Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

My name is not on the mortgage and I pay him £700 per month

395 replies

Star54 · 09/02/2022 17:56

I have been with my partner for 30 plus years, we have grown up children and I work full time in a high pressured role. I have always worked and paid towards the house and the bills. We never married although we got engaged. He is now retired and has been for circa 10 years, I give him £700 per month and pay a significant part of the food bill, I also pay when we go out for meals etc. I have left him before twice but returned in part because he refused to give me any money from the house to start anew. My name is not on the house deeds and there is no mortgage, if I raise it the issue always causes a row and he says that he is saving the family as I could walk off and take money from him. I am at the end of my tether and now fel I should leave. Am I being unreasonable given that he had a property in his own right when we first met (I was 21 and am now in my 50s). I am strong him my job but not assertive in my relationship as I have felt bad for leaving him before.

OP posts:
Mikey87 · 12/02/2022 13:57

You should not stay with someone due to money. If you leave legally you are entitled to a pay out, although not married you have lived together for 30 years. Any court of law will see your side. Move away and lawyer up, you will be OK.

lap90 · 12/02/2022 12:55

Blimey, he's had it good hasn't he?

SueStan · 12/02/2022 12:45

See a solicitor or possibly a direct access barrister - ring a local barristers chambers, speak to the clerk and explain that you want someone who specialises in TOLATA (Trusts of Land and Trustee Act). The house was bought for the purpose of providing a home for both of you and for your children, so your partner holds it on trust for both of you and you can claim an interest in it.

Beemagirl · 12/02/2022 12:13

@Delphigirl if you can't give constructive advice or practical solutions why criticise others.

Roxy69 · 12/02/2022 11:47

As you are not married and have no rights I am not sure what you think you might be entitled to.

Delphigirl · 11/02/2022 20:21

@ginger21

Well let's face it the legal costs will be less than half the value of the property. Chances of success? Notice of Home Rights can be registered unilaterally. Making a Will? Less than the £700 she's currently paying monthly. These protect her position and after that it depends what she does next ...
You can’t leave something you don’t own to someone else by testamentary disposition. By all means make a will if you don’t have one and have other assets, it this won’t help your legal position re your partner one bit.
Delphigirl · 11/02/2022 20:19

@ginger21

Definitely see a solicitor, ask about a Notice of Home Rights (she'll explain). Have you made a will, leaving your interest in the house to your children? If not, do so, another one for your solicitor. After doing these things, if you then stop paying and stay in the house what's he likely to do? He can't evict you, he can't sue you for unpaid rent as there's no tenancy agreement. Negotiate that you will re-start paying a reasonable amount only after the property is transferred into joint names. This is just an outline, not full legal advice, obviously, but if you get a pro-active solicitor then it's feasible.
This sort of uninformed nonsense is why you should not trust numpties on the internet, no matter how certain they sound. This is wrong from start to finish.
Pedallleur · 11/02/2022 19:00

Not having read the whole thread how was the money paid, cash? DD? Was there a record of the payments and has the recipient paid tax over the years on this income?

Lockdownbear · 11/02/2022 15:36

If you aren’t named on the title deeds
If you’re not married or in a civil partnership, or you haven’t sorted out what happens to your home, you might still be able to prove your right to the home if you can prove you have a 'beneficial interest'. This usually means you've contributed to the home financially.

In court, you’ll need to show a judge how you’ve contributed towards paying for the home - this can be difficult, socontact your nearest Citizens Advicebefore you start. An adviser can help you through the process

From CAB for England.
The Op needs legal advice

ginger21 · 11/02/2022 15:32

@DrSbaitso - rhetorical question?

DrSbaitso · 11/02/2022 14:37

[quote ginger21]@Beautiful3 - you are completely wrong.[/quote]
Is she?

Blossomtoes · 11/02/2022 14:36

[quote ginger21]@Beautiful3 - you are completely wrong.[/quote]
She’s not. A notice of home rights only applies to people leaving a marriage or civil partnership.

www.gov.uk/stay-in-home-during-separation-or-divorce

ginger21 · 11/02/2022 14:32

@Beautiful3 - you are completely wrong.

ginger21 · 11/02/2022 14:29

Well let's face it the legal costs will be less than half the value of the property. Chances of success? Notice of Home Rights can be registered unilaterally. Making a Will? Less than the £700 she's currently paying monthly. These protect her position and after that it depends what she does next ...

Beautiful3 · 11/02/2022 14:20

You're not married. It's his house. You'd get nothing.

UppermillSarah · 11/02/2022 14:09

What a crazy arrangement. As others have said, get legal advice and then take whatever action protects your interests

ginger21 · 11/02/2022 14:03

Definitely see a solicitor, ask about a Notice of Home Rights (she'll explain). Have you made a will, leaving your interest in the house to your children? If not, do so, another one for your solicitor. After doing these things, if you then stop paying and stay in the house what's he likely to do? He can't evict you, he can't sue you for unpaid rent as there's no tenancy agreement. Negotiate that you will re-start paying a reasonable amount only after the property is transferred into joint names. This is just an outline, not full legal advice, obviously, but if you get a pro-active solicitor then it's feasible.

NWE231 · 11/02/2022 14:02

how much is all this legal advice going to cost and what are the chances of success?

AlDanvers · 11/02/2022 10:07

@M0RVEN that's all assumptions. Op has given next to no detail at all.

So again, it's all based on assumptions. 'Pretty sure' when there's 2 brief posts, doesn't mean anything. Loads of people post things and leave really important information out. Like the poster that left out that her and her partner weren't together when he slept with someone else.

I can't understand why someone would accept this, without good reasoning either. She left sever times and only came back because he wouldnt give her money from the house. She could a did leave. She chose not to.

