Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand how a jury reaches its verdict

84 replies

Sportslady44 · 09/02/2022 15:19

I am following a court case at the moment and have been in the public gallery for a few days.

Listening to the evidence and prosecution and defence statements and summing up etc.

I wonder how the hell does a jury know who to believe. Both prosecution and defence make you believe they are right? So much to listen too etc and consider?

The only person who knows is the person on trial right?
How do the jury know?

I guess there is no fairer way of deciding but i realised that i wouldnt really want to make that call when you dont know?

OP posts:
Crunched · 09/02/2022 15:44

I found it a privilege to be a juror for exactly the reasons ElizabethinherGermanGarden states.
Despite being 12 strangers from very different backgrounds, we managed to co-operate and give everyone's opinion fair consideration. We reached a 11 to 1 majority in a pretty complex case.

ElizabethinherGermanGarden · 09/02/2022 15:37

It's really difficult. If you are on a jury with a disparate group of people and the evidence isn't a slam-dunk, the interesting thing is how entrenched some people get on reasonable doubt. I was on a jury where we were directed by the judge that we were entitled to draw reasonable inferences from the evidence, but the defence barrister really hammered the idea that we couldn't draw inferences, we had to have direct proof - the judge called the barrister out and said that he was wrong; reasonable inferences based on an accumulation of evidence are allowed, but at that point a couple of jurors had decided it wasn't fully proven and really dug in.

The amount of evidence you have to sift through in a complex case is huge and some jurors don't want to or struggle to read it all through again after the cases have been presented.

We reached a majority decision in the end as couldn't reach unanimous verdict and it was actually really quite an upsetting process. The thing that was great, though, is how seriously everyone on the jury took it. We took a week to reach a verdict and it was serious hard work every day. No one messed around or was flippant or casual.

Lockheart · 09/02/2022 15:35

Not sure what that errant 'based' is doing there!

Lockheart · 09/02/2022 15:34

It's not about "belief", or at least it shouldn't be. They weigh up the evidence and decide whether or not the accused is guilty beyond reasonable doubt based.

givemushypeasachance · 09/02/2022 15:29

Based on the evidence presented, do you think beyond reasonable doubt the defendant did what they're being prosecuted for. If not, you find them not guilty. And 12 of you, or less if allowed to have a majority opinion, have to reach that threshold.

I'm always amazed anyone gets found guilty at trial tbh!

BigFatLiar · 09/02/2022 15:26

I think a lot of it goes on personal bias.
From experience... the police charged him so he must be guilty; he looks the sort; she's such a nice looking girl she wouldn't have done that.
If there's no real proof it's just a matter of who you believe, your own bias comes into play.

Namechangehereandnow · 09/02/2022 15:23

The judge also points them to facts of law. Actual law not theories. It’s about literally the letter of the law that can be proven, not who you believe.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 09/02/2022 15:23

You're supposed to decide on the evidence. If there isn't enough actual evidence to convict, then you can't. In theory anyway. But that's the yardstick.

ThePants999 · 09/02/2022 15:21

That's why there are 12 of them, and why it takes them somewhere between hours and weeks to reach a verdict. They discuss everything they've heard and how to weight it.