Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Failure to breastfeed = less bond?

191 replies

Shutupandcry · 08/02/2022 22:27

I’m in an NCT mums WhatsApp and today there has been a lot of discussion from the breastfeeding mums about the amazing bond, nothing like it etc that breastfeeding has created. I’ve spent all day so upset- despite trying to bf I was rubbish and just couldn’t- managed 6 weeks bf with shields, expressing tiny amounts and topping up but at 4 months now DD is fully FF.

I feel I have a lovely bond with her but now feel like maybe I’m missing this amazing womanly experience and my daughter is missing out and it’ll never be as good. DH thinks I should just mute or say something about how I’m struggling with the comments but I don’t want them to think I’m shaming them or don’t want them to talk about it- they have every right to be proud. I wish I could join them.

Have I ruined her life and our bond? Anyone fed their babies differently and noticed a difference in your bond?

OP posts:
Whoopsies · 09/02/2022 06:25

I've had one of each, ds1 I gave up bf pretty much straight away and formula fed him. Ds2 I breastfed totally exclusively to 18 months! I can honestly say that my bond with each is totally the same. Ds1 is 8 now and we are just the closest. Actually ds2 is the more independent one and far more a daddy's boy! I totally get all those feelings, u felt like such a failure for not bf ds1 but as time has gone on I can recognise all the wonderful things I've done for him and all the ways I'm a great mum.

Darbs76 · 09/02/2022 06:11

I have 3 kids and only managed to BF one for longer than 2-3wks (not for want of trying). It didn’t affect our bond no, not at all. People need to be more sensitive around what they say and it’s rubbish anyway

Queenie6655 · 09/02/2022 06:09

Utter nonsense

Some of the bull spouted in. These nct groups infuriates me

Ignore all of it

EdgeOfACoin · 09/02/2022 05:26

I combi fed in the early days because my baby wasn't gaining enough weight. One thing I noticed was that my baby tends to close her eyes when breastfeeding. When bottle feeding she would stare into my eyes. Sometimes she would smile at me mid-bottle, which was beautiful, and not something she does when breastfeeding (she's too busy trying to extract the milk). Those are the lovely moments when bottle-feeding that I do miss. It was definitely bonding time, and the snuggles from bottle-feeding are the same as those from breastfeeding.

All that said, I'm unimpressed by some of the comments on this thread. Women sharing their experiences of breastfeeding and talking about how they enjoy it and how they feel it helps them bond with their babies aren't 'twats' or 'competitive mummies' or any of the other nonsense on here. They are talking about their own experiences, not running the OP down! If a new mother can't talk about the enjoyment of breastfeeding with her NCT group, who the hell can she discuss it with? Should women shut up about their own positive experiences in case it makes other women feel bad? Breastfeeding is a unique experience between mother and baby - of course it's a special thing and one that women are allowed to talk about without having to tiptoe on eggshells.

RedRobin100 · 09/02/2022 05:22

Sounds like we had very similar experiences!

I’m due soon with my no 2 and really hoping I can give expressing a better go this time - will Invest in a better pump for one!

RedRobin100 · 09/02/2022 05:19

@Okla

Absolutely untrue. Fed is best and so not dictate strength in bond. I would absolutely say something along the lines of. "with every respect, talking about breastfeeding and bonds is a little insensitive to those who have been unable to".
and this.. call them out on it
RedRobin100 · 09/02/2022 05:19

Nonsense

I breastfed exclusively for 10 months - can’t say I felt like it was a “bonding experience”
I kinda hated it and feel like I grew to resent DC a bit before I stopped.
I remember crying a lot when he kept fucking clawing at me and climbing on me to feed.

Also, because only I was feeding him, it was like he hated my husband until he was weaning.

I’ll be doing things differently this time around and trying to pump (couldn’t get it to work for me last time)

People are idiots don’t listen to them - they’re living their insta-lives talking about bonding and shit. It’s honestly not real life, breastfeeding is fucking hard (and it actually went very easily and smoothly for me with no real issues)

HoppingPavlova · 09/02/2022 05:12

Absolute rubbish. In fact, I’d say my bond with my one who wasn’t breastfed (pumped and bottle fed as they physically couldn’t breastfeed), was stronger than that with my breastfed ones. People talk a load of shite.

Antsgomarching · 09/02/2022 05:09

I was breastfed - am NC with my mum, DH bottle fed, calls his mum weekly.

Okla · 09/02/2022 05:05

Absolutely untrue. Fed is best and so not dictate strength in bond. I would absolutely say something along the lines of. "with every respect, talking about breastfeeding and bonds is a little insensitive to those who have been unable to".

nameisnotimportant · 09/02/2022 04:42

No complete rubbish. I breastfed both of mine for a year but I hated it and the bond definitely got better once I stopped!

bunnyskywalker · 09/02/2022 03:58

These holier than thou sanctimonious NCT mums really piss me off. There was one in my group who was very vocal about "the bond" but luckily the rest of my group were pretty chilled (we all breastfed our kids for various lengths of time 3 months - 3 years) and she was in the minority. I am combined feeding now with my newborn after EBF my first and it almost destroyed me. I agree with pp that breastfeeding can also break bonds too. I found it absolutely overwhelming but by the time I tried to switch to formula at 3 months, my DC refused a bottle and I couldn't use a pump to express (doesn't work in everyone) so I was forced to continue and I hated it. As soon as she was eating well and taking a sippy cup of formula I stopped

Suzi888 · 09/02/2022 03:53

@rainyskylight

I think first time mums get confused by the breastfeeding and think it’s a massive part of the bond they have with their baby. Ridiculous. The bond with their baby is there because they’re a new mum flooded with hormones utterly in love with their new baby. Which is exactly the same as you.
^ This Utter BS to say if you don’t or indeed can’t BF that your bond is affected. DD age 6 was FF and if the bond was any stronger she would ‘climb back in my tummy’ if she could! - her words not mine. She’s addicted to me, which is occasionally overwhelming! In fact she’s in bed with me now and DH has slipped into her bedGrin. Everyone is now fast asleep, apart from me!
PurBal · 09/02/2022 03:36

Breastfeeding isn’t pass or fail. Your NCT mums are dicks frankly and talking out of their arses.

