Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Primary school children to wear indoor shoes?

114 replies

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 10:26

I've just followed a group of parents/children/dogs on the school run. I go to my daughter's house in my car and then I walk her daughter to school (with her sons in a double buggy).

I saw two children in front of us tread in the same fresh pile of dog dirt. It was in the tread of their footwear and up the sides.

I followed them all the way to school and I saw them walk into school with the mess still on their shoes. There were at least twelve dogs at the school this morning.

The last 100 yards or so of pavement before the school are covered with heaps of dog mess.

I sometimes have to walk on the road (no footpath on the other side of the road) with the double buggy as it's impossible to avoid going through it.

Children on scooters and bikes trail through it and take it in to the school playground. Children will tread in these traces and take them into the class.

Afterwards, I have to fold the double buggy and load into my car, hoping that there's no dog mess going in the car. I often wonder when I'm putting shopping bags in the boot, whether there's any traces of dog dirt from the pushchair wheels on them.

The children go into school and the first thing they do is sit on the carpet for the register. My granddaughter has told me several times that the teacher has had to ask the teaching assistant to clean someone's shoes because they can all smell dog dirt.

Obviously children put their hands on the carpet and then on lots of different resources in the class. Children do not wash their hands after sitting on the carpet. Traces of dog dirt are being spread far and wide.

Some schools have a policy of changing to indoor shoes in the cloakroom to avoid this problem.

So the AIBU is that: should all primary schools have an in door shoe policy?

I'm a retired primary school teacher - the schools I worked in had this policy.

My granddaughter has just returned to school today after being off Friday, Monday, Tuesday due to a stomach bug. It's her fourth one this academic year. The first time it happened she was in hospital for two nights and had to have ondansetron to stop the sickness. She lost a significant amount of weight and hasn't put it back on (she wasn't 'big' to begin with) and after this last bout she's looking very frail and bony. I'm beginning to think there's something deeply concerning about the state of the classroom floors that children are sat on, several times a day. I'm not convinced that every episode is viral.

OP posts:
RobotValkyrie · 10/02/2022 07:10

Carpet time is disgusting. It's not just about dog poo, the ground outside is covered in muck for a lot of the year: leaves, mud, etc. And I'm just talking about your average playground!

Indoor shoes would make sense. They do that in Japan.
Sitting on a chair would make sense. They do that in most countries around the world (when kids are above reception age).

Carpet time is completely unsuitable for a lot of SEN kids. Not comfy at all. Too chaotic.
I suspect the only reason carpet time is a thing, is because classroom are too small for the number of kids they contain, so you couldn't fit enough chairs and desks. In other words it's a cost saving measure, not done for the kids benefit. It's shit. And COVID highlighted how fundamentally unhygienic the whole set up is.

labyrinthlaziness · 10/02/2022 06:50

@1AngelicFruitCake

All these posters coming on saying children shouldn’t be on the carpet! 😄 You clearly haven’t had 30 KS1 children at tables, distracted, too spaced out to keep them all focused for a length of time!
I agree, kids are happy on the carpet, it is comfier for them.

Indoor shoes are a good idea, it is what a lot of us do at home.

1AngelicFruitCake · 10/02/2022 06:39

All these posters coming on saying children shouldn’t be on the carpet! 😄 You clearly haven’t had 30 KS1 children at tables, distracted, too spaced out to keep them all focused for a length of time!

megletthesecond · 10/02/2022 06:39

Yanbu.
I remember being at primary school and the dog mess on the carpet incidents.

labyrinthlaziness · 10/02/2022 06:37

Indoor shoes was a thing at one school one of mine went to, it was good, made the school nice.

labyrinthlaziness · 10/02/2022 06:36

Also your local council need to sort out the dog poo problem. Write a letter to the council and to school.

hahahahahaha!

We have a Tory government which has mercilessly cut council budgets - there is no money for this. It isn't 2005 any more.

Lemonsandlemonade · 10/02/2022 06:33

I love sitting on the carpet with the children especially to read

In our place of a child walked in with mud or something on boots we clean it. We do have wooden floors and some rugs.

Indoor shoes wouldn’t work for my children as not all would remember.

liveforsummer · 10/02/2022 06:28

Most 4 year olds can change their shoes without help, and quickly slip out of their
Outdoor shoes into plimsolls. They do PE 3x week and manage without the teacher helping. I don’t think it would take up more time than taking off/putting on coats, gloves etc, sunhats in summer?

I work in a class of now 6 year olds and there are Kmart that still need help. Taking shoes off/putting on for PE is significantly more time consuming than coats and hats I can assure you.

Fwiw we wouldn't have the space for 30 extra pairs of shoes. We barely have the space for the 30 dc, their coats go one one small coat rack that gets shoved out in the corridor once they've taken them off and if they have a bag it goes under their desk. Shoes in the corridor or under desks would get kicked around, tripped over muddled up, lost. There are a couple of dc who would probably Chuck them about. A logistical nightmare.

user1477391263 · 10/02/2022 06:12

One other thing, if kids have "indoor shoes" they need to be actual trainers or whatever that are simply assigned for indoor purposes. Not slippers. Slippers lack support and are not good for your feet, and are a falling and tripping hazard, especially on stairs. They are not OK for wearing all day.

My daughter wears white trainers with proper support and grips that are just used as indoor shoes.

user1477391263 · 10/02/2022 06:08

We do this in Japan. It works OK, but you have to have the space around the entrance area(s) for shoe cupboards/shoe racks, and space for people to actually sit and get their shoes on and off. Bear in mind that kids tend to come in and out of schools in massive surges, not in dribs and drabs. I can see a new-build school doing this, but would really question whether it's possible for the average crowded ancient UK school.

Much as I admire UK schools in many ways, I really don't get the obsession with carpet sitting. I think it's to do with the tendency to cluster children round tables so that half of them can't see the board, so when you want them all looking in the same direction, you have to sit them somewhere else. I think paired desks in rows (which is what they do in most of the world) works better IMO.

Stevenage689 · 10/02/2022 05:56

In reception classes, there aren't meant to be as many chairs as children because they should be playing. Their "carpet areas" are small so there wouldn't be space for all children with chairs.

In key stage one, most schools have carpet time. I think it's mainly a control thing - less to fiddle with, fewer distractions. It allows better teaching.

Most key stage two classes don't have carpet time and children sit at desks. But I'm not sure it substantially increases hygiene. Some kids pick at their shoes all lesson. Some pick noses. They all touch their faces and many put fingers in their mouths. Feet go on chairs. And that's just in the classroom...

FrenchFancie · 10/02/2022 05:35

I work with the equivalent of year 1 kids (5/6 year olds) and am laughing at the the thought of them being able to do their shoes or pE kit by themselves!! Yes a good few can but I have about 1/4 of the class that can’t tie laces but come in with lace up shoes, or who just can’t get shoes and socks on and off. When questioned it turns out that mum or dad still dress them and undress them at home each day…

We don’t have a big dog poo problem but I shudder at the thought of trying to get 26 pairs of shoes routines on and off the correct feet. I’m still traumatised by swimming lessons where children would regularly end up in each other’s pants!

BuanoKubiamVej · 10/02/2022 05:30

Making national legislation forcing all primary schools to follow a solution which is only necessary in specific schools is a silly idea. Yabu there. In our area in a mixed suburb near a city centre there's not a massive problem with dog poo. I guess I see one maybe once a week on our route to school but almost never see a footprint in it showing that someone trod in it. Getting our school to a react to a problem at your school is crazy.

Obviously there is a problem at your school and you certainly should raise it with the school governers and the local council- the governers to change school policy to improve hygiene to take into account that shoes are likely to be dirty, and the council to step up efforts to reduce dog mess on the streets. The specific solution of forcing all kids to change shoes isn't necessarily the best idea to address this, but there are other options.

MrsMonkeyBear · 10/02/2022 05:08

My daughter uses indoor and outdoor shoes at school. Depending on the weather she wears trainers/wellies to school and then has black pumps for indoor use. And in her 3 years at school, she's had one stomach bug.

I remember (30+ years ago) having slippers at school for indoors, more for the wet/winter months when we'd all be in wellies.

MangoSeason · 10/02/2022 01:47

Slightly off topic but this thread is making me reminisce about my primary school days in the Australian tropics. Most kids never wore shoes at all. Ever. Not to school, not to the shops, not when riding your bike around to see friends. I had one pair of shoes that I had to wear to church on Sundays. Very upsetting. We sat in the floor at school and didn’t get diseases or veruccas.. Perfectly middle-class area. Great times!

Theyellowflamingo · 10/02/2022 01:28

[quote MyOtherCarIsAPorsche]@soapboxqueen

I agree - I thought that indoor shoes caused more palaver. I've seen children deliberately swapping/hiding other children's footwear.

It would be much easier if children weren't made to sit on the floor.

This would make assemblies impossible. [/quote]
As a parent I would be absolutely delighted if the absolutely enormous waste of time that is “assembly” was done away with. Or cut back to once a week with benches (they have the space, just probably not the manpower to stack/unstack daily.) Won’t happen though.

Flaxmeadow · 09/02/2022 23:53

We used to have this policy years ago. I can remember wearing pumps/plimsols in thr 1970s at school. But back then schools were far more hygienic and a lot cleaner than they are now anyway

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 23:27

@lollipopsandrainbows

DD primary has a plimsole policy but I have the same argument with them every year. DD has low arches, and wears properly fitted Clarke's shoes which I buy at the start of term (or twice a year if she grows). I'm therefore not having her change into what are effectively slippers with no food support. Every year we have a new class teacher, I have the same argument and never back down. I just don't understand the logic of them being in poorly fitted shoes all day.
Low arches are quite common in children up to the age of 10 yrs, foot arches can take up to decade to develop.

Our family has EDS. We all have to be careful about well fitting shoes.

My granddaughter is no different - she is hypermobile. She has to wear a shoe boot to give more ankle support. We try to get Geox when we can. We avoid Clark's. However, we are told that it's fine to wear flat shoes indoors.

OP posts:
lollipopsandrainbows · 09/02/2022 22:49

DD primary has a plimsole policy but I have the same argument with them every year. DD has low arches, and wears properly fitted Clarke's shoes which I buy at the start of term (or twice a year if she grows). I'm therefore not having her change into what are effectively slippers with no food support. Every year we have a new class teacher, I have the same argument and never back down. I just don't understand the logic of them being in poorly fitted shoes all day.

switswoo81 · 09/02/2022 22:48

The school I work in had slippers/indoor shoes up until 2020. Teachers hated them so much.
Plimsolls kept getting mixed up as names rubbed off the inside from wearing them.
Children kept slipping their feet into them and walking on the back of them which meant they were falling and the indoor shoes were falling apart.
Sometimes shoes would have to be changed 4-5 times a day. Yard breaks, movement break, pe , daily mile etc. This took ages especially now as extra hand washing is thrown into the mix
At the end of the year we had to throw out bags of leftover slippers and plimsolls that were unclaimed.
Loads storage needed they had drawstring bags but inevitably were only perched on top.

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 22:43

@Rainbowshit

Yes - a more hygienic school is what I would like, in an ideal world - that's what I'm after.

It's a pity that not every parent thinks that it's a priority.

We're talking hundreds of pairs of shoes walking-in contamination every day. Urgh.

Or - no sitting on the floor.

OP posts:
MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 22:38

@BeefSupreme

We didn't sit on the floor either even though we had clean shoes. We sat on benches for assembly.
Our school only had four benches which were used for PE. Year 6 would sit on them in assembly. Although the children at the back of the line would have to sit on the floor (with the squashed peas).
OP posts:
Rainbowshit · 09/02/2022 22:36

My kids used to have to put on indoor shoes when they were in primary school. It was a rural school with a great but muddy play area.

The design of the school was such that each class had its own entrance and lobby area with space for changing shoes and storing them.

It wasn't a big deal for them all to change their shoes when they came in. Their outdoor shoes lasted a lot longer as a result and then inside of the school much cleaner.

I don't remember any issues with either indoor or outdoor shoes going missing.

velvet24 · 09/02/2022 22:36

Our primary always had an indoor shoe policy

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 09/02/2022 22:35

@womaninatightspot

At my friend's school (she's a head teacher) the children wear slippers. Children there don't wear plimsolls because indoor PE is bare foot and outdoor PE, children wear their trainers.

At my granddaughter's school they are still in pandemic mode and go to school once a week in full outdoor PE kit which includes trainers which are worn outside of school/weekends. I don't think they have school trainers and an additional pair for home use at primary level - so just one pair of trainers.

My granddaughter has slippers, school shoes, trainers, wellies (which are bought a size bigger and usually last two years) and a pair of smart shoes. She has two younger brothers who have one pair of shoes each (they don't walk far, mainly in a double buggy outside). Yes - footwear can be expensive but I would think at a push most can afford a pair of plimsolls as indoor shoes for school. They can be purchased for £2.50 in Asda/supermarket. Schools also pass on plimsolls/uniform which has been donated.

When I was teaching I had a pair of plimsolls in every size which were used for children who forgot theirs. If a child was a size I didn't have, I would buy some. Indoor shoes was our policy and children chose to wear their plimsolls. Our head teacher was aware that sitting on the floor could be grimy if children wore outdoor shoes in school. Plus, the school was fully carpeted. I wouldn't want to sit on a carpet that had hundreds of outdoor shoes clomping across it. Urgh.

OP posts: