Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4 year old assembly “girls can be boys”

266 replies

AnotherNameChanged1234 · 09/02/2022 10:08

Is this the norm? My childrens school had an assembly (via zoom of course) on boys can be girls and girls can be boys. The whole school attended - rising 3 year olds through to 11 year olds (nursery is part of schools here -devolved U.K. nation)

I’m so angry, this doesn’t feel age appropriate at all. I’m so angry, my 6 year old was sobbing over it and it completely took me off guard.

I’m not an anti-trans person, I have some good friends who are trans, I’ve seen the pain they’ve gone through, and I’ll always encourage sympathy and no judgement, but this seems like madness. 3 and 4 year olds barely even know what boy and girl are. These poor kids have had two year’s socialisation stolen away from them, can’t we just let them be kids for a few years?

AIBU to be cross, or is this the norm in every school?

YABU- it’s the norm
YANBU- it’s not the norm for this age group

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
CaptainSmartarse · 09/02/2022 13:42

YANU at all. Batshittery. Check out Safe Schools Alliance . I wonder of the assembly highlighted that children can have visible or invisible disabilities or health conditions or that children can be Black etc I bet only a token mention if any.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 09/02/2022 13:39

My daughter has a friend in her class who identifies as a girl and changed from male to female pronouns at the beginning of year one. She and my daughter are both 6. All the children and parents that I know have literally just accepted it and it's not a big deal for them (or the parents!).

EmmaH2022 · 09/02/2022 13:37

[quote AnotherNameChanged1234]@WorriedGiraffe DD has been very over dramatic since the pandemic started. We get a lot of floods of tears, usually because something has upset her but she can’t explain it.

If I’m being over dramatic apologies. I had some bad news last night totally unrelated and I barely slept. I’m still really angry about this being pushed on children so young.[/quote]
You're not being dramatic

It's bad enough that young children are being introduced to such complicated matters

But this is on top of lockdowns

And I hadn't even realised school stuff was still happening on zoom.

I would ask them why they think it's okay to befuddle children with this.

Swear · 09/02/2022 13:34

I sometimes wonder whether people who advocate teaching children this, including the Labour led Welsh Government, ever think about the effect on the NHS. How do you feel about never being able to get a hip replacement, despite constant pain and lack of mobility, because there are thousands of young people queueing up for "essential" top and bottom surgery, and then for IVF treatment because they've been made infertile, and then for whatever treatment they can get when the drugs they have to take for life cause some horrendous medical condition? Are you happy to lose the NHS over this issue?

DdraigGoch · 09/02/2022 13:31

[quote Cattenberg]I do think this is very confusing for young children. My DD is nearly four and she wouldn’t understand it.

But having read about this tragic case today, I think schools need to teach older children about gender dysphoria to prevent trans and gender non-conforming children from being bullied.

[https://www.miltonkeynes.co.uk/news/people/pupils-in-shock-after-bullied-classmate-aged-12-reportedly-takes-his-own-life-in-milton-keynes-3560190][/quote]
I suspect that there is more to this story than the press is aware of. It's not unusual for FtM transitioners to have a hidden history of sexual abuse. It's quite likely that this child was already suffering from poor mental health. There has been no evidence yet given of a gender dysphoria diagnosis.

What is really shocking is how organisations and individuals have been preying on vulnerable adolescents, telling them that all their problems can be solved using some magic potions and a surgeon's knife. Adults need to act in a child's best interests, not just blindly agree with whatever their wants are through the threat of self-harm.

Bullying and sexual harassment are of course rife in schools, which is a big part of the problem.

jeaux90 · 09/02/2022 13:29

@Strictlyfanoftenyears
No. DSD is nothing to do with trans.
People with DSDs are still either male or female and it has nothing to do with dysphoria.

Bellex · 09/02/2022 13:28

Could this be linked in a child that is transitioning in school or going by different pronouns

AnotherNameChanged1234 · 09/02/2022 13:27

@Sillydoggy

In fact given the Welsh Assembly's approach I doubt there is any misunderstanding on the part of the child.
This exactly. I can’t believe people are questioning what my child has said was said.
OP posts:
WorriedMumsDontSleep · 09/02/2022 13:27

That child's death will be the result of a combination of circumstances and safeguarding fail.
Homophobia and bullying are fails that the school should have picked up on. If a parent chooses to affirm a child, however and use a new name and pronouns, schools have to use them. They rightly have no obligation to do so without parental consent.
What that child needed was counselling and support. Not for people to politicise their death to push a homophobic agenda.

jeaux90 · 09/02/2022 13:26

OP get your facts together then get in touch with safe schools alliance for help.

I managed to get this stuff out of my kids primary school.

Teaching tolerance and diversity yes
Teaching you can become the opposite sex, that certain hobbies make you a girl, that you can be born in the wrong body...big fat no

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 09/02/2022 13:26

@Sillydoggy

Are you muddling Disorders/Variations of Sexual Development with trans because they are not remotely related.
Its a form of body dysmorphia isnt it?
Dishwashersaurous · 09/02/2022 13:25

Any response from school on exactly what the assembly content was?

Swear · 09/02/2022 13:24

[quote rainrainraincamedowndowndown]@WorriedMumsDontSleep

Yes, I know it's different. But my point was, it's better than not teaching it's ok to be different.

I've just read this article. It's heartbreaking. This shouldn't happen. So, to prevent a tragedy like this, then I think it's worth few children crying which can be rectified the misunderstanding by their parents, imo.

www.miltonkeynes.co.uk/news/people/pupils-in-shock-after-bullied-classmate-aged-12-reportedly-takes-his-own-life-in-milton-keynes-3560190[/quote]
No, it's not a good idea to teach all our 4 year olds (and via that their parents) that if you're good at Lego (or whatever) you are maybe actually a boy and can choose to change sex. In the full knowledge that that may lead to life long and dangerous medical treatment, untold psychological damage, infertility, etc. Not even if you know of a child who has committed suicide due to bullying about them using different pronouns. (And let's face it, before all this trans hsyteria it wouldn't even have occurred to them to use those pronouns.)
You teach children to be tolerant of difference, generally, and if there is a child in the class who presents as trans you can talk about that as appropriate. But without teaching children that it's possible to change sex. It isn't, and there is no option to transition medically (which obviously doesn't change your sex anyhow) while of school age anyway.

Skilovingmama · 09/02/2022 13:24

Sorry but it’s sick what they are doing to kids by peddling this utter shit. I don’t blame your child for crying - she probably knows it’s shit but can’t understand why adults she trusts would gaslight her like this. I’d do a massive complaint to the school.

Yes, everyone can be who they want and do what they want. No, a female person cannot become a male person. All that being trans involves is trying to emulate the opposite sex, often through surgery and hormones, in an effort to appear genuine. Feeling unhappy with who you are doesn’t mean you are actually something else. It just means you feel unhappy. Even if you pretend you are something else, you’ll probably still be unhappy.

BiBabbles · 09/02/2022 13:23

Following up with the school is a good idea. The whole topic is all over the map n schools so it's hard to say what's common.

I'd also look up the PSHE policy and see what it says around this topic, though I've noticed some policies have some great ideals, but how it plays out is very different, especially in recent years where it's squeezed even more with COVID.

My DS1 at 8 had an upset about this - not in school, but someone who thought they were being kind trying to explain transgender in an absolutely butchered to the tune of 'most boys grow up to be men, but some grow up to be women'. Compounded with many incidents of people asking if he was or wanted to be a girl from his hair to his hobbies, I had a freaked out kid with child logic who thought he was going to change any minute. I had to add in the missing details the woman left out, reinforcing our conversations about puberty and how some who are distressed with their bodies change their appearance to one they hope they'll be more comfortable with, but the changes he feared would require medications and surgeries & wouldn't just show up.

Some years on, we ended up in another sudden conversation with him at the wrong end of the stick where he thought being trans was all about clothes - that thinking of wearing a skirt meant he was trans. We had a long conversation about different ways that word is used now.

The issue in a lot of the teaching is that it is simplified to appearances and just deciding to be different makes everything happy & tends to erase gender dysphoria. I think it can be compounded by puberty education that sometimes leaves out how some even significant discomfort at the changes and just in the idea of growing up is entirely normal & not something that needs pathologized, just space to talk and work through it.

Wafflesnsniffles · 09/02/2022 13:22

I would take my child out of a school promoting that sort of agenda. 100% no question. Either transferring to another school or home educating.

Jux · 09/02/2022 13:21

Cbtb that looks like a great explanation of everything. Maybe OP should c&p that and suggest the school adopt that for their assembly!

Phobiaphobic · 09/02/2022 13:20

*We don't teach that swans are or can be black, we have white swans, swans are white.

That there are about half a million back swans in the world doesn't affect swans being a white bird. Black swans are an anomaly that we teach about in specific classes covering diversification in birds.

So why teach anything about anomalous human conditions in a general PSHE style assembly? Especially to a whole school session?*

Exasperating, isn't it? Diversions from the norm does not mean the norm is diverse.

jellyfrizz · 09/02/2022 13:19

Ohh did they say girls have to consider being boys? That’s definitely not on, I would complain.

I was sent to a catholic primary school and one assembly they had a nun in talking about how they had had 'the calling' to god. It was described as something you could not ignore. For about a year after I was absolutely terrified that I would get 'the calling' and have to be a nun.

They didn't say anyone had to consider being a nun but my six year old brain worked out that if this happened to some people it could happen to me.

Cbtb · 09/02/2022 13:17

@WorriedMumsDontSleep

“Non based pronouns” ? I’m not even sure what that means!

If you mean victims of sexual assault having to call their attacker by female pronouns I fully agree it’s horrific. Rapists are men (under uk law). Male pronouns only. I don’t feel this nuance is needed at 6. If it was to be relevant to a specific child under whatever horrible circumstances I think you could deal with that separately.

Primary aged kids are probably only going to be dealing with this in very specific circumstances. So if Mr Jones the y4 teacher becomes Mrs Jones then I would expect my dd to call her Mrs/her. If I was not comfortable with the SG protections in place I would be removing my DD but probably not telling her why. It might be different in senior school.

If you mean “cat gender” Etc I don’t think it’s relevant at this age. If Johnny thinks he’s a cat/superman then we can call him a cat/superman but at this age it’s not gender ideology it’s a normal child development phase.

Outside of school she’s not going to be hanging out with any adults who think they a cats/adult babies or whatever!

In conclusion at primary age especially under 8 I think a blanket rule of “call people what they want to be called” works with the caveat that the “pants” rule and the other “be nice” rules are also followed. We have lots of chats about the fact that the rules apply to other kids as well and if they are not nice to her then she dosent have to be nice to them!

Echobelly · 09/02/2022 13:14

I do think it sounds like an unhelpful approach OP.

I too, have trans friends and family so I have no issue with it, but I don't think young kids should be taught along the lines of 'anyone can be any gender' as though it's really common.

More that a small number of people really cannot live as their birth sex and can get help so they live as a member of the opposite sex, and some people feel a profound sense of being neither and may use they/them pronouns. And that this group of people often face unfair prejudice that we should combat when we can.

They should be taught that you can be a boy or girl however you like; there are no 'rules' about clothes, toys and interests - these are just things created by historical limitations that longer apply. Being interested in 'gender atypical' things is, in the vast majority of cases, not an indicator that you are trans, though it can be part of trans people's experience.

DC (13) identifies as NB as it happens - they've always been quite an unconventional child (like their mother). I support them but also try to provide my perspective to encourage them to think about whether this degree of reflection on gender/sexuality really 'helps' them or not andremind them that they don't have to worry too much about it really and they have plenty of time to explore.

rainrainraincamedowndowndown · 09/02/2022 13:14

@WorriedMumsDontSleep

Yes, I know it's different. But my point was, it's better than not teaching it's ok to be different.

I've just read this article. It's heartbreaking. This shouldn't happen. So, to prevent a tragedy like this, then I think it's worth few children crying which can be rectified the misunderstanding by their parents, imo.

www.miltonkeynes.co.uk/news/people/pupils-in-shock-after-bullied-classmate-aged-12-reportedly-takes-his-own-life-in-milton-keynes-3560190

SamphiretheStickerist · 09/02/2022 13:11

@rainrainraincamedowndowndown

The fact is, there are children born ambiguous, so I don't think it's a bad idea to share the information from early age, so those who suffers doesn't feel different and discriminated. From data, it looks like 1 in 1500, so it's rare, but not totally rare either. It maybe confusing for normal children, but what about the children born different? That's my thinking.
And why teach to that 1 in 1500?

We don't teach that swans are or can be black, we have white swans, swans are white.

That there are about half a million back swans in the world doesn't affect swans being a white bird. Black swans are an anomaly that we teach about in specific classes covering diversification in birds.

So why teach anything about anomalous human conditions in a general PSHE style assembly? Especially to a whole school session?

Normal children can ;learn about diversity in many varied ways. But they should all be age appropriate and free of gender ideology, claptrap and downright lies. Lies as no matter what the VSD under discussion, human beings are all male or female. The mistake in coding, the VSD, does not change that basic fact.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 09/02/2022 13:09

Thankfully my school agreed not to do it when I pointed this out. Many just don’t think it through proper
Sadly some schools routinely ignore their staff. Glad yours listened.

Foxglovers · 09/02/2022 13:09

@Whatsnewpussyhat

Funny how the examples are almost always little girls wanting to be boys, which is to draw attention away from the adults who are mostly males claiming to be women, who wish to violate female boundaries.
Totally agree