Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS Last one picked in PE

483 replies

GoldenLightNights · 09/02/2022 22:32

AIBU to contact the teacher with regards to this:

DS is 9, he’s a wonderful child, great at all things science and maths related but not so much at sports. He plays football outside of school for one of the lower ability teams and sort of enjoys it, he isn’t forced to play or anything like that.

Anyway today at school he had PE, we’ve never had any issues before but today for some reason the teacher let two boys pick teams and my son was the last to be picked. He is quite upset especially as one of the boys doing the picking is a close friend.
Anyway I find the idea of letting other children pick teams horrendous and if not my son some child will be picked last. I actually thought this method of choosing teams was done away with years ago!
I want to contact the teacher to ask if he would consider adopting a new approach to team selection. My husband says I’m jumping the gun and to wait to see if it happens again…… so what do you think?
He was properly upset this evening 😢

OP posts:
HunkyPunk · 11/02/2022 12:31

Surely anyone with half a brain knows that this is appalling practice

I’m afraid that it has the potential to get much worse in secondary schools, where some PE staff are positively Neanderthal in their practices.

In a year 8 school report his dickhead games teacher declared that ds3 was ‘not blessed with a great deal of physical prowess’. He was never going to be in the school’s pride and joy rugby ‘A’ team, no, but was average at and enjoyed having a go at most sports. This remark dented his (already shaky) confidence in any sporting ability he had or might have developed, so much, that he gradually withdrew from anything which wasn’t compulsory, left his junior football team, and now does little in the way of physical activity despite encouragement from us.

If only all teachers were aware of the benefits of positive reinforcement and the potential impact of their throwaway ‘clever’ comments. Especially PE/Games teachers, some of whom don’t seem to realise that part of their remit is to facilitate an enjoyment of sport and physical activity for all their pupils, not just the chosen few. It’s a really important role, when sedentary pastimes are so prevalent.

AssignedBlobbyAtBirth · 11/02/2022 12:26

Shame comes from humiliation not resilience
Resilience comes from being encouraged to try, accepting failure and learning new ways to try

Appleandoranges · 11/02/2022 12:22

Being subject to being the last out of the class to be picked for a team does not teach you any resilience or independence or any important life lessons. It's just a very painful and humiliating experience for a few children, especially if it's done on a regular basis. Being picked last is a completely different experience and a million times worse than not being picked at all. It's different from not being picked for school football team/play/even coming last in a test which can be very disappointing but is not as hurtful. What is the point of it? What are the benefits? Who wants their unpopularity rubbed in their face? Why doesn't the teacher just pick the teams? I would just write an email to the school saying you noticed this happened. It was upsetting for your child. Can't there be another method of picking teams which doesn't make children feel bad? I don't think you would need to dress it up like a complaint - more like this is what you think. And hopefully that will make the teacher think again. All in all, writing an email saying you don't like that way of choosing teams or just talking to the teacher about it would be sticking up for those children "picked last" now and in the future. And I think someone's got to stick up for them...

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 11/02/2022 12:19

@Quincythequince

So if you used to put in the minimum effort required, that’s on you! Just because you don’t give a crap if your team wins or loses, why shouldn’t others.

You’ve just partially reinforced and explained exactly why under these circumstances, teams are chosen the way they are.

If you’re meant to be playing a game with a view to point scoring, why would anybody choose you if you don’t give a crap about playing properly.

I sure as hell wouldn’t. I would chose a lower ability person who actually tried, every single time, than someone who didn’t try.

You really are struggling with this aren't you?

I DID get picked. That's the point.

Despite putting no effort in, I was picked third or fourth because of how I looked. I looked athletic. I was also an attractive teenager who hung out with a "popular" set.

That's why I got picked. Not because I was good at sport but because of how I looked and my social status.

Hope that helps.

MarshaBradyo · 11/02/2022 12:09

The op’s dc was upset - not because op made a big deal out of it beforehand but at the time he felt bad

What’s so great about that - when it’s so easily avoided?

If it’s just once then why even do it at all. He’d know where he fitted with sports teams without this extra part. And is fine with where he stands. He knows

If it is just once then too late as it has happened already but a pity they bothered with it at all

Northernparent68 · 11/02/2022 12:06

@thing47

Picking teams on ability for an inter-school match, or an inter-house competition is OK (OP says her DS plays competitive football outside school so I'm sure he understands the concept of relative ability).

Doing the same for a class PE lesson is totally unnecessary. That is an all-ability class, presumably, so the emphasis should be on enjoyment and exercise and in that case it's much better if the teachers sorts it out.

DS coaches sport to primary age children and would approach the all-ability class sessions in a completely different way from the teams playing competitively.

This.
Quincythequince · 11/02/2022 12:03

Agree Juniper

That can of course happen, but there is no suggestion that that’s what has happened here.

And this peer selection has happened once to OPs son.

Because people are saying they don’t think it’s a problem, the whataboutery of bullying has come into play.

Once.

starrynight87 · 11/02/2022 11:54

I don't think this that shocking, in the real world you wont always be picked first for everything.

Juniper68 · 11/02/2022 11:51

@Quincythequince

Picking teams is not bullying. No matter how you try to dress this up, it’s not.

And I do get it, I get that occasion (which this is) peer selection is fine.

Good luck in the real world if you’ve never had to relate to your peers this way.

Are people forgetting there was a teache present. Is he/she a bully too imagen, using your warped logic.

Teachers can be bullies. We had some right bastards when I was at school.
maddy68 · 11/02/2022 11:49

Really?

ChocolateDigestivesMmmm · 11/02/2022 11:41

I've done very well in the "real world". Good education and career, nice family and house, lots of friends and hobbies like swimming, hiking and two winter sports, one of them at a club at decent amateur competition level. I
love the challenge and the benefits of exercise.
However. At school I was one of the last to be picked for teams. I was actually athletic but not popular socially. It was always the same few popular girls who got to pick the teams and they always picked their friends first, then the next clique in the popularity pecking order, and finally me and my friends. It was nothing to do with being good at sport or not, just one of many forms of insidious bullying at my school, and yes it is bullying!
It taught me no "resilience" whatsoever. Never have I faced anything remotely similar in the "real world"!

Quincythequince · 11/02/2022 11:19

Picking teams is not bullying. No matter how you try to dress this up, it’s not.

And I do get it, I get that occasion (which this is) peer selection is fine.

Good luck in the real world if you’ve never had to relate to your peers this way.

Are people forgetting there was a teache present. Is he/she a bully too imagen, using your warped logic.

Lizzy1980 · 11/02/2022 11:18

I remember the feeling like it was yesterday. I was always the last to be picked because I was and still am crap at all sports! Like your Son though I excelled at other things and you do have to learn to accept that you can’t always be first in everything. I agree that it’s a lazy and unpleasant way for teachers to pick teams but by going to see his teacher every time he’s upset you won’t be doing him any favours, especially if the other kids become aware of this. If this became a regular occurrence though I could understand and I would hope that the teacher did not allow the same child to be picked last every time. I’m hoping that PE teachers aren’t the sadists they were in my day

Quincythequince · 11/02/2022 11:16

So bullying is also minor? What's the difference, especially if team picking is used as a tool. Why do you WANT team picking by students is what I do not understand

My comprehension is fine imagen! Don’t be disingenuous, your narrative here implies it’s similar and that someone has previously mentioned it

I can infer just fine thanks, you however can’t reason, nor write very persuasively either.

And I’m not a PE teacher, and I also did very well in school, and since then too. An all-rounder you might say - except for Art, I’m terrible at that. Really really bad.

I won’t mention my achievements of course, you might get upset because it’s probably not fair.

trumpisagit · 11/02/2022 11:14

It's not great by the teacher but it's exactly what the kids do at play time or at the park.
I would work on building your son's confidence, and help him find sports he is better at.

Somethingsnappy · 11/02/2022 11:09

@Quincythequince

Who the hell sits there whispering about kids who aren’t good at sport? Who is doing this whispering? What are you in about?

Talk about projecting.

My goodness. I read through all your comments, thinking, 'maybe she doesn't quite understand the crux of the issue, or perhaps not read the whole thread'. This comment confirmed it.
imagen · 11/02/2022 11:06

@Quincythequince

imagen who has said bullying is minor? Who has said that?

Why is being picked in line with your ability, bullying?

Would it be bullying to make sure the more able kids got picked last just to accommodate the less able ones?

Would that be ok? Would it make sense? Do you think everybody wouldn’t know why that was being done, this making it worse.

Peer engagement and building teams is an important skill to learn, done with kindness and reasoned choices.

There is nothing wrong with this.

Stop calling more able children bullies.

It’s just not true.

Reading comprehension. Spend less time in PE picking people last and more I'm English class.

It was a question- why is this ok and not bullying, especially as it's usually part of bullying?

thing47 · 11/02/2022 11:05

Picking teams on ability for an inter-school match, or an inter-house competition is OK (OP says her DS plays competitive football outside school so I'm sure he understands the concept of relative ability).

Doing the same for a class PE lesson is totally unnecessary. That is an all-ability class, presumably, so the emphasis should be on enjoyment and exercise and in that case it's much better if the teachers sorts it out.

DS coaches sport to primary age children and would approach the all-ability class sessions in a completely different way from the teams playing competitively.

Volhhg · 11/02/2022 11:04

I can't believe schools are still doing this how awful

Quincythequince · 11/02/2022 11:04

If parents make a big deal of it, then kids will too.
Nuff said.

And people need to stop calling kids good at sports, bullies.

That is annoying me yes.

MarshaBradyo · 11/02/2022 10:57

@Quincythequince

Our kids generation are screwed! Literally.

I wonder how many parents here will be phoning in when their children are adults re jobs and university places etc. bemoaning lack of fairness.

Hmm I think you are going off on a tangent and getting worked up for some reason.

I know it’s hard to get if you don’t separate it out but the dc will still have the opportunity to be in top teams or not. Without this process.

Northernparent68 · 11/02/2022 10:57

@Quincythequince

The fact of the matter is, teams are selected on ability!

No amount of mollycoddling will ever change that.

You’re not good at football!! That’s ok. Everyone gets their chance to shake sometimes.

Everyone.

Teach your kids resilience!

Exactly, which is why team sports should be optional
Quincythequince · 11/02/2022 10:56

OP - your husband is right.

Don’t phone the school for this one incident.

If it keeps happening, different story.

Maybe next time your son will be captain and can choose.

Quincythequince · 11/02/2022 10:55

Our kids generation are screwed! Literally.

I wonder how many parents here will be phoning in when their children are adults re jobs and university places etc. bemoaning lack of fairness.

Quincythequince · 11/02/2022 10:53

@MarshaBradyo

Is he in front of his peers standing together when the selection happens?

And if so are there many others with him that also don’t get picked?

I think the hard part is being last in a public group and all that goes with it, not so much not being in the best teams, not all dc can be and are fine with that.

It happens in forms for house competitions. He isn’t picked for teams where the best athletes are.

He doesn’t care!

There’s 30 boys. They can’t all be chosen as the best, most of them know this.

I still fail to see why it’s so bad to be the worst at one thing! Why is that bad?