Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

My name is not on the mortgage and I pay him £700 per month

395 replies

Star54 · 09/02/2022 17:56

I have been with my partner for 30 plus years, we have grown up children and I work full time in a high pressured role. I have always worked and paid towards the house and the bills. We never married although we got engaged. He is now retired and has been for circa 10 years, I give him £700 per month and pay a significant part of the food bill, I also pay when we go out for meals etc. I have left him before twice but returned in part because he refused to give me any money from the house to start anew. My name is not on the house deeds and there is no mortgage, if I raise it the issue always causes a row and he says that he is saving the family as I could walk off and take money from him. I am at the end of my tether and now fel I should leave. Am I being unreasonable given that he had a property in his own right when we first met (I was 21 and am now in my 50s). I am strong him my job but not assertive in my relationship as I have felt bad for leaving him before.

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 12:46

Yes. The point is, it wasn't relevant to the problem being discussed here.

Inspectorslack · 10/02/2022 12:44

The statement I quoted did not refer to common law wife. It said specifically common law rules.

babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 12:42

It's not relevant though.

England and Wales has a common law legal system, yes. That means that the law develops through jurisprudence as judges interpret the law on the basis of what has been decided before in relation to a specific point of law. Sometimes a higher court can disagree with a previous decision made by a lower court and the law effectively changes. Sometimes the issue has never come up before and the judges are breaking new ground. But they are interpreting statute, not simply making it up as they go along.

There is no law in this country that gives unmarried partners rights to their partner's property as though they were married when they are not. The phrase "common law wife" (curiously we hear this a lot more than "common law husband"), or "common law marriage" is quite simply meaningless. There is no such thing. If you are not married, in the eyes of the law you are two single people who happen to live together.

Inspectorslack · 10/02/2022 12:28

@Inspectorslack

I was responding specifically to this comment /

Today 11:20 canigooutyet

Nothing stupid about not having common law rules.

Which is legally incorrect.

As I said. I was responding specifically to the above Comment.
Dixiechickonhols · 10/02/2022 12:27

Spodocomodo0 That’s incorrect. Op is in England. There is no common law marriage. Judges don’t have discretion to take ‘motherhood’ into account.
The Op needs to take specialist legal advice. As several posters have stated she might have a case to try and claim a beneficial interest. This isn’t straightforward. Advice won’t be cheap - specialist solicitor and probably barrister, private paying, will want monies on account. Whether op may have a case depends on evidence. What documents she has, what she can prove was agreed, what payments she can prove she’s made and for what eg home improvements. No one on here can say yes or no it’s very complex.
Poster sandgrown is currently going through this. I won’t be crass and ask how much paid in legal costs but I suspect it’s a lot.
This gives an idea of what’s involved if Op goes down that route.
www.3pb.co.uk/content/uploads/TOLATA-A-brief-guide-to-issuing-proceedings-by-Luke-Nelson.pdf

babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 12:26

@Inspectorslack

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law

Common law is the law as decided in cases and recorded in judgements.

This has absolutely nothing to do with the topic under discussion.
Inspectorslack · 10/02/2022 12:03

I was responding specifically to this comment /

Today 11:20 canigooutyet

Nothing stupid about not having common law rules.

Which is legally incorrect.

Lockdownbear · 10/02/2022 11:46

The question isn't do we have common law of course we do. The question is, is common law wife a thing.

I looked it up years ago in Scotland, the answer was year circa 1906 a Judge ruled a woman was wife after 9 mths because of the element of pretence to be man / wife. Circa 1969 a Judge ruled a woman wasn't a wife because they didn't pretend to be married in any way they were co-habitees. I do believe some law change this century means co-habitees have some rights but I don't know about England.

She really needs legal advice.

Inspectorslack · 10/02/2022 11:26

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law

Common law is the law as decided in cases and recorded in judgements.

Blossomtoes · 10/02/2022 11:23

@Inspectorslack

We do have common law rules in this country.

We just don’t have legal recognition of common law wife as a status.

What are those common law rules? I’ve never heard of them.
Inspectorslack · 10/02/2022 11:22

Edit. In England Wales and Northern Ireland.
Not sure on Scotland but believe it is similar.

Inspectorslack · 10/02/2022 11:22

We do have common law rules in this country.

We just don’t have legal recognition of common law wife as a status.

canigooutyet · 10/02/2022 11:20

Nothing stupid about not having common law rules. If the shit hits the fan it's easier to remove the other person from your life. If we had this it would have been a lot harder to remove my violent ex from my property. He would have also had access to my property, savings etc. Things that he couldn't be bothered with.

As for the Will, doesn't matter what it says today and if he's included the op. He could quite easily change it tomorrow, same with he could easily remove her name from his pension and vice versa. You also don't have to put your spouse on your pension, mine has always been named to my eldest (SN), adult dc have named each other.

Blossomtoes · 10/02/2022 11:01

@Momijin

Unfortunately this stupid country's rules doesn't have anything about common law spouse. So, speak to a solicitor but I suspect you've just been paying rent all these years. Stop paying tent and look to buy your own property
Because marriage and its benefits should be an active choice.
AlDanvers · 10/02/2022 10:56

@Spodocomod0

Ok, if common law wife isn't legally recognised, but motherhood still is. It's a technicality.he has entered into an in written contract with her by excepting money every month for thirty years. Judges have discretion.she is not a lodger .
What do you mean he has entered a written contract with her? He hasn't (ie marriage) and thats the issue.

Motherhood isn't a status that means you automatically get a chance of assets. Surely you know that? Why would yiu think it is?

Judges can't just make things up as they go along.

Besides which, that's a lengthy and costly process. Which isn't guaranteed to win. People say 'go to court' like you cab rock up there tomorrow and get it sorted.

Obviously, rules send laws are different in different countries. But unless op drip feeds she lives in a country where having a child means you get a chuck of assets (do any?) it's all irrelevant.

HelloFrostyMorning · 10/02/2022 10:55

@Spodocomod0

Ok, if common law wife isn't legally recognised, but motherhood still is. It's a technicality.he has entered into an in written contract with her by excepting money every month for thirty years. Judges have discretion.she is not a lodger .
I hope you're not a solicitor.
Inspectorslack · 10/02/2022 10:50

@Spodocomod0

Ok, if common law wife isn't legally recognised, but motherhood still is. It's a technicality.he has entered into an in written contract with her by excepting money every month for thirty years. Judges have discretion.she is not a lodger .
No he hasn’t.
Spodocomod0 · 10/02/2022 10:40

Sorry meant unwritten!

Spodocomod0 · 10/02/2022 10:39

Ok, if common law wife isn't legally recognised, but motherhood still is. It's a technicality.he has entered into an in written contract with her by excepting money every month for thirty years. Judges have discretion.she is not a lodger .

dottydodah · 10/02/2022 10:03

I think you would benefit from some legal advice .After so long I would hope you would be entitled to some share of the property .As unfair as it may seem if you are not married it is not straightforward sadly .

babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 10:00

@Chely

That's a bit expensive for a lodger
This.

£700 a month is above the legal limit for rent a room, and presumably she doesn't even have her own room.

I bet he hasn't been paying tax on that.

babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 09:58

@RandomLondoner

You could almost be my soon-to-be-ex. My flat is in my name only, mortgage paid off before she started making any contribution to join finances. She then paid £700 a month plus half of groceries for about 20 years. And a lot more on child-related stuff, which is also a joint expense.

I guess many here would think she should be entitled some equity, But according to my calculation, if I add up all joint expenditure, including what I spent on buying the flat, then deduct the housing equity I got at the end from my contribution, I still paid 75% of our joint costs.

So I would say having paid 700 a month does not necessarily prove any moral entitlement to a share of house equity. It's meaningless in isolation, we need to know everything both parties put in and got out, to come to a conclusion.

I think it's a bit immoral to profit from your partner in this way.
Nomoreusernames1244 · 10/02/2022 09:47

You charged rent to a woman you had children with?! This blows my mind. Did she charge you for use of her womb? Unbelievable

Have you read the update? She is able to buy a 600k house with the money she saved over the course of the marriage, with a pension that will pay off the mortgage when she retires.

She hasn’t been left destitute. Of all joint costs, her £700 was 25%, he contributed the other 75%. This meant her savings and pension were healthy enough to buy her own house.

AlDanvers · 10/02/2022 09:26

I do think the OP has left out some fairly relevant information.

Such as, if he has older kids.

Its also clear she has been aware of his intention to never combine assets for quite a while.

I think this situation is ridiculous, but I don't think op has shated all the information or being duped as such. I think she made a decision that she regrets. Which happens to the best of us.

Naunet · 10/02/2022 09:21

@RandomLondoner

You could almost be my soon-to-be-ex. My flat is in my name only, mortgage paid off before she started making any contribution to join finances. She then paid £700 a month plus half of groceries for about 20 years. And a lot more on child-related stuff, which is also a joint expense.

I guess many here would think she should be entitled some equity, But according to my calculation, if I add up all joint expenditure, including what I spent on buying the flat, then deduct the housing equity I got at the end from my contribution, I still paid 75% of our joint costs.

So I would say having paid 700 a month does not necessarily prove any moral entitlement to a share of house equity. It's meaningless in isolation, we need to know everything both parties put in and got out, to come to a conclusion.

You charged rent to a woman you had children with?! This blows my mind. Did she charge you for use of her womb? Unbelievable.
Swipe left for the next trending thread