Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this cheeky fuckery re wedding gift

545 replies

Checkered1 · 09/02/2022 09:55

I know I am unreasonable re the story as it’s my fault, but wondering if it’s CF behaviour! Lighthearted.

NC in case my dear friend is on here! If you are L, hello!!

Around 8 years ago, a friend and I went to one of those 90s band reunion concerts. The ticket was around £120 each and for some reason I never paid her back. I assume I completely forgot but I never paid her. I’m honestly not one to never pay back, so I really can’t remember what happened. She also never mentioned it herself as if she did, I would have paid.

So 8 years pass and I forget about it and she never mentions it.

I got married two weeks ago. Her wedding card included a note that her wedding gift is those concert tickets that I never paid her for. I checked my bank account (lucky in that the latest I can go back online is 2014!) and indeed I can’t see that I transferred her anything. I honestly cannot remember why I never paid her, it’s unlike me, but looks like I never did.

I text her to apologise for never paying her back, so there’s no issue between us at all, in fact I was more embarrassed that there was this debt hanging over us all this time.

But I’m just wondering if the way she approached it is in the realms of cheeky fuckery, or if it’s actually clever!

OP posts:
rookiemere · 10/02/2022 09:59

I think OP did absolutely the right thing sending the money, to underline the point that she would have done exactly that at any point during the previous 8 years if only she had been asked.

BorderlineHappy · 10/02/2022 09:57

Oh FWIW though OP, I don't think you should have transferred her the money again - if her "gift" was writing it off that should have been it, I'm surprised she accepted it and didn't send it back to you.
I'm glad the op sent her the money,at least this way it can't be held over her in future.

At least at your next wedding 😜 she'll have to get you a gift🤣

mistermagpie · 10/02/2022 09:46

@CurbsideProphet

I don't see how she could have felt awkward to remind you, yet not too awkward to remind you 8 years later via a message in a wedding card. Sounds like she's not a friend after all. I'm really baffled so many posters think not mentioning the concert tickets for 8 whole years until your wedding day is completely normal behaviour from a friend.
Totally agree. Even if the OP was undertaking some long-game scheme to fiddle her friend out of £120 (which I don't think she was, doesn't sound like £120 matters much to the OP) the friend could still have asked for the money back at ANY point in the last 8 years, thus avoiding all this.
Scbchl · 10/02/2022 09:46

I actually think its a massive dick move on her part. Knowing you would be sat there the day after your wedding on a massive high opening gifts and to get that which sounds like it overshadowed the moment as you felt mortified. I think it was really underhand and snidey of her. Eight years ago and she never mentioned it once but does that for your wedding is shady to me.

5keletor · 10/02/2022 09:37

Oh FWIW though OP, I don't think you should have transferred her the money again - if her "gift" was writing it off that should have been it, I'm surprised she accepted it and didn't send it back to you.

WhaleSnail · 10/02/2022 09:36

She sounds really cruel. She’s had ample opportunity to raise this issue when money was owing back and forth for other events yet that was apparently awkward for her. Sticking an note in your wedding card wasn’t awkward then? It’s a very cruel and strange way to approach the situation. She’s not much of a friend.

If it’s unusual behaviour form her I’d be wondering if she’s found herself cash poor recently though? Maybe she didn’t have cash available to provide a wedding gift so added the note about the £120 as a get out of not giving a gift. Lots of people that seem financially comfortable can suddenly find themselves in debt etc with not much cash available after bills debt repayment etc even if they still have their previous live style they can be “keeping up appearances”.

For what it’s worth I feel, given what you’ve written about your approach to money with friends (which I understand and have done similar systems in the past), that it’s orro than likely you did repay her the £120 at the time via other bills like the meals or other tickets etc. You don’t sound like someone who would just forget as money and favours seem to go back and forth in the group regularly. Now you’ve repaid her I’d leave it at that but be wary around her now. You can afford to write off the £120 it seems so you’ve done the right thing transferring even if you probably already settled that debt in kind at the time. The interesting thing now will be to see if having received “debt” back she gives you day £100 as an ACTUAL wedding gift now. Her behaviour is quite bizarre in this really.

5keletor · 10/02/2022 09:33

I think you're the CF here OP as £120 is a lot of money to simply forget.
I think she's handled it in a fairly lighthearted way, you seem to have taken it well, and you don't owe her anymore, so it's resolved.
I'd laugh and move on, I actually think it's good that she didn't just write the money off, too many people end up at a loss because it's too awkward to ask, or people need continual prompting to pay money back.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 10/02/2022 09:29

Oh FFS, that's a ridiculous thing to hold a grudge about and then write in your friend's wedding card eight years later! If she was that bothered - which she clearly was - she could have just, you know, reminded you at some point over the last EIGHT years?!

SparklingStars10 · 10/02/2022 09:28

This all seems so complicated. I paid for this, he/she paid for that. I think in future just pay for your own, unless it’s a special occasion like a birthday. This reminds me of a time when I went out, mid 20’s when I didn’t have a lot of money and it was decided at the end before checking first that the bill was going to be split, so instead of just paying my £17, I paid £40. Not everyone can afford to just pay for/towards things and if it’s expected it should be agreed first. She should have reminded you to pay her back but it’s also your responsibility to remember to pay back any money owed.

SunshineCake1 · 10/02/2022 09:21

I have changed my mind actually. It was mean to put it in your wedding card so that negates any positiveness of writing it rather than speaking and it becoming a row.

Jumpingintomenopause · 10/02/2022 08:58

@Lunificent

I think you’ve handled this well. It was inappropriate of her to sour your wedding gift experience with her reference to your debt. It was right of you to transfer her the money. From your description of what you’re typically like, I wouldn’t be surprised at all if you had paid for the meal that night and called it quits. A few weeks later she’ll have seen the £120 on her bank statement but forgotten the meal. She doesn’t sound like the loveliest of friends.
I fully agree. We do things the same way in our circle and it all balances out.

It’s sad that your friend has soured the friendship by doing this.

TheApexOfMyLife · 10/02/2022 08:57

@Checkered1 I actually think you’ve handled it perfectly.

She thought she could have a go at you and calm her resentment about the ‘payment’ by landing the issue on your knees just in the day if your wedding.
Instead, you’ve paid her back. And made the clear point that, if this was that hard to let you know until now, surely do) g it in your wedding day should have been even harder? Unless the aim is to be petty and somehow get revenge of course.

I think you’ve ‘lost’ a friend there.
Or rather I’m not sure I could be close to someone I couldn’t trust anymore.

BorderlineHappy · 10/02/2022 08:57

Is she having trouble with her own marriage,that she has to take the shine off yours.

I can just imagine reading all the lovely cards and messages from other people.
Having a great day,and then you read her card.
What a slap in the face and a way to take the shine and memories from a lovely day.

TrufflesAndToast · 10/02/2022 08:55

@LillianGish

I'm surprised at most of the responses on here. If anyone is a CF it's you for not repaying your debt - just be grateful you weren't paying interest over 9 years! Her message in your wedding card is really funny - I don't see why you can't ring her up and have a laugh about it. £120 is not an inconsequential sum (even if you thought she could afford it!) - certainly it would seem a generous amount to splash out on a wedding gift. You are all square now - I think she's played a blinder. Also you don't dispute that you owed her the money. I say good for her.
If her goal is to come across as a weird and petty bitch and to lose a friend then yes, she has played a blinder.

I’d be totally creeped out to feel that a friend had been simmering silently over something I’d accidentally done for eight fucking years without saying a word - and the friendship would be over. I’d never feel comfortable around her again.

I feel a lot of people are responding to this whole completely ignoring the context - that these are financially very comfortable people who pay for stuff for each other all the time and something can easily slip between the cracks.

I’m agog that people are in awe of someone stewing silently about an honest mistake for nearly a decade then writing a nasty message in a card on the OP’s WEDDING DAY! And you think that’s playing a blinder?! What nasty, nasty little people there are in the world Sad

Possuminthereddress · 10/02/2022 08:49

What a cruel and spiteful thing to do. She’s trying to take the shine off your wedding day. Put you in your place in front of your new husband. I would be devastated and humiliated. Is she the jealous type? Was your wedding more extravagant than hers? Are you in a better financial position?

I wouldn’t be able to continue the friendship. You will always remember this now when you think about your wedding.

TheApexOfMyLife · 10/02/2022 08:48

Oh fgs

Who on Earth waits 8years!! to ask for their money back?
And then do it in such a PA way?

Should the OP have paid the money back? Of course
But why on Earth did the friend never mention it? Why has she carried in with the friendship with resentment clearly eating at her?
I’m sorry I don’t get it.

Lunificent · 10/02/2022 08:48

I think you’ve handled this well. It was inappropriate of her to sour your wedding gift experience with her reference to your debt. It was right of you to transfer her the money.
From your description of what you’re typically like, I wouldn’t be surprised at all if you had paid for the meal that night and called it quits. A few weeks later she’ll have seen the £120 on her bank statement but forgotten the meal.
She doesn’t sound like the loveliest of friends.

labyrinthlaziness · 10/02/2022 08:38

I would be buying her a very large bunch of flowers and profusely apologising for it going out of your mind.

