Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you split the holiday?

211 replies

Mumstheword8 · 09/02/2022 18:17

So basically I have booked a holiday with my son (5), my dad and my dad's wife. We have got two rooms and also a free child place. How would you split the cost? Would you split per room so basically half the holiday each or per adult which is the holiday split into 3 as the child place was free?

OP posts:
Rewis · 09/02/2022 21:19

Talk with your dad and nit with his wife. Your dad asked to have a holiday with you, I'd say you split it amongst 3 adults and maybe you pay a bit extra for the inflated price of "free child". Normally paying per room would be fair but in this case there would have been 2 rooms anyway.

mightytights4 · 09/02/2022 21:09

I'd look at what it would cost you each to book separately then apply the same share to the actual cost.

If I understand right it would cost the same if your dad and his wife or you and your DS booked separately because your DS would pay the same as an adult. That means you'd each have the same cost.

Say its £1000 for 2 people

Cost for you and your DS going alone £1000
Cost for your dad and his wife going alone £1000
Total cost if you all booked separately £2000
Share 50% each

If you're saying it is £1650 instead of £2000 then you're right that your dad and his wife pay less splitting 50% but so do you. I agree with other posters that a dad might be generous about it and not take the saving but I don't think they're being unreasonable splitting half each.

HettieHelvetica · 09/02/2022 20:46

@Dutchesss

Book separately. You'll get a free child place and they'll have to pay for their own.
You tend to need to book two adults to get one free child place though. Yes, that sucks for single parents.

I would do two dummy bookings to see the costs for you & DS and them individually and then work backwards from there.

MrsDrDear · 09/02/2022 20:37

Has your dad offered to split by 3? What man would stitch his daughter and grandchild up? You need to speak to him direct, he might not have realised.

Dutchesss · 09/02/2022 20:15

If it's a free child place then the child is free. Split between the 3 adults who will be eating, drinking and paying the air fare.

How much would the holiday have been if you had booked for 4 adults? Probably another 30% on top and you would have split it.

Your price breakdown on the confirmation should show up as per person.

Inanun2 · 09/02/2022 20:06

@LizzieMacQueen

As you only got the free child space with their participation I'd divide total by 3.5. They pay 2, you 1.5.
Yes I agree with this as a compromise if they will not split 3 ways then only next fairest IMO based on full price of £3300 they pay £1885 (£944 each) and you pay £1414. Do not pay 50/50 that’s too much.
thickthighs73 · 09/02/2022 19:56

Split between three

kitcat15 · 09/02/2022 19:55

Does your dad have form for this? I regularly go away with My kids, GC and my Mum..... we always split costs of package holidays between adults only ( me my partner and mum are only too happy to pay for GC and we can afford to) ....if we go on flights and accommodation hols....my DC pay for their own flights and their children's..... then we split the accommodation between the adults.... maybe just go on holiday with your MUm in future OP

gogohm · 09/02/2022 19:53

All depends on the pricing- if you have two separate rooms, was there a surcharge for your room because prices are usually based on 2 adults sharing - free child places are usually only when they share your room. I would look at the invoice, if their room cost twice as much they should pay twice as much

ChocolateMassacre · 09/02/2022 19:49

Even if you put a value on the 'free' child's place, it should be less than the adult value because they're going to eat less, not drink alcohol obviously etc. They will get less benefit from the holiday.

I'd value the child's place at 50% of the adult's place. So you pay 1.5 places and they pay 2 places. What that comes out as is that you pay 3/7 of the cost of the trip and they pay 4/7.

rookiemere · 09/02/2022 19:47

Your DF and DSM should pay what the holiday would have cost them as a couple.

Kite22 · 09/02/2022 19:41

If I was taking my son away on my own I would have to pay 2 full adult prices so because there are at least 2 adults on the booking we got a free child place. Obviously I think the price was inflated due to a free child place. The price split in half is less than I would of payed anyway if I was to take him away on my own

I think this ^ is key.