Aussiegirl123456 · 09/02/2022 03:00

Nope. Just a tiny bit of parenting.
Currently feeding my 2.5yr old and I can honestly say it’s a love hate relationship we have with breastfeeding. She loves it and I hate it.
I’ve fed all my children (I have 4), the first child was only fed for a few weeks; others fed for min of 2 years. The bond I have with them all is exactly equal. My 16 and 15 year olds have no recollection of how I fed them and quite frankly they wouldn’t care. They remember everything else I’ve done for them and the sacrifices I’ve made for them and the time, energy and love I’ve given them. They’re going to remember me helping with home work, listening to their problems and supporting them and our funny experiences with driving lessons (which is where we’re at right now).

Bonds can also be broken by breastfeeding too, people forget that. It also takes its toll on the mother’s body and is a huge commitment - especially when they’re toddlers and you want to stop months ago but you know the child really needs it. Projecting there.

So please don’t beat yourself up. You’re doing your best so be happy with that.

marthasGinyard · 09/02/2022 02:33

It's bollox Op

Joenlivsmom · 09/02/2022 02:30

Please don’t beat yourself up. If you can name me one child who remembers being breast fed…. Well you get what I’m saying. Just be confident in your mothering ability and ignore anyone who is trying to guilt you. Being a mum is hard enough xx

FrenchFancie · 09/02/2022 02:26

It’s total shite OP.
Due to a traumatic birth dd didn’t get a drop of breast milk or colostrum from me, she’d had two bottles by the time I came out of surgery and had decided that’s the way she wanted to be fed.

Our bond is amazing, she’s 9 now and an amazing bright child. I work in a primary school and couldn’t tell you which child was fed in which way.

Feeding method becomes all consuming when they are small because it’s pretty much the only thing you do for them, but in a couple of years time when they are toddlers eating dog biscuits and licking the wheels of the pram to find out what they taste like, none of of matters a bit.

Enjoy your baby and your bond and tell the NCT bunch to sod off.

Quail15 · 09/02/2022 02:15

Baby number 1 was combi fed due to severe tongue tie until 6 weeks then FF.

Baby number 2 breast fed until 9 months

No difference with my bond with them. This is one of the reasons why I never really got on with my NCT group and 3 years on I don't have any contact with them.

FartnissEverbeans · 09/02/2022 02:07

Just to add - I obviously adore both babies equally! No difference at all.

FartnissEverbeans · 09/02/2022 02:06

I ff my first and am now combo feeding my second.

If anything I think the bond came more readily with my first, because second time round I was so focused on breastfeeding! I found it so hard for many reasons (past trauma, nonexistent/poor latch, bleeding and awful pain, after pains that I would have happily taken gas and air for, and a condition named DMER that makes me feel sick and sad when I get a letdown) and the first few weeks just became all about me and my boobs. I still don’t enjoy it, tbh.

Also I think the poster who mentioned that ff let’s you look into your baby’s eyes more easily is absolutely right. It’s an underrated benefit of ff.

Leilala · 08/02/2022 23:58

You should never feel like you are missing out, you are doing a great job and so very blessed to have a little one to call your own.

I have DS9 and DD 8 months (long gap due to career- always get asked). DS would not BF and I did exactly like you did- all the expressing and I felt like a cow with very little to show for it. Me and him are like best friend now. In the long run the adult you are raising is not going to remember how you fed them and there are so many more ways to bond than feeding. The main positive was that he was such a content baby with all the family members not only me, he has continued to build such good relationships with DH and all his grandparents. I use to feel guilty and blame myself for not being able to BF him but there is not a single thing I would change about him now and our journey (including feeding) is why he is who he has become.

DD is so different. BF since the start and won’t take a bottle so I have delayed going back to work. She is more clingy but I wouldn’t say I feel closer to either they are just individuals like anyone else. I was anxious about feeding before she was born though. But it’s completely unfair to stress and out blame on yourself.

The way you bond will be unique between you and your child and not related to how they get their food in the first few months. Some babies will like to be held others more independent.

Enjoy your little one while she is little, they do grow up so quick.

StickyToffeePuddingAndIceCream · 08/02/2022 23:55

Your bond is no different, just mute them. I say this as someone who has/is breastfeeeding too, it isn't a competition or something to be smug about. If it works great, its convenient, if it doesnt well it isnt the end of the world, you'll still have a strong bond (and a fed, happy, content baby).

Alloutofglove · 08/02/2022 23:52

Psychological blinkers on now OP and don't remove them until baby is secondary school age. I experienced some circles of awful competitive Mumming. Nothing inferior about your bond whatsoever, regardless of what some insecure smuggoes tell you

SleepingStandingUp · 08/02/2022 23:49

Can someone please tell my three sons were not as bonded as I expressed and bottle fed cos I can't pee without one of them needing to touch me. Maaaaaaaam Mam Mam. I walk in the living room, one toddler immediately grabs my skirt. One will happily sit on my lap kissing me for 5 minutes. 6 year old likes to climb into bed and put his hands under my armpits for closeness (🙄). They all like to be under my clothes for closeness. They'll happily seperate and hang with other people so they're secure in their attachment, providing I don't want to be alone 😂😂😂. We're def attached and your friends are being quite inconsiderate and naive.