Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give up on the gym?

61 replies

ShittyFingers · 09/02/2022 07:36

I joined the local gym around a year ago. Went once … didn’t go again until last month. Had a personal fitness plan created and then went 3 times the week after, twice the week after that, 3 times the following week and then once last week.

I don’t bloody like it that’s the problem! I don’t enjoy it! That fucking cross trainer thing kills me and I could just about manage 5 minutes on it before feeling like I’m going to melt in a heap.
I do not like being hot and sweaty, I find it incredibly stressful. Why am I paying for this??

Well, I have a stone to lose … doing calorie counting. Do I need the gym, I mean … do I really need it??

I do around 10,000 steps a day without the gym.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PaddleBoardingMomma · 09/02/2022 11:20

@Allsorts1

You do need to exercise to look good and importantly to feel good - mentally and emotionally. Find something that works for you though! I love a HIIT or weights class - do three a week and you are sorted. Find something that works for you - whether that’s Pilates, taking up an actual sport (eg tennis or a work netball team or something, or downloading an exercise app and doing home workouts) as you can’t live a happy long life without exercise.
you can't live a happy long life without exercise

This ^

I wish I'd realised this much sooner than 32, I wish a love of exercise had been instilled in me as a child, actually!

Allsorts1 · 09/02/2022 11:07

You do need to exercise to look good and importantly to feel good - mentally and emotionally. Find something that works for you though! I love a HIIT or weights class - do three a week and you are sorted. Find something that works for you - whether that’s Pilates, taking up an actual sport (eg tennis or a work netball team or something, or downloading an exercise app and doing home workouts) as you can’t live a happy long life without exercise.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 09/02/2022 11:03

It took me 32 years on this planet before I actually took the gym seriously and joined one I really liked, despite it costing an arm and a leg (thanks David Lloyd) and I was dreading it, thought I would absolutely hate it, like other gyms I've joined and ended up not going to. But it's a different world! The people are encouraging and friendly, I love using the pool, there's so much variety of equipment that I can do a different set each day every week and not get bored. I love it because it's finally the right fit for me, maybe try other gyms? And I've found as well as losing weight I'm mentally so much happier. After a gym session I go for a half hour swim, sit in the sauna for 10 mins then dip back into the cool pool before getting out. That last part is absolute bliss, I leave feeling so relaxed and with a clear head. Although those two hours away from the kids are probably the biggest factor 🤣 I hope you find something you really love going, it's a game changer x

HomeHomeInTheRange · 09/02/2022 10:43

Hmmm.

I would say keep at it a bit before you give it up.

You don’t have to follow the plan.

If you don’t like the cross trainer try other things. Lower the speed / intensity, listen to music or a podcast. You only need to get slightly out of breath, not ‘hot and sweaty’.

But if you do lots of walking anyway, it might be that what you most benefit from is weights at the gym. High reps on low / medium weights will tone lots of muscles in no time. Which makes you (me!) feel much better, stronger, and looks good.

People say you don’t need exercise to lose weight but I lose quicker, and keep it off more easily, if I do regular weights / weight bearing exercise.

If you really hate it, stop and do something else but I would say see if you can make it fit you better first.

Do they do different classes? I have enjoyed trying different sessions, Les Mills Body Pump being my current favourite.

rookiemere · 09/02/2022 10:31

Yes I've always thought it's a bit ironic that people drive to the gym to walk on the treadmill. But then I joined a gym a 15 minute drive away Blushmainly for the outdoor pool and I do Body Pump ( a weights class) once or twice a week, but I also walk the dog every day and run with a friend and do parkrun.
To be honest my gym membership is more about enjoying the outdoor heated pool than expecting to get all my fitness needs met, and it's just handy that there's classes on at times that work for me.

Gladioli23 · 09/02/2022 10:25

The key thing about exercise is you need to not hate it.

I don't like running, so I hate the treadmill. I also don't much like the cross trainer. I'm quite happy on the bike, and also on the rowing machines. I also love swimming.

Classes scare me because I don't want to humiliate myself and have to commit for the entire class.

BUT I really enjoy weights - I have genuinely really surprised myself by enjoying them. I do a 10 minute cardio warm up, then pick 5 things and do them, then go for a swim afterwards.

The thing I find ideal about weights is there's an equality in them - I can go with a friend and it doesn't matter if they lift more than me or less than me, we just use a different dumbell or set the weight on the machine differently and then we're doing the same thing. Then you can just increase it in increments as and when you feel able. I still have loads to learn and I don't very often do free weights with the big plates etc but I am learning more every time. I'm not prepared to commit to e.g. push, pull and legs type days or anything even vaguely complicated but I know I have been getting stronger and fitter even just using the somewhat haphazard methods I have been using so far!

There's no point trying to commit to exercise you hate as that's a sure fire way to be miserable - but if you find something you like then that's great.

CounsellorTroi · 09/02/2022 10:23

I don’t like the cross trainer either, prefer the rowing machine. I can go into a sort of trance on that. I do 20-25 minutes. Also use the shoulder and chest presses, leg press and abductor/adductor. Swimming is also good.

ShittyFingers · 09/02/2022 10:20

Dog walk will be 5000 steps

OP posts:
ShittyFingers · 09/02/2022 10:20

I’ve just done a 4000 step walk to asda. To be fair I only tend to do 3000 steps in the hour long tone up class I was meant to go to so I don’t feel as bad about not going now (I was going to drive to asda from the gym, doesn’t make sense does it 😂)

OP posts:
ShittyFingers · 09/02/2022 10:18

I don’t know what it is about the cross trainer, it just knackered me after a minute. I hate it. Yet I could do an hour on the treadmill

OP posts:
SpongebobsPants · 09/02/2022 10:18

Definitely give outdoor exercise a try. I thought I hated running because I had only ever done it on a treadmill. I decided to do Couch 2 5k about 18 months ago and have enjoyed running ever since. I use kettlebells at home for toning (although I'm not very consistent with them!)

Of course, it doesn't have to be running, but any exercise outdoors can really give you the feel good factor. Gyms are great, but they aren't for everyone. I do a lap of my local playing fields during my run and see people sweating away indoors on the leisure centre treadmills and think it just seems so pointless, although I do realise there are other machines available!

Brainwave89 · 09/02/2022 10:10

I agree OP I find gyms quite challenging places. At times something akin to a medieval torture chamber. I have found classes much more useful than gym sessions. Also (difficult one for me personally), the heavier focus needs to be on what you eat rather than exercise. A good gym workout for me will take out maybe 600-700 calories. Through my head then goes the thought I have earned something nice (muffin or a bacon role). If I do this, I can easily undo all my good work

WeAreTheHeroes · 09/02/2022 10:07

@AnnieLobeseder

And all those people saying "weight loss is about what you eat", well, yes, but being thin and unfit is a fairly pointless goal unless looking good is all that matters to you. Maintaining good cardiovascular health, muscle tone and bone density is far more important for long term health.
Not one poster before you advocated not doing any form of exercise. Not one.
SpaghettiArmsMurderer · 09/02/2022 09:53

If you were intimidated at karate could you try capoeira?

SpaghettiArmsMurderer · 09/02/2022 09:52

You’re never going to go if you don’t like it so end your membership and stop wasting the money. Look for something else that’s more fun, like swimming, dancing, hiking, cycling etc.

rookiemere · 09/02/2022 09:16

Actually rereading what you said about Karate, you could try Body Combat. Similar exercises but no coming into contact with others.

I used to do a circuits class with a bit of sparring and in the end I had to give it up
As some of the men there made it a point of honour to go as hard as they could against your pads if you were female.

LibbyL92 · 09/02/2022 09:15

No: I’ve lost 3.5 stone since Feb last year doing low carb high fat.
Zero exercise.

I joined the gym in December to purely tone my body.

queenofarles · 09/02/2022 09:09

It doesn’t make sense that you can manage 10000 steps but not 5 minutes on the Cross trainer.

I don’t enjoy doing any form of Hiit ,
The way I see it, working out is not an enjoyable experience. But it’s a must and the end result is worth those 30-40 minutes of being uncomfortable.

Sprig1 · 09/02/2022 09:00

Give up the gym and find something that you enjoy. I have just started couch 2 5k. It is v good as it makes you take it at a v steady rate so you don't knacker yourself and decide you want to stop all together.

Campervangirl · 09/02/2022 08:57

I'm with you, I hate it.
I've started walking instead.
To put it in perspective I walked 5 miles and burnt 400 calories according to my app, that about the same calories as two small bars of chocolate 🙄
I'm still going to walk (quite enjoy it) and I've got weights and kettle bells at home.
My OH is a gym bunny and even he says it all about calories in to calories out.
So count your calories and use weights to tone up, also you could try yoga for beginners, plenty of free videos online.
Good luck

CocoPancakes · 09/02/2022 08:57

I should add the stuff I do with the PT is mostly weights/strength training with a bit of cardio chucked in.

CocoPancakes · 09/02/2022 08:55

Have you tried working with a PT? I was the same with the gym. Went once and had a "personalised plan" put in place for me, which was essentially an hour of the woman beasting me to the point of nearly breaking. I honestly could barely walk up/down the stairs without nearly crying for about 5 days after. I tried going on my own once or twice more after but the whole feeling of being there and hating the equipment on my plan meant I of course gave up. About a year later I started seeing a PT once a week and it was a huge difference. Working with someone who starts at your level, rather than the generic level the set everyone at and works with you every week makes such a huge difference. You still have to work hard and sweat buckets, and you still ache the day after but I've found it actually enjoyable. I've been going solidly for about a year now.
I also do a lot of miles - mostly just fast paced walking - every day like you and can feel a real difference in both fitness and body strength. I lost a couple of stone in a year as I was calorie counting too.

Changeee15467 · 09/02/2022 08:49

My two cents:

When I started exercising for the mental not physical benefits I got hooked. Have run and off for a few years. Never liked the gym but recently found one very close by and I do the classes only. In and out in an hour or less. Loving the weights and realise how much I was knackering myself just doing cardio. Really enjoying it.

No point doing something you hate, you won’t stick at it. Do it for the feel good factor and it’ll happen because you’ll want that high not to try and lose weight. I agree with PPs that weight loss is mostly diet anyway unless you’re really pushing exercise to the limit. Good luck!

Funkyslippers · 09/02/2022 08:41

Yep, I've managed for most of my adult life without a gym and kept my weight down. I used to run and do YouTube fitness videos. (I'm now a member of David Lloyd but that's not the point!!)

OldEvilOwl · 09/02/2022 08:39

Do something else! try hiking/walking? I lost quite a bit of weight doing this in the last year.
You could just diet, but I find it easier to stick to if exercising as well, and you see the results quicker which motivates you

Swipe left for the next trending thread