Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Failure to breastfeed = less bond?

191 replies

Shutupandcry · 08/02/2022 22:27

I’m in an NCT mums WhatsApp and today there has been a lot of discussion from the breastfeeding mums about the amazing bond, nothing like it etc that breastfeeding has created. I’ve spent all day so upset- despite trying to bf I was rubbish and just couldn’t- managed 6 weeks bf with shields, expressing tiny amounts and topping up but at 4 months now DD is fully FF.

I feel I have a lovely bond with her but now feel like maybe I’m missing this amazing womanly experience and my daughter is missing out and it’ll never be as good. DH thinks I should just mute or say something about how I’m struggling with the comments but I don’t want them to think I’m shaming them or don’t want them to talk about it- they have every right to be proud. I wish I could join them.

Have I ruined her life and our bond? Anyone fed their babies differently and noticed a difference in your bond?

OP posts:
SockFluffInTheBath · 09/02/2022 10:25

They’re spouting absolute nonsense, evangelising about their own choice or ability to exclusively BF to the detriment of other people’s feelings in the group

This. I breast fed my first and absolutely hated it, he kept losing weight and it was so stressful. Breast fed my second for 24hrs and sent DH out for bottles. There is no difference in the bond I have with them.

DiscordandRhyme · 09/02/2022 10:18

I don't think it's the breastfeeding as much as the skin on skin. I think if you're doing skin on skin and making eye contact whilst giving the bottle you're not doing too much different bonding wise.

I exclusively breastfed 2 of mine and kid fed but mostly formula fed my eldest.

I felt they were all really close to me.

Somethingsnappy · 09/02/2022 10:13

@WTF475878237NC

I think you should mute it and not be hard on yourself. There was nothing like the feeling of seeing the baby I breastfed de-latch give me the biggest smiles, sign for my milk and stroke my boob tenderly as she grew. With enough support I would have loved this with all of them. I know that's painful for people who couldn't breastfeed but it's true for me.
Were your other babies who weren't breastfed not able to smile at you, sign for milk, and stroke your boob too?
Fangdrew · 09/02/2022 10:07

They’re spouting absolute nonsense, evangelising about their own choice or ability to exclusively BF to the detriment of other people’s feelings in the group. It’s very hurtful. As someone unable to BF I would have taken this really badly. I think you should say something, one would hope they are just being thoughtless and not intentionally mean.

My 16 month old still holds my finger in his fist when he has his bedtime bottle, as he’s done since he was a newborn. A bond is a bond regardless of feeding method. If he hadn’t have had formula, he wouldn’t be here today.

Woahthehorsey · 09/02/2022 10:03

Nope.

Breastfeeding made my bond worse because I resented being the only feeding & comfort mechanism.

Nomoreusernames1244 · 09/02/2022 10:03

I bf, and found it relatively easy.

However I never found it an “amazing” bonding experience. I fucking hated it most of the time if I’m honest. But I did it because it was easier and cheaper than formula.

I’d be asking how their partners all feel not being able to bond with their children Hmm.

The obsession with feeding babies is wierd. The amount of times bf mothers all get called selfish and told they need to give bottle so others can “share the experience”, and dad/granny/next door neighbour can’t bond if they don’t get to feed the baby.

R3ALLY · 09/02/2022 09:56

[quote Justilou1]@R3ALLY - sorry I didn’t see your question. I answered a bit further up.[/quote]
Thanks and sorry again for hijacking the thread! I'm just fascinated by what causes this. I'm totally over it - my kids are in secondary school! but all of my family BF so there doesn't seem to have been a genetic link but I have classic IGT, tubular breasts, wide spacing, minimal changes etc. I would love if more was known about it simply because I was given so much wrong information when I tried to BF - no amount of skin to skin or porridge was going to help.

To get back to the OP - I think it's fine for parents to say what they are doing and enjoying and what helps THEM, be it BF, or co-sleeping or leaving the baby overnight with a grandparent or whatever. But it does get hurtful if someone says this is the 'only' way to get it right or, 'my experience is better than yours'. Only you know what the tone of the group is but at this early stage, if anything upsets you, just tune it out.

takealettermsjones · 09/02/2022 09:56

I really struggled with breastfeeding, I did it for about a week but it was horrendous. Baby would only feed on one, and then only for a few minutes, and she was always fussing and crying. I absolutely loved her to pieces so I wouldn't say that I couldn't bond, but it was difficult. I felt like I was failing her and she was losing weight. I switched to FF and she was suddenly a happy, settled baby and about 73% of my stress just went away.

I'd just ignore the comments, but if you want to, you could respond with something like "guys, it's lovely to be proud of breastfeeding, but can we knock it off with the 'there's nothing else like it' comments? Formula feeding is right for some mums (including me!) and it'd be great if there was less mum guilt in the world."

Rainbowdrops2021 · 09/02/2022 09:54

It’s a load of crap to put it bluntly. I thought that people had stopped talking like this and were much more aware of the impact on new mums mental health when they can’t breastfeed but they wanted to.
I bottle fed my first dd as I couldn’t breastfeed and I remember these comments well, four years later I had my son and I breastfed him for 3 1/2 years 😳 (he wouldn’t even take a bottle) the bond with each of my children was equal. Bottle fed or breast fed it hasn’t made a difference to my children.

Tothemoonandbackx · 09/02/2022 09:47

I tried my hardest to breast feed, but my daughter just didn't want to latch, and on the rare occasion she did, I just couldn't express enough milk. What was I going to do, let her starve so we could 'Bond' or feed her??? Plus it meant that my ex and family members got the chance to BOND with her too, just in a different way Xx

pointythings · 09/02/2022 09:44

How you feed doesn't make the bond, it's far more complex than that. People just like to big themselves up - competitive mothering at its worst.

I'm one of those lucky sods who found bf easy, but my bond with my now adult DDs didn't come from that - it's come from everything that's happened since they were born, and it's still growing and changing now that they have flown the nest.

Flowers
FinallySomeNormality · 09/02/2022 09:44

I think it's total bollocks tbh.

Bonding is established by turning up everyday, every hour and being there for your baby and developing trust and nuturing relationship. That's more than simply feeding. It's about touching your baby, showing love and attention to baby. Teaching them about the world and about your family. Bonding continues well beyond the baby years, and I doubt BF mums are suggesting that when they stop BF their toddlers that suddenly their bond with the child is reduced?

Feeding is genuinely such an insignificant part of an infant's life when you think of the bigger picture.

BF mums might think they love BF and feel bonded during BF. But FF mums feel the same too. I loved bottle feeding my babies - stroking their faces, squidging their podgy legs and having them hold my fingers. It was beautiful at times. .... But... similar to BF mums, there were also countless bottles/feeds when I'd just watch TV or scroll my phone.

Let's all remember not to over romanticize feeding babies!

miltonj · 09/02/2022 09:35

Breast feeding is what it is. It certainly wasn't some amazing, serene, peaceful bonding experience for me. In fact in the early days I may as well have been a big walking hot dog as that's all my daughter saw me as!
With FF there's less of a food association with mum so they are more content with just cuddles without demanding anything else which is more bonding in my opinion!

Not bashing breast feeding cos it's great in lots of ways but if the only way someone can bond with their child is through breast feeding then that says a lot... it's also got a shelf life! I know women who don't want to give it up as they say they Like that toddler only wants them! But they want them for a reason iyswim,

Bloatstoat · 09/02/2022 09:34

I've breastfed all 3 of mine, for what feels like about 200 years. With my first I ploughed on through tongue tie, mastitis, blocked ducts, reflux...it was awful. With hindsight, I should have stopped long before I did, in a way it made me bond less with him as it was so awful. My younger 2 were easier to feed, but with older children the feeds were never very relaxing or bonding times, just something I try to do as quickly as possible while shouting instructions to the toddler who inevitably needs a poo just as I start feeding.Confused
When I have had the me with each baby, holding them while they sleep, cuddling them, bathing them, talking to them while I change them, comforting them when they're upset - that's when I feel the bond. As I get to know them, as they grow, as I feel I understand them and they understand me and we work on communicating, when their little faces light up and they smile when they see me, that's our bond. I'm a long term breaastfeeder, I was lucky it worked out for me, but it wasn't where I felt bonded and connected to my children.

I felt the whole time with my first I was doing something wrong and had a constant feeling of guilt and not measuring up and I put a lot of that down to the NCT WhatsApp group. If it's helpful great, but if it's not, no shame in leaving it, I wish I had.

Change123today · 09/02/2022 09:22

I seem to be the rare person that had a really lovely NCT group - it could have been because we all where on the 2nd or 3rd baby. Yes the person that ran it was a little militant with some things - I was having a planned c-section and she was quite rude I felt about it during the birthing class.

I’ve had 2 planned sections Breastfeed one bottle fed one - bonding was fine. I couldn’t breastfeed my first it never clicked but my second was a lot easier - that helps. Am I disappointed that I didn’t stick at trying with my first - NO - she was hungry & crying, I was tired emotional mess feeling like a failure - it wasn’t worth my mental health to try and make it work (sorry not sorry) my job as a mother was to take care of her and bottle feed it was :) no regrets! Second one breastfeeding was so easier it just worked - she got it I got it - doesn’t mean I bonded more with her! Snuggles same with both :)

Why people say stuff like this - having a baby is tough! And no one should be laying on crap like this!! It can make an already tough emotional time bloody harder!

montysma1 · 09/02/2022 09:21

I didn't beast feed.
Not couldn't
Didn't.
Don't want to. Despite intrusion and unsolicited advice from the breastfeeding mind control woman at the hospital, who seemed more than a little unhinged.

Apparently this makes me akin to a serial killer.

Just10moreminutesplease · 09/02/2022 09:20

In my group of mum friends we have people who formula feed and people who breastfeed. I combination fed my LO.

The only difference is the formula/combination feeding mums tend to have been able to share the nights more, especially in the early days which meant more sleep! There is no difference in our bonds. Please don’t worry Flowers.

Katerurn · 09/02/2022 09:18

I had 2 emergency c-sections and was unable to breast feed due to milk supply. I was made to feel like a failure by some people in a baby group, I left after that. The bond with my children has always been excellent. Now they're older, we are still really close and have an excellent bond. I've seen some of the people from my baby group recently and they don't share the same bond with their children who were bottle fed and natural delivery so it's swings and roundabouts.

Doesn't matter how you feed your baby, as long as baby is fed and happy!

morechocolateneededtoday · 09/02/2022 09:15

@AnneLovesGilbert

The angry responses aren’t proportionate to what OP has written. She hasn’t said these women have criticised her or said anything deliberately unkind or hurtful to her. They’re talking about their experience and she acknowledges that’s okay.

They’re not saying they’re better women or superior mothers. They’re talking about something that’s a positive for them.

I had a car crash of a c section and was under GA. Not the delivery anyone would want. When people talk about the joy of a natural birth, the wonder of having your baby placed on your chest, first cuddles, an amazing bonding experience, I don’t think wow, bunch of bitches, you’re telling me I’m a shit mum who failed. I think how lovely, lucky them.

This. They aren't belittling you are trying to make you feel bad. As another pp said, it's very easy to get confused and equate breastfeeding with bond in the early days but they are 2 separate things.

Sorry you had such a tough time. Its clear from your post that you have a wonderful bond with your child and she is very much loved

WTF475878237NC · 09/02/2022 09:11

I think you should mute it and not be hard on yourself. There was nothing like the feeling of seeing the baby I breastfed de-latch give me the biggest smiles, sign for my milk and stroke my boob tenderly as she grew. With enough support I would have loved this with all of them. I know that's painful for people who couldn't breastfeed but it's true for me.

elliejjtiny · 09/02/2022 09:07

Absolute rubbish. I breastfed 2 of mine, mix fed 2 and bottle fed 1. I preferred breastfeeding as I hated faffing around with sterilizers and dc4 would only drink the milk if it was body temperature. Didn't make any difference to bonding.

Spudina · 09/02/2022 08:54

I breast fed DD1. It was hell. Mastitis four times, and the pain from cracked nipples that made me cry every time I had to feed her. It was not a bonding experience aside from the fact that I couldn’t leave her at all to do something because she needed me. So we spent all our time together. I had PND (which the feeding definitely worsened)I tried and couldn’t feed DD2. We had a great bond because I was happy and smiley and enjoyed being with her knowing it wasn’t going to cause me physical pain whenever she needed feeding. Ignore the NCT lot. You are doing great.

yaboreme · 09/02/2022 08:49

There's a lot of pressure around this. Do what is right for you and your child. Whatever everyone else is doing is irrelevant (I know it can feel like everyone is breastfeeding and doing better, but it's not true).

Feeding is just one part of how you bond, playing, snuggles and generally just being there as the mother/ parent all plays a part.

If they are fed, clean and clothed (and you are too for that matter) you are winning.

You are no less of a mother because you don't breastfeed, your bond with your child will be perfectly fine and breastfed or bottle fed, you will be the one they come to for comfort.

Cocogreen · 09/02/2022 08:45

You poor thing!
It makes absolutely no difference.
My friend had twin girls - she had plenty of milk but one twin just couldn't get the hang of BF so was FF from 3 weeks while her sister was BF.
Those girls are 20 now and both have a great bond with their mother.

MaryShelley1818 · 09/02/2022 08:42

Absolutely a load of rubbish!
I combi fed both of mine and they couldn't care a less where the milk was coming from as long as they got some.
I also work with children who've suffered severe trauma and attachment difficulties....some of these were bf! That's not the only/most important way to create a bond, there's thousands of other things you can do.