But I don't think anyone can be pretty sure of anything. I remember my cousin moaning she paid board every month and there was never her favourite food in. She paid £10 a week, twice.

All I am saying is that no one can post in absolutes. We can guess, but we can't say definitely.

Gonnagetgoing · 11/02/2022 10:03

@2205A

Some of these comments are so unhelpful! As you’ve been there so many years and contributed towards that house and the upkeep etc you have theoretically been paying into it. After an amount of time you do have some entitlement to the costs.

A friend of mine is going through a similar thing - and has been advised that she has entitlement.

As others have said, get legal advice and get out when the time is right - if that’s what you want Smile

@2205A - I agree with you. I used to work for a lawyers and we occasionally got these sorts of queries - can't recall exactly what happened as it was a while ago.

Legally, on paper, yes it doesn't look good.

But the adult children will kick up a fuss re their father and OP will have bank statements showing a monthly payment going out every month as rent.

My stepdad I think had similar - parents not married - but he's been paying rent into the house and contributing re upkeep and physical repairs - so a lawyer told me yes, my DM could get the house if they separated but he could have some form of entitlement - the house was in her name for many years and set to go to children (me and DB) but we both thought that was unfair.

That's what I said above to the lawyer - it's pointless saying unkind and thoughtless comments as then OP might think it's not worthwhile/she won't get anything so wouldn't seek legal advice.

So OP if you come back - please, please go to a good - preferably local or nearby (to save travelling miles to see them) high street solicitor - check google reviews. Some lawyers do both family and conveyancing/property law and some do it separately. You should get a free 30 minute phone or in person consultation. take care. Smile

Lockdownbear · 11/02/2022 09:31

What I can’t understand is why someone would let this continue for 30 years without taking action

Fear, control, kids. She must have loved him at some point. We don't know her background she might not have had family to turn to either.
Sad but so many think people are CF if they move in with a partner and not expect to pay rent even if the partner owns the house.
My answer is the non-owner should pay half the interest, and half other monthly bills but nothing to the mortgage repayment they should put money aside in a savings pot instead so they have something to fall back on should it go belly up.
The majority knock me down as q CF why should the person live rent free!

HappySM1 · 11/02/2022 09:20

Ask a solicitor about a constructive or resulting trust.

M0RVEN · 11/02/2022 09:08

@AlDanvers

The problem here, is that we have no clue of any details. So anything is a guess.

He may have been explicitly clear that its she had no interest in the property or she may have signed something to say she hasn't.

It could be a multi million pound house and £700 could deemed very cheap rent. Don't think op has even confirmed how long she has been paying so much to like there.

Legal advice for her own situation is definitely best as they can look at everything. No one can say wether she does have a case or doesn't. Or even if she will win. Or how much it will cost vs how much she will get.

Its all speculation. As is the 'well it could be just rent' or the 'he has manipulated you and abusing you'. There could be details that spin everything on its head.

The Op says she’s been with him for more than 30 years - she met him when she was 21 and she’s now in her 50s.

She says She has always worked full time, even though they have children.

I’m pretty sure she would have mentioned it if she has signed any legal documents . And even if she had done so, they would be invalid ( or at least easily challenged ) if she did not have independent legal advice at the time.

As her partner is obviously a clever man, he would know this.

And I also think it’s likely that the OP would have mentioned if they were multi millionaires Hmm .

I assume he’s a lot older than her - he’s at least 70 while she’s mid 50s. I can see how this unequal set up could start when they were ( say ) 21 and 36.

What I can’t understand is why someone would let this continue for 30 years without taking action.

Thebingo2011 · 11/02/2022 08:59

Hi

I was in a similar situation with my partner .
I would say it varies where you live .
As in essence this is rent .
I own my property with a morgage .
My partner pays me towards bills ect .
Which was made clear when she moved into the property .
I charged her what a room is in a shared house in the local area as I couldn't decide what was fair .
She jumped at it .
Due to her paying £1000 a month for a small flat above a pub which she didn't like to a house with a garden ect .
I don't even charge her half that with all bills .
She has asked about ownership before .
So I did say if she matched half the deposit I paid and half the morgage and increase since I've been paying the morgage .
At the time bills and morgage were around £1200 .
Which she instantly declined .
As I've saved since I was 17 towards a property.
When she come from a more well of family and was given substantial money at points in her life which she spent on hoildays ect ect and didn't save any .
which is fine but I won't lose a lot of my equity what I sacrificed luxurys for .
Plus I have children from a previous partner . So I need to make sure there cared for .
I have wrote in my will she can stay in the property if I die .
But has no ownership ..
Then when she dies will go to the children .
Where I live just outside london .
You won't get a studio flat for £700 Inc bills .
1 bedroom in a shared house around here is £650+ .
I would look what a bedroom in a shared house costs and offer that amount .
If he declines go and live with someone else .
I would imagine your struggle saving/geting a morgage now unfortunately .
Unless u have a substantial amount of savings

I do understand u have children and it's a long term relationship , but £700 may be less than if u was private renting and splitting the bills ect . And it's his property to do as he wishes . It's your choice to pay/stay ect

AlDanvers · 11/02/2022 08:30

The problem here, is that we have no clue of any details. So anything is a guess.

He may have been explicitly clear that its she had no interest in the property or she may have signed something to say she hasn't.

It could be a multi million pound house and £700 could deemed very cheap rent. Don't think op has even confirmed how long she has been paying so much to like there.

Legal advice for her own situation is definitely best as they can look at everything. No one can say wether she does have a case or doesn't. Or even if she will win. Or how much it will cost vs how much she will get.

Its all speculation. As is the 'well it could be just rent' or the 'he has manipulated you and abusing you'. There could be details that spin everything on its head.

Swipe left for the next trending thread