Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand how a jury reaches its verdict

84 replies

Sportslady44 · 09/02/2022 15:19

I am following a court case at the moment and have been in the public gallery for a few days.

Listening to the evidence and prosecution and defence statements and summing up etc.

I wonder how the hell does a jury know who to believe. Both prosecution and defence make you believe they are right? So much to listen too etc and consider?

The only person who knows is the person on trial right?
How do the jury know?

I guess there is no fairer way of deciding but i realised that i wouldnt really want to make that call when you dont know?

OP posts:
TheHaka · 09/02/2022 17:36

@IntermittentParps

Champion, yes, that sounds clear and yes, I think many are very different. One I did was sexual assault: a woman on her own in her flat and a man who came to give her a massage. No one else there. No physical evidence. It was awful. We couldn't agree, even as a majority, so it got thrown out.
Plus you should never, ever discuss it outside the courtroom!
TheHaka · 09/02/2022 17:33

The judge direct you, & will sometimes accept a 10-2 or 11-1 verdict.

lljkk · 09/02/2022 17:24

The judge is supposed to give them guidance about the very specific points they are supposed to decide. So they can narrow their decisions. And what exactly the charge is & the legal burden of proof for being convicted of that crime.

I listen to a lot of legal podcasts.

Lawyers will tell you that juries are fickle, however...

sometimes American jurors get interviewed afterwards & will break down how they decided. the recent podcast about the Silicon valley con artists, Elizabeth Holmes, has quite a bit of detail how the jury decided. They graded witnesses by credibility for instance.

I have a close relative who is a judge, so has served on a panel of judges which tends to be invoked rather than jury, preferentially by defendents often, only when the basic evidence isn't in dispute, but whether the story meets the threshold for certain levels of the crime (ie, manslaughter vs. 1st degree homicide, and the corresponding severity of penalties that follow from different crimes).

Susu49 · 09/02/2022 17:15

Interesting that judges seem to be encouraging "You must be sure". I always wondered what defined "reasonable doubt". Hmm

IntermittentParps · 09/02/2022 17:10

Champion, yes, that sounds clear and yes, I think many are very different. One I did was sexual assault: a woman on her own in her flat and a man who came to give her a massage. No one else there. No physical evidence.
It was awful. We couldn't agree, even as a majority, so it got thrown out.

ChampionOfTheSun · 09/02/2022 17:07

I sat on the jury for an ABH case when I did jury service and for that case there was some very damning evidence, including blood spatter and forensics which made it simple for us to come to a guilty verdict. We weren't just presented with people saying that this happened and that happened. We had pictures of the scene, officers who were there giving evidence, social worker reports of historic abuse, pictures of the alleged weapon, video evidence from a child who witnessed the attack etc. If those things weren't presented it would have been much harder, of course! I was lucky that the jury I sat on were all very balanced people and there was no peer pressure or anything. That said, the case was quite clear, maybe would have been different if it were less so? I'm not sure.

IntermittentParps · 09/02/2022 17:06

@MrsRobinsonsHandprints

Always remember you are found innocent or guilty on the basis of 12 people too stupid to get out of jury service.

(Apologies can't remember who said it)

Thankfully, I can't say that was the case in mine. It is a lottery though; but I guess that's why you have a) careful direction from the judge and b) twelve people ie a large enough pool that there should be a range.
IntermittentParps · 09/02/2022 17:05

@DazedandConfused3

Oh I am absolutely with you on this one! I was once at a trial where in my mind the answer was either a) offence x and y if you believed the prosecution [essentially they’d had article x with them and therefor they had also committed offence Y] or b) offence Z if you believed the defence [they had not had article x with them and therefor committed offence Z] . The jury went for just guilty on offence Y. Still no idea why but I think there was probably a bit of horse trading in the Jury room
Not in the jury room, surely; it's only the twelve jurors who are ever in there/party to the conversations in there. Do you mean horse trading between the prosecution and defence counsels?
BigFatLiar · 09/02/2022 17:01

@Youdoyoutoday

I served on a jury for a historical rape case and I'm sorry to say, it was ridiculous, how the CPS thought it would get a conviction, I don't know. No physical evidence, all based on 1 single statement from the woman who had a mental health issues, a troubled childhood and who was taken in by her friends family. She said the older brother of the friend raped her on multiple occasions even whilst his own mother was in the room!! Such a bizarre case and a massive waste of money in my opinion. We had to be sure beyond reasonable doubt that he was guilty, we just couldn't!!
Unfortunately some juries would have convicted as a young woman wouldn't have made it up, no evidence required. Just a lottery who you get on the jury.
Youdoyoutoday · 09/02/2022 16:54

I served on a jury for a historical rape case and I'm sorry to say, it was ridiculous, how the CPS thought it would get a conviction, I don't know. No physical evidence, all based on 1 single statement from the woman who had a mental health issues, a troubled childhood and who was taken in by her friends family. She said the older brother of the friend raped her on multiple occasions even whilst his own mother was in the room!! Such a bizarre case and a massive waste of money in my opinion. We had to be sure beyond reasonable doubt that he was guilty, we just couldn't!!

DazedandConfused3 · 09/02/2022 16:53

Oh I am absolutely with you on this one! I was once at a trial where in my mind the answer was either a) offence x and y if you believed the prosecution [essentially they’d had article x with them and therefor they had also committed offence Y] or b) offence Z if you believed the defence [they had not had article x with them and therefor committed offence Z] . The jury went for just guilty on offence Y. Still no idea why but I think there was probably a bit of horse trading in the Jury room

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 09/02/2022 16:52

Always remember you are found innocent or guilty on the basis of 12 people too stupid to get out of jury service.

(Apologies can't remember who said it)

Laiste · 09/02/2022 16:50

@deeplyrooted

I heard a radio discussion on this once and peer pressure to fall in with the majority and get home quickly seemed to be a key factor in many cases. Quite a few jurors said that the experience made them very wary of ever having to depend on the system,
This was DHs experience.

He and one other were unsure but the rest just wanted to get home and the pressure was awful.

Aworldofmyown · 09/02/2022 16:49

@Sportslady44

Where the accussed says they were sexually abused as a child by this person when they were younger but they didnt mention it until after they were arrested how do you know whether they are telling the truth?

There is absolutely no way anyone apart from the two people involved know for sure whether abuse took place if there are no witnessess..

Very hard for a jury to call on that one they werent there.

DP was a juror on a case like this. It was awful as there was no way of knowing and no evidence (50 year old case too)
scaredsadandstuck · 09/02/2022 16:49

I was on a jury years ago. It was fascinating. One case we said not guilty - I actually can't remember the details, but there was definitely reasonable doubt about it, even though I think we also though the person concerned was not completely innocent.

The second got thrown out because the judge said it was clearly a 'he said, he said' case and no strong evidence either way.

The third we agreed guilty and found out that the person had a long string of other convictions. The case was for drug dealing - he was so young really it was very sad. His defence was that the reason police had found him with lots and lots of drugs individually wrapped up was so he knew how much he was taking. The scales and cash we just coincidental. Based on the evidence we heard, we were sure he was dealing drugs.

knittingaddict · 09/02/2022 16:46

@Justcallmebebes

I've served on a jury twice. The first trial it was a no brainer - not guilty and everyone agreed so it was easy and we were done in a couple of hours. That was a rape trial

The second one 90% of us thought guilty but a couple of people picked at certain elements of the evidence. It took 2 days before we all finally agreed on a guilty verdict. One person very reluctantly agreed with the majority. Turned out after giving our verdict that he had a long and violent past history anyway and by all accounts was a dangerous individual. That was a violent assault and robbery

My husband was a jury member years ago and had a similar experience. It was a "going equipped to break in" trial, so nothing violent. My husband has a strong sense of fairness and did agonise more than others on the jury about making the right decision, but did agree that the man was guilty. He said that it was a huge relief when they read out a list of his previous convictions.
formalineadeline · 09/02/2022 16:43

Of course there are fairer ways of deciding.

A panel of experts judges who have to provide a written decision that can be challenged if their basis is faulty (a jury's decision can't be challenged because they never have to provide their reasons).

An inquisitorial system that is focused on establishing facts rather than our adversarial system that is pure theatre.

There are loads of fairer and more effective ways functioning very well in other parts of the world.

YellowAndGreenToBeSeen · 09/02/2022 16:39

It’s not the case you are never told - blanket ruling - about a defendants past convictions. I sat as a juror on a case and we were told his previous. He had used the characters of the prosecution witnesses as part of his defence so the judge ruled we were able to hear his.

