Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be concerned wrt the future when there are so many people needing support?

57 replies

Jupitersmoonandstars · 09/02/2022 20:02

Prepared to be told IABU, but since covid, and more especially, the lockdowns, I have noticed how many people need quite a lot of support from outside of their families, and I am becoming increasingly concerned about how we will manage to support so many people now and in the future.
I admit, I was completely astonished at the sheer numbers of people who need assistance to even buy food, so many people who either cannot drive yet dont live close to a supermarket so rely heavily on online deliveries, people who cannot shop alone due to their mental health, people who are too frail to shop, people who are longterm too sick to shop.
There seemed to be so many more people than I expected who were completely dependent on a delivery service and when they couldn't get a slot, were understandably panicking!
People who couldn't get their prescriptions, people who didnt have enough money to buy food and needed to use the services of a food bank, people who couldn't get the medical or therapeutic help they needed. People whose operations and procedures were postponed causing massive amounts of stress and anxiety.
People suffering from serious mental health conditions which impact their day to day lives considerably.

As I read more and more on social media community pages, and forums about how utterly dependent on services so many people are, it began to make me extremely concerned how we, as a society, are going to be able to adequately support people who rely on others, now and into the future.

I began to realise that almost all of the families, friends and neighbours
I know have at least one member of their family who is in great need of support, without which, they would be unable to access supermarkets or medical needs, and this adds up to a huge amount of people overall in the UK.

Am I seeing this from a skewed perspective?

Are there people in your circle who depend on outside support to carry out basic functions?
What can be done to help support these people?
Are we doing enough?

In my family and friends circle, many of us are needed to help support other members of our families, and without that support, life would be incredibly difficult if not impossible for those people.
I'm quite happy to assist my family and friends but should I find myself unable to help, what help is available? What would happen to these people? Am I catastrophising?

YABU There is only a small percentage of people whose health or age prevents them from coping independently and as such, only a small amount of people depend on outside help in order to afford or perform basic tasks to enable them to buy the food and access the medical help amongst other things they need and I dont know anyone in my own circle who is dependent on others to help them to get what they need?

YANBU We are seeing more and more people who need support to afford or perform basic tasks to enable them to get the food/medical help they need amongst other things and not enough is being done to support these people adequately.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Boood · 10/02/2022 19:52

@MaChienEstUnDick is right- a major cause of this is that our economy and society were always heavily reliant on women’s unpaid labour, and this has now largely been withdrawn. There were just as many people who needed care and support in the past, and they got it from their mothers, sisters, daughters, nieces… who are now busy doing paid work, or living too far away. And people who didn’t have that help available for whatever reason just fell through the cracks and didn’t survive. We don’t find either of those alternatives acceptable now*, but we haven’t worked out a palatable alternative, because we aren’t prepared to pay what it really costs either.

*I suspect the likes of Jacob Rees-Mogg are actually completely fine with both of these options, hence they aren’t trying that hard to fix it.

latetothefisting · 10/02/2022 19:19
  1. as others have said, some of these issues were due to a very specific issue (lockdown) - some people usually cope, for example, with their family getting their shopping but this was curtailed when family members themselves had to isolate/weren't allowed to travel etc. They were a very specific one off, not indicative of general, ongoing issues.

  2. similar to above, lots of people would usually be able to do these things for themselves, but because of age/illness etc were advised to isolate only due to this very specific circumstance (air born virus disproportionately affecting the old and clinically vulnerable). So the only reason lots of people needed delivery slots was because they were specifically told by the govt not to go out. It isn't applicable that the same will happen in the future just because of an aging population.

  3. back in the day there were still people with various physical and mental health issues, but because there weren't other options they HAD to go out and fend for themselves. Same might apply in the future. Not saying it's ideal/easy or dismissing anyone's illness, physical or mental, but if the choice is between going to the supermarket/starving to death SOME people will have to, and be able to, force themselves to go. Obviously some won't be able to, but others only don't "cope" now because help is (rightly) available.

  4. we could arrange things a lot easier for people who struggle for whatever reason, e.g. more autism friendly hours, shops open 24/7 so people can go in the middle of the night when it's quiet, free shuttle buses to supermarkets etc.

  5. In home care will be the biggest issue. I can see the end of council/govt funded home care because too many people will need it. Unfortunately I think it might end up being a case of either paying (A LOT) for private care in your own home, or having to go to a centralised home if you can't afford it. No option for free/subsidised care at home. For all disabled/elderly people.

  6. An alternative would be an increase in IT so we basically have robots that are capable of caring for people. Sounds mad but are we that far off? People can already use alexa/even their fridge to record what food they need, order it online and have it delivered without ever leaving the house.

  7. The other alternative would be we realise how much we need people who will work hard for minumum wage, and completley reverse brexit to employ staff from other countries as carers.

  8. Or we could start putting enough money in from the time children are born to try and stop various issues ever developing so people have the support they need throughout their life to be as self-sufficient as possible...but that would require upfront investment, a degree of forward planning, and a smidgen of care for others so unlikely to happen with our current government

daisypond · 10/02/2022 19:15

@Fr0thandBubble

The answer isn't more state help - the answer is more people standing on their own two feet and taking responsibility for themselves.
FGS, so what will you do if you become seriously ill and disabled and bedbound and you need a carer, or several, and no matter how much money you have, there are no carers available? Because that is happening now.
Cocomarine · 10/02/2022 19:15

@Fr0thandBubble

The answer isn't more state help - the answer is more people standing on their own two feet and taking responsibility for themselves.
How does my 85yo XMIL with advanced dementia and arthritis do that, do you propose?

And she saved plenty for the rainy day, and worked and paid in all her life. Her house has long since been sold to fund care. Which I agree with.

But I’m really too sure how she’s going to stand on her arthritis riddled two feet, or indeed how she’ll understand that she has to stand, with her dementia riddled mind.

Interested in your suggestion though 🤷🏻‍♀️

Fr0thandBubble · 10/02/2022 18:55

The answer isn't more state help - the answer is more people standing on their own two feet and taking responsibility for themselves.

Ghostofchristmaspasty · 10/02/2022 18:42

Not rtft but this used to called community.

People lived and worked locally. Many more SAHMs. People had more capacity to help others, look after their neighbours and family.

These days we are battered by austerity, cuts to services, covid, zero hour contracts/ stagnant wages and rising house prices. Family's are scattered. Few family's can afford a sahp. It's harder to volunteer/offer help when are struggling to keep afloat yourself.

People are living longer and with multiple illnesses. The NHS is seriously creaking under the strain. Mental health services were slashed in the great austerity drive.

Society is better set up in some aspects- online deliverys/ internet, but the community safety nets and state safety nets gave large holes in them which it's easy to fall through.

SweetFelicityArkright · 10/02/2022 17:38

@MorningStarling

I think the way out of this is through robots and AI. It's a way off yet but it won't be many decades before robots can reliably be trusted to carry out care work, diagnose illnesses, give therapy and fill almost any medical need.

People might not think that is as good as having a network of humans doing the jobs, but there will become a point where robots can do the job more efficiently and without human error.

I think the key is to get robots that look, smell and behave as real people. If they are indistinguishable from the real thing, they will become more acceptable. The current system of having too few resources thinly spread, people getting poor quality of care or not enough of it, can and will be replaced. It will be a phased process of course, it can't happen overnight.

I don't disagree with the idea, but the thing about robots is you can't exploit them, you can't guilt trip them and you can't bully them. They just will not do things that they are programmed not to, and if they're programmed to do something that's wrong, then the provider will not be able to hide behind the robot and blame them for bad practice, like they currently do with humans. You can't tell a robot to keep quiet about bad practice under threat of their job, robust safeguards would need to be built in around programming and reporting, and that will mean everything needs to be done properly, above board and that is going to cost money.