I would also factor in finances in general. So when my dc were little and my Dad were alive, he would have delighted in treating us / subsidising things as - at that point in his life and that point in my life - he had a lot more money than I did. The fact you have paid for it all and they are paying you back suggests you can afford it as much, or possibly more than they can. That would influence my thinking too.

Ultimately though, by paying half, you and your dc are still getting a cheaper holiday than you would have if you had gone without them.

Maybe your friend should stop stirring?

wanderlustgirl · 09/02/2022 19:39

Go on to the website and see how much it would be to book just the two of them on the same holiday. Normally hotels charge per room to tours operators so you would need to pay half

AnotherEmma · 09/02/2022 19:34

Typo
does she he agree

budgiegirl · 09/02/2022 19:34

Very simple - ring travel agent and ask how much it would be for just you and your son and pay that

It would probably cost the same or more than the half the OP is being asked to pay, as you don't generally qualify for a free child place with only one adult.

Seems like there’s not an easy answer. If you split it 3 ways then you dad and partner are paying more than if they just booked their room themselves as a separate booking as essentially they are “subsidizing” the free child’s place. I’d image most grandparents wouldn’t quibble about that as would appreciate the family time it brings

This. While I can see both sides, I know my mum would never have quibbled over this. But I guess that depends on their financial situation.

Awakened22 · 09/02/2022 19:34

What would you dads room cost if they’d just booked it independently? That’s what they then pay you right? Then the child is an added bonus by “combining” bookings?!

AnotherEmma · 09/02/2022 19:34

Ridiculous to book a holiday together without first agreeing who is paying what. If they don't agree to a fair split you don't book it. Too late for that now, of course.

What does your dad say about the money? Is it just his wife wanting to split it this way or does she agree?

I think there are various different ways to split the cost:

Divide per person with child costing half the adult price. So you pay 43% (1.5/3.5) and they pay 57% (2/3.5).

Split the cost in half, one half is divided by adult (each adult pays 1/6) and the other half is divided by room (1/4 per room). So you would pay 42% (1/6 + 1/4) and they would pay 58% (2/6 + 1/4).

As you can see, the two ways of dividing it up end up pretty equal anyway.

Could you call your dad and suggest something like that? I think it's best to discuss these things in person or over the phone if possible.

Mumstheword8 · 09/02/2022 19:32

@DirtyDancing

Doesn't make sense ... you're not getting a child place for free if you are playing for 2 adults?! I don't get it. Lol
Haha I know, I've only just realised this 🤣🤣
OP posts:
DirtyDancing · 09/02/2022 19:30

Doesn't make sense ... you're not getting a child place for free if you are playing for 2 adults?! I don't get it. Lol

Midlifemusings · 09/02/2022 19:29

Divide the cost by 7 - they pay 4/7., you pay 3/7

That way you pay half the cost between full cost (if you had gone alone) and free (because they also bought packages).

That way all 3 adults are paying the same for adult rooms / flight and food and you are paying 50% for child flight / room / food.

Pbbananabagel · 09/02/2022 19:28

Massively cheeky! The room is only a tiny part of it and you’re subsidising their food and drinks.

Awakened22 · 09/02/2022 19:26

Seems like there’s not an easy answer. If you split it 3 ways then you dad and partner are paying more than if they just booked their room themselves as a separate booking as essentially they are “subsidizing” the free child’s place. I’d image most grandparents wouldn’t quibble about that as would appreciate the family time it brings.

Some of it may depend on who can afford to pay a bit more and whether there’s any “extras” like days out that could be used to balance out the costs.

BaronessBomburst · 09/02/2022 19:25

Cancel the booking and go with your mum instead.

LizzieMacQueen · 09/02/2022 19:24

That's s very good price if it includes flights. Mind saying where it is OP?

HTH1 · 09/02/2022 19:24

Also I would look into cancelling and going somewhere with your mum instead if they keep arguing.