Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

My name is not on the mortgage and I pay him £700 per month

395 replies

Star54 · 09/02/2022 17:56

I have been with my partner for 30 plus years, we have grown up children and I work full time in a high pressured role. I have always worked and paid towards the house and the bills. We never married although we got engaged. He is now retired and has been for circa 10 years, I give him £700 per month and pay a significant part of the food bill, I also pay when we go out for meals etc. I have left him before twice but returned in part because he refused to give me any money from the house to start anew. My name is not on the house deeds and there is no mortgage, if I raise it the issue always causes a row and he says that he is saving the family as I could walk off and take money from him. I am at the end of my tether and now fel I should leave. Am I being unreasonable given that he had a property in his own right when we first met (I was 21 and am now in my 50s). I am strong him my job but not assertive in my relationship as I have felt bad for leaving him before.

OP posts:
cherish123 · 10/02/2022 18:22

Effectively, he has been charging you rent. You should consult a solicitor. Not sure what you are entitled to. Maybe you could prove you paid for most of the running of the home costs/costs involved in bringing up the children.

YDBear · 10/02/2022 18:20

@Fairylightsongs

Op, if you rented for thirty years do you feel you’d be entitled to the house. This is no different. It’s his, yoire not married, you have no entitlement, it’s just like paying rent.
Normally when renting you don’t have to have sex with the landlord and bear him two kids, though.
racingnowhere · 10/02/2022 18:19

@Fairylightsongs

Op, if you rented for thirty years do you feel you’d be entitled to the house. This is no different. It’s his, yoire not married, you have no entitlement, it’s just like paying rent.
No its not. When you rent a place its yours whilst you live there. You also have legal rights.

Its clear this man has deliberately set up this situation as a means of coercion - he even says it - he keeps the family together by financially making it difficult for her to leave.

Fluffyhairteddy · 10/02/2022 18:14

No such thing as common law marriage. Ongoing contributions to upkeep of house/mortgage over long period may mean you’ve got an equitable interest which needs to be registered as a charge on the house. You need proper legal advice here to get this going.

CairoLiverpool · 10/02/2022 18:07

If you want to leave him you have the right to do so without worrying about money. More importantly, your first responsibility is towards yourself, you can’t stay in a relationship that is unhappy/unfulfilling out of guilt. I don’t know what the law would say but it seems this is a common law marriage and you have rights. Talk to a lawyer and do what makes you happy.

pomers · 10/02/2022 18:04

@Fairylightsongs

Op, if you rented for thirty years do you feel you’d be entitled to the house. This is no different. It’s his, yoire not married, you have no entitlement, it’s just like paying rent.
Completely untrue. You will be given ‘consideration’ for your contribution both financially and in kind. This is part of contract law. Do not let I’ll informed comments such as this make you afraid to seek advice or leave
yrellim · 10/02/2022 18:04

You are 50, welcome to the club. Lifes too short.

See a solicitor as advised for proper legal advise.
And start looking around for your own home to buy too- look int shared ownership perhaps or over 50, 55 years places tend to be cheaper or simply move area get a 10-15 year mortgage-temporary lodgers.

Do not be held hostage for a house he may never give or leave it to you anyway so you may be in a worse position at 67 if you stay.

All the best

Fluffyhairteddy · 10/02/2022 18:00

I’d be looking to register a charge on tbe house

Mumontour85 · 10/02/2022 17:53

umm..... what now?
Get yourself a lawyer, I would say you are more than entitled to half of the house at LEAST given you pay for most of it. You have proof that you paid into the equity, and you have lived together long enough to certainly have some rights.
He is literally blackmailing you into staying - that is also illegal.
Get out of there, live your life for you and definitely, definitely take what is your on your way out the door!

Sprucewillis · 10/02/2022 17:53

What about a trip to Vegas?

restingbitchface30 · 10/02/2022 17:53

If the mortgage is paid why are you giving him 700 a month? Surely outgoings can’t be any more than 700 a month including food for the 2 of you. You are a bit of a mug sorry. He’s well taking advantage.

PetuniaT · 10/02/2022 17:51

My eldest daughter is in a similar position with a man 15 years her senior - name on the mortgage and she pays it but she's not on the title deeds and it worries me dreadfully. He's got kids with two other women including twins of almost the same age as my daughter, one of whom had just presented him with his first grandchild at the same time as my daughter had her second child prematurely during lockdown. Why do women go for such lowlifes?

Grayday · 10/02/2022 17:48

If your partner is the sole owner, you may have no rights to stay in the home if your partner asks you to leave. However, if you have children, you can ask the court to transfer the property into your name. The court will only do this if it decides it is in the best interests of your children. If you don't have children, you may be able to claim a beneficial interest in your home if you can show you contributed financially by, for example, paying for improvements or towards mortgage repayments. If you do have a beneficial interest in the home, you might be able to stop the other person from selling it. You will need to get legal advice about whether or not you have a beneficial interest.

www.citizensadvice.org.uk/family/living-together-marriage-and-civil-partnership/living-together-and-civil-partnership-legal-differences

dcthatsme · 10/02/2022 17:46

Go and talk to a solicitor immediately. I'm hoping that you can prove that you have been contributing £700 pcm towards the mortgage via bank statements, paper and online records etc. I think you need to sort out the legal position first and foremost. What right has he got to control the family finances? Surely you are in a partnership? If he can't see or respect your point of view and rights I think that is the sign you need to up sticks. I think you need to be careful too. Say he passed away, you would have to fight for a share in the house. It is incredibly important to protect yourself and the fruit of all your hard work.

KarenTheGammonRemoaner · 10/02/2022 17:43

You can create a contract through behaviour. Nothing has to be written or agreed. If he is accepting monthly payments towards the mortgage then in court you will 100% be deemed to be "on the mortgage" for all intents and purposes. Keep doing it. Let him try to swindle you, he will be in for a nice shock.

I studied law.

Plumbuddle · 10/02/2022 17:43

@Star54

I have been with my partner for 30 plus years, we have grown up children and I work full time in a high pressured role. I have always worked and paid towards the house and the bills. We never married although we got engaged. He is now retired and has been for circa 10 years, I give him £700 per month and pay a significant part of the food bill, I also pay when we go out for meals etc. I have left him before twice but returned in part because he refused to give me any money from the house to start anew. My name is not on the house deeds and there is no mortgage, if I raise it the issue always causes a row and he says that he is saving the family as I could walk off and take money from him. I am at the end of my tether and now fel I should leave. Am I being unreasonable given that he had a property in his own right when we first met (I was 21 and am now in my 50s). I am strong him my job but not assertive in my relationship as I have felt bad for leaving him before.
Sorry not reading the rest of this thread as am a family lawyer. Get legal advice immediately before you take any step whatsoever. It will cost you but to not pay for it is a false economy. Ask the solicitor to advise you on all fronts including regarding coercive control as well as property interests. If you don't know which solicitor to pick, get one from the Resolution website. Do not ask anyone but an expert about this subject, there are a lot of myths and ignorance about amongst the general population. There is no short cut to competent global legal advice.
Dixiechickonhols · 10/02/2022 15:17

I suspect Op has done what many other women have done. Moved in with boyfriend who owned a house. Got engaged, had 2 children. Not got around to marrying/can’t afford it/he says it’s only a piece of paper.
Then moved to family house but still in his name. She says children were 4 and 6. Maybe she wasn’t working and mortgage company said only he could get mortgage/go on deeds, maybe it was easier as he was transferring existing mortgage, maybe he was fully aware and deliberately wanted asset in his name. Op may not have been involved in dealing with solicitor etc.
Op certainly isn’t only woman in this position.
I suspect over years she’s realised and buried head in sand. Making out women like this are stupid doesn’t help. Lots of people wrongly believe cohabiting gives rights akin to marriage when it doesn’t.
She obviously urgently needs proper legal advice.
She can help herself immediately by collating documents, sorting her will, sorting who benefits from her pension/death in service.
Best wishes Op if you are still reading.

YouDoYouHun · 10/02/2022 14:49

Im a lawyer myself. You need to speak to a legal professional asap re a potential TOLATA claim. Also, if you havent done already you need to take advice on wills. If you're not left the house under his will you could have a potential inheritance family and dependants act claim if anything were to happen to him.

Jmaho · 10/02/2022 14:30

@Nomoreusernames1244

*Can you imagine that's how your 'soon-to-be-ex-partner' might feel? You know the one that gave birth to your children and no doubt raised them?

Because I mean only a cold, hard-hearted mercenary cunt would have taken that money all those years, whilst doing his little calculations, and would now turf the mother of his children out onto the streets with nothing after a lifetime together.
And you're not like that are you?*

Read tft. Randomlondoner updated: the 25/75 split of household expenses enabled his ex to build up significant savings and pension. She’s just bought a 600k house which will be paid off when she retires.

Hardly turfing her out with nothing.

It wasn't a 75/25 split of expenses. She paid £700 a month for 20 years when there was no mortgage at all plus additional costs for the children. I imagine the £700 each month covered the vast majority of the household bills leaving the OP with a very nice lot of disposable income each month. He is claiming that overall he paid 75% taking into account the purchasing of the property and what he paid before she started contributing. He has obviously worked this out almost to the penny
DogsAndGin · 10/02/2022 13:40

If your £700pcm went towards upkeep, maintenance, remodelling, extensions, plumbers etc then yes I think you may have a reasonable argument that the value of the house has been maintained, in part, by your contributions.

Collate some evidence of transfers you have made to above contractors, or of any suppliers who completed work and were paid for by your partner immediately after you made the transfer to your partner. Ie your money clearly went to him, to be pay for the house work. I would then take that evidence and seek legal advice.

Nomoreusernames1244 · 10/02/2022 13:34

*Can you imagine that's how your 'soon-to-be-ex-partner' might feel? You know the one that gave birth to your children and no doubt raised them?

Because I mean only a cold, hard-hearted mercenary cunt would have taken that money all those years, whilst doing his little calculations, and would now turf the mother of his children out onto the streets with nothing after a lifetime together.
And you're not like that are you?*

Read tft. Randomlondoner updated: the 25/75 split of household expenses enabled his ex to build up significant savings and pension. She’s just bought a 600k house which will be paid off when she retires.

Hardly turfing her out with nothing.

QforCucumber · 10/02/2022 12:59

[quote alwaysontheloo]@RandomLondoner can you read the panic in the OP?

Can you imagine that's how your 'soon-to-be-ex-partner' might feel? You know the one that gave birth to your children and no doubt raised them?

Because I mean only a cold, hard-hearted mercenary cunt would have taken that money all those years, whilst doing his little calculations, and would now turf the mother of his children out onto the streets with nothing after a lifetime together.
And you're not like that are you?[/quote]
@alwaysontheloo don't forget while also managing to remember that his partner lost 1.5 months pay by dropping to half pay for 3 months.

I was only on maternity leave last year, I can guarantee that my DH has no idea what I got paid, how long for, when I dropped to SMP or what part was unpaid. Never mind remembering this many many years later to hold against me.

YayaTata · 10/02/2022 12:50

I agree with PP that the £700 figure is irrelevant without knowing where and how OP lives. Round here it would get you a two bed house to rent, round other parts it would get you a small room in a house share.

The issue is two fold. OP (respectfully) being stupid enough to accept this situation for 30 years and her "partner" refusing to put her on the deeds and get married.

I don't think there is anything wrong with wanting to keep a house you owned yourself prior to a relationship (I appreciate the DP here bought it during the relationship with OP though), but in that case I would not accept any payment toward household expenses precisely because I'd be worried they could then lay claim to the equity in a split.

Why oh why you didn't insist on purchasing in joint names at the time I have no idea. I could understand more if you still lived in the house he owned before you got together but not one you moved into after children and years together.

I'd see a solicitor and even if I weren't entitled to any equity, I'd cut my losses and leave anyway. You'll be £700 a month better off and this isn't a partnership anyway, he's fleecing you whilst giving you no assurance.

Dixiechickonhols · 10/02/2022 12:49

www.natcen.ac.uk/blog/common-law-marriage-a-peculiarly-persistent-myth
I dug this out for a similar thread recently. I’ll admit I was surprised that stats for believing ‘common law marriage’ exists were so high - 46% of adults incorrectly believe it exists. Interestingly stats have remained unchanged since previous survey in 2005. You’d think with internet etc people would be more clued up.