days not 5.
Leaving aside the fact that they've done what you first requested and now you're asking for something else tailored to your wishes, for every solution suggested on the thread, you've found another reason why you can't, or won't.

You keep saying you are ill. As others have said-then you get signed off sick. You don't go to work and expect work to revolve around your needs. Harsh but true.

You're in a job which clearly already affords a great deal of flexibility. You've asked and been given what you wanted. But now you want something else.

CorrBlimeyGG · 10/02/2022 10:06

You need to demonstrate that the reduction in hours does not substantially impact the business. How can you do this?

I'd expect OH would recommend a reduction in hours while you recover, but it's unlikely to be what you suggest. More likely they'll suggest half days, or even less than that, slowly building up to full days or remaining on a 0.5 contract.

RunningFromInsanity · 10/02/2022 10:03

So you don’t really want to reduce hours for your MH, it’s actually because of childcare arrangements?

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 10:01

@StepAwayFromGoogling

Will four hours a week really make the difference to your mental health, OP? I wonder whether looking for a new job with fewer hours might be better?

Yes because, with the remaining 33 hours compressed over 4 days, it allows me a full day off a week. Which would be very helpful in terms of my recovery from postnatal illness.

OP posts:
Iamkmackered1979 · 10/02/2022 10:00

Do you think you perhaps need more time prior to going back to work or could you speak to occupational health? And do something similar to phased return to ease you back into working full time, it sounds like you’ve had a terrible time and for your own health yOu need to take your return slowly. I have a friend who was in a similar situation (nhs and work were amazingly supportive) but I think you need to get occ health and hr involved to support you. I hope you continue to make a good recovery but I would put yourself first here. This is an illness and you need to get better.

FortVictoria · 10/02/2022 10:00

@girlmom21

If other people have had requests approved prior to yours being submitted it stands to reason that there's left flexibility left for everyone else now.

You're not being mistreated IMO - it's just bad timing.

I feel for you, OP, and can well understand your disappointment and frustration. But Girlmom21 is correct - as more staff have been granted flexible working, there is less flexibility for the remaining staff. You’re not being treated unfairly - it’s bad timing for you, but this is an operational decision, not a personal one. I hope you manage to find a solution.
StepAwayFromGoogling · 10/02/2022 09:58

Will four hours a week really make the difference to your mental health, OP? I wonder whether looking for a new job with fewer hours might be better?

DoubleChinWoes2 · 10/02/2022 09:55

Oh course it's legal! You can dismiss as long as it's reasonable and fair. If the business genuinely cannot support your request and you're too ill to fulfil your contract they could dismiss you. They'd need to follow a fair process and look at all other options first.

If they suggest an alternative to you and you don't accept and they genuinely cannot agree to your request, and you cannot work your contracted hours, that invalidates your contract and they don't need to keep you employed.

formalineadeline · 10/02/2022 09:54

@careerchangemaybe

No, but they would consider whether they can continue to employ her and may dismiss her on the grounds of ill-health if she can't fulfil the contract.

Is this legal?!

Yes.
Gingerbreadman1972 · 10/02/2022 09:54

@RaspberryTed what @DoubleChinWoes2 has said is absolutely right. Any medical advice is recommendations, it is ultimately the business decision as to whether accomodate it or not. If OP is unable to fulfill her contract and the business cannot support the recommendations , then OP has the option to go sick.

Granted, refusing reduced hours would be more difficult to justify than someone bringing in a med cert saying they couldn't do particular parts of their role, but it is the business decision nonetheless.

Whether it's a risky decision is completely different. If they did do that, OP could put in a claim for failure to make reasonable adjustments, and if she was able to successfully show she is covered under the EA, and they could reasonably support the reduction of hours, she would win. But ultimately the business get to decide whether they think its reasonable to accommodate or not.

ancientgran · 10/02/2022 09:53

Would they consider you doing the 4 hrs work from home? Not ideal but you could be at home, maybe doing a Saturday morning if DH can look after baby or an hour at night when baby in bed.

I know it isn't what you want exactly but might it help you and make it doable for them.

Lilylovetulips · 10/02/2022 09:53

I was in the same situation 3 years ago when I returned to work after mat leave. I also had severe PND and wanted to work compressed hours ie 5 days over 4. My request was refused even though there was lots of people already with the same arrangement which had been in place for some time without any mechanism for review. So these people had been doing compressed hours for 4/5 years which then seemed unfair when I was told it didn't meet business needs, yet it was ok for them to continue when we were doing the same job??

In the end i raised a grievance which went to senior management and I also got my union rep involved. The manager who reviewed my case had a different opinion and didn't feel it would impact on business need so the decision was ultimately overturned and they allowed the compressed hours.

It didn't work out for me in the end as working compressed hours was too stressful but I'm glad I challenged it and had the opportunity to try.

Porcupineintherough · 10/02/2022 09:53

So if you do 4 hours less how does the business replace that time? They can hardly advertise for a 4 hour a week replacement. I can see how what you are asking for helps you but not how they can make it workable.

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:51

No, but they would consider whether they can continue to employ her and may dismiss her on the grounds of ill-health if she can't fulfil the contract.

Is this legal?!

OP posts:
AintNoPartyLikeANumber10Party · 10/02/2022 09:51

[quote careerchangemaybe]@AintNoPartyLikeANumber10Party

Thank you.

Does it make a difference if my mental health decline actually began in pregnancy and I was referred to the perinatal team for support more than 12 months ago? [/quote]
Yes it does.
OH assessment is the best place to start.

DoubleChinWoes2 · 10/02/2022 09:49

[quote RaspberryTed]@DoubleChinWoes2 - I’m confused by this. If OP is currently unable to work full time because of a health condition and there is medical evidence to support this, the company doesn’t get to decide if they “accept it” or not.

This is a separate issue to the working flexibly request, as has been pointed out.[/quote]
No, but they would consider whether they can continue to employ her and may dismiss her on the grounds of ill-health if she can't fulfil the contract. There is no obligation to keep a contract in place if the employee can't fulfil their responsibilities within in

Arbeity · 10/02/2022 09:47

Sorry, see that you have just answered that!

formalineadeline · 10/02/2022 09:47

I would also say, when I became disabled and had to look at changing my working pattern I thought I knew what would work best for me. Except I really struggled and started to become more unwell.

When I met with OH they identified a pattern that would never have occurred to me but that turned out to be transformative - and that my employer could agree to. OH brought their wealth of knowledge and experience to bear.

I get why you're a bit wedded to your current proposal, but it might not be the right solution and simply digging your heels in won't change the obstacles.

Being eligible in law for reasonable adjustments doesn't mean we get whatever we would ideally need or wish, only what is reasonable for the employer. But absolutely do get OH input. It can be very valuable.

Dreambigger · 10/02/2022 09:47

I wonder if you work for the NHS ? This sounds so familiar. They have such outdated views on flexible working (in some departments everyone is doing their own thing and as the policies are so vague...depending on business need /discretion of the manager ...there is no consistency) I would get advice from ACAS and the equality commission.failing that you go part time and they can advertise for the other half of job. They can't argue with this. (I know you can't afford it but with less childcare/travel costs it might not be as unaffordable as you think ) .. just look for another role. Sorry its like this .... take care of yourself Flowers

Arbeity · 10/02/2022 09:47

If your boss is happy with you compressing your hours into 4 days, would you be OK with this if childcare was possible?

Has your DH/DP asked for flexible working to enable him to do pick up or drop offs four days a week, thus allowing you to compress your hours? Or can he drop hours by the 4 per week to allow this?

You would still keep one full time wage and get a full day off a week, and your DH would be able to take some of the slack childcare-wise. Thus is not your problem to solve alone, it needs to be both of you coming up with a solution

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:47

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Where is your husband/partner for pick ups?

He works long shifts and there is no space for flexibility with that due to the nature of his work. But he is asking for a fixed day off work every week to look after our baby, enabling me to work a longer day on that day.

OP posts: