Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if it would be a good idea to sell house and rent instead

138 replies

Telematics1234 · 10/02/2022 08:05

I have got this idea we could sell the house and put proceeds of house sale in the stock market.

We are in our late 50s and have paid off our mortgage. We are both still working. The idea of selling up and investing the capital in the stock market is appealing.

We are both still working, so have wages coming in to cover everyday expenses and rent.

I like the idea of the flexibility of renting. ie we could move house much more easily.

It seems to me that the stock market probably out performs the housing market for the most part.

Has anyone done this?

OP posts:
nitsandwormsdodger · 10/02/2022 11:11

Down size
Buy a rental
I get £2k a month from rental ( £700 actual profit after mortgage is paid )
How on earth could you earn £ 700 from the stock market? What a huge risk
SEEK PROFESSIONAL ADVICE

Lockdownbear · 10/02/2022 10:53

It isn't quite a crazy as people are suggesting here, it's an investment decision like any other.

It's not an investment, its a gamble, you don't risk your house for anything. Even pensions start to move towards lower risk investments as you get older.

Op don't be stupid. Downsize if you must but don't risk losing your security on the stock market.

Gonnagetgoing · 10/02/2022 10:52

@MrsSkylerWhite

Good grief, no. Professional brokers with decades of experience sometimes call it wrong. It’s generally not their money, though.

Only do it if you’re potentially prepared to lose everything.

@MrsSkylerWhite - this a million times over. I inherited a bit of money in my mid twenties and made the mistake of investing in areas where I had no experience with medium to high risk. Lost a small amount of money but got vast majority out - when Iraq war happened it impacted it a lot.

I recall speaking to my older uncle who I should've spoken to before about this and he said unless you have experience and know what you're doing (like he did) then either choose low risk or get a good savings account etc.

The amount of worry I did have watching shares etc fall wasn't worth long term investment.

To OP - you would be completely and utterly mad to risk your house which you own on this hare brained scheme.

EmmaH2022 · 10/02/2022 10:51

@Telematics1234

Oh well, you've all talked me out of it!

Back to the drawing board then!

The drawing board for what though? What are you trying to achieve?
FiveShelties · 10/02/2022 10:49

@Tricked2003

Only invest in the stock market an amount you are prepared to lose!

It would be a very risky thing to do.

This, absolutely this and I speak as an investor heavily into shares, but I would never risk my home.
Tohaveandtohold · 10/02/2022 10:48

It doesn’t have to be all or nothing. That’s the crazy part. You can decide to sell your house and downsize even if you have to take on a small mortgage that’s less than 10 years and invest the rest of the money you have.
That way, you’ll be paying the new small mortgage instead of paying rent and you still have the security of the new small house and stocks as well.

Getoff · 10/02/2022 10:47

Two reasons why this is a bad idea.

In the UK, renting is for many reasons a second-best option for almost everyone who can afford to buy. Lack of security and lack of ability to tailor your home are first two reasons that spring to mind.

Also, looking at it purely in financial terms, by buying you are hedging your future need for housing with an asset that is price-matched with the cost of housing. For this reason, I would say everyone who can should own one house, even if they don't live in it. Although it is more tax-efficient to live in the property you own, as you are not taxed on the rent you pay yourself, or on any capital gain.

The only time I'd choose to rent is if I had a short life expectancy and wanted to use up capital.

Stillrunning1 · 10/02/2022 10:46

Given you are considering this you are definitely not the right people to play the stock market. First, the stock market is massively overvalued at the minute, second, things are unstable - 5% got wiped off the The US stock exchange the others week. Third, at your age any good financial advisor would be diversifying you into safer assets with guaranteed returns. As for getting rid of your home to do this - madness..

whatisheupto · 10/02/2022 10:43

If you've really got an itch OP then take out a mortgage on your current house and invest that money in shares.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 10/02/2022 10:42

@whatisheupto

Your house will double in value every 10 years. That is all that needs to be said on the matter.
Bit optimistic.
whatisheupto · 10/02/2022 10:41

Your house will double in value every 10 years. That is all that needs to be said on the matter.

Chewbecca · 10/02/2022 10:39

I wouldn’t want to be beholden to a landlord after being a homeowner.

A compromise is a possibility though. For example, DH and I have toyed with something like this in early retirement:

  • sell our house for around £800k
  • buy a small ‘lock up and leave’ apartment nearby for around £300k
  • invest the bulk of the balance
  • take long term (3-6m) lets in other countries over winter
  • take lots of holidays!
Tricked2003 · 10/02/2022 10:39

Only invest in the stock market an amount you are prepared to lose!

It would be a very risky thing to do.

MimiDaisy11 · 10/02/2022 10:39

I thought of moving into rental accommodation (to break chain before buying new place) as I thought we’d save money but rent costs the same if not usually more than mortgage payments.

Plus you say this I like the idea of the flexibility of renting. ie we could move house much more easily but unless you’re very minimalist then moving house is a pain and stressful regardless if you rent or own. Plus given the property market you can sell up easily. Granted there are no fees etc but still as someone who recently moved it’s not something I’m looking to do for a long while if ever.

bunfighters · 10/02/2022 10:33

You also don't seem to be factoring in if one or both of you became seriously or chronically ill and couldn't work, let alone have the energy/ability to move or manage stocks and shares. I have experienced this. Thank God I already have a mortgage and a roof over my head (and am much younger than you).

Sell now while the market is hot, rent (get that out of your system, it can be miserable!) while you find somewhere else that's smaller/cheaper, which will release some capital that you can play with... but only as much as you are prepared to lose.

Doris86 · 10/02/2022 10:32

Absolutely crazy idea. The housing market has proved to be one of the best investments over the past 20 years. Your money would be at much more risk in the stock market. My Grandad once lost over £100k in some banking shares he had.

Also having had your own house, the reality of putting up with regular rental inspections, not being allowed to put up pictures or decorate, and the ever present possibility of being given 2 months notice to leave, would be a bit of a shock,

AngelinaFibres · 10/02/2022 10:29

@AngelinaFibres

My husband and I are retired. He inherited a lot of money from his late father. We didn't need that money to fund our life so SOME of it is in investments.He is very good at it but....he spends hours reading relevant articles in financial magazines, he listens to podcast after podcast, he tracks the market daily. He takes part in at least one webinar a week from the investment platform he uses.That , and golf, are his thing.He spends hours on it. He has spread the investments around different world markets so lessen the risk. He has been very successful but we have benefited from the bear market of the last few years. That time is ending. We are well off and own a large house outright. If every investment went pear shaped overnight it would not affect our ability to live a lovely life. You would be absolutely mad to sell your house and risk that money. Low risk investments may save your capitol but won't make you any money. Moderate risk are not doing as well as they were and high risk is exactly that. You could lose the lot just as you get to retirement age and you have no house anymore.
This is me quoting me. It was a bull market .It now a bear. Avoid bears. I walked into the kitchen and told my husband ,mentioned in above post, what you were thinking of doing. He screwed his face up like a baby eating a lemon and said "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. They'd be utterly mad to do that'. We have moved everything into low risk investments and are currently in a holding pattern. We wont make any profit this year but we won't, hopefully, lose any. You must absolutely not need the money for anything at all and you must be in it for the long haul to invest in the stock market.Anything else is disaster.
Whadda · 10/02/2022 10:28

If you’re looking for more flexibility around location while your husband works remotely, why not rent your house out for a year and then do a tour of places you want to go, using AirBnB?

milkyaqua · 10/02/2022 10:27

Insane. In the brain.

Telematics1234 · 10/02/2022 10:23

Oh well, you've all talked me out of it!

Back to the drawing board then!

OP posts:
Chely · 10/02/2022 10:22

Nah, not worth the risk for me.
Dh is allowed to use his extra cash to invest in stocks but I treat it like gambling, only what we can afford to lose can go on it. We can not afford to lose our home and renting in old age is shite.

Dillydollydingdong · 10/02/2022 10:21

Ridiculous. You've got no security if you rent. You say it would be more flexible - it might be more flexible than you want as the landlord could kick you out at any time. You could end up homeless and penniless.

Orchid876 · 10/02/2022 10:19

As has been said already, it's a crack pot idea. But, there is an alternative to downsizing, you could buy a property to rent out then rent something else yourselves. If going down this route, I'd buy something that you'd potentially be happy to live in, should you need to. Then invest the rest if you want, but be prepared to lose it all, and obviously being a landlord won't be a picnic. But to relinquish all your property and put it on the stock market is madness.

Crumbleburntbits · 10/02/2022 10:19

No, your idea is madness.

Telematics1234 · 10/02/2022 10:16

@GizmosEveningBath

I planned to rent to test an area out before committing to buy, however there were 30+ applicants for every home so buying was the easier option (still had bidding wars etc).

Your home is your home first, investment second.

Yes, I have heard from people I know that it is difficult to source rented properties at present, so my idea wouldn't work unless this situation changes.
OP posts: