Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS Last one picked in PE

483 replies

GoldenLightNights · 09/02/2022 22:32

AIBU to contact the teacher with regards to this:

DS is 9, he’s a wonderful child, great at all things science and maths related but not so much at sports. He plays football outside of school for one of the lower ability teams and sort of enjoys it, he isn’t forced to play or anything like that.

Anyway today at school he had PE, we’ve never had any issues before but today for some reason the teacher let two boys pick teams and my son was the last to be picked. He is quite upset especially as one of the boys doing the picking is a close friend.
Anyway I find the idea of letting other children pick teams horrendous and if not my son some child will be picked last. I actually thought this method of choosing teams was done away with years ago!
I want to contact the teacher to ask if he would consider adopting a new approach to team selection. My husband says I’m jumping the gun and to wait to see if it happens again…… so what do you think?
He was properly upset this evening 😢

OP posts:
worriedatthemoment · 10/02/2022 12:04

@thewhatsit they know the results within their classes and they are fully aware of what the top set / bottom set is
They have work read out in class that may not be to standard of others
So it happens across school
Mine just knew that some things they were not good at and we had the moto at home as long as you tried your best thats all that matters
The new reading and tests is a whole competition thing and its clear kids have failed tests as they often sit them in a room together

worriedatthemoment · 10/02/2022 12:00

@appleturnovers yes i think its better by ability like its done in all other subjects but the general consensus is not using ability in sports and its unfair in the kids
Kids are not stupid they generally know there strengths and weaknesses and also that of their peers
What would be better is that we teach that all of us are different and thats fine and that we are all good at somethings and not so good at others
At ds school we had parents complain their child wasn't picked for the school team etc and that everyone should be picked etc and your not allowed to have an A and B team in sports teams now

CoastalWave · 10/02/2022 11:50

Hmm. I really don't agree with the teacher getting the kids to do this..

However..

ANY way you do it , there will be a kid who is 'last' Either their name is read out last, or if you wrote it down, there'll be a child at the bottom of the list.

How can you do it so no child is read out last? Genuine question..

wishtotravel · 10/02/2022 11:49

What is the goal of school PE though and what other skills are being taught alongside the actual physical movement?
Is it to encourage movement and exercise in the moment, or harbour a lifelong interest in sports, or to teach a sport/skill so it can be played. Or is it to encourage competition and leadership and dealing with our own and other people's strengths and weaknesses. Is it a combination of all of t he above and more.
It all depends on what we as a society wish to achieve , and whether we want to reflect life and society as it is and teach children to cope with it, or promote different values. These were just some of my thoughts, but to answer your question I 'd base whether to speak to school on if this situation appears to be occasionally or routine and the effects it was having on my child.

MarshaBradyo · 10/02/2022 11:49

My point is in the real world someone needs to be last, someone needs to be slowest, someone needs to be less able in a particular field than the next

You can still have some dc do well and shine etc you can just scrap the one thing that has a negative impact on some. It means they are more likely to stick with it which is good for their fitness and health.

thewhatsit · 10/02/2022 11:45

[quote worriedatthemoment]@thewhatsit kids today do know who is in which set and they so know test results etc
Mine have also been kept in at break at primary to relearn their spellings as they didn't get enough right ? Had a detention at secondary for not getting a good enough grade
So it totally does happen to some extent in other subjects
They could always say who would win the dressing up prize or drawing comp so never bothered as they knew that wasn't their thing
All kids are good at something [/quote]
How would they know test results? I assume the test results on those in lower sets aren’t read out to those in the top set because that would be pretty awful?

If you’d shown me 10 children I knew not to be in the top set I wouldn’t have the faintest clue which of them was the bottom of the bottom set and which one was doing well in the middle set and probably going to do pretty well in their GCSE. I honestly wouldn’t have had any kind of idea.

But being kept on for spelling practice is pretty sad Sad. DS normally gets 10/10 for his spellings but after the latest period of home learning got really bad results for a few weeks (as in like 3/10.. 4/10…). I am really grateful that the teacher didn’t mention it even once to him or to us (although I knew). They just let him get on with things and get back used to school again and then eventually results went back to 10s every week. I think if a teacher had sat him down and said his results weren’t very good that week it would have been really counter productive and probably would have made him sad and embarrassed.

AnEpisodeOfEastenders · 10/02/2022 11:44

@ElftonWednesday

Being last doesn't mean you have a learning disability - surprised it was your default go to response and seems to be an ignorant view to have

But it might, and yes, if my DDs started coming last in maths tests when previously they usually did better then I would speak to the teacher. In fact most parents wouldn't even have a choice as the school would be speaking to them.

So, what actually was your point other than a completely irrelevant straw man argument in support of teachers being able to bully pupils? As others have pointed out to you, a maths test is not an analogy to being picked last in PE. Perhaps you could explain it more clearly, if you remember what the point was yourself, as in spite of my post-graduate education I don't seem to be understanding what your point actually is. If there even is one. Go for it. Knock yourself out.

My point is in the real world someone needs to be last, someone needs to be slowest, someone needs to be less able in a particular field than the next. Accepting that is a valuable life lesson unless you walk around with your head stuck up your postgraduate educated arse avoiding reality.
appleturnovers · 10/02/2022 11:36

[quote worriedatthemoment]@appleturnovers that happens even if the teachers pick the team, which is why its generally better to have teams picked of similar ability but many see that as unfair in sports , but fine in other subjects [/quote]
It shouldn't be considered unfair! I was one of the worst at sports and my favourite lessons were where I was placed with similar ability. At least then I had a fighting chance of doing well (comparatively, within our little group - I was never under any illusions I would actually be good at sports), plus the other people in the group weren't going to laugh or moan at me because they weren't that much better, which meant I had the confidence to try harder and get a bit better.

I imagine it's better for the athletic kids too, so they can stretch themselves and really shine rather than being held back by a kid on their team who can't even throw a ball in a straight line.

Nospringchix · 10/02/2022 11:31

@user1745

I don't really understand the comments about resilience. You don't get resilient to the point where your weaknesses being made publicly obvious doesn't hurt. You can get to the point where you don't say anything or outwardly show that it hurts, but it always stings and you don't just get used to it. You can become resilient in the sense that you understand you aren't good at sport but it doesn't upset you because you understand everyone has things they are good at and things they aren't good at, but that doesn't mean you won't care when the thing you aren't good at causes you to be publicly singled out.

Unfortunately I suppose PE teachers were the sporty ones when they were at school so they probably don't know how it feels to be picked last. I can't think of any other subject where this regularly happened when I was at school.

Yes, I guess most likely the PE teacher wouldn't have been the one last picked every lesson when they were kids so don't know how it affects a child.

One of the kids who used to pick me last and make my life a misery in PE is now wait for it.... a PE teacher in a local secondary school!

GrolliffetheDragon · 10/02/2022 11:31

@CocoCookieCream

OP, you sound like a right snowflake.

It used to happen when I was a kid and should still happen now.

Because to a degree it reflects real life and does teach kids about social/life skills. And kids also need to learn to cope with being picked last, and/or improving their standing to not be picked last all the time.

Just going to repeat my previous post - I wasn't worst at sport by a long way. But I was bullied and unpopular so there would be an argument over not wanting 'her' on the team, teacher did nothing about this. If there were an odd number of us, the teacher would have to choose which team I went on, with both of them backing away from me.

There was no way I could improve at sport to not be picked last, because being picked last was nothing to do with my ability. It was to do with who was friends with who and my general pariah status.

Eventually, and it took a long time because I like to do my best and I don't think I lack resilience, I stopped making any effort in games because it was just too miserable to make that effort to help other people who treated me like dirt and appeared to despise me. Resilience will only take you so far, and I was bullied on and off from 8 or 9 until I left school at 16.

MarshaBradyo · 10/02/2022 11:28

[quote worriedatthemoment]@thewhatsit kids today do know who is in which set and they so know test results etc
Mine have also been kept in at break at primary to relearn their spellings as they didn't get enough right ? Had a detention at secondary for not getting a good enough grade
So it totally does happen to some extent in other subjects
They could always say who would win the dressing up prize or drawing comp so never bothered as they knew that wasn't their thing
All kids are good at something [/quote]
Yes they know and they’ll still know re sport without doing the team picking element.

It’s not necessary and just puts dc off exercise and team sports when they need more not less.

worriedatthemoment · 10/02/2022 11:28

@appleturnovers that happens even if the teachers pick the team, which is why its generally better to have teams picked of similar ability but many see that as unfair in sports , but fine in other subjects

worriedatthemoment · 10/02/2022 11:26

@thewhatsit kids today do know who is in which set and they so know test results etc
Mine have also been kept in at break at primary to relearn their spellings as they didn't get enough right ? Had a detention at secondary for not getting a good enough grade
So it totally does happen to some extent in other subjects
They could always say who would win the dressing up prize or drawing comp so never bothered as they knew that wasn't their thing
All kids are good at something

maryd84 · 10/02/2022 11:26

It's so humiliating to always be picked last in PE. Happened to me in primary and secondary school. Dreaded PE because of it. Its an awful feeling being judged as not being good enough☹

GrolliffetheDragon · 10/02/2022 11:18

@appleturnovers

It's not just the being picked last. IME the worst part is the rest of the team who've already been picked whispering to the team leader "pick her, pick her, no, not her, oh I hope we don't get her, oh god, no, not her, OH FOR F**K'S SAKE" and then giving you dirty looks and sulking when you go to join their team.
This. And I wasn't even the worst at sport, I was however bullied and unpopular so nobody wanted to be associated with me.
thewhatsit · 10/02/2022 11:17

@ChocolateMassacre

It's not a question of not making the team or of not being singled out as the best. Yes, of course sporty kids who are not academic should get recognition for their achievements.

But this is a question of being singled out as the worst. In no other subject is it considered acceptable publicly to single out children as being the worst in their class. You just wouldn't do this for English or Maths or anything else. Instead, they would be quietly helped to improve. Why should PE be different?

Singling out the 'worst' students in a subject is entirely different from recognising and praising the top students. I'm surprised people can't see the difference. One is positive, one is not.

I agree with this. Plus you’re often set for English and Maths.

I was always in the top set and I had no idea who was in the sets below me (whether a particular child was middle or in the bottom set - I just knew they weren’t in the top set) and it wasn’t something I ever gave any thought to.

There’s no concept of lining children up and asking there peers to point at (in full view of everyone else) who ranks worst at maths or spellings.

worriedatthemoment · 10/02/2022 11:17

@edwinbear yes mine have had the same

edwinbear · 10/02/2022 11:15

@worriedatthemoment DS was given a detention a few weeks back for failing a test. He'd genuinely revised hard for it and did his best, but he finds the subject very hard and it really doesn't come naturally to him.
He took it on the chin.

thewhatsit · 10/02/2022 11:13

I don’t think you are a snowflake at all Op.

It’s a horrible method and sports at school put me off exercise for a long, long time which is presumably the opposite to what they want. I thought that methods had changed a lot since I was at school and this was very much in the past.
Obviously children are still going to realise who is less athletic but being singled out in this way is unnecessary.

worriedatthemoment · 10/02/2022 11:12

@ChocolateMassacre except you were when you were give exams back etc and your grade on the top , my ds also knew who got best / worst grade in maths , science etc so it is the same
Sometimes they even got told off for not doing well

FixTheBone · 10/02/2022 11:06

I'm going to be in the minority, but I was usually last to be picked.

Not a problem, I was well aware I was crap at football and cricket, but at least it meant the teams were reasonably balance.

I always found it much worse when for example we played against a much better team and got battered, what do you learn or gain from that experience?

ChocolateMassacre · 10/02/2022 11:05

It's not a question of not making the team or of not being singled out as the best. Yes, of course sporty kids who are not academic should get recognition for their achievements.

But this is a question of being singled out as the worst. In no other subject is it considered acceptable publicly to single out children as being the worst in their class. You just wouldn't do this for English or Maths or anything else. Instead, they would be quietly helped to improve. Why should PE be different?

Singling out the 'worst' students in a subject is entirely different from recognising and praising the top students. I'm surprised people can't see the difference. One is positive, one is not.

TabithaTiger · 10/02/2022 11:05

I'm surprised this method of picking teams is still used. I remember primary school and always being one of the last to be picked, it's a horrible feeling and led me to believe I wasn't good at sport, therefore didn't bother trying with any sport as I got older.

CocoCookieCream · 10/02/2022 11:04

@anormalperson

I don't think OP sounds like a snowflake at all. Completely unnecessary way to pick teams and always leave someone feeling shit. I probably wouldn't say anything unless it happened again.
Tbh, I always excelled academically, but was terrible at all sport. So I know full well what it's like, and yes it sucks. I just shrugged, coped, and carried on.

If anything, it develops a stronger character. My personal observation is that often the people picked last in sports in school end up being more successful and determined in overall life. I.e. Nerds Vs jocks. (Guess who ends up with better/good friends, married, good income, etc after they leave school.)

worriedatthemoment · 10/02/2022 10:59

I was always last picked at pe but thats just how it was
This method not usually much in primary but is in secondary, my kids now are sporty and quite good
But. Academically they used to do just ok , so never won the awards or praise for that so Pe was there only chance to stand out
Also teams would be picked sometimes based on ability and all those who think it should be fair and all play thats not so easy as the better kids don't pass wtc so its better being on the team of similar ability like you would be in any other subject
That said at your sons age I would let it go this time if happens again a quiet word with the teacher that there are other ways

Swipe left for the next trending thread