Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that you don't post this on even a private group in Facebook?

159 replies

NatashaBedwouldbenice · 09/02/2022 07:37

DP is a member of a Facebook group for people trying to find biological family via DNA (usually birth parents and usually via hobby DNA sites such as Ancestry or 23andMe).

One woman has had a terrible time. She traced her dad a couple of years. They arranged to meet but he never turned up and his wife messaged her to drop it. She only lives six blocks away. This is horribly unfair and unkind, but unfortunately very common.

Yesterday she said that she'd finally been able to meet him. He was in hospital, unconscious and dying from Covid. She has posted a selfie with his head in the background and all sorts of tubes and things on his face. In the photo he is either dying or dead.

AIBU that as tragic as this is for her, she is horribly misguided in posting such a photo on social media?
It is a private group but has about 180 000 members.

OP posts:
Branleuse · 09/02/2022 16:21

@saraclara

DNA proof that it would be their sister, not just a claim so maybe theyd also be angry with you that youd try to prevent the reunion and them meeting their sister before he was actually dying?

I was talking about ME, @branleuse. Not this man who rejected the daughter. I wouldn't have done so, but given the same timeline of this person meeting me, my DD's would still be essentially dealing with a stranger of a half sister that they'd only just met, and who put a selfie of her with me, dying or dead, on Facebook. It would be absolutely traumatic for them.

yes I understood that, but if it was you and your family then there would be no reason for you to be in the same private group and you and they wouldnt even know that someone had a picture with him. If it was my children, I think we would likely feel much more kindly towards the woman, especially on discovering that she had been prevented from meeting us all until then. I think the trauma of losing their father would be enormous, and the fact that they also had a half sister who they had been prevented from meeting, would be quite a headfuck, but the fact that theyd taken a photo of him and her would be a non issue.
Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/02/2022 15:52

People on MN seem horrified at the very idea of ‘judgement’. Judgement doesn’t have to be a negative thing. How does anyone ever understand that their behaviour is wrong if no one ever judges them for it?

Accurately put, though TBF it can depend on what someone wants to do with that judgement. Within the law none of us get to tell others what they must do, but then neither do we get to expect no comment on what we choose to make public

And that can be a problem when folk want validation from social media; all the hunning is very welcome, but ask some if they're making the best possible choice and they go berserk

Sportslady44 · 09/02/2022 15:49

downside of camera phones today.

Anything can be photographed and put online.

Just because you can though, dosent mean you should.

saraclara · 09/02/2022 15:35

DNA proof that it would be their sister, not just a claim so maybe theyd also be angry with you that youd try to prevent the reunion and them meeting their sister before he was actually dying?

I was talking about ME, @branleuse. Not this man who rejected the daughter. I wouldn't have done so, but given the same timeline of this person meeting me, my DD's would still be essentially dealing with a stranger of a half sister that they'd only just met, and who put a selfie of her with me, dying or dead, on Facebook. It would be absolutely traumatic for them.

HoliHormonalTigerlilly · 09/02/2022 14:29

@NatashaBedwouldbenice

Could you gently suggest that she might like to keep the photos private?

Someone did and got lambasted. It's not there now anyway.

(Not sure how she could have got into a covid ward...) He was dying/dead of covid-related complications apparently.

You'r think the admin's of the group would take it down.
lunar1 · 09/02/2022 13:22

Nobody is owed a picture with someone who is dying and can't consent.

Yes what happened to this woman is awful, but that grief doesn't come with entitlement.

I'm owed an awful lot by my biological dad, he's a hideous human being and I wish nothing but paper cuts and cold sores on him and the thing he married for the rest of their natural lives.

But they don't owe me the opportunity to photograph them dying and publishing the images for people to see.

Sadly in life we don't always get what we deserve, we aren't always treated kindly and with empathy and understanding. It doesn't give us the right to behave however we please out of grief.

Pamlar · 09/02/2022 13:19

Social media has completely skewed the way people interact. The attention seeking and over sharing is hideous.
Here was a woman looking for a father, rejected and devastated -it doesn't take much to work out why she needed all the attention and validation. It's hideous and distasteful. I feel sorry for all involved

AlternativePerspective · 09/02/2022 13:02

But for all anyone knows she might well have posted it all over her own social media as well. Clearly she has no boundaries if she’s posting it to a group full of strangers, any one of who could also have been related to the man for all we know. So it’s not a huge leap to think that she might have posted it on her own profile as well.

SomePosters · 09/02/2022 13:00

It wasn’t you that said about people posting pics of their kids in hospital, that was to another poster but the quote got lost

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 09/02/2022 12:58

Not saying it's likely or inventing anything. It's a situation which could happen by posting images like this on social media.

Cocomarine · 09/02/2022 12:54

@BellaTheDarkOverlord that’s a reach, it wasn’t even this woman’s personal SM. Even if one of her friends from the group referred to it on the daughter’s own SM, this really doesn’t sound like a situation where grandad rejected a grandchild’s aunt, yet aunt and niece are buddies on Facebook. There’s enough here to discuss without inventing the unlikely!

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 09/02/2022 12:48

You'd hope if he was indeed dead that the family had already been notified, and there wasn't possibly a grandchild somewhere who learns of grandad's death from social media photos before family have chance to tell them.

Branleuse · 09/02/2022 12:42

@saraclara

I cannot imagine what it would do to my daughters to have a photo like that of me, put on FB after my death by ANYONE, never mind by some stranger who'd just blown into their lives claiming to be their sister.
DNA proof that it would be their sister, not just a claim so maybe theyd also be angry with you that youd try to prevent the reunion and them meeting their sister before he was actually dying?
Branleuse · 09/02/2022 12:40

my ex who was adopted, was also rejected by his biological father when he traced him. Thankfully some of his other relatives on that side wanted contact, as it was such a hurtful rejection.
In my family we have had a few instances of new cousins appearing since DNA testing became mainstream and affordable. Its unthinkable that they would have been rejected once discovered. You might well find that the family of this dead man would actually be more sympathetic than you think, maybe except the wife that tried to stop the reunion from happening.
This woman has as much right as anyone in the family to post that selfie, and the fact is, she wont have other photos of him in better health, so please try not to judge so harshly.

WomanStanleyWoman · 09/02/2022 12:31

Very nicely put. I’m surprised about all the judgement on here but I guess I shouldn’t be. It’s a bit demoralising to see how cold people are re:grief.

People on MN seem horrified at the very idea of ‘judgement’. Judgement doesn’t have to be a negative thing. How does anyone ever understand that their behaviour is wrong if no one ever judges them for it?

Cornettoninja · 09/02/2022 12:18

I don’t disagree @Puzzledandpissedoff. I would hate to think a picture of me really ill/dying could be put on social media. I’m not even comfortable with the idea of being paraded around in a hearse!

The existence of the picture isn’t the problem, you’re right, it’s the sharing of it over social media with unvetted, strangers. The man may have been beelzebub but now an image of some of his final moments on earth has been offered up to random people to immortalise their opinions about him and his mistakes with no defence or right of reply. I don’t see how that’s helpful to anyone involved.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/02/2022 11:57

It’s not the first time I’ve come across this kind of report

Nor me, Cornettoninja - in fact I originally thought the thread was a rehash of this one: www.thesun.co.uk/fabulous/16526392/disrespectful-funeral-selfie-daughter-dad/

It's not the actual taking of the photo though - my dad took one of my mum in her coffin, and though I hated it I respected his choice - but the plastering of it all over social media
Which is why I said that, faced with a keyboard, some people's brains appear to fall out

saraclara · 09/02/2022 11:55

I cannot imagine what it would do to my daughters to have a photo like that of me, put on FB after my death by ANYONE, never mind by some stranger who'd just blown into their lives claiming to be their sister.

Cornettoninja · 09/02/2022 11:28

I think there’s a fairly deep generational divide with opinions here.

I feel for the woman, but also am uncomfortable with the idea that someone can lose all autonomy over their image at such a vulnerable time. I don’t think there’s really anything that justifies taking that away without clear consent from either themselves or someone advocating in their best interests with the knowledge of their boundaries.

It’s not the first time I’ve come across this kind of report, although it’s usually involving people with an established relationship.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/02/2022 11:27

It's the same old, same old isn't it - people get on SM and their brains fall out
Whatever happened to discretion? Hmm

Nowayoutonlydown · 09/02/2022 11:06

I'd say it's really inappropriate, but who knows how most of us would react if we wanted to meet our dad for what I'd assume is a long time, then when the time came, it was in that situation.

I can see there's a few steps between sharing a picture of meeting your dad, and a picture of your dad dying/dead but honestly i can imagine she's pretty emotionally fucked up by it at the moment.

Maybe she will notice how inappropriate this was in time

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/02/2022 11:04

@thinkingaboutLangCleg

All my dympathy is for the woman who was rejected twice.
You have no sympathy for his family?
LouisRenault · 09/02/2022 11:01

I feel bad for her that she knew who part of her real family was....

What about the family who brought her up? Are they not her 'real' family?

katepilar · 09/02/2022 10:53

Private group or not, makes no difference. Posting a picture of anyone else without his explicit consent is wrong.
I dont post pictures of myself, let alone anyone else and dont want to take group pictures anywhere anymore because most people just dont understand and/or dont care.

LimeSegment · 09/02/2022 10:50

I see the concern but not sure I'd be worried about it. He is dead. His family knows the story. The photo isn't going to go viral around the world, because it's just a photo of a man in a hospital bed. The photo wasn't taken to make money or gain any advantage.

Its her story to share as well.