And - as PP - you are given the law by the judge. That is where job - to direct the jury to the finite and complete law. And it’s that legal line you apply to the evidence.

Jury service is one of the hardest things I’ve ever done. A huge responsibility. After a 2 week trial, we deliberated and agonised for a week to reach our verdict. Emotionally draining but each and every person in the room was completely determined to see justice done and everyone one of us got space to be heard and to listen. It was an honour to serve with such a committed jury. Even if we didn’t all agree, there was respect for every point of view.

ruthieness · 09/02/2022 16:38

I think some jurors apply the wrong test
"beyond a shadow of a doubt"
and get fixated on any remote possibility that is most unlikely to have actually happened.

If the jury cannot reach a unanimous decision or an acceptable majority verdict then they are a hung jury and are discharged - the prosecution then can decide whether or not to have a retrial.

DdraigGoch · 09/02/2022 16:31

Yes, past convictions usually aren't disclosed until it is time to sentence. Otherwise we'd have "this man has been committing burglary since the age of 10, of course he did it this time too."

Pazuzu · 09/02/2022 16:21

@Justcallmebebes

I've served on a jury twice. The first trial it was a no brainer - not guilty and everyone agreed so it was easy and we were done in a couple of hours. That was a rape trial

The second one 90% of us thought guilty but a couple of people picked at certain elements of the evidence. It took 2 days before we all finally agreed on a guilty verdict. One person very reluctantly agreed with the majority. Turned out after giving our verdict that he had a long and violent past history anyway and by all accounts was a dangerous individual. That was a violent assault and robbery

That's why they don't tell you until after.

Even much as some people are utter scumbags, you can't have them convicted for the crime in question just because of anything else they've done.

psychomath · 09/02/2022 16:19

I was a juror on a case where it was one person's word against another - even without any physical evidence, we decided the accused was guilty based on the fact that their account of events seemed implausible, they contradicted themselves on a few occasions, and on careful scrutiny of interview transcripts and police accounts there were things that wouldn't have made much sense if they hadn't done what they were accused of. The prosecution also had a witness to the immediate aftermath of the crime who had no obvious motive to lie, and in fact would have had quite a strong motive to avoid getting involved in the case at all. On balance, it just seemed overwhelmingly more likely that the defendant had done it.

The whole experience did make me think it would be easy to get away with a lot of crimes if you could manage to come across as respectable and keep your story straight. Most criminals aren't exactly the sharpest tools in the shed though, and police interviews are designed to catch people out if they're lying.

DdraigGoch · 09/02/2022 16:17

@Sportslady44

The jury have to decide on this one as to whether it was murder or manslaughter and whether the person meant it and planned it or was mentally ill at the time.

Only one person who knows this?

Manslaughter through diminished responsibility is quite a common plea. Be careful how much you post OP, if they haven't yet given a verdict. It may identify the case (I know of one which is ongoing at the moment).
Leftbutcameback · 09/02/2022 16:14

Guidance from the judge is very important. When I was on the jury in a complicated trial he did a flow chart for us. We were told “you must be sure” to give a guilty verdict. I think this is the new wording rather than beyond reasonable doubt.

We had heard about 9 days of evidence but not all of it was actually relevant. There were some key parts and we had made notes and looked at those. We asked the judge for clarification on one point. It want that difficult tbh (but I did a lot of criminal law as part of my degree so that did help).

DdraigGoch · 09/02/2022 16:13

@Sportslady44

Where the accussed says they were sexually abused as a child by this person when they were younger but they didnt mention it until after they were arrested how do you know whether they are telling the truth?

There is absolutely no way anyone apart from the two people involved know for sure whether abuse took place if there are no witnessess..

Very hard for a jury to call on that one they werent there.

I was on a historical CSA case. We first heard from the victim, then from a number of other people including her first husband (who described how the trauma had damaged her in adulthood), religious leaders and others who were around the family at the time so could provide the circumstantial evidence that the defendant was often left in sole charge and so had the opportunity. On the morning that the defendant was due to tell his side, the defence barrister announced to the judge that his client had decided that he no longer wished to give evidence. The judge said that the Jury could infer what they liked from that. So we didn't deliberate for very long before agreeing to convict.