Fuck that, I wouldn't. The friend is being weird to have not mentioned it for so long and then to do this on a special occasion.

She's got her £120 back now anyway.

Did she buy you any birthday gifts in the interveing years? Or was this the only time she would have bought you anything?

labyrinthlaziness · 10/02/2022 08:35

@Checkered1

So she called me. Said that I didn’t need to transfer her the money and it was her wedding gift to me. I told her that I didn’t like there was an unspoken debt and I’d rather just pay it. I then said I’m confused why she didn’t mention it all this time when there were many opportunities for her to bring it up. She said she didn’t know how as it had been a long time and didn’t want to seem petty, but it was always on her mind I hadn’t paid. I listed several opportunities that she had to mention it, such as holidays going back to 2015 and she said it felt awkward bringing it up so she never said anything and hoped I would remember.

I then asked if she’s sure that I didn’t pay her back in kind, as I checked my bank statement and I have a transaction for dinner that night, and we would have also gone out for dinner again a couple of weeks later for Christmas. She said she can’t remember going out for dinner before the concert and all she remembers is me buying her a drink that night. I just said oh ok, as because whilst I do see a transaction for that night and I do recall being with her in that restaurant, I can’t remember if it was that day (the transaction date was that day, but I’m just assuming I paid her back in kind so didn’t push it).

She said she’s disappointed that I felt the need to transfer the money as she hoped it was the end of the matter and I said I’m disappointed she waited 8 years until my wedding to bring up a matter I didn’t know existed. And then conversation moved on to my wedding and it was a change of topic. Awkward conversation but a change of topic nonetheless.

So I’m not quite sure what to make of it. It’s actually really saddened me and I’m not sure what to think.

I am sorry but I actually think this person may be a frenemy having read this.

It is deeply weird to bring this up on your wedding day, IMO.

I'm not surprised you are saddened, just let the dust settle and see how thinsg develop. What a silly person she is to have done this!

lucythejuicy · 10/02/2022 08:34

It's very strange - she should have just reminded you that you owed her the money. It would piss me off actually

Sunnyday321 · 10/02/2022 08:31

Be assured she has in some way held it against you all those years , it has irked her , bubbling under the surface but not quite enough to finish the friendship.
Tbh , I don't blame her £120 for a ticket that many years ago is a fair sum of money .
I would be buying her a very large bunch of flowers and profusely apologising for it going out of your mind.

LillianGish · 10/02/2022 08:30

I'm surprised at most of the responses on here. If anyone is a CF it's you for not repaying your debt - just be grateful you weren't paying interest over 9 years! Her message in your wedding card is really funny - I don't see why you can't ring her up and have a laugh about it. £120 is not an inconsequential sum (even if you thought she could afford it!) - certainly it would seem a generous amount to splash out on a wedding gift. You are all square now - I think she's played a blinder. Also you don't dispute that you owed her the money. I say good for her.

rookiemere · 10/02/2022 08:28

@ThinWomansBrain yes that's how I do it with my friend. Prior to lockdown we used to go for a walk and a coffee and breakfast roll once a week or so, and took turns to pay it.

Trouble is with both of us being menopausal we'd sometimes forget whose turn it was, but as the overall cost was around £10, then no biggie.

For bigger expenses we'd do bank transfers. I generally book tickets so just whatsapp friend how much she owes me and in it goes.

It does seem in this case - and I would implore everyone to at least read all of the OPs posts if nothing else - that OP may well have repaid concert ticket through paying for meals and drinks around the event.

I think paying her back was absolutely the right thing to do, and for me it would be a bit of a line in the sand for the friendship. If I was to go out with her going forward, it would be awkward as I'd insist on us each paying our share separately so no future situations arose. Dick move to use a wedding gift for payback, not nice at all.

NinaDefoe · 10/02/2022 08:27

8 years is a long time not to mention this ‘debt’ to you.
She’s gone about it in a very spiteful way. Who claims a debt in lieu of a wedding present? Why wait until then to make a point?

I would transfer the money to her regardless of what she says. Tell her that you had no idea you still owed her money and would prefer it if she had the cash.
I would also make it clear that you do not want or expect a wedding gift.

PainterMummy · 10/02/2022 08:26

Really bizarre thing to do. Particularly over the course of 8 years never saying anything to you. Out for dinner, come time to split the bill would be a good time to mention it? Out shopping, passing cash points etc. a number of scenarios where money is being used, payment being made, to bring up the £120. But to stew in it for 8 years and write that in your wedding card is not on.