Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel that I'm being treated unfairly at work?

166 replies

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 08:40

I'll try to keep a long story short and just the facts - trying to be as objective as possible.

Recently returned to work from 10 months maternity leave - been back 6 weeks now. I have struggled with my mental health whilst on maternity leave quite significantly - I spent some time admitted to a mother and baby unit when my baby was born, and have struggled on and off with anxiety and low mood throughout my maternity leave. I have been seen regularly for therapy by a perinatal mental health team, who are fabulous and have helped me lots.

Part of my struggles relate to separation from my baby, which sends my anxiety into overdrive. Hence the return to work has been extremely hard indeed, to put it mildly. But I've put a brave face on and tried to just get on with it thus far.

I submitted a request for flexible working / reduced hours to my manager. I wanted to go from FT (37 hours a week) to PT (33 hours a week). So in effect I'm asking for a reduction of just 4 hours per week. It's been declined. On the basis that it cannot be justified in the current for climate of severe staff shortages and the service being at crisis point as a result of Covid (I am in a large public sector organisation).

However, I know for a fact that some other colleagues work flexibly and have reduced hours, for their own reasons. So in effect I am being treated differently because of the work climate at the moment.

I honestly feel as though I will end up on long term sick if I have to continue to work FT hours. I am asking for a small bit of flexibility to enable me to keep working and to meet my health needs.

Am I being unreasonable? Any advice on how to proceed with this? I'm really lost. Thanks.

OP posts:
Phineyj · 10/02/2022 13:23

Which was annoying as I actually needed 7 till 4 but had to pay till 6...

Phineyj · 10/02/2022 13:22

I think you should look for a nursery nearer work (I'm sure you have though) as that would make the hours possible and mean the baby was nearer which might help psychologically? I had to use a nursery near work for several years in order to get to my teaching job on time. I've never heard of childcare closing at 5.30 either. It's all 6pm round here or sometimes later.

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 13:16

There’s no point trying to go down the occ health / fit note / equality act / disability / reasonable adjustment route as you don’t have a leg to stand on.

Interesting - my Occ health dept who I've just spoken to couldn't disagree with you more.

OP posts:
MRS54321 · 10/02/2022 13:16

Of this will be me,too OP fully expecting my request for less /different hours to be denied as I work nights
But the same shift pattern in the day, have several mums accommodated and positions found for them.

StormTreader · 10/02/2022 13:07

If some of your job can be done remotely then that sounds like a possible way out - once you don't have to fit in commuting times then you might have a bit more flex in terms of "take half an hour to get child but then add the half an hour back on the end of the day since you're now home anyway".

TulaOfDarkWater · 10/02/2022 12:51

There’s no point trying to go down the occ health / fit note / equality act / disability / reasonable adjustment route as you don’t have a leg to stand on.

I've asked to reduce and compress my hours for MH reasons, as having a fully day off per week would help massively with my recovery (this view is supported by MH professionals working with me since my baby's birth).

My manager does not have an issue with me working FT hours over 4 days - so the compression is not an issue. The issue is the reduction, ie losing 4 hrs of my time.

Right so they are willing to accommodate you working 4 days a week instead of 5 which is what you need to aid your mental health recovery i.e. they are giving you exactly what you asked for and require as per the MH health professionals working with you on recovery.

Ideally this would be FT hrs over 4 days (this way I'd also not lose any money). However, I can't work FT hours over 4 days because my childcare provider doesn't work past 5.30pm, and it's 30 min drive to her house from work, so there's no way I can leave work later than 5pm on those days.

So the reduction in hours isn’t for MH health reasons but purely childcare.

They declined your flexible working request due to legitimate business reasons - which you agree exists - but then offered you an alternative of the same hours compressed over 4 days which gives you the day off you need for your mental health recovery.

The fact they offered you an alternative and tried to compromise / meet you half way shows they are trying to be fair and accommodating. Childcare isn’t their issues and isn’t solely yours either considering you have a partner who should be sharing the load and finding solutions.

I find it interesting that you chose not to mention their alternative proposal at the start and instead framed it as if they had turned you down flat and then moaned about everyone else getting their requests accepted; for all you know they may have accepted alternative proposals too.

It’s also interesting that you’ve framed this as a mental health issue / need when it’s not (as you’re being offered what you need to recover) and it’s actually a childcare issue when you get right down to it.

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 12:50

@JuicySatsuma85

I highly recommend reaching out to Pregnant Then Screwed. They can offer free legal advice for exactly this situation.
Thanks - I've heard of them before.
OP posts:
JuicySatsuma85 · 10/02/2022 12:46

I highly recommend reaching out to Pregnant Then Screwed. They can offer free legal advice for exactly this situation.

Doorhandleghost · 10/02/2022 12:39

I think going to OH and potentially having your request supported as a reasonable adjustment by them/your medical professionals is your best bet here. Although, I’ve dealt with a lot of similar requests recently and OH almost always say good to consider but up to the business to decide.

Re the “other people have it” thing - I inherited a team recently where lots of PT working arrangements has been given out to suit the individuals without an eye on the business and it’s an absolute bloody nightmare to run the service.

theemmadilemma · 10/02/2022 12:39

@MajorCarolDanvers has given you sound advice on how to proceed.

Sadly while it feels unfair, I can completely understand the business side of this. If things have shifted and due to other already approved flexible working resource is such that they cannot afford to lose that half day then they have to reject the request. If that means losing a good member of staff sometimes while a great shame, that would just be what has to happen and the pain of retraining someone to cover the full resource requirement would have to happen. It's not necessarily easy to the cover that shortfall. In terms of someone wanting to work that short period of time, and budget for that resource (you haven't freed up a full head count, just a tiny portion) it becomes a much bigger pain than just replacing you.

girlmom21 · 10/02/2022 12:29

@DoubleChinWoes2 no I'm not she was on a disciplinary for sickness-related absence which would've been avoided if they'd followed OH's recommendations

DoubleChinWoes2 · 10/02/2022 12:27

[quote girlmom21]@careerchangemaybe definitely change one. I know someone who was on a stage 3 disciplinary but because OH had recommended changes the employer had rejected the union rep got them to end all disciplinary proceedings and do what the professionals had suggested [/quote]
I think you are using disciplinary in the wrong context here

UseOfWeapons · 10/02/2022 12:26

Hi OP, you’re getting some good advice here, but all I have to add is that it’s all very well joining a union, but as the situation you describe is ongoing and will predate your membership, they may not be able to help you. It may be union-specific, but this happened to me…I joined a union to help with support and guidance for a work issue, but they were unable to give advice on a ‘now’ issue. Worth checking before you join.

Pinkdelight3 · 10/02/2022 12:22

- My manager does not have an issue with me working FT hours over 4 days - so the compression is not an issue. The issue is the reduction, ie losing 4 hrs of my time.

Then the real hurdle is your childcare provider's hours. Is there absolutely nowhere closer to work that does longer hours? 5.30pm is an unusual cut-off for childcare and not conducive to most people's hours.

I don't think it's especially helpful in this case getting stuck on the fact that others were allowed flexible working in a different work climate. Surely the work climate having changed is a fundamental difference that dictates they can't be flexible any more. Feels like a dead end 'not fair' argument so better to see the bigger picture and pursue some of the more constructive possibilities on the thread. Hope you find a solution - and feel much better in yourself - one way or another.

ilovesushi · 10/02/2022 12:22

How stressful for you! I remember being pushed into going back to work too early after my son was born (5 months) and I really really struggled and was very unhappy. I think I lasted a few months then quit. I ended up having a few years being a full time mum and doing a little freelancing then went back to full time work when the kids were older. I would look around elsewhere and take some time out if you can afford to.

7eleven · 10/02/2022 12:19

Fingers crossed you can do those extra 4 hours at home. You’ll get your day at home and won’t lose any moneySmile

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 12:17

@SeaToSki

Could you offer to work the key 4 hours remotely over the weekend, say 2 on Sat and 2 on Sun?

Then look for another job that fits your needs better.

Good luck, keep battling on, it is worth it.

Yes I'm seriously considering this. Only issue will be on my OH's working weekends - he has to work every other weekend. I'd have no childcare on those weekends and would have to rely on my baby napping to get some work done! But it's not impossible, just needs a bit of planning and problem solving.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 10/02/2022 12:16

@careerchangemaybe definitely change one. I know someone who was on a stage 3 disciplinary but because OH had recommended changes the employer had rejected the union rep got them to end all disciplinary proceedings and do what the professionals had suggested

Kudupoo · 10/02/2022 12:08

I think you should speak to Occupational Health. You have legitimate health needs that working full time could exacerbate. They may be able to advise and then recommend less hours for you. Good luck.

SeaToSki · 10/02/2022 12:05

Could you offer to work the key 4 hours remotely over the weekend, say 2 on Sat and 2 on Sun?

Then look for another job that fits your needs better.

Good luck, keep battling on, it is worth it.

NavigatingAdolescence · 10/02/2022 12:04

@careerchangemaybe

No, but they would consider whether they can continue to employ her and may dismiss her on the grounds of ill-health if she can't fulfil the contract.

Is this legal?!

HR Director here.

It absolutely is, provided the right process is followed.

afrikat · 10/02/2022 12:03

Hi OP, given the nature of your illness and the length of time you have been ill, could this be classed as a disability? If so then the request could fall under reasonable adjustments rather than flexible working, which may be easier to implement especially if you are in a large organisation- the 'reasonable' provision is company wide, not just within your team. If you haven't already had an occ health review this would be the first step

Hoowhoowho · 10/02/2022 12:01

Could you go via occupational health? In general a request for reductions in working hours for health reasons is taken more seriously if made by occupational health.

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 11:53

@girlmom21

a fully day off per week would help massively with my recovery (this view is supported by MH professionals working with me since my baby's birth).

Did you provide evidence of this when you submitted your request? Are you in a union?

I didn't provide evidence but I referenced this in my application. I am going to approach my MH team for this evidence though. Incidentally my manager is fully aware that I am under the care of a MH team currently.

No I'm not in a union. I need to join one I think.

OP posts:
Zilla1 · 10/02/2022 11:47

HNRTT but perhaps an attitude of 'it's not fair because Joe Bloggs works this pattern' might not be helpful given that has been agreed and they are presumably looking at the balance of staffing and demand based on current work patterns. The alternatives would be not to agree any flexible working they employer could cope with in case someone else wants it in future or to cancel someone's flexible working on which they've based their domestic arrangements because someone else wants the same. Neither seem fairer or better to me, nor legally sound in the UK.

I would have a discussion whether remote working might work or an in confidence chat if you haven't already and if you are comfortable setting out the medical reasons why you want this and why they might want to look at making 'more than reasonable adjustments' in the circumstances.

Good luck.