Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand how a jury reaches its verdict

84 replies

Sportslady44 · 09/02/2022 15:19

I am following a court case at the moment and have been in the public gallery for a few days.

Listening to the evidence and prosecution and defence statements and summing up etc.

I wonder how the hell does a jury know who to believe. Both prosecution and defence make you believe they are right? So much to listen too etc and consider?

The only person who knows is the person on trial right?
How do the jury know?

I guess there is no fairer way of deciding but i realised that i wouldnt really want to make that call when you dont know?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheSoapyFrog · 10/02/2022 11:34

Having spent many years working for the CPS and watching juries return not guilty verdicts in cases which had, what we thought was, overwhelming evidence, I can honestly say I don't know.
Most of these cases were involving sexual offences as well.

MorningStarling · 10/02/2022 11:18

I agree with the PP who said if they were innocent they'd want a judge to decide their case, if they were guilty they'd want a jury.

I dislike the jury system because it solely relies on pot luck as to whether you get people who are biased towards/against you. Undoubtedly there are many people who'd try their best to judge a case fairly, but it's impossible for people to ignore their prejudices. Some will instinctively see a young black male as guilty, someone else will see them as a victim of a prejudiced society. Both views are wrong and have no place in a jury trial.

A relative always used to say (if they got called up for jury service) they'd find the person innocent if white and guilty if not, simply because the jury system is so inherently unfair there is no point actively engaging in it.

Sportslady44 · 10/02/2022 10:48

the jury are out now on this one,

OP posts:
AfraidToRun · 10/02/2022 10:25

I really recommend the books by the Secret Barrister I think it's called. It really explains the judicial system and how it's got to where it is and the difference in the burden of proof between trials brought by the Crown and those that go before a magistrate.

MrsToddsShortcut · 10/02/2022 10:10

I found Jury service fascinating although I was very young at the time. I had always assumed that juries were made up of a panel of terribly wise people & I had no idea until I did it, that we were all just picked from the the electoral register.

Hence my shock at realising that over the three cases that we sat on, there were people on the jury who were sexist ('you just want to let him off because you fancy him'), had low level prejudice ('Well, he looks guilty doesn't he') and also racist ('The judge is one of them -they all stick together, don't they').

At the time it scared me because I realised that (of course) people bring their own experiences and prejudices into the room with them. That said, the majority of jurors were fair minded and happy to shut down all of the above as irrelevant and inappropriate and steer the focus back on to the evidence in front of us.

I was also horrified by the theatrical nature of the adversarial system. One of the barristers was clearly enjoying the performative aspect of his job but was using it to hugely slant the perspective of some fairly mundane information that he was presenting to us.

i.e (obviously this is made up and not the actual case!)

'In 1983, the defendant won numerous plaudits for his portrayal of Wishy Washy in the local amateur dramatic production of Aladdin. Clearly therefore he is a man capable of adopting many disguises and so was easily able to infiltrate GCHQ and jeopardise National security'.

It was a massive eye opener but I'm incredibly glad I had the opportunity to do it.

YellowAndGreenToBeSeen · 10/02/2022 10:10

@FusionChefGeoff when they are putting juries together, they let you know / ask you if you are able to take part in a long trial. Being self employed is a reasonable excuse I believe.

FusionChefGeoff · 10/02/2022 09:36

@YellowAndGreenToBeSeen oh God that would be too good to be true! I run my own business which I can structure to allow for 2 weeks off but my worst nightmare would be a trial which drags on beyond that.

Ariela · 10/02/2022 09:33

@ElizabethinherGermanGarden

It's really difficult. If you are on a jury with a disparate group of people and the evidence isn't a slam-dunk, the interesting thing is how entrenched some people get on reasonable doubt. I was on a jury where we were directed by the judge that we were entitled to draw reasonable inferences from the evidence, but the defence barrister really hammered the idea that we couldn't draw inferences, we had to have direct proof - the judge called the barrister out and said that he was wrong; reasonable inferences based on an accumulation of evidence are allowed, but at that point a couple of jurors had decided it wasn't fully proven and really dug in.

The amount of evidence you have to sift through in a complex case is huge and some jurors don't want to or struggle to read it all through again after the cases have been presented.

We reached a majority decision in the end as couldn't reach unanimous verdict and it was actually really quite an upsetting process. The thing that was great, though, is how seriously everyone on the jury took it. We took a week to reach a verdict and it was serious hard work every day. No one messed around or was flippant or casual.

I had similar, it was a he said she said type of fraud case and the defendant was a glib sales-man type, and we (9/12) had to convince 3/12 - all women- who felt sorry for the accused and believed his sob story, even when the facts clearly pointed to his crime. We spent 2 days arguing the science and evidence with the 3. In the end we (the 9) managed to get to a 11/12 majority by insisting on a paper anonymous vote, where finally 2 of the women (who were saying but he's too nice he couldn't possibly have done it ) changed their vote - we did it anonymous so that nobody lost face by changing what was at the start an adamant viewpoint. The last lady was a lost cause she blanked us and said nothing we would say would make her change her mind she couldn't convict anyone!
Thisbastardcomputer · 10/02/2022 09:12

I've done jury service and you have to decide on evidence presented, does it prove without doubt that the person did in fact do the crime.

Listening to the Judges summing up, is guidance.

You can't do your own assessment, ie they look like a thug so they must be one.

ElaineMarieBenes · 10/02/2022 09:08

If I was guilty of a crime I’d want a jury trial (chances are 50/50). If I was innocent I would prefer a judge only!

It’s a terrible system and should be abolished (I say this as someone who worked in the criminal law system for over 20 years - and yes I have also been selected for jury service - more shocking than I expected and completely unfair on the public).

BigFatLiar · 10/02/2022 08:46

@VladmirsPoutine

I sometimes think it must largely hinge on the jury members' personal prejudices / biases i.e. 'she looks so sweet no way she would be lying'.
You must have been on our jury, that's the sort of reasoning they had along with 'he looks the type'.
IntermittentParps · 10/02/2022 08:36

Our judge said that we were an exemplary jury . He added that we probably thought that he said that to all of his jurys but he didn’t and sometimes you could just tell when people weren’t going to take their roles seriously!

Well done you Grin
Reminded me that the judge in my case where we couldn't come to an agreement was very kind about it. I felt terrible, but he said something like 'You mustn't feel that this means you didn't do your duty well; it actually shows that you have all thought very carefully about it and taken it very seriously.'
It did reassure me a bit, although I still felt/feel that justice was possibly not done that day.

Sickoffamilydrama · 09/02/2022 22:23

The jury service I did someone wanted to do a not guilty because the defendant was late teens and it would ruin their life 🤦‍♀️ luckily they were persuaded by a few or us that tough as the life changing injuries or the victim meant they had ruined their own life.

YellowAndGreenToBeSeen · 09/02/2022 22:10

@FusionChefGeoff

This has been such an interesting thread - my jury duty starts in a few weeks and I'm really really nervous!
If it helps, being summonsed does not necessarily mean being sworn in to a jury.

On the Monday I was called (everyone is called on a Monday I think), some people were instantly dismissed (for no reason other than Numbers).

Ginger1982 · 09/02/2022 21:53

Interesting thread. As a former criminal lawyer I've always wondered how the juries I've appeared in front of have thought.

triggers34 · 09/02/2022 21:45

I'm in my second week of jury service 1 case last week and second this week . I'm hoping it will be done by Friday.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 09/02/2022 21:41

I did jury service last year - a historic child abuse case.
Most evidence was limited to videos of police interviews due to illness and one key witness having since passed away.

We reached a majority verdict - it was our spokesperson who didn’t agree with the rest of us in the end. We told our usher that 11 agreed and 1 was not going to change their kind. He informed the judge and we had this odd situation where we had to go into court, say we didn’t all agree, got sent out and then immediately returned and the judge was happy to accept a majority verdict.

Our judge said that we were an exemplary jury . He added that we probably thought that he said that to all of his jurys but he didn’t and sometimes you could just tell when people weren’t going to take their roles seriously!

It felt a privileged to play a part in the trail to be honest and I felt we did a good job.

80sballetgirl · 09/02/2022 21:40

@FusionChefGeoff

This has been such an interesting thread - my jury duty starts in a few weeks and I'm really really nervous!
Me too! Be glad when it’s over, nervous of such a huge responsibility.
DdraigGoch · 09/02/2022 21:22

@StrictlyAFemaleFemale

I did jury service and got 2 trials. At the end of the first one the judge said 'if you have any. doubt. then you must return a verdict of not guilty.' The second time she just reeled it off, and when we said guilty it was revealed he had previous.
Obviously though that doubt must be reasonable. It has to be based upon the evidence presented (or lack of evidence), and not on the wild speculation of a juror
DdraigGoch · 09/02/2022 21:16

@Youdoyoutoday

I served on a jury for a historical rape case and I'm sorry to say, it was ridiculous, how the CPS thought it would get a conviction, I don't know. No physical evidence, all based on 1 single statement from the woman who had a mental health issues, a troubled childhood and who was taken in by her friends family. She said the older brother of the friend raped her on multiple occasions even whilst his own mother was in the room!! Such a bizarre case and a massive waste of money in my opinion. We had to be sure beyond reasonable doubt that he was guilty, we just couldn't!!
Unfortunately the CPS seems to jump between phases of
  1. "Always believe the victim no matter how many contradictions there are in the statement and clear evidence that the suspect was on a six month Antarctic expedition at the time"

and

  1. (After a bunch of cases collapse) "every case must be 100% watertight complete with DNA, CCTV, and a signed confession before it gets near a trial" (followed by an outcry at low prosecution rates and back to step 1).

Neither extreme helps victims.

VladmirsPoutine · 09/02/2022 21:05

I sometimes think it must largely hinge on the jury members' personal prejudices / biases i.e. 'she looks so sweet no way she would be lying'.

FusionChefGeoff · 09/02/2022 20:57

This has been such an interesting thread - my jury duty starts in a few weeks and I'm really really nervous!

IntermittentParps · 09/02/2022 19:08

TheHaka, you can't disclose your discussions in the jury room, no. All I said was the charge, the circumstances, the (absence of) evidence and the outcome, all accessible both at the time and now by any member of the public.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 09/02/2022 18:33

I did jury service and got 2 trials. At the end of the first one the judge said 'if you have any. doubt. then you must return a verdict of not guilty.' The second time she just reeled it off, and when we said guilty it was revealed he had previous.

YellowAndGreenToBeSeen · 09/02/2022 18:00

You can discuss the case once a verdict has been delivered - you are allowed to discuss the facts as discussed in what will have been an open court and that are now in the public domain.

You cannot ever discuss who was on the jury with you and what was discussed (how you came to your verdict and who said what).

Swipe left for the next trending thread