Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if it would be a good idea to sell house and rent instead

138 replies

Telematics1234 · 10/02/2022 08:05

I have got this idea we could sell the house and put proceeds of house sale in the stock market.

We are in our late 50s and have paid off our mortgage. We are both still working. The idea of selling up and investing the capital in the stock market is appealing.

We are both still working, so have wages coming in to cover everyday expenses and rent.

I like the idea of the flexibility of renting. ie we could move house much more easily.

It seems to me that the stock market probably out performs the housing market for the most part.

Has anyone done this?

OP posts:
Everydaydayisaschoolday · 10/02/2022 08:58

It's a terrible idea unless you like risk and uncertainty. A good friend of mine had a similar notion about 25 years ago. They sold up, rented and invested the money. After 14 years in a beautiful rented property where they were very happy they were given 4 months notice to quit as the landlord was selling the house. By that time a series of bad choices and bad luck meant they had very little of their original investments left. chronic ill health meant they were living on benefits so they found it hard to rent a new place. They ended up sofa surfing in their mid fifties.

They are retired now on a very low income. They currently rent a house at below market rates from one of their children who works overseas but even that isn't 100% secure because one day that child will either return to the U.K. and want to live there themselves or will want to sell it to buy overseas.

My current house is part of my pension plan. At some point in the future I will downsize and use the sale proceeds to supplement my existing pensions. There is no way I would risk that for risky investments in the stock market.

AngelinaFibres · 10/02/2022 08:55

My husband and I are retired. He inherited a lot of money from his late father. We didn't need that money to fund our life so SOME of it is in investments.He is very good at it but....he spends hours reading relevant articles in financial magazines, he listens to podcast after podcast, he tracks the market daily. He takes part in at least one webinar a week from the investment platform he uses.That , and golf, are his thing.He spends hours on it. He has spread the investments around different world markets so lessen the risk. He has been very successful but we have benefited from the bear market of the last few years. That time is ending. We are well off and own a large house outright. If every investment went pear shaped overnight it would not affect our ability to live a lovely life. You would be absolutely mad to sell your house and risk that money. Low risk investments may save your capitol but won't make you any money. Moderate risk are not doing as well as they were and high risk is exactly that. You could lose the lot just as you get to retirement age and you have no house anymore.

Imyourvenus · 10/02/2022 08:55

No way

IamnotSethRogan · 10/02/2022 08:55

This sounds like a terrible idea in my opinion.

If you really want to invest can you not tale out a small remortgage or something?

danni0509 · 10/02/2022 08:55

Oh please don’t.

I rent and honestly this post is stressing me out!!!

dreamersdown · 10/02/2022 08:54

@TinySaltLick

It isn't quite a crazy as people are suggesting here, it's an investment decision like any other.

However, you would need your investments to effectively outperform housing, plus enough profit to cover the additional rent cost, stamp duty, fees on withdrawing - to even break even, which becomes less likely. Also the stock market goes up and down - you need to consider what happens if your health deteriorates unexpectantly and you can't withdraw without major losses if the market is down - eg you can't wait 5 years for it to return to value (whilst your house would quite robustly maintain its value)

To be honest this is something which you might want to do earlier in life when you hsvr thr opportunity to rebuild your wealth if it goes wrong rather than die destitute

Investments are exciting until the market starts going down, then they are a continuous source of anxiety unless you have money to burn

It isn’t an investment decision like any other (stocks or bonds? Passive or active? Etc).

It’s a lifestyle decision, and one which given the challenging circumstances renters face has the potential to make OP’s lifestyle significantly more precarious.

Think of it like this, OP, when you’re managing your risks: you’re 87, you’re still in rented as the market crashed and you weren’t able to catch up with house prices, and your landlord tells you they’re selling the house so you have to start applying around again. Nightmare.

PenStation · 10/02/2022 08:52

Talk to a financial advisor who can give you proper advice. Randoms on the internet won’t give you a facts based assessment of the potential risks or rewards.

DefaultParent · 10/02/2022 08:45

For reference, I've just had a look at rentals available in my area on rightmove. I pay £745 per month on a property I moved into last year. To rent something similar now I would need to pay £1000 per month.

DefaultParent · 10/02/2022 08:38

It's not easy to move as a renter, you will be up against 10 to 20 other people on every house you like. I ended up renting 15 miles from where I wanted to live, and that house took 6 months to find, with £60,000 in the bank. Not to mention renting is so bloody expensive at the minute. And don't forget to factor in moving costs, deposits on each rental ect. I'm so looking forward to owning my own home again in the next couple of months and not having the worry I could be given 2 months notice on my property.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 10/02/2022 08:37

We are in our late 50s and have paid off our mortgage

Why not redirect the old mortgage monthly amount into stocks and shares? And keep the safety net of your home?

Robinfeed · 10/02/2022 08:36

This is just nuts!

Smidgy · 10/02/2022 08:34

My aunt and uncle told my mum to do this and tried to convince her it was a great idea. We all thought it sounded mad- she was mortgage free and about to retire on a good pension. Why would she want to take a gamble on her future financial security?

Anyway, she ignored their advice (these were people with a long history of disastrous financial decisions).

Don't do it, OP.

sunshinesupermum · 10/02/2022 08:34

Crazy idea.

elbea · 10/02/2022 08:31

That would be madness - invest the potential rent payments instead

ThinWomansBrain · 10/02/2022 08:30

as others have mentioned - stockmarkets crash as well as rise (I know housing markets fluctuate, but not to the same extent), rent out of a pension could be painful...
and have you not seen the threads on here where people have to move on at short notice because the landlord has decided to sell? that may be a bit more flexible than you'd like.

TinySaltLick · 10/02/2022 08:30

It isn't quite a crazy as people are suggesting here, it's an investment decision like any other.

However, you would need your investments to effectively outperform housing, plus enough profit to cover the additional rent cost, stamp duty, fees on withdrawing - to even break even, which becomes less likely. Also the stock market goes up and down - you need to consider what happens if your health deteriorates unexpectantly and you can't withdraw without major losses if the market is down - eg you can't wait 5 years for it to return to value (whilst your house would quite robustly maintain its value)

To be honest this is something which you might want to do earlier in life when you hsvr thr opportunity to rebuild your wealth if it goes wrong rather than die destitute

Investments are exciting until the market starts going down, then they are a continuous source of anxiety unless you have money to burn

Summersdreaming · 10/02/2022 08:27

Madness. Moving every 6-12 months gets old very very fast. I moved 4 times in 5 years before finally getting into a house that wasn't full of hidden nasties, damp painted over for viewings, dodgy electrics etc. Then my landlady sold the house as soon as the covid boom started.

Downsize if you must and put the difference in stocks.

Arbacadarba · 10/02/2022 08:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Clymene · 10/02/2022 08:23

@LlamaLucy

Yes I agree - gone are the days where a house is a guaranteed investment. Two bedroom houses in the Midlands selling for £450k… The bubble will burst again very soon! Sell up whilst prices are high, and enjoy your investments in stocks.
Never become a financial adviser.

OP this is an insane idea

scissorsorknife · 10/02/2022 08:20

In a few years when you have retired most landlords wont even consider you as you wont have a high enough income. They wont accept possible income from shares. Plus you could have to move on at any time whenever landlord gives you notice. A totally insane idea especially for retirement.

LlamaLucy · 10/02/2022 08:20

Yes I agree - gone are the days where a house is a guaranteed investment. Two bedroom houses in the Midlands selling for £450k… The bubble will burst again very soon! Sell up whilst prices are high, and enjoy your investments in stocks.

AnyFucker · 10/02/2022 08:18

Are you quite well ?

RidingMyBike · 10/02/2022 08:15

It's not as easy as that. We're currently renting after selling our house (trying to buy in new area) and renting is far from flexible. There's very limited availability of certain types of housing (if you want a flat you'll probably be fine!), landlords are asking for minimum tenancies of 12 months without a break clause so not much flexibility there, although it will improve after a year! It's very restrictive - we can't put up pictures, or even stick blu-tack up! And it's costing far far more than our mortgage did. You have to go thru very intrusive affordability checks to check you can afford the rent, have regular house inspections and our landlord has been quite slow about getting things done. Despite all the checks we had to go thru, the letting agent didn't check the house so we arrived to find oven didn't work - took 3 weeks to get that fixed (you have no control over the timeframe or who does the work). It took several weeks to mend the broken garage door, during which time we couldn't access the garage.

Meanwhile the house we sold had almost doubled in value in 12 years.

There's also a danger if you go into rented long term of pricing yourself out of the housing market.

Blueroses99 · 10/02/2022 08:15

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER

I’d never do it. At least put some of it into a smaller property.

I have known of people doing this years ago, confident that property prices were going to crash. Instead they’ve done the opposite, and rents have soared, too.

Actually I’ve known people who’ve done this too and they now feel that they are ‘stuck’ renting and won’t be able to get onto the property ladder again. It’s a massive gamble.
bigbluebus · 10/02/2022 08:15

That you are even considering this makes me think that you do not have the financial acumen to understand the stock market.
Do not risk the roof over your head. Renting is expensive and insecure. Why do you think people want to get on the housing ladder.
Downsize to release some equity if you can and want to but remember stock markets can go down as well as up.