Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that you don't post this on even a private group in Facebook?

159 replies

NatashaBedwouldbenice · 09/02/2022 07:37

DP is a member of a Facebook group for people trying to find biological family via DNA (usually birth parents and usually via hobby DNA sites such as Ancestry or 23andMe).

One woman has had a terrible time. She traced her dad a couple of years. They arranged to meet but he never turned up and his wife messaged her to drop it. She only lives six blocks away. This is horribly unfair and unkind, but unfortunately very common.

Yesterday she said that she'd finally been able to meet him. He was in hospital, unconscious and dying from Covid. She has posted a selfie with his head in the background and all sorts of tubes and things on his face. In the photo he is either dying or dead.

AIBU that as tragic as this is for her, she is horribly misguided in posting such a photo on social media?
It is a private group but has about 180 000 members.

OP posts:
NatashaBedwouldbenice · 09/02/2022 09:02

Does it not have moderation either? Usually these kind of groups moderate consent on third party pictures.

Very active moderation. The admins "cross-posted" but explained that they allow photos of dead people and they allow photos of living people if it's a reunion photo.

OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 09:02

@Noisyneighneigh

It's not OK. I feel the same about kids who post pics of their kids in hospital. Wtf is wrong with them?
Some sick children spend most of their short lives in hospital and they don’t have any other occasions to take photos.
NatashaBedwouldbenice · 09/02/2022 09:01

Ah, understood @AutomaticMoon and my apologies, I missed the part about a mental crisis. I need to slow down and read posts more carefully, please accept my apology.

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman · 09/02/2022 09:00

A picture for herself. Not 180,000 strangers.

Exactly. I get she wanted it for herself - so why not keep it to herself? The charitable explanation is that, given she’s upset, she’s convinced herself this is okay as it’s a ‘private’ space (with a population bigger than some cities). But it smacks of making a point, as do some of the responses on this thread.

Lalliella · 09/02/2022 08:59

@Violet869

Everyone deals with things in different ways. If it makes them feel better about their situation, then it’s a positive thing.
No it isn’t. It’s not acceptable to post photos of a dying person without their consent and upset their close family just to make them feel better. Nothing positive about that.
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 08:58

@NatashaBedwouldbenice

hmm That’s not how grief works for everyone. Not everyone is you.

That's an unkind reply to a very dignified post. What do you mean that's not how grief works? You mean that some widows have a grief that gives them carte blanche to behave however they choose?

No, I meant that grief can turn into mental illness and is not under the control of the grieving person. PP said she was encouraged to ‘go crazy’, that’s unkind, not what I said. My mother’s grief turned into paranoid schizophrenia and it wasn’t because she had ‘carte blanche’ to ‘act crazy’
Lalliella · 09/02/2022 08:58

@JuicySatsuma85

“He owed her”.

Sure he owed her an explanation. Not a photo of his dead body immortalised on social media.

Some of you sound psychotic.

^^ this

Where’s the consent in all this?

fourandtwo · 09/02/2022 08:58

@NatashaBedwouldbenice

The person who gently suggested she remove the photo from her post got roundly told off. That it's her choice and that challenging this is against the Safe Space nature of the group.

Two admins posted at about the same time, defending the OP's right to post the photo. One said that the group allows Reunion photos and the other said they allow photos of dead people.

I really feel for his other family. Can you imagine finding out that you have a half sibling or half auntie and that she's posted such a private image on social media?
Not only that, but over 300 posters have replied in sympathy for her loss and writing mawkish things such as she was His Angel?

And now you’re writing about it on a separate site with - presumably - no permission from the woman in question 🤷🏼‍♀️ I don’t think you’re much better to be honest. I’d have just hidden her post and moved on.
ThePlumVan · 09/02/2022 08:56

It’s not at all appropriate but I’ve never been abandoned by my father so it’s difficult to judge her.

@NatashaBedwouldbenice what was the JW reply ?

Violet869 · 09/02/2022 08:56

Everyone deals with things in different ways. If it makes them feel better about their situation, then it’s a positive thing.

