Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s nobody’s business what I do with my money?

235 replies

ToffeePennee · 08/02/2022 21:29

I went in to my bank to withdraw a large amount of cash. I explained to the cashier what I wanted to do and she proceeded to ask some security questions - all fine.

One of the questions was what I wanted the cash for so I said I was having building work done. She then started saying that I should pay by bank transfer, it was tax avoidance etc. etc. When I insisted I still wanted to withdraw the money, she sighed and rolled her eyes and I felt really judged and like I’d done something wrong.

I’m glad now that I didn’t admit the real reason is in case the banking system collapses and it’s now stuffed under my mattress.

Please tell me I’m not wrong to think she had no right to judge me and if she did, she should have been professional and not passed comment?

OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 00:28

@VanGoghsDog

Noone has suggested banks do this because they care about people, they do it because they are compelled to by law.
Yes, there was a PP who said that. Why is when I said, I’ve heard it all now.
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 00:25

Oh my mistake it was Barclays and Natwest too!

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 00:23

@tttigress

I had a similar thing a few years ago, I wasn't withdrawing mega money.

But the cashier (HSBC) bought into the conversation what I was doing with the money.

HSBC were just caught last year laundering cartel money.
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 00:21

@Ilovelblue I posted about HSBC laundering money for drug cartels, they were fined billions, this was only last year. Like I said, they seem happy enough to launder the cartel money.

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 00:19

@ToffeePennee

She believed I was paying for building work and shouldn’t do that via cash, I assume because she believed it an attempt to avoid tax.

Why do PPs never believe what’s been posted? Why would I bother posting a thread about a normal banking transaction with boring normal questions? I’m not stupid and I left feeling judged and like I’d done something wrong because of her tone, mannerisms, and her not accepting my answers, trying to dissuade me from making a perfectly legitimate transaction.

It’s gaslighting, the fuel that keeps society going 😭
LorelaiDeservedBetter · 09/02/2022 00:18

@blacksax

If the entire banking system were to collapse, then your cash would be worthless anyway, because nobody could do anything with it. Chances are that inflation would be totally out of control and the value of the cash would plummet.

Not that you'd earn much interest by leaving it in the bank anyway. Confused

Yy this. It's hilariously misguided to think putting your money under your bed is protection against the banking system collapsing. But tbh it fits with you thinking the bank are being 'nosy' rather than looking for scammers, money launderers and tax avoiders. You might benefit from speaking to a financial adviser.
Ilovelblue · 09/02/2022 00:18

@WhatIsThisPlease

I inherited quite a large sum of money and after it had been deposited into my bank, they rang me and asked me where I'd got it from!

I told them I'd had a win on the horses 😂

A few years ago, I had inherited money after my mother died and the bank was handling the investment for me. The manager knew how much I would be receiving. I banked the solicitor's cheque at the counter and the assistant never queried it. However, when I went to see the manager a few days later to complete the process, he still required proof (ie the solicitor's letter) before we could finalise the transaction. The banks are terrified of being caught up in any money laundering.
YankeeDad · 09/02/2022 00:17

@ToffeePennee, this is a bit off topic, but if your withdrawals are really about keeping cash at home in case of a banking crisis, then have you considered National Savings and Investment instead? It's basically direct lending to the government, backed by HM Treasury, unlike any of the banks. I would worry that in a house fire, or if thieves enter your home, you could lose it all. But even if all the banks fail, so long as cash in UK pounds has any value, NS&I should also be safe.

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 00:16

@VanGoghsDog I said he didn’t ask the bank for the money back from themselves but he did tell them this happened. PP said ‘you’d ask the bank for your money back’ but he didn’t do that. He asked them if there’s anything that can be done to get the money back from the scammer

Make sense now, or is it still odd?

MaryAndHerNet · 09/02/2022 00:15

Sounds like she was doing her job.
Must be fucking hard for some people to function in society...

"Hi, welcome to McDonald's, what would you like?"
"How DARE you be so NOSEY.... It's none of your business!"

"Hi, welcome to Tesco, 1 24.pack of beer, having a party?"
"HoW VeRy DaRE You Axe ME pErSoNaL questions!"

"So you've a problem with your laptop? What do you use it for?"
"WHAT?!!" *Convulsions begin...

ToffeePennee · 09/02/2022 00:14

She believed I was paying for building work and shouldn’t do that via cash, I assume because she believed it an attempt to avoid tax.

Why do PPs never believe what’s been posted? Why would I bother posting a thread about a normal banking transaction with boring normal questions? I’m not stupid and I left feeling judged and like I’d done something wrong because of her tone, mannerisms, and her not accepting my answers, trying to dissuade me from making a perfectly legitimate transaction.

OP posts:
VanGoghsDog · 09/02/2022 00:13

Do you really think that 56yo Joan who works as a bank cashier three mornings a week gives a shiny shit that you're taking money out? Do you think banks tell their staff "be really difficult, we don't like people to withdraw money, we want to keep all the money"?

They don't. They really don't.

HelloFrostyMorning · 09/02/2022 00:10

@TheHateIsNotGood

But OP she didn't "believe you" and suspected, quite rightly, that you were lying. Sure take it out and do what you want with it but don't take umbrage when a bank clerk is very good at their job.
Being very good at what job? Being nosey?
OfstedOffred · 09/02/2022 00:09

Tradespeople wanting paid in cash can be to facilitate tax evasion.

A trades person doesn't have to register for & charge vat if they can keep their revenues below a threshold, among other reasons.

HelloFrostyMorning · 09/02/2022 00:08

Crosspost with OP!

ToffeePennee · 09/02/2022 00:08

I’m not actually paying for building work but even if I was, the last workman I used said he was happy for me to pay cash or BT and quoted the exact same price either way. He also gave me a receipt.

OP posts:
HelloFrostyMorning · 09/02/2022 00:08

@RedToothBrush

You are paying in cash in order to get a lower price. So the builder can dodge tax and pay cash in hand to casual labour.

This screws lots of people.

How do you know that those who are working on your house aren't being exploited and are all legally employed?

Not only this, but you also are exposing yourself to problems if the builder doesn't do the work properly. You have no real proof of how much you've paid.

The OP didn't say she is paying any builder ANYTHING. She lied because she didn't want to tell the nosey cashier what the money was for.
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 00:08

@EmmaH2022

AutomaticMoon "Natwest and their carbon counting is extremely tiresome"

What do Natwest do on carbon please?

Carbon Footprint calculating and guilt tripping me that I apparently could’ve charged a billion mobile phones with this energy. No idea where they’re pulling numbers from as I’m disabled and don’t go anywhere other than work and don’t drive or ever go on any holidays, here or abroad. I couldn’t even go see my mother on her death bed cause care workers in this country are almost worthless (minimum wage, even cleaners get paid more)

Oh dear, I’m sorry for the ranting. If you want I can send you a screenshot of it on my app, perhaps only happening to app users. Which I hated to get but their website is extremely hard to log on to and I just couldn’t access my statements without the app.

But it’s too reminiscent of CCP style social credit score and frightens me as I was born in a communist dictatorship and it’s not fun.

HelloFrostyMorning · 09/02/2022 00:07

@tttigress

I had a similar thing a few years ago, I wasn't withdrawing mega money.

But the cashier (HSBC) bought into the conversation what I was doing with the money.

They always do don't they? Nosey as fuck. Hmm

As I say, they HATE it that you're taking YOUR money out of THEIR bank! Grin Like fuck do they care if you are getting scammed by someone!

TheHateIsNotGood · 09/02/2022 00:07

But OP she didn't "believe you" and suspected, quite rightly, that you were lying. Sure take it out and do what you want with it but don't take umbrage when a bank clerk is very good at their job.

RedToothBrush · 09/02/2022 00:05

You are paying in cash in order to get a lower price. So the builder can dodge tax and pay cash in hand to casual labour.

This screws lots of people.

How do you know that those who are working on your house aren't being exploited and are all legally employed?

Not only this, but you also are exposing yourself to problems if the builder doesn't do the work properly. You have no real proof of how much you've paid.

HelloFrostyMorning · 09/02/2022 00:05

@AutomaticMoon

That does sound a lot like many banks/bank staff. Power trips/power crazy, giving you fuck-all help when you need it, but crawling up your arse when you come into a bit of money, advising you on how to 'invest it' with them. Bore off banks. My money's going in my house, in my secret hiding place! Grin

VanGoghsDog · 09/02/2022 00:02

Noone has suggested banks do this because they care about people, they do it because they are compelled to by law.

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 00:01

@ClariceQuiff

Personally I would far rather have extensive questioning about unusual activity on my account, than have my bank let me/someone pretending to be me withdraw large amounts of cash from my account willy-nilly.
Interesting, I’ve been in this situation when I was homeless and didn’t have a card and no safe address to send it to, bank staff power tripping over my combination of marriage certificate and passport to prove my ID and refusing to give me my money. Thankfully a lovely manager lady apologised profusely and gave me my money and arranged for a card to be sent to her bank for me to pick up. She was very kind but all my other experiences with banks over the years have been awful. They used to regularly take £40 if there was just a few pence overdrawn, when I had no OF facility. Why let the payment through? Then I would get paid my measly jobseekers allowance and they would keep over £40 which was supposed to last me almost a week for all expenses. They did this regularly. I just thank God I’m not in that position anymore but banks caring about people is just a bizarre proposition. Is that why banks did what they did with the world economy in 2008?
VanGoghsDog · 09/02/2022 00:00

[quote HelloFrostyMorning]@VanGoghsDog

You seem incredibly over-invested in other peoples financial affairs.

Are you a bank cashier by any chance?[/quote]
No, I am not a bank cashier. Not that it's any of your business.

And I don't think I have shown ANY interest in anyone's financial affairs actually.

Is your tin foil hat a bit tight tonight?