Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Failure to breastfeed = less bond?

191 replies

Shutupandcry · 08/02/2022 22:27

I’m in an NCT mums WhatsApp and today there has been a lot of discussion from the breastfeeding mums about the amazing bond, nothing like it etc that breastfeeding has created. I’ve spent all day so upset- despite trying to bf I was rubbish and just couldn’t- managed 6 weeks bf with shields, expressing tiny amounts and topping up but at 4 months now DD is fully FF.

I feel I have a lovely bond with her but now feel like maybe I’m missing this amazing womanly experience and my daughter is missing out and it’ll never be as good. DH thinks I should just mute or say something about how I’m struggling with the comments but I don’t want them to think I’m shaming them or don’t want them to talk about it- they have every right to be proud. I wish I could join them.

Have I ruined her life and our bond? Anyone fed their babies differently and noticed a difference in your bond?

OP posts:
Sideswiped · 08/02/2022 23:01

As they say, OP, 'fed is best'. That means as long as you are taking care of your baby's needs, you are doing what is right for you and your baby.
FWIW, I had one baby who was breast-fed until eight months, but by then only fed morning and last thing at night - I returned to work. With them, BFing was hard work. I had a cracked nipple (which was agony) and DC had colic (unrecognised then as they were considered too young). I also suspect they had a degree of tongue tie.
DC2 fed very well, but was born with a genetic condition which was very difficult to deal with. Now XH left me alone to deal with it, and the antidepressants I was prescribed were incompatible with BF, so ultimately I started to bottle feed at less than 2 months old.
That's a bit of a long post, so to sum it up, you aren't doing anything wrong.
Yes, it's lovely if you are able to, and want to, breastfeed, but ultimately anyone who looks after their baby's needs whatever they are, is still a good parent. The bond you have with your baby will be the same, however you choose to feed them.

Volhhg · 08/02/2022 23:00

Turn it off and enjoy your baby!!!

FortniteBoysMum · 08/02/2022 22:59

Formula fed both my boys due to me being severely anemic during and after pregnancy. My bond with my boys has not suffered at all because of it. My youngest is 11 and he still wants cuddles daily. He couldn't be anymore of a mummies boy. My eldest is a grumpy teen but he still wants to come food shopping every week with me. That's despite him hating shopping because its one on one time. (with the occasional cake for a treat).

InTheNightWeWillWish · 08/02/2022 22:58

Of course you have an equal bond with your baby. When you bottle feed them, you can look in their eyes, stroke their head - I got told off by a midwife for stroking DD’s hair when I tried to breastfeed. Even if you didn’t bond during formula feeding, you bond in other ways - when you talk to them, sing to them, bath and change them, play with them. If that wasn’t enough, your heartbeat is the first sound they heard, you were the first things they sensed, first thing they knew. You are their safe place and how you feed doesn’t change that. You recognise their cries, know their hungry cry, know if they like their milk at a certain temperature or if they prefer certain bottles.

For me, breastfeeding wasn’t bonding. It was DD screaming, wrestling her into position, me getting stressed and upset. It was feeling like a failure. FF is DD looking into my eyes, nestled into the crook of my arm, smiling as I offer the bottle, her grabbing my finger as she takers her bottle and falling asleep into me as she finishes. Trying to force myself to breastfeed would have seriously damaged my mental health and possibly my bond with DD.

Hapoydayz · 08/02/2022 22:58

How ridiculous. The same people 5 years on will be banging on about what book band their child is on as nobody will care how they were fed

Genzymoo · 08/02/2022 22:57

I was in a very similar position. Re breastfeeding. The comments, even the supportive ('oh well done for trying for so long', 'she will have had so much benefit from those first few weeks') made me feel crappy.

But, to be fair, there was always someone banging on about something that was going so well for them; baby being a great feeder, baby sleeping through the night, baby being really easygoing/happy/whatever. Unfortunately these all tend to play to our own insecurities.

After a while, I just ignored the messages. I couldn't breast feed; my body was not 'made for it' as was suggested by some and I couldn't deal with the added anxiety of constant comparison. I dipped in every week or two if I wanted to.

If being in the group is a negative experience, take a step back from it. You can always step back in if you want to in the future.

My children are 2 and 5. No signs that the bond us buggered.

EllaVaNight · 08/02/2022 22:53

They're just talking about their experience. Your experience is different but neither is superior or inferior. Don't take it personally (easier said than done).

I breastfeed my 2.5yo which many people disagree with. We have a great bond. Her dad has never breastfed her and they have an equally great bond.

DiddyHeck · 08/02/2022 22:52

@rainyskylight

I think first time mums get confused by the breastfeeding and think it’s a massive part of the bond they have with their baby. Ridiculous. The bond with their baby is there because they’re a new mum flooded with hormones utterly in love with their new baby. Which is exactly the same as you.
Very well said.
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 08/02/2022 22:52

The only tenuous link I can think of is that some women put a lot of pressure on themselves to breastfeed. And if it doesn't work out, they are slightly more likely to have PND if they have wanted to breastfeed. And pnd may make them feel temporarily feel like they havent bonded as well.

It's all the same, the baby is fed, they get that snuggley time with their mum, they stare into each others eyes, they fall asleep cuddling them afterwards. Anyone who says otherwise is pushing an agenda or at best, attributing their bond to something though wishful thinking - thinking about it objectively, how the fuck would they know what bond they would have with their baby if they hadn't breastfed?

I think you need some new friends to be honest. I breastfed and am a big breastfeeding advocate and think there are benefits and it should be normalised etc but a better bond is not one of them and saying that on a group chat is really insensitive. I think I'd ask them if they really think that bottle feeding mums dont bond with their kids as well?

Also...have you ever heard anyone saying 'I have such a lovely bond with my mum, it must be because she breastfed me', not because she always listens to my problems or supports my dreams or cheers me up or gives the best hugs etc

MuchTooTired · 08/02/2022 22:51

Oh love, you’ve not ruined her life or destroyed your bond. I had pnd with my DTs, didn’t even feel like their mother until they were 12 weeks, and (whilst I knew I loved them) didn’t feel the rush of love until I started ads. We were bonded just fine. I couldn’t bf and gave up expressing at 6 weeks, and FF from then on. It seems a massively big deal whilst you’re in the thick of new baby months, but once you start weaning nobody cares how you feed. Mine are 4 now, and we’re super bonded, but we always have been even if I didn’t feel it. Looking back, I can’t believe I put myself through utter hell and punishment due to my inability to bf - I wish I’d had a bit more confidence in myself that I was doing right by my babies.

Be kind to yourself, a happy mum = happy baby. You’re the expert on your baby 🌸

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 08/02/2022 22:50

It can be devastating when you hope to do it but don’t manage it. I managed a bit so I knew what it felt like and it was an amazing experience. But I couldn’t sustain it. So exclusively FF from about 4 weeks. Even now with DS now 19, I still have the odd pang of missing out. I dream about it sometimes. I sat next to a young relative doing it at Christmas and I ached at her ease in doing it. However, all those feelings are from the loss of not doing what felt so natural to me. Like I said had let my body down by not being successful. As for our bond though. Pah!! No. It mattered not a jot. We were so close we were one. 🥰 Not now though! Not physically! He moves out. But we are still a bonded pair. Well. I am… 🤔 I’m sure I’m not that far off his mind!

StillWeRise · 08/02/2022 22:50

@rainyskylight

I think first time mums get confused by the breastfeeding and think it’s a massive part of the bond they have with their baby. Ridiculous. The bond with their baby is there because they’re a new mum flooded with hormones utterly in love with their new baby. Which is exactly the same as you.
I'm sure this is true, and never thought of it that way before! don't worry about it OP and mute them. I think it's also true that you cab be a bit bonkers when you have your first baby and very narrow in focus. They probably don't have the headspace for 'don't forget Op is FFing, let's be tactful'
Justilou1 · 08/02/2022 22:49

Absolute bullshit and don’t let anyone get into your head.

I can honestly say that this whole cult of “Natural Everything Motherhood” is psychologically very damaging. If you have a C-Section, you’re made to feel like you’ve failed or missed out on something magical. (Or that you don’t deserve the mythical Olympic gold medal that women who have delivered vaginally deserve…) Nobody talks about how common post-partum injuries are, and how little is done for them. The expectation that you must spring back into Instagram-worthy shape is also dangerous and puts so much pressure on relationships.

I felt terrible guilt with my first (who is now 17). I was even abused when bottle-feeding in a change room for the first time. Nobody believed me when I said that I didn’t think I was producing enough milk. I explained that my boobs hadn’t grown, either during pregnancy or after birth, and I didn’t feel anything different. They dismissed this entirely. I gave up and felt a failure after a month with a screaming, non-growing baby.
It was only when I had my twins two years later - in a different hospital - that a midwife noticed that my boobs were the wrong shape for someone who was supposed to have had milk come in, etc, and believed me that they hadn’t grown during pregnancy, and I didn’t get a feeling of “let down”, etc… She organised an ultrasound and we discovered that I have four milk ducts in total. (Most women have at least 32 in each boob.) Obviously wasn’t going to feed one baby, let alone two. Psychologically a lot easier to deal with, and also to share the load with DH. (With twins, you absolutely need to!)

Anyhow, regardless of the reason, you snuggle and feed your baby the way you feel is best. You will absolutely bond. Everyone else can fuck off.

gogetta · 08/02/2022 22:49

So what about the dads who definitely can't breastfeed? A whole load of bollocks!! Baby just knows food. You feed them they're happy

Simple as

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/02/2022 22:46

What a load of old codswallop. Eye contact when you’re feeding is what creates the bond.

AnneLovesGilbert · 08/02/2022 22:44

The angry responses aren’t proportionate to what OP has written. She hasn’t said these women have criticised her or said anything deliberately unkind or hurtful to her. They’re talking about their experience and she acknowledges that’s okay.

They’re not saying they’re better women or superior mothers. They’re talking about something that’s a positive for them.

I had a car crash of a c section and was under GA. Not the delivery anyone would want. When people talk about the joy of a natural birth, the wonder of having your baby placed on your chest, first cuddles, an amazing bonding experience, I don’t think wow, bunch of bitches, you’re telling me I’m a shit mum who failed. I think how lovely, lucky them.

Ionlydomassiveones · 08/02/2022 22:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

TerribleZebra · 08/02/2022 22:43

Some people are thoughtless/smug fuckers. OP I failed to bf my DD after a traumatic birth that nearly killed the pair of us. I tried for 10 weeks because I felt such a failure. I had no milk and she was failure to thrive. She's now 17 and I have exactly the same bond with her as I do my DS who I exclusively bf until he was 18 months. Ignore the twats who have no idea how difficult breast feeding can be both physically and mentally.

Winbourneflight · 08/02/2022 22:43

I struggled to breastfeed both my children, only managed a few days with both of them.

With my first I struggled to bond with her and she has only just started expressing affection in a way I recognise at the age of 8.

With my second we bonded very quickly and he's always been very affectionate little boy who says the most gorgeous things to me.

If I had managed to breastfeed him I would be convinced that our special bond was due to that, but it's not, he just shows his love for me in a way I understand. I had to learn how to read my first born.

You have not ruined her life or your bond. It might feel very raw now but I promise you it won't feel this way in a few years time.

Fridgeorflight · 08/02/2022 22:42

They couldn't possibly know that their bond is down to BF, they're just making it up to make themselves feel good.

Unless you have identical twins and choose to BF one and not the other (and not for medical reasons) then you can't really draw a conclusion about whether it makes a difference. And even then, it probably wouldn't tell you the answer for singletons.

I liked FF - you can make really good eye contact while FF, which feels like bonding. And also I think going past the horrible bit where it all went wrong into an easier stage made bonding easier. Being in the midst of a hellish BF experience is certainly not conducive to bonding.

Muststopeating · 08/02/2022 22:42

I have 3DC. Have FF and EBF.

I absolutely loved BFing... for about 1 minute a day when I remembered or had the energy to 'bond' (i.e. look at the baby instead of the telly or my phone or chivvy other kids to get dressed etc).

There are occasional moments where the baby looks up at you while I'm feeding. But I'm bloody sure you have similar moments while feeding your baby.

Of all the ways that you may or may not fail your children, not being able to breastfeed long term is not one of them.

Next time your baby looks at you, try to imagine being any more bonded to them. Bet you can't!

GTAlogic · 08/02/2022 22:40

I bonded fine with my dc and they were both bottle fed. They're lovely, confident and happy children. One child did get some breast milk, the one got none; you really can't tell to look at or listen to them. I know it feels like a big thing when they're tiny babies but it really isn't. What matters is that they're fed well and are loved and supported throughout their lives and babyhood is just a tiny part of that.

TeenagersandFurbabies · 08/02/2022 22:40

Bonding is simply loving your child. For some it's and immediate thing for others it takes a while. Stop over thinking it and comparing yourself to other mums. You tried breastfeeding and managed to do it for 6 weeks which is more than many new mums manage. You're doing the best for your daughter be proud of that.

Teacupsandtoast · 08/02/2022 22:39

Breastfed both of mine for 18 months. My 6 year old happily tells me I'm a rubbish mummy when I'm doing something that displeases her. It makes not a jot of difference

AliasGrape · 08/02/2022 22:38

Oh OP, I felt this so badly when I had my DD.
I never produced any milk and was completely unable to breastfeed despite doing everything the feeding team suggested. I hadn’t realised how badly I wanted to breastfeed and was heartbroken and convinced I’d damaged our bond forever and that I might as well just be anyone and not her mother since I couldn’t do the proper motherly thing of breastfeeding.

Honestly it was such nonsense. She’s 18 months now and our bond is incredibly strong.

How you feed is such a tiny part of bonding, such a tiny part of parenting/ motherhood overall. It seems so overwhelmingly important for the first months/ year but honestly that will fade. Cuddle your baby close and enjoy those snuggles and the beautiful bond you definitely have.