You can't guilt trip a robot that's out of charge to stay on and do the night shift because another robot is out of action, if they're broken they need to be fixed, there's no disciplinary for a robot that's malfunctioning and can't complete it's tasks. It needs fixing or it needs replacing.

I just can't see anyone (government, society, providers) stumping up the sort of cash that would be needed to invest and maintain this kind of technology to provide proper care. They'd have to invest in proper numbers and programming and maintenance or they'd be caught out cutting corners and costs like they do now and have no one to hide behind.
I mean in principle, it's a fantastic idea to improve the standard of care, but it will come at the cost of profit and I don't think providers are going to take kindly to that.
It would only work if there was a massive culture change in the area that puts care before money, and I can't see any will for that happening.
If people were invested in properly to care for those who need it, then care would still improve, there's no appetite for that though.

Jupitersmoonandstars · 10/02/2022 15:04

I'm not confident that we will see the improvements we need to see.
I fear that more and more people will struggle to cope and the support wont be there to enable them to live a quality of life independently.
How can we maximise our chances of remaining healthy enough, both mentally and physically, in order to avoid needing support that possibly wont be available?

I cannot prevent myself from ageing, despite wishing to, but can I maximise my chances of remaining healthy, or is much of my health down to genes and chance?

OP posts:
Jupitersmoonandstars · 10/02/2022 14:57

@MorningStarling

I think the way out of this is through robots and AI. It's a way off yet but it won't be many decades before robots can reliably be trusted to carry out care work, diagnose illnesses, give therapy and fill almost any medical need.

People might not think that is as good as having a network of humans doing the jobs, but there will become a point where robots can do the job more efficiently and without human error.

I think the key is to get robots that look, smell and behave as real people. If they are indistinguishable from the real thing, they will become more acceptable. The current system of having too few resources thinly spread, people getting poor quality of care or not enough of it, can and will be replaced. It will be a phased process of course, it can't happen overnight.

This reminds me of the netflix series 'humans'. Grin
OP posts:
MorningStarling · 10/02/2022 13:57

I think the way out of this is through robots and AI. It's a way off yet but it won't be many decades before robots can reliably be trusted to carry out care work, diagnose illnesses, give therapy and fill almost any medical need.

People might not think that is as good as having a network of humans doing the jobs, but there will become a point where robots can do the job more efficiently and without human error.

I think the key is to get robots that look, smell and behave as real people. If they are indistinguishable from the real thing, they will become more acceptable. The current system of having too few resources thinly spread, people getting poor quality of care or not enough of it, can and will be replaced. It will be a phased process of course, it can't happen overnight.

MsMeNz · 10/02/2022 13:38

You aren't wrong. for pretty much all of human history most people lived in the same area as their extended family and very rarely did people leave, and befor that we lived in tribes of close family and friends for the most part. This was hie we developed.

Now we live in some single units often miles away from family etc and often barely know our neighbors this is new in human history and the vunereable are not part of the tubes like they used to be. It still happens in other cultures still but. It much in western societies. So no it becomes people's jobs and acts of stranger charity to look after those with additional needs. It's pretty sad but it is what it is. I don't think it will go back to how it was beyond small pockets if individuals

Seemslikeagoodidea · 10/02/2022 01:44

YANBU. I think much of this is due to people living longer than people previously did, but often having multple health problems that are difficult to cope with, for them and their families. Dementia affects around 50% of the 85+ group, and is a diabolical disease that destroys its victims piece by piece, while making them ever needier and more confused. Also, many premature babies are surviving against the odds, but some of them have multiple health problems and learning difficulties throughout their lives, so need a lot of care and support as they can never be fully indepdendent.

Property prices have risen much faster than earnings, making it much harder for people to get on the property ladder. Meanwhile rents are very high, and fuel prices are rocketing due to rising gas prices globally. The NHS is underfunded but in some ways is like a bottomless pit as no matter how much money is sunk into it, it never seems to be enough. Brexit and Covid have both affected the economy, and impacted on food prices.

It is worrying. All I can suggest is that everybody does their best to support each other through these tough times, and if anybody is aware of a friend, relative or neighbour who needs help and support, then offer any help that you feel able to give. Generally speaking UK residents are in a much stronger position than many people in other parts of the world, we do at least have health and social services (albeit stretched to breaking point) but we are living through strange times and we can't rely on the state to do everything that is required. It's time for our politicans to stop partying and covering each others backs, and to start being honest and realistic about what can be done to fund health and social care, and what sort of tax will be needed to fund it - tax rises are inevitable, no matter how unpopular they will be.

AbsentmindedWoman · 10/02/2022 01:00

@Cheekypeach

The NHS under a Conservative government refuse to fund type 1 or type 2 diabetes properly. They have immense buying power and it would make sound economic sense to plough money into continuous glucose monitoring, insulin pumps and education.

My type 1 diabetes care has been excellent. And I get a continuous monitor on the NHS.

A Libre or Dexcom? If you mean Dexcom then you are in a tiny group of people who qualify.

If you mean a Libre, it is a flash monitor and not the same thing as CGM because of the lack of alarms. So for people with hypo unawareness, or if you drop suddenly like a stone for something as incongruous as showering or brushing your teeth like I do - it doesn't solve the problem.

Are more modern forms of Libre available on NHS with alarms now? They weren't when I was last living in the UK.

Neither will integrate with an insulin pump at present.

I had to wait a year and a half to access a pump on the NHS. A year and a half that further damage was accumulating.

My NHS team in London were excellent by the way - but their hands were tied due to lack of funding. I could never get an a1c lower than the 7s at best and racked up load of damage over the course of decades.

A1c now at non diabetic levels thanks to Dexcom and Tandem and Control IQ technology and I thank my lucky stars every day this is possible because it is slowing down my damage.

Cheekypeach · 10/02/2022 00:00

The NHS under a Conservative government refuse to fund type 1 or type 2 diabetes properly. They have immense buying power and it would make sound economic sense to plough money into continuous glucose monitoring, insulin pumps and education.

My type 1 diabetes care has been excellent. And I get a continuous monitor on the NHS.

MaChienEstUnDick · 09/02/2022 23:51

But it was always thus. It's just that the people who took care of people were women, usually older women, who either looked after ageing families or volunteered in their communities.

Now women are working until 68. Women ain't got time for that shit.

My aunt used to live in a rural community and shop for everyone on her street. I have such clear memories of going to the little shop in the village and then once a fortnight to the 'big' supermarket with 8 different shopping bags to get Mrs Forbes' bread and Mr Smith's milk. That's how communities ran, on the unpaid labour of women. My aunt wasn't old at that point by the way, she was in her early 50s but she never really went back to work after her children were born. Today she'd be like me, still working full time.

Now we outsource that and people pay for it. But it's in the govt's interest to make all that work because we don't actually make things anymore. So creating a service economy is vital for the economy. It's another form of industrial revolution, really.

AbsentmindedWoman · 09/02/2022 23:48

@Tootiredallthetime

NHS and social care spend huge proportion of budget on...

Diabetes and related conditions (over 10% of NHS budget).
Dementia - diet and diabetes are leading causes
Mental health - affective disorders like depression - emerging evidence of the importance of a good gut microbiome to good mental health

So if we can get people eating healthier, that’s a lot of savings right there!

The cost of getting the nation eating healthier would be minuscule compared to treating the diseases caused by poor diets.

Type 1 diabetes is autoimmune, it is not caused by diet or lifestyle.

Type 2 has genetic factors at play, not everyone is able to reverse it.

The NHS under a Conservative government refuse to fund type 1 or type 2 diabetes properly. They have immense buying power and it would make sound economic sense to plough money into continuous glucose monitoring, insulin pumps and education.

They will not do this.

The human cost, as well as the cost to the taxpayer, is astronomical.

The fucking tsunami coming down the line when the diabetes epidemic explodes with all the attendant complications (kidney failure, loss of eyesight, cardiovascular) is going to devastate and enrage a lot of people. And will cost a lot of money, directly and indirectly. Much more money than just funding decent bloody care in the first place.

AbsentmindedWoman · 09/02/2022 23:41

@OfstedOffred

The essence of society has always been to care for/support those who needed it.

It is breaking down because inequality is creating circumstances where too many people end up with poor mental & physical health (often preventable) due to poverty. It is driving a gap between sectors of society where there is high need, and where there is less need.

100% agree with this.
ToykotoLosAngeles · 09/02/2022 23:29

My grandad and his wife died within 6 months of each other a few years back, and required support (mainly shopping/cleaning/lifts) for a couple of years beforehand. They had 3 children and 3 children-in-law. Of all 6, in their 50s, only one was available and that was my mum who retired early due to - surprise - ill health. 4 were still working, 2 of those being the only income for that household, and my mum's brother had COPD (also now dead, at 58).

Growing up, mum's mum didn't need to work, and she was one of the people helping neighbours, friends and relatives as part of her daily routine. That's not a thing now.

BigGreen · 09/02/2022 23:11

Honestly humans are social animals - we ALL need support. The fact that some forms of support get devalued in our culture is what's weird. The idea that humans are rational individuals is relatively new in history.

StScholastica · 09/02/2022 23:07

I worry that the NHS will go down the American route and just stop funding diabetic meds. God help those people then!
The sugar tax is a good start as is a focus on healthy living (rather than just medicating) in primary care. Our local GP refers everyone in the obese category to a lifestyle programme.

Nowayoutonlydown · 09/02/2022 22:56

YANBU however a lot of people had their needs change during the pandemic.
A lot of people who mightve gone under the radar for certain help due to a working family member, lost that during the pandemic.
A lot of people lost their jobs and businesses which meant they were reliant on financial help, some may have been receiving care from family members who they could no longer see due to the family member posing an additional risk because of Covid.
Others had their conditions deteriorate due to Covid.
I think some families were also just getting by, but during covid things worsened financially. Even if not in the amount of money coming in, but certain bills increased.

Covid was the perfect storm to make the vulnerable seem more reliant on services that they either needed before, or were just scraping by before it got worse.

Tootiredallthetime · 09/02/2022 22:55

NHS and social care spend huge proportion of budget on...

Diabetes and related conditions (over 10% of NHS budget).
Dementia - diet and diabetes are leading causes
Mental health - affective disorders like depression - emerging evidence of the importance of a good gut microbiome to good mental health

So if we can get people eating healthier, that’s a lot of savings right there!

The cost of getting the nation eating healthier would be minuscule compared to treating the diseases caused by poor diets.

Bagadverts · 09/02/2022 22:55

@Cocomarine

I live in a large village and was part of a network of volunteers during the first lockdown. I was allocated about 100 houses, and leaflet dropped my number to all, speaking to about 80 of them, explaining the network and letting them know they could call me. I had two calls - and both were from older people who admitted that they didn’t want to bother their own local adult children. One call started off awkwardly - I was calling back, and the visiting adult child answered! And was initially quite affronted, as if I was accusing her of not being their for her mum! The call ended on smoother terms.

My experience was replicated by the network of volunteers - very few were actually needed.

Of course there are people with no-one, but I still think they’re a minority.

I think one of the differences during lockdown, particularly 1 was that there were healthy people available. That includes people on furlough or with less self employed work. Also people wfh who had less commute. Parents may have been struggling with home schooling. The adult children may not be available now as the economy opens up, their own children have activities or they have their own illness including MH issues they may be going to GP after avoiding due to Covid.