C8H10N4O2 · 09/02/2022 08:56

It is a private group but has about 180 000 members

In practice there is no such thing as a private group with 180,000 members, you have to assume anything there might be shared.

Does it not have moderation either? Usually these kind of groups moderate consent on third party pictures.

Givemehopeee · 09/02/2022 08:54

You’re focussing too much on the man in the photo rather than the event. This was the first and last time she met him. She will never get that opportunity again. This is the only thing she has from him - a photo with him whilst he’s on his death bed.

You don’t know what internal battles she has gone through, and to judge her for sharing the only photo they have together is the greater sin IMO. So so judgmental when for her, it’s probably a case of I finally met him, here it is. The fact that he’s on his death bed is circumstantial.

Also, I highly doubt he was dead. Dead people are not left alone with tubes still in them. They are (or should be) treated with more dignity than that.

NatashaBedwouldbenice · 09/02/2022 08:50

hmm That’s not how grief works for everyone. Not everyone is you.

That's an unkind reply to a very dignified post. What do you mean that's not how grief works? You mean that some widows have a grief that gives them carte blanche to behave however they choose?

OP posts:
Berengaria1 · 09/02/2022 08:49

I think it's disgraceful. I can't believe anyone is saying it's ok. He has a right to privacy.

Noisyneighneigh · 09/02/2022 08:48

It's not OK. I feel the same about kids who post pics of their kids in hospital. Wtf is wrong with them?

NatashaBedwouldbenice · 09/02/2022 08:47

That's the only photo she'll ever have with her and her Dad. She deserves one.

Again, she deserves a photo. She deserves so much more. She does not have a right to this photo, let alone a right to post it on social media.

OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 08:45

@CrinklyCraggy

Is it not worse to describe the exact situation on a much bigger site with a history of having things picked up by the press?. She has reasons for not thinking entirely straight about the situation. What's your excuse?
This.
NatashaBedwouldbenice · 09/02/2022 08:45

(@Pawsin, did you see the reply from the Jehovah's Witness?).

OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 08:44

@EishetChayil

I really dislike the prevailing sentiment that grief gives a free pass to behave in selfish and damaging ways. When I lost my partner, I was almost encouraged to go a bit crazy, lash out, behave out of character. But even in the depths of my grief, I never allowed myself to forget that I was still a member of society with certain responsibilities and expectations.
Hmm That’s not how grief works for everyone. Not everyone is you.
Ceramide · 09/02/2022 08:43

Not OK to post the photo, or even to have taken it without permission.

AdmiralCain · 09/02/2022 08:42

That's the only photo she'll ever have with her and her Dad. She deserves one.

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 08:42

@saraclara

I really feel for his other family. Can you imagine finding out that you have a half sibling or half auntie and that she's posted such a private image on social media?

That. None of this is their fault, yet suddenly, not only do they have to deal with their own grief, but they also have to cope with this person appearing in their lives, and posting such a distressing picture.

Why would his family see it, they’re not in the FB group
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 08:41

@Cocomarine

“I really feel for his other family. Can you imagine finding out that you have a half sibling or half auntie and that she's posted such a private image on social media?”

My sympathies lie more with the person who was rejected my their parents over the people gaining a sibling. I do have sympathy with both - but far more the former.

If posting that photo helps her in her own mind with the connection to him and grieving now - so be it.

The mawkish types posting about Angels are just wanders - but that’s not her fault.

Maybe she needs to read that she was really His Angel and lie to herself that he might have given a shit, though?

This 😞 but apparently we’re psychotic for thinking like this Hmm
saraclara · 09/02/2022 08:39

I really feel for his other family. Can you imagine finding out that you have a half sibling or half auntie and that she's posted such a private image on social media?

That. None of this is their fault, yet suddenly, not only do they have to deal with their own grief, but they also have to cope with this person appearing in their lives, and posting such a distressing picture.

NatashaBedwouldbenice · 09/02/2022 08:35

@EishetChayil Thank you for your perspective Flowers I hope you are faring well.

OP posts: