Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help me choose wedding menu please

109 replies

thinkingoutloud1989 · 09/02/2022 14:10

I need to pick my choices for my wedding menu tasting and really struggling to decide. We get to pick 2 options for each course and I have ruled some out already but would love to get some feedback. It is a spring wedding (May) in Scotland and our guests are mainly a mix of people in their 30s and older relatives (from both Scotland and Ireland).

Starters:
-Smoked salmon with dill creme fraiche, capers and soda bread
-Scotch egg wrapped in haggis on a bed of leaved with dijon mayo
-Warm venion sausage salad with bacon, tomatoes and balsamic dressing
-Potted smoked mackerel with dill horseradish and seeded bread
-Tomato with bufallo mozzarella and rocket pesto on souordough

Mains:
-Sirloin of beef, potatoes, savoy greens, yorkshire pud and gravy
-Lamb loin with garlic potatoes and roast root veg
-Chicken wrapped in pancetta, dauphinoise potatoes, beans and pesto
-Seabass in a dill and fennel butter, potatoes and asparagus

Pudding:
-Salted caramel brownie with vanilla ice cream
-Cranachan with double cream, oatmeal brittle and honey
-Blueberry and vanilla cheesecake
-Strawberry and passion fruit cheesecake
-Mixed berry eton mess
-Tiramisu cheesecake
-Apple tart tatin with cinnamon butterscotch sauce and creme anglaise
-Pear and rhubarb crumble

As you can see I'm having most trouble narrowing down desserts haha. My partner and I love food and not fussy so would like to go with what would be popular (he does want the roast beef included though which I agree with!). Any vegetarians/vegans will be catered for separately. Thanks :)

OP posts:
thinkingoutloud1989 · 09/02/2022 14:46

Thank you so much everyone-loving hearing all your suggestions! This is my first post and didn't expect to get so many replies so quickly. I think I'll go for one lighter and heavier option for each course.

Thinking:
-Scotch egg or smoked salmon
-Beef or Seabass (or chicken haha)
-Brownie (never my choice but always seems popular!) or Cranachan (more scottish version of Eton Mess)

We're having about 120 guests and no difference price wise what we pick. Vegetarians/vegans will be catered for separately (likely another decision I have to make haha the struggles )
Would love to hear more people's thoughts :)

OP posts:
JanuaryBlues84 · 09/02/2022 14:45

Personally I would go for:

Smoked salmon/Scotch egg - nice to have the Scottish thing run through

Chicken/Seabass - I work in events, and beef can be super-tricky as people like it cooked differently which can be a nightmare en mass, and a lot of people don't really like lamb (it would be my personal favourite)

Cranachan/Apple Tart Tatin - again the Scottish thing, and that tart tatin sounds delicious!

Whatever you do, don't put the veggie/vegan option on the menu you put on the tables, as people always think that's an option for anyone and the kitchen ends up running out!!!

FantasticFebruary · 09/02/2022 14:45

I'm vegetarian, so my opinions might not count for much!!

If it was me, being brutally honest, I'd choose something my parents would enjoy, (or Grandparents etc.)

Smoked Salmon
Scotch Egg

(Scotch egg is a bit of an odd choice, but I wouldn't have 2 fish, or venison or something vegetarian ( as they're not choosing from this menu)

Beef (as STB DH wants it)
Chicken (most meat eaters will eat it)

Cheesecake (anyone)
Apple tart

Personally I'd live the brownie, but I think the above two will appeal to more of) your guests)

Hope you have a lovely day!!

cookiemonster2468 · 09/02/2022 14:44

If you want the most popular I would say:

Starters: Tomato mozarrella and the scotch egg
Mains: Beef and chicken
Desserts: Brownie and one of the fruit cheesecakes

Not what I'd personally choose, but they'd be the most popular items.

ivykaty44 · 09/02/2022 14:38

Mackerel sounds lovely, but to many people would turn their nose up at it, so wouldn’t pick it for a wedding

Myrightbigtoe · 09/02/2022 14:38

All sounds delicious. I'd go:
Scotch egg or tomato and mozzarella
Beef or seabass
Brownie or cranachan

Marmm · 09/02/2022 14:37

Tomato with bufallo mozzarella and rocket pesto on souordough and scotch egg

Beef or lamb and chicken

Brownie or tarte tatin

Marmm · 09/02/2022 14:35

Mackerel sounds horrible

Ponoka7 · 09/02/2022 14:34

Tomato mozzarella, not sure what else.

Beef and Chicken,

Brownie and Eton mess.

TheFlis12345 · 09/02/2022 14:34

What a fantastic menu choice! I would go for:

Starters:
-Smoked salmon with dill creme fraiche, capers and soda bread
-Tomato with bufallo mozzarella and rocket pesto on sourdough
(The scotch egg sounds amazing but so many people don’t like - or think they don’t like - haggis)

Mains:
-Sirloin of beef, potatoes, savoy greens, yorkshire pud and gravy
-Chicken wrapped in pancetta, dauphinoise potatoes, beans and pesto
(Personally I’d prefer lamb but these are the crowd pleasers)

Pudding:
-Salted caramel brownie with vanilla ice cream
-Mixed berry Eton mess

foreverandalways · 09/02/2022 14:33

I would try to choose a warm and cold option for each course

Tillsforthrills · 09/02/2022 14:31

Chicken should definitely be an option seconded by beef.

duvetdayforeveryone · 09/02/2022 14:31

Another consideration is cost. What is the least it could cost and what is the most it could cost?

Whitney168 · 09/02/2022 14:31

Picking for me, I'd have:

Potted mackerel
Sea bass
Cranachan

Picking for wide appeal, I would go:

Scotch egg / Tomato & mozzarella
Beef for your husband (I'd pick chicken for general) / Sea bass
Brownie / strawberry cheesecake

duvetdayforeveryone · 09/02/2022 14:29

Starters:
-Smoked salmon with dill creme fraiche, capers and soda bread
-Tomato with bufallo mozzarella and rocket pesto on souordough

Mains:
-Sirloin of beef, potatoes, savoy greens, yorkshire pud and gravy
-Seabass in a dill and fennel butter, potatoes and asparagus

Pudding:
-Salted caramel brownie with vanilla ice cream
-Tiramisu cheesecake
-Apple tart tatin with cinnamon butterscotch sauce and creme anglaise

Rosieposie101 · 09/02/2022 14:29

I'd pick:
Starters:

-Smoked salmon with dill creme fraiche, capers and soda bread

-Tomato with bufallo mozzarella and rocket pesto on souordough

Mains:
-Sirloin of beef, potatoes, savoy greens, yorkshire pud and gravy

-Chicken wrapped in pancetta, dauphinoise potatoes, beans and pesto

Pudding:
-Salted caramel brownie with vanilla ice cream

-Strawberry and passion fruit cheesecake

RunningFromInsanity · 09/02/2022 14:27

You ALWAYS include Brownie as a dessert. It should be law.

I like the idea of the haggis scotch egg too

HeyItsPickleRick · 09/02/2022 14:26

I agree with @AryaStarkWolf 's choices. Essentially light/heavier, light/heavier, fruity and creamy/chocolately

itwasntaparty · 09/02/2022 14:26

Any veggies / vegans?

I dont eat fish, or eggs, the only starter I could eat would be the tomato / mozarella but I am more than happy to forgoe a starter over my food issues!

The beef sounds lovely but do yon want a roast dinner in your -too tight in my case-- wedding outfits, chicken sounds lighter and then the sea bass.

Eton Mess and crumble for desert.

HamsterTrumpet · 09/02/2022 14:25

I’d go for:

Smoked salmon
Tomato mozzarella

Beef
Seabass

Brownie
Eton Mess

Pedalpushers · 09/02/2022 14:24

I'd go for one safe/boring option and one more adventurous for each course, and try and get a bit of a taste of Scotland into the menu seeing as it's there.

Starter: haggis scotch egg or tomato/mozzarella salad

Main: beef (as that's your choice) or seabass. I would never go lamb at a wedding - nearly everyone is fussy about it even if they like it and done en masse it often isn't great.

Dessert: cranachan or blueberry cheesecake

Comedycook · 09/02/2022 14:21

For the main I'd definitely go for beef ..then either the chicken or fish. Personally I prefer lamb but I think beef is more widely preferred

brieislife · 09/02/2022 14:21

I’d personally choose mackerel or scotch egg, lamb or chicken, then apple tarte tatin or eton mess.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 09/02/2022 14:21

No way I can only choose 2, but can I come to your wedding?!

Qwill · 09/02/2022 14:20

I’d say chicken over beef, it looks like it would be better mass catered. Unless you are only having a few people? Roasts out are usually disappointing, especially when mass produced.