Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Little Matchstick Girl

34 replies

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 00:47

AIBU to think children of age 5-6 shouldn’t be exposed to this story? I just realised that I think this is when my life long depression started (2 attempts on my own life), it’s too disturbing and traumatic for small children to know this is the world we live in.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SomeOwlsCoo · 13/02/2022 01:50

It was one of my favourite stories as a child, even though it made me cry. As a teen I loved the song "Artificial Flowers" by The Beautiful South.

I have a long history of depression and anxiety as an adult but I don't think it has a link to linking sad stories.

BigPlanes · 13/02/2022 01:41

I think that if you are more prone to anxiety and depression it’s going to happen as a kid too? Or childhood trauma is reflected back at you. This is one of the stories that have stayed with me. Off the top of my head these are some of the worst:

Little Matchstick Girl - dying in the snow
A Little Princess - parental death, poverty
Goodnight Mister Tom - horrific abuse

Viviennemary · 13/02/2022 01:35

I agree. Its horrible. No need to expose children to this kind of thing.

SwissCheeseRentedChildren · 13/02/2022 01:15

AutomaticMoon

I wonder if it was the illustrations in the particular book I read. She had very clearly died at the end!

I was diagnosed with ASD (atypical) last year.

My childhood was… stable but chaotic? In that we all lived in the same slightly-too-small house with our parents until adulthood, went to same primary and secondary schools throughout. But there was a lot of stress, Dad was alcoholic and could be really nasty, there was a lot of strife between him and Mum.

My brothers weren’t very nice either. I never quite understood the “point” of my existence.

Bright enough, but massively lacking in motivation, I really struggled with school, and couldn’t really cope with any job I had (haven’t worked in quite a long time now, I just need peace!).

Overemotional, overthinking, overexplainer. That’s me! 🤓

I’m really sorry you’ve had such a rotten time. ☹️

Rainartist · 09/02/2022 21:12

I had a book with the most beautiful illustrations of this story but it always broke my heart as did The Little Mermaid, The Ugly Duckling, The Snow Queen and The red shoes (omg she had her feet chopped off to stop dancing then lived in the church for the rest of her life!) And many, many more. I have suffered depression throughout life too although I'm NT and had no particular trauma. I think some children are more prone to being affected by stories as they empathise with the characters. My first trip to the cinema age 5 was the old Snow White and I can still remember going to nans after and my aunt saying did I enjoy it and me bursting into tears even though I'd seen the happy ending, it was the first real dramatisation I'd been exposed to and was all a bit overwhelming.

I was an early reader and don't remember these stories ever being read to me, I read them to myself and maybe I was too young when I did as you felt you were too op. I never talked about my worries to my parents though. I always asked my children how they felt about books we read but they never seemed particularly bothered, they still roll their eyes at me for getting teary at certain stories even now!

Honourofgrayskull · 09/02/2022 21:05

As a child I had this most beautifully illustrated fairy tale book which had many stories in it and The Little Match Girl was my favourite. I loved the pictures I think and although I felt bad for her I too thought she had magically went to live with her lovely gran and don't think I realised she had died.
I still have this book and read this story to my son a few years ago, it was so sad I cried and couldn't read to the end. Still love it though.

Theworkhouse · 09/02/2022 21:04

It's an extraordinarily sad story. I'm afraid I couldn't read that one, or the one about the sparrow and the statue, or the one about the grumpy old man and the garden, out loud to the children without crying.

And I'm not a particularly sentimental or empathetic person.

LazySaturday · 09/02/2022 20:55

*This really hit me in the guts.

I’m not crying, you’re crying! 😭

Are you a psychologist or something like that? I think I really do identify with the little girl. Still! After living with my grandparents I had to be in foster care and let’s just say the time with my grandparents was paradise, in comparison.*

Not a psychologist but I work with children affected by trauma.
I'm so sorry you had difficult experiences as a child.
I think fairy tales, the real versions are often incredibly dark for just this reason. They're stories originally designed to give children a context to explore those feelings in, but in a safe way.
I hope you're getting the IRL support you need now?

Vanellopee · 09/02/2022 03:46

I’ve only seen the Disney and I cried.

Must have been in my mid 30s.....

nettie434 · 09/02/2022 03:44

It's sad to imagine you trying to teach yourself to read on your own. It's like a sad children's story in itself.

I found most Hans Christian Anderson stories very sad. Even the happy ending of The Snow Queen has got some very upsetting episodes. A lot of Oscar Wilde fairy stories are very sad too but I think readers at the time - including children - were much more accepting of sadness and death. I think they are really written for older children but as Disney has Disneyfied many of the stories, it's easy to assume the stories are for the same age group as the films.

I hope life is a bit better for you now AutomaticMoon, even though you have had to battle with depression.

Thepollonator · 09/02/2022 02:16

I loved this story as a child but granted I never realised that she had died, I just thought that she had gone to live with her lovely grandmother! I remember watching it on tv on Christmas eve whilst my mum made mince pies!
I make sure that I watch it every Christmas eve now just to remind myself of that one happy day as a child!

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 02:04

*content not consent

OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 02:04

@Titfortatfortit

I find his little mermaid more disturbing. I remember hiding it upside down under my bed until I could take it back to the library.
We didn’t have the little mermaid but I know what you mean, that could scare a small child too. Sirens in folklore are not pleasant, they lure sailors to death but I guess it’s not new for Disney, they have some questionable consent.
OP posts:
Titfortatfortit · 09/02/2022 01:48

I find his little mermaid more disturbing. I remember hiding it upside down under my bed until I could take it back to the library.

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 01:26

@DoubleChinWoes2

I suppose another way to say what you're getting at is "had I not have read this book, I wouldn't have depression" and presumably that's not true.

I'm sorry you had such a difficult start in life x

Thank you most kindly, that’s true, I would most likely be the same way had I not read it x
OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 01:22

@steff13

I always thought it was The Little Match Girl. I think that the causes of depression are more complicated than exposure to a sad story.
I’m sorry, that’s my mistake. I was in a different country and it was another language, and I translated it incorrectly in my head.
OP posts:
DoubleChinWoes2 · 09/02/2022 01:20

I suppose another way to say what you're getting at is "had I not have read this book, I wouldn't have depression" and presumably that's not true.

I'm sorry you had such a difficult start in life x

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 01:20

@SwissCheeseRentedChildren

I read this when I was little and I found it so incredibly sad.

I, too, have had a lifetime of debilitating depression!

My friend read it as a child and thought it was a lovely book. She’s far better at life than I am.

That’s odd, isn’t it? Did you have adverse childhood experiences that your friend perhaps didn’t? It’s impossible to know what goes on behind closed doors though. If you don’t mind mr asking, are you neurotypical? I don’t think I am, I struggle with a few things but not sure if it’s my cPTSD or maybe autism/adhd.
OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 01:17

@LazySaturday

I was unhappy to not be with my parents as a child so maybe this played a part

This and the fact that you were teaching yourself to read rather than being read to make it sound as if you were incredibly lonely and empathised strongly with the girl.
I'd guess life events rather than the book are at the heart of things.

This really hit me in the guts.

I’m not crying, you’re crying! 😭

Are you a psychologist or something like that? I think I really do identify with the little girl. Still! After living with my grandparents I had to be in foster care and let’s just say the time with my grandparents was paradise, in comparison.

OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 01:12

@LazySaturday

I'd agree that it's a very sad story. Good for older children to read and think about the lives that other people lead. At 5-6 it sounds as if you were too young for it and a sensitive soul. But the root of long term depression, no. I'd guess that a natural inclination towards depression as a very sensitive child plus maybe a collection of other things happening in your life are the root cause. Probably to you, that story is the first concrete example you have of those intensely sad feelings occurring so it stands out in your memory. On its own it's unlikely to be the cause I'd think.
That makes a lot of sense, thank you. Also read Uncle Tom’s cabin (I know it’s racist but this was communist eastern bloc and I was around 7) and it also upset me when the little girl dies and it’s described heartbreakingly. I didn’t know about slavery otherwise that would’ve made me cry too!

When I asked my mother once whether I used to cry a lot as a baby, she said no, never. I find it hard to believe!

OP posts:
LazySaturday · 09/02/2022 01:08

I was unhappy to not be with my parents as a child so maybe this played a part

This and the fact that you were teaching yourself to read rather than being read to make it sound as if you were incredibly lonely and empathised strongly with the girl.
I'd guess life events rather than the book are at the heart of things.

SwissCheeseRentedChildren · 09/02/2022 01:07

I read this when I was little and I found it so incredibly sad.

I, too, have had a lifetime of debilitating depression!

My friend read it as a child and thought it was a lovely book. She’s far better at life than I am.

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 01:06

@GTAlogic

It depends on how the story is told. In one way it's a depressing story of a little girl freezing to death yet in another way she leaves behind an awful and miserable life to go and stay with her grandmother.

Stories and age appropriate news are important because children should know that the world isn't always a lovely, welcoming and happy place and that bad things do happen. They read and hear about these things in a safe environment and can then talk about them with the adults surrounding them. If they're never exposed to death, grief, sadness and never hear about the serious side of life until they're adults then it'll hit them like a tonne of bricks.

I was in a communist country, children were definitely exposed to all those things. But it doesn’t have to start at 5, imo.
OP posts:
LazySaturday · 09/02/2022 01:05

I'd agree that it's a very sad story. Good for older children to read and think about the lives that other people lead. At 5-6 it sounds as if you were too young for it and a sensitive soul. But the root of long term depression, no. I'd guess that a natural inclination towards depression as a very sensitive child plus maybe a collection of other things happening in your life are the root cause. Probably to you, that story is the first concrete example you have of those intensely sad feelings occurring so it stands out in your memory. On its own it's unlikely to be the cause I'd think.

toomuchlaundry · 09/02/2022 01:04

If you didn’t have your parents around surely that’s impacted you more than a story

Swipe left for the next trending thread