Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Failure to breastfeed = less bond?

191 replies

Shutupandcry · 08/02/2022 22:27

I’m in an NCT mums WhatsApp and today there has been a lot of discussion from the breastfeeding mums about the amazing bond, nothing like it etc that breastfeeding has created. I’ve spent all day so upset- despite trying to bf I was rubbish and just couldn’t- managed 6 weeks bf with shields, expressing tiny amounts and topping up but at 4 months now DD is fully FF.

I feel I have a lovely bond with her but now feel like maybe I’m missing this amazing womanly experience and my daughter is missing out and it’ll never be as good. DH thinks I should just mute or say something about how I’m struggling with the comments but I don’t want them to think I’m shaming them or don’t want them to talk about it- they have every right to be proud. I wish I could join them.

Have I ruined her life and our bond? Anyone fed their babies differently and noticed a difference in your bond?

OP posts:
clearvowelsriselikeballoons · 09/02/2022 08:40

I had to leave my NCT WhatsApp. Not because anyone was being nasty or boasty, but I just couldn't handle the comparison at that stage, while I felt so vulnerable and not knowing what I was doing.

When babies are really little there's honestly not much you CAN do with them, other than fed, clean, cuddle, sleep. So I think for some mums the breastfeeding is a way to 'prove' themselves as 'good' mums (of course it's not but in the early days that's how it felt for me when I couldn't bfeed).
Looking back, it's bollocks! The feeding is all consuming for the first few months, but that's because there is literally nothing else. As soon as they start having personalities, THEN the real parenting begins.
Fwiw I drove myself crazy worrying about 'bonding'. It seemed like this mythical concept that I thought about all the time, but worried I would never have, not 'properly' like the breastfeeding mums.
Bonding is just a fancy way of saying love. Love grows, everything you do for your baby is love. Feeding is just one small part of loving your baby, but in the months and years ahead, there will be so many more things you do out of love. They'll be the ones that count- do you show up to pick your kid up from school on time? Do you listen to them talking about their day? Do you give them hugs when they're feeling upset? That's the stuff that counts

Maray1967 · 09/02/2022 08:37

It is utter nonsense. I bottle fed both mine and have a wonderful bond. What I never did was shove a bottle in a baby’s mouth while they’re in a buggy though - personally I don’t like that at all. Mine were always held securely, their head to my boob, eye to eye contact.
There seems to be no limits to what some people will do to make others feel bad.
Ignore them in confidence that all will be well.
And by the way - mine are both strappingly healthy. They have far fewer illnesses than some of my friends’ DC who were exclusively breastfed.

EishetChayil · 09/02/2022 08:35

I just wonder how mothers have the time and mental space to worry and think so much about how others feed their babies.

Remytherat · 09/02/2022 08:33

I do feel like breastfeeding helped establish a bond with my baby after a traumatic birth. But so did cosleeping, having baths together, and a million other things.

My husband has never breastfed her and they have a lovely bond.

Mumoblue · 09/02/2022 08:23

No that’s bollocks.

My health visitor said something like she was worried my bond with my baby would suffer because I was stopping breastfeeding.
At the time I was devastated, but now I wish I’d told her to fuck off because that’s a load of nonsense.

It was (and is) insulting to suggest that my bond with my son is so fragile that my tit was the only thing holding it together!

3cats4poniesandababy · 09/02/2022 08:19

What thoughtless comments and also what absolute crap.

I usually find the people critising and putting down other people's parenting are doing it because they themselves are insecure and often struggling with their mental health and need treatment/support themselves. Doesn't make it any easier being on the receiving end of it though.

TulipsGarden · 09/02/2022 08:16

I bonded a lot better with my child when I stopped trying to establish breastfeeding, because it wasn't working and he was losing weight fast. It was incredibly stressful and I didn't like him very much at all.

Two days of formula feeding and he was a different baby, and I could finally bond with him rather than worrying about the feed.

Try to encourage honestly in your NCT group. They're such a good resource, but if you're all trying to out-compete each other in parenting it won't work. Just say how you're really feeling and hopefully some (it won't be all) will be honest too. You don't have to be friends with all of them.

