Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand how a jury reaches its verdict

84 replies

Sportslady44 · 09/02/2022 15:19

I am following a court case at the moment and have been in the public gallery for a few days.

Listening to the evidence and prosecution and defence statements and summing up etc.

I wonder how the hell does a jury know who to believe. Both prosecution and defence make you believe they are right? So much to listen too etc and consider?

The only person who knows is the person on trial right?
How do the jury know?

I guess there is no fairer way of deciding but i realised that i wouldnt really want to make that call when you dont know?

OP posts:
IntermittentParps · 09/02/2022 16:13

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

It's a shame that jury groups can be swayed by more vocal members rather than being able to have an open discussion on it all. It's such a massive responsibility.
You appoint a foreperson, who 'chairs' the discussions and hopefully makes sure everyone understands, participates and is heard. I agree with Lockheart it's a human system and therefore basically the worst option apart from all the other worst options. What struck me, and stays with me, is that our judge impressed upon us that we must be sure the person was guilty (the term 'reasonable doubt' wasn't used; I think this is deliberate as 'sure' is a much more relatable term for most people). He said this was not to protect the guilty but to protect the innocent. I've thought about that a lot since. It may well mean that some people who should be locked up get to walk the streets; but the alternative, an innocent person being stuck in prison, is far far worse.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 09/02/2022 16:13

Although from 1957 USA, the film 12 Angry Men is a compelling fictional account of the process.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/02/2022 16:11

It was a majority verdict and they barely even indicated their agreement at that stage - heads down, mumbling etc. Absolute twats

Let's hope they never find themselves in the Dock.

BooksAndHooks · 09/02/2022 16:11

You don’t need to decide if they are guilty or innocent only if there is reasonable doubt. If there is reasonable doubt regardless of who you believe it should be not guilty.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/02/2022 16:10

@anotherheadache

I've never been on a jury, before they sit, are they provided the points to prove? As in if it's an aggravate burglary for example, is it explained to them what the points to prove are in law to make it 'aggravated' rather than just burglary?
Explanations to the Jury are provided throughout- before the defendant comes in, during the trial if the Judge suspects more clarification is required, and during the deliberation at the Jury's request.
Traumdeuter · 09/02/2022 16:09

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

It's a shame that jury groups can be swayed by more vocal members rather than being able to have an open discussion on it all. It's such a massive responsibility.
When I was on a jury a few years ago, there were a few people who said nothing in the several hours we were deliberating, though. Not a peep, even when directly asked for their input. It was a majority verdict and they barely even indicated their agreement at that stage - heads down, mumbling etc. Absolute twats.
IntermittentParps · 09/02/2022 16:09

@anotherheadache

I've never been on a jury, before they sit, are they provided the points to prove? As in if it's an aggravate burglary for example, is it explained to them what the points to prove are in law to make it 'aggravated' rather than just burglary?
Yes, you get given a copy of what the charge is to refer to while you're in the jury room. The judge may also direct you about specific elements to be sure of/bear in mind.
IntermittentParps · 09/02/2022 16:08

@Sportslady44

The jury have to decide on this one as to whether it was murder or manslaughter and whether the person meant it and planned it or was mentally ill at the time.

Only one person who knows this?

I was on a jury in a case a bit like this (except the charge was GBH). Two expert witnesses in mental health were called, one for the defence and one for the prosecution. Even the prosecution expert said in their opinion the defendant was not in their right mind while committing the crime. It was an easy and quick unanimous 'not guilty by reason of insanity' from us. Surely there are expert witnesses in play in this case?

Of course, if the prosecution expert witness had said, 'Actually, not sure he was mentally ill at the time', then it wouldn't have been so simple. But I assume the witness would have had to present their opinion/evidence as to why they thought that.

nordica · 09/02/2022 16:07

The burden of proof is on the prosecutor and the jury is provided with all the facts and evidence. The defendant does not need to prove their innocence.

When I did jury duty, it initially seemed like a straightforward case but the longer it went on, the more unsure I was. We had really long discussions in the jury room and reached a majority verdict in the end as we couldn't all agree. It was quite shocking (but not surprising) how much people are swayed by their prejudices ("he seems like a dodgy type so he's clearly done something wrong even if he didn't do this") Shock But as there are 12 people, it balances things out a lot. I was actually thinking not guilty and quite strongly held onto that view despite some clearly wanting for us all to agree so we could get it done.

anotherheadache · 09/02/2022 16:07

I've never been on a jury, before they sit, are they provided the points to prove? As in if it's an aggravate burglary for example, is it explained to them what the points to prove are in law to make it 'aggravated' rather than just burglary?

Lockheart · 09/02/2022 16:05

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

It's a shame that jury groups can be swayed by more vocal members rather than being able to have an open discussion on it all. It's such a massive responsibility.
It is, but it's a human system and humans are flawed.

Unless we develop some sort of psychic ability or foolproof lie detector test, a jury of a decent number of people is the best way we have and that will mean that some people go free that shouldn't (and vice versa, although that will be much rarer).

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/02/2022 16:04

Good point. The Jury should always walk in on day one with the mindset "this person is innocent".

Hopefully the information shared from both sides will then give jurors an end point they are comfortable with.

Zilla1 · 09/02/2022 16:02

But in a criminal case in the UK, the starting point isn't in the middle. Does the prosecution demonstrate that the evidence shows an offence occurred beyond reasonable doubt and all the other requirements and tests. If it doesn't (and unfortunately the case I observed didn't, the prosecution case was an assertion of a story with no sound evidence. The defendants were found guilty after the judge directed the jury) then the defendants should be found innocent (or not proven in Scotland?). If a civil case with a jury then balance of probability.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/02/2022 16:02

It's a shame that jury groups can be swayed by more vocal members rather than being able to have an open discussion on it all. It's such a massive responsibility.

BigFatLiar · 09/02/2022 16:01

@Cattenberg

If the jury discusses the evidence, then doesn’t agree, what happens next? I know the judge will sometimes accept a majority verdict, but I’m interested in what happens before then. Does the jury just keep on discussing the points of disagreement until one side gives in? It must be very intense.
Basically yes or they tell the judge that they can't reach a verdict and that's unlikely to change. As @deeplyrooted says peer pressure plays a big part.
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/02/2022 15:59

The jury have to decide on this one as to whether it was murder or manslaughter and whether the person meant it and planned it or was mentally ill at the time

In this case, as a Juror, I would need evidence of a mental illness in order to use that "fact".

I would then hope to have been given evidence of premeditation, intent, any threats etc made.

Then I'd want to discuss reasonable outcome - I.e did what they do actually have the potential for death? Is it common sense that if they did X then death would occur?

deeplyrooted · 09/02/2022 15:56

I heard a radio discussion on this once and peer pressure to fall in with the majority and get home quickly seemed to be a key factor in many cases. Quite a few jurors said that the experience made them very wary of ever having to depend on the system,

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/02/2022 15:55

I've done Jury Duty. The Judge was exceptionally clear that if there was the slightest bit of doubt, we had to reach a Not Guilty verdict.

The Prosecutions says "we did it, here's why we are saying that"
The Defence say "ah but this could have happened, this did or didn't happen, this alternative scenario could be true"

If the Defences argument is enough to cast a doubt over what the Prosecution (and evidence) tells you happened, then you have to choose Not Guilty.

Cattenberg · 09/02/2022 15:55

If the jury discusses the evidence, then doesn’t agree, what happens next? I know the judge will sometimes accept a majority verdict, but I’m interested in what happens before then. Does the jury just keep on discussing the points of disagreement until one side gives in? It must be very intense.

Justcallmebebes · 09/02/2022 15:52

It is, and this is one reason why the conviction rates for rape and sexual abuse cases are low. In many cases the evidence is not strong enough to prove a crime was committed beyond reasonable doubt. This does not mean that it did not happen and that the accused is innocent, but it does mean that the test has not been met to convict / sentence.

This is what happened in the rape trial I was a juror on. The Judge criticised the police for bringing a case with such poor evidence and so badly put together. There was no real concrete evidence, they couldn't even give us a definite date the alleged attack took place on. He may have been guilty but there is no way we could have convicted him on what was put before us. It was very much "he said/did / She said/did" but no proof or evidence whatsoever

Sportslady44 · 09/02/2022 15:52

The jury have to decide on this one as to whether it was murder or manslaughter and whether the person meant it and planned it or was mentally ill at the time.

Only one person who knows this?

OP posts:
Lockheart · 09/02/2022 15:48

@Sportslady44

Where the accussed says they were sexually abused as a child by this person when they were younger but they didnt mention it until after they were arrested how do you know whether they are telling the truth?

There is absolutely no way anyone apart from the two people involved know for sure whether abuse took place if there are no witnessess..

Very hard for a jury to call on that one they werent there.

It is, and this is one reason why the conviction rates for rape and sexual abuse cases are low. In many cases the evidence is not strong enough to prove a crime was committed beyond reasonable doubt. This does not mean that it did not happen and that the accused is innocent, but it does mean that the test has not been met to convict / sentence.
BigFatLiar · 09/02/2022 15:46

@Lockheart

It's not about "belief", or at least it shouldn't be. They weigh up the evidence and decide whether or not the accused is guilty beyond reasonable doubt based.
Our jury had a strong chairwoman who managed to convince most of the jury that the reasonable doubt was only for murder other than that you just had to think that one was more believable than the other. We had next to no guidance from anyone on what we should do.
Justcallmebebes · 09/02/2022 15:45

I've served on a jury twice. The first trial it was a no brainer - not guilty and everyone agreed so it was easy and we were done in a couple of hours. That was a rape trial

The second one 90% of us thought guilty but a couple of people picked at certain elements of the evidence. It took 2 days before we all finally agreed on a guilty verdict. One person very reluctantly agreed with the majority. Turned out after giving our verdict that he had a long and violent past history anyway and by all accounts was a dangerous individual. That was a violent assault and robbery

Sportslady44 · 09/02/2022 15:45

Where the accussed says they were sexually abused as a child by this person when they were younger but they didnt mention it until after they were arrested how do you know whether they are telling the truth?

There is absolutely no way anyone apart from the two people involved know for sure whether abuse took place if there are no witnessess..

Very hard for a jury to call on that one they werent there.

OP posts: