Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Primary school children to wear indoor shoes?

114 replies

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 10:26

I've just followed a group of parents/children/dogs on the school run. I go to my daughter's house in my car and then I walk her daughter to school (with her sons in a double buggy).

I saw two children in front of us tread in the same fresh pile of dog dirt. It was in the tread of their footwear and up the sides.

I followed them all the way to school and I saw them walk into school with the mess still on their shoes. There were at least twelve dogs at the school this morning.

The last 100 yards or so of pavement before the school are covered with heaps of dog mess.

I sometimes have to walk on the road (no footpath on the other side of the road) with the double buggy as it's impossible to avoid going through it.

Children on scooters and bikes trail through it and take it in to the school playground. Children will tread in these traces and take them into the class.

Afterwards, I have to fold the double buggy and load into my car, hoping that there's no dog mess going in the car. I often wonder when I'm putting shopping bags in the boot, whether there's any traces of dog dirt from the pushchair wheels on them.

The children go into school and the first thing they do is sit on the carpet for the register. My granddaughter has told me several times that the teacher has had to ask the teaching assistant to clean someone's shoes because they can all smell dog dirt.

Obviously children put their hands on the carpet and then on lots of different resources in the class. Children do not wash their hands after sitting on the carpet. Traces of dog dirt are being spread far and wide.

Some schools have a policy of changing to indoor shoes in the cloakroom to avoid this problem.

So the AIBU is that: should all primary schools have an in door shoe policy?

I'm a retired primary school teacher - the schools I worked in had this policy.

My granddaughter has just returned to school today after being off Friday, Monday, Tuesday due to a stomach bug. It's her fourth one this academic year. The first time it happened she was in hospital for two nights and had to have ondansetron to stop the sickness. She lost a significant amount of weight and hasn't put it back on (she wasn't 'big' to begin with) and after this last bout she's looking very frail and bony. I'm beginning to think there's something deeply concerning about the state of the classroom floors that children are sat on, several times a day. I'm not convinced that every episode is viral.

OP posts:
BeefSupreme · 09/02/2022 22:26

We didn't sit on the floor either even though we had clean shoes. We sat on benches for assembly.

BeefSupreme · 09/02/2022 22:24

We changed our shoes before we went into the classroom. Everybody had a pair of plimsolls or trainers that were for indoors only. It didn't take that much time.

soapboxqueen · 09/02/2022 22:20

[quote MyOtherCarIsAPorsche]@soapboxqueen

I agree - I thought that indoor shoes caused more palaver. I've seen children deliberately swapping/hiding other children's footwear.

It would be much easier if children weren't made to sit on the floor.

This would make assemblies impossible. [/quote]
I've taught with carpet space and without. Pros and cons to both.

With regards to assembly time, the hall is used for PE anyway so it's going to have shoes and children touching it anyway. It's usually easier to clean though.

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 22:01

@soapboxqueen

I agree - I thought that indoor shoes caused more palaver. I've seen children deliberately swapping/hiding other children's footwear.

It would be much easier if children weren't made to sit on the floor.

This would make assemblies impossible.

OP posts:
soapboxqueen · 09/02/2022 21:49

Indoor shoes are a pain the backside. A school I taught at had them and we got rid of them. It eats up time before and after break as well as lunch time (unless you don't mind complaints from parents about their child missing out on break). That's before the children who can't find their shoes because it's been kicked under a bench, or they just need help or all the shoes look the same or somebody is accidentally wearing their shoes(this applies to older children too).

It adds expense for parents (even a couple of quid is too much if you don't have it) or the school which can't afford it.

Some schools get around this by just wearing socks indoors but it only takes one drawing pin or loose staple to put an end to it plus the issue of having a school full of children stood in their socks in the rain should there be a fire alarm.

Plus there needs to be space to store shoes and change shoes. Something many schools just don't have.

Now, none of those things are insurmountable if there was a real need or drive for it. However, there would need to be a recognition of the time taken out of the school day and the costs.

womaninatightspot · 09/02/2022 21:31

We have indoor shoes for school. Honestly costs a fortune everytime a child goes up a size. Outdoor shoes, indoor shoes, gym shoes, outdoor pe shoes. I buy black geox trainers for school shoes and outdoor P.E. Bright coloured obvious trainers for indoors and indoor P.E. as they seem to go missing a lot and I want them to spot them. I refuse to buy lots of school shoes only for them to spend the majority of time in ill fitting plimsoles.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2022 21:25

@FateHasRedesignedMost

think indoor shoes added to the mix is just going to take up time that teachers just don't have

Most 4 year olds can change their shoes without help, and quickly slip out of their
Outdoor shoes into plimsolls. They do PE 3x week and manage without the teacher helping. I don’t think it would take up more time than taking off/putting on coats, gloves etc, sunhats in summer?

The thought of all the bacteria and potentially toxoplasmosis trodden into carpet corners, which kids put their hands on, is horrific!

I mean more the having to help kids look for missing shoes.
Drunkpanda · 09/02/2022 16:44

My dc's state school has indoor shoes. So some have this policy. Not sure if all children follow it though.

Mylittlepixie · 09/02/2022 16:31

Obviously people should pick up after their dogs.
But i also dont understand why schools in the Uk dont have indoor shoes. Its completely normal where I live and it causes no issues. School starts at 9am. First bell rings at 8.55 telling kids to head inside. When it rings again at 9 everyone is expected to sit on their chair ready to begin. Its never an issue at all. Teachers of lower grades remind kids to change before entering and exiting the classroom. It was already like that 25 years ago when i was in school and it never caused any issues.

EmpressSuiko · 09/02/2022 16:10

I think it would be brilliant if schools adopted an indoor shoe policy, it works well in Japan and it’s not only in schools, outdoor shoes are prohibited in certain work places, restaurants and places of worship/historical importance.
The school do really need to get the council to try to combat the dog poo issue, it’s absolutely disgusting that people don’t pick up after their dogs especially around schools, it only take a minute to clear it up!

Caspianberg · 09/02/2022 16:09

Schools are 4+ years. A 4 year old should be able to take Velcro shoes off and add plimsoll on very easily themselves

Like I said, here you buy the plimsolls from the school, and anyone needs will be given a pair for free. They charge €3.50 each, but the plimsolls cost the school about €2 so the extra basically contributes to those who can’t or didn’t pay.

They also have wellingtons you have to buy the same as they use weekly for forest school. Again they stay at school, and anyone who needs is given a pair for free.

Sam with morning snack. You pay something like €5 per term towards morning snack. But anyone who hasn’t paid will still get the same snack

It’s not the 1960s anymore, schools shouldn’t be making children feel bad for lack of money or things

FateHasRedesignedMost · 09/02/2022 15:58

I worry that it would further disadvantage parents who struggle to provide one pair of decent shoes, never mind two

Most teachers have a box of spare plimsolls which kids donate when they outgrow. And they’re about £2 in Asda or Primark (and essential for PE).

Also very few children have only one pair of school shoes these days, they’re cheap to buy from supermarkets or eBay and essential for when you can’t get them dry overnight.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 09/02/2022 15:54

think indoor shoes added to the mix is just going to take up time that teachers just don't have

Most 4 year olds can change their shoes without help, and quickly slip out of their
Outdoor shoes into plimsolls. They do PE 3x week and manage without the teacher helping. I don’t think it would take up more time than taking off/putting on coats, gloves etc, sunhats in summer?

The thought of all the bacteria and potentially toxoplasmosis trodden into carpet corners, which kids put their hands on, is horrific!

sadpapercourtesan · 09/02/2022 15:47

I see the hygiene benefits, obviously, but I worry that it would further disadvantage parents who struggle to provide one pair of decent shoes, never mind two. Also those children who come from homes where any extraneous needs for school (PE kit, pencil cases, decent lunchbox) are ignored. I remember in the 80s when we were taught in a sopping wet portacabin and the teacher decided we all needed a pair of indoor shoes that would live at school. My mother flatly refused. Said teacher lost her rag after the first week of asking "where are your indoor shoes" and sent me flying across the classroom. Obviously that wouldn't happen now, but I do still remember the sting of being the kid sliding around in socks because I didn't have indoor shoes, just as I remember being punished for not having a PE kit and jeered at for bringing my lunch in an old bead bag.

User260486 · 09/02/2022 15:43

It would be great. Indoor shoes would be much more hygenic in primary years and in nurseries as well. When mine were in nursery I suggested it to the manager and got an extensive reply why it is not a good idea, which effectively was "we can't be bothered helping them change". Most kids took off shoes at some point during the day and wore socks in the room, and the socks got quite dirty by the end if the day, so we changed the socks immediately after coming home.

Volhhg · 09/02/2022 15:42

I have noticed children having to dodge dog poo several times on the school runs. I think the onus should be on the government to make our streets cleaner by reducing dog ownership especially in urban areas. Councils should be allocated more money from central government to keep paths clean. You can report dog mess to your local council and I regularly do this, the more people do this the more recognition the problem will get.

AppleTangerine · 09/02/2022 15:29

I agree with you.

I think we took off shoes in my primary school in the 1990s but could be misremembering. I hate wearing shoes inside and am currently shoeless in my office.

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 15:23

@onedayoranother

Yes - yr 6 sit on benches (PE ones) for assembly. Every other child is on the floor in the hall, picking up squashed peas from lunch (and worse). This and other times throughout the day that they sit on the floor in class.

My last school had a row of pigeon holes underneath the coat pegs which accommodated a pair of black pumps/plimsolls/daps but children rarely got a pair of outdoor shoes in them. This resulted in squabbles and delays getting into and out of class (especially in massive fur lined boot season).

OP posts:
onedayoranother · 09/02/2022 14:58

Maybe the school needs to have a 'no dogs on school property' making it clear the dog mess is the issue (unless the kids are just taken to the gate).
I can't see inside shoes working unless they all have a cubby to put their shoes in.
My kids had to sit on the floor until secondary for assemblies - the girls in particular hated it because they wore skirts. Wish schools would get some benches.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/02/2022 13:48

@MyOtherCarIsAPorsche

In my last teaching post, the whole school was carpeted (apart from the hall). I don't know why this happened - came back from the summer holidays and voila - a sea of blue carpet (expensive quality). That's why we had an indoor shoe policy (bane of my life).

Art lessons in particular made me anxious (especially at Christmas when the glitter came out) as the head inspected the carpets regularly.

When walking down the corridors you got several patches of vomit aroma greeting you. Never got rid of some stains.

Oof!

Id say carpet is softer on the kids when they fall but school carpets tend to be made of velcro IME so definitely not that

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 13:46

In my last teaching post, the whole school was carpeted (apart from the hall). I don't know why this happened - came back from the summer holidays and voila - a sea of blue carpet (expensive quality). That's why we had an indoor shoe policy (bane of my life).

Art lessons in particular made me anxious (especially at Christmas when the glitter came out) as the head inspected the carpets regularly.

When walking down the corridors you got several patches of vomit aroma greeting you. Never got rid of some stains.

OP posts:
Andacherryonthetop · 09/02/2022 13:31

I once worked in a school where the children all took their shoes off in class and either walked around in socks or slippers. The children really liked it and the carpet always stayed clean. They would put the shoes on to walk down the corridors to the toilets or to go to the hall etc

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 13:27

@APurpleSquirrel

This sounds disgusting. DD school don't have the space to change shoes but it's not a problem re. Dog mess here. Do you have a local newspaper you could contact? If they run a story it might shame the council etc into doing something about it.
That's a good shout for the future.

I'll see if my recent requests are dealt with appropriately first.

OP posts:
MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 13:26

@SliceOfCakeCupOfTea

There's a lady doing the school run who is always walking down the road with her son at least 15 mins late. I meet her on the way back to my daughter's house. She does this deliberately to avoid the crowds. (She told me.)

OP posts:
APurpleSquirrel · 09/02/2022 13:24

This sounds disgusting.
DD school don't have the space to change shoes but it's not a problem re. Dog mess here.
Do you have a local newspaper you could contact? If they run a story it might shame the council etc into doing something about it.