Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think they might actually read a book in English? (Secondary)

179 replies

runningoutofnewnames · 09/02/2022 16:00

DS's English class start reading books, then the teacher uses them to demonstrate some kind of grammar exercise or other construction of the English language - then they never actually finish it.

He's in Year 8, and they've only read one book from beginning to end in class since he started at secondary last year.

They're told they're not allowed to read ahead and often they're not even given the book, they're given photocopied sheets each lesson.

So, they read half of Animal Farm. The point of that was to teach them how to write a paragraph with a persuasive argument, apparently. Once they'd done that exercise, the module was finished and they stopped reading the book. DS loves reading and wants to discuss the content of the book in class. This isn't allowed.

This half term, they've done dystopian fiction but they've only read passages from books, not whole books (e.g. photo copied pages from the Hunger Games). The point of that was to demonstrate the elements needed to do a "creative" short story exercise - they were marked on the inclusion of these specific elements, not encouraged to be creative.

He's only read one whole book at school since he started nearly 18 months ago.

Do your DC read whole books in school?

We used to read loads when I was young! We did English Language AND literature when I went to school - it wasn't all about the mechanics of language, it was about appreciating books too and exploring ideas. I loved doing Animal Farm. We certainly read it to the end!

There's a similar focus on the mechanics and lack of creativity in his art lessons too, but that's another story.

Is this is the curriculum (fucking Gove's influence, still?) or his school, I wonder?

OP posts:
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 09/02/2022 16:09

That sounds fairly standard to me and I did my GCSE's over 15 years ago now.

We rarely read full books until AS level. It was mainly symbolism and grammar and syntax - focusing on specific chapters or paragraphs from the books rather than the entire books themselves.

Faffandahalf · 09/02/2022 16:06

We teach all of:
Roll of thunder (7)
Anita and Me (play in 8)
Of mice and men (yr9’s as it’s not gcse any more)

Aaannnd…that’s probably it.

We don’t read an entire shakespeare play at ks3. We often use extracts of novels in order to teach creative writing (that’s pretty standard really). We use extracts from novels for other things too.

There just isn’t the time. We have assessments every 5-6 weeks. You can’t read a full text and teach the skills necessary for the assessment in that space of time. Teachers would love to just read and talk and enjoy teaching a love of literature. The reality of the English classroom is very different. It’s all about progress and data entry points and the assessment flight plan. 😴😴

ChiselandBits · 09/02/2022 16:05

I think DS, also y8 has similar, but we did read ahead, watched the film and talked about the story a lot, the Russian Revolution etc. Same with Lord of the Flies. I think there is a funding issue with multiple copies of books and they get handed out and not returned and time constraints are such that if they do read the whole book in class they won't cover anything else. Maybe if schools weren't told to teach every bloody social skill and life skill they'd have time to reach academic subjects properly (I'm a teacher btw )

ClariceQuiff · 09/02/2022 16:03

I agree it's unreasonable but as a workaround, could you borrow the books from the library (or borrow as e-books) so he can finish them?

He mightn't be allowed to read ahead in class but they can't stop him reading what he wants at home.

Personally I would buy a copy of Animal Farm if you don't have one, as it's the sort of book you want to re-read.