MarmaladeToastAndAMarmaladeCat · 09/02/2022 08:10

This was one of the things I found most upsetting after my Ds1 was born - the implication that breastfeeding gives you some kind of next level bond that just isn’t available to those of us who didn’t manage it. And it’s utter bullshit.

I intended to breastfeed but because of complications with the birth I wasn’t able to. My nct group all managed to and were very smug and self congratulatory about it. There were a lot of similar messages on the WhatsApp group and it really got to me. I felt like my baby would never love me as much as theirs did because of it.

4.5 years on I can see it is utter nonsense. My son is extremely bonded to me, as is my ds2 who I bottle fed intentionally from day 1.

Try and ignore the comments and enjoy your baby.

Chely · 09/02/2022 08:08

Leave the group, they are a bunch of arseholes.
Breastfeeding makes no difference to bonding, feeding is only a small part of a child's life.

Shutupandcry · 09/02/2022 08:04

Thank you all for the lovely reassuring messages. I will save this thread and have a read if I’m feeling a bit low. Thanks so much.

OP posts:
T00Ts · 09/02/2022 08:03

Your bond will be perfect. Do not worry about that.

But maybe muting the group is a good idea. Presumably these women know what you endured, so to speak that way in the group is pretty ignorant and insensitive.

KevinTheKoala · 09/02/2022 08:00

Me eldest was formula fed from day 1, my youngest was exclusively breastfed and still going at 2.5 years. I love them both equally, I would say that there were differences in bonding but none of those were caused by how they were fed! It was caused by:

  • post natal depression
  • interfering in laws
  • my children's personalities
  • two very traumatic births for different reasons
edenhills · 09/02/2022 07:49

I had twins, one breastfed easily from birth but the other never would. I expressed milk for her and bottle fed. They are now 12 years old and I have a great relationship with both. Absolutely no difference in our bond so don't stress about it x

BabyInTheJungle · 09/02/2022 07:47

I don't think it's unfair to say that breastfeeding a baby can help a mum feel bonded to their baby.

However! Bottle feeding can help a parent feel bonded to their baby. Playing with them, cuddling them to sleep, chatting to them on a walk, taking them to their favourite place, watching them play football every Saturday, planting seeds with them, colouring in a picture with them or baking a cake etc etc etc all help you feel bonded to your child over the years.

It's not an all or nothing. Breastfeeding is one activity in a thousand parental activities that help form a close and loving bond. I like it because I love the closeness it gives me and it is one way that I bond with my baby.

It's difficult to say without the tone of the messages but presumably they feel they are in a safe space where they can talk about their own experience of feeding and bonding. If I was in a group and said I loved the bond I had from breastfeeding and someone came at me saying it 'made no difference' etc I'd be a bit taken aback.

I've combi fed all my babies btw so love breast and bottle feeding them! Just putting a different slant on it to say it's not necessarily a comment on your experience or parenting.

KatieKat88 · 09/02/2022 07:44

Of course breastfeeding (when working well) helps you to bond, it releases oxytocin. It's not the only way to bond though and of course you can build a relationship with a baby in a myriad of other ways. I'm sure you have just as strong a bond with your baby - it's not a reflection on you.

Yaty · 09/02/2022 07:44

Honestly just ignore...I breastfeed my DD for 6 months. She was easy, no problems feeding from the start. But I really didn't like it I don't k kw why just felt so intense and constantly being touched/needed for food. I had sever PNA and OCD and breastfeeding definable didn't help. Moved to bottles mainly by 4 months ish and I felt so much happier. DD wasn't the slightest bit bothered and we have a great bond. So yeah just ignore the zealots everyone if different and I'm sure you have a perfect bond with your baby

HeyBlaby · 09/02/2022 07:37

Breast fed my DS, can't imagine ever feeling the need to harp on about an 'amazing bond', sounds like they are self obsessed with nothing better to do.

AliceW89 · 09/02/2022 07:35

Are you all close and do they know about what you have been through with breastfeeding? If they do it’s pretty insensitive. Aside from that, as long as they haven’t been equating formula feeding to ‘less bond’ I don’t think they are doing anything wrong personally. They are allowed to enjoy breastfeeding and discuss privately the effects it has on the relationship with their child. If it turns into a bash on formula feeding then that’s a completely different kettle of fish. But I’m struggling to see how they are being smug or anything like that. If it’s upsetting for you (which I can entirely see how it would be) just say to them you need a bit of space to process your breastfeeding grief. If they are good people they’ll stop the chat about it.

Trunumber · 09/02/2022 07:34

I breastfed DS for bloody years. Our bond is absolutely no different because of it. I liked breastfeeding/ it was easy for me but don't let others convince you there is some magical motherly bond in there, there isn't.

Mum didn't breastfeed me and I adore her, always have and always will

Justilou1 · 09/02/2022 07:22

@R3ALLY - sorry I didn’t see your question. I answered a bit further up.

RegardingMary · 09/02/2022 07:15

Please don't let them upset you OP.

I remember mine being that age. All conversations seem to revolve around the how little pain relief you had in labour and how you're feeding. Next up will be sleeping through the night, crawling and talking. Women like that are simple horrid and trying to cover for some inbuilt mum guilt they're feeling.

It makes absolutely not 1 jot of a difference. You love your child because they're yours, not because they've breastfed.

Tell them...

Hmm I can't imagine needing to rely on breastfeeding in order to bond with my own child, that just came naturally to us.

Nc123 · 09/02/2022 07:14

BF is great but not the only way to have that bond. I couldn’t BF DS1 as he’s adopted and so I didn’t have milk - I haven’t bonded with him any less because of it.

VikingOnTheFridge · 09/02/2022 07:12

@EdgeOfACoin

I combi fed in the early days because my baby wasn't gaining enough weight. One thing I noticed was that my baby tends to close her eyes when breastfeeding. When bottle feeding she would stare into my eyes. Sometimes she would smile at me mid-bottle, which was beautiful, and not something she does when breastfeeding (she's too busy trying to extract the milk). Those are the lovely moments when bottle-feeding that I do miss. It was definitely bonding time, and the snuggles from bottle-feeding are the same as those from breastfeeding.

All that said, I'm unimpressed by some of the comments on this thread. Women sharing their experiences of breastfeeding and talking about how they enjoy it and how they feel it helps them bond with their babies aren't 'twats' or 'competitive mummies' or any of the other nonsense on here. They are talking about their own experiences, not running the OP down! If a new mother can't talk about the enjoyment of breastfeeding with her NCT group, who the hell can she discuss it with? Should women shut up about their own positive experiences in case it makes other women feel bad? Breastfeeding is a unique experience between mother and baby - of course it's a special thing and one that women are allowed to talk about without having to tiptoe on eggshells.

Well no. If they're saying there's nothing like the breastfeeding bond, that means they're also talking about other people's experiences too, experiences they haven't actually had and thus cannot understand. Those other people then have the right to comment on the matter.

And actually, it is pretty bad behaviour on the part of the BF mums in question here. If they simply said it was unique and special and they liked it, that would be fine. Wouldn't involve making assumptions about anyone else's experiences or appropriating them for some ranking system.

MsFrog · 09/02/2022 07:04

I actually bonded better and quicker with my FF baby because the difficulties of bf affected my bond with my first baby. Its rubbish, the bond comes from nurturing, not breastfeeding xxxx

Pamlar · 09/02/2022 06:59

It's dreadful smugness and totally ridiculous. I am a big believer in breastfeeding it worked with some of mine but not all and it's so much more important to do what is right for you and your baby.
I am grateful that all my kids are close to me but the relationship is different with each -as it should be.
New mothers sometimes feel overwhelmed with baby high hormones and need to tell everyone -fair enough, good for them. Ignore ignore ignore and enjoy your baby.
Sorry to say that all parenting WhatsApp groups are generally the work of satan