Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s nobody’s business what I do with my money?

235 replies

ToffeePennee · 08/02/2022 21:29

I went in to my bank to withdraw a large amount of cash. I explained to the cashier what I wanted to do and she proceeded to ask some security questions - all fine.

One of the questions was what I wanted the cash for so I said I was having building work done. She then started saying that I should pay by bank transfer, it was tax avoidance etc. etc. When I insisted I still wanted to withdraw the money, she sighed and rolled her eyes and I felt really judged and like I’d done something wrong.

I’m glad now that I didn’t admit the real reason is in case the banking system collapses and it’s now stuffed under my mattress.

Please tell me I’m not wrong to think she had no right to judge me and if she did, she should have been professional and not passed comment?

OP posts:
VanGoghsDog · 09/02/2022 10:15

[quote AutomaticMoon]**@VanGoghsDog* I said he didn’t ask the bank for the money back from themselves but he did tell them this happened. PP said ‘you’d ask the bank for your money back’ but he didn’t do that. He asked them if there’s anything that can be done to get the money back from the scammer*

Make sense now, or is it still odd?[/quote]
What's odd is that you e been scammed yet you object to the banks trying to actively stop you getting scammed.

I think, on balance, you're an outlier here.

00100001 · 09/02/2022 10:04

@NumberTheory

Last time I transfered a large amount of money and got similar questions and insinuations about it obviously being dodgy I just said "That's rich coming from a banker" and raised an eyebrow.
How very witty and droll. A bank worker is definitely a banker and is definitely the ones responsible for dodgy moving of millions around... Hmm

That's almost as clever and hilarious as going to the checkout operator "oh the items doesn't scan? go on let me have it for free ha ha ha"

Aprilx · 09/02/2022 10:03

@WhatIsThisPlease

I inherited quite a large sum of money and after it had been deposited into my bank, they rang me and asked me where I'd got it from!

I told them I'd had a win on the horses 😂

This is a perfectly normal thing for them to do. They are supposed to know the source of funds. It is crime prevention. You lying and making a joke of it helps nobody and is a silly and childish waste of time.
MoneySmartMummy · 09/02/2022 10:01

@AutomaticMoon I didn't say it was fair, I said they can.

They have to allow you to withdraw any state benefits, but you usually have to visit a branch with ID to do this each time.

They also have to allow the payment of essential bills and enough money to pay for food/fuel.

It's money laundering law, fairly easy to look up if you're interested in knowing the details.

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 09:59

@StylishMummy

“Yes, they can block your account for as long as it takes to investigate and they don't have to tell you why. If they did, it could be considered 'tipping off' and the cashier could face a fine and 2 years in prison.”

And how is the person supposed to live, without access to their own money, for up to 2 years, without so much as an explanation of what or why it’s happening? That seems fair to you?

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 09:41

@Penners99

What do you want the money for?

Mostly drugs and strippers, the rest I will just waste.

Same!
StylishMummy · 09/02/2022 09:41

I love how there's so much misinformation rife on this thread.

Yes, cashiers should ask about large or unusual transactions - it's part of their job role and not 'nannying'.

Yes, they can block your account for as long as it takes to investigate and they don't have to tell you why. If they did, it could be considered 'tipping off' and the cashier could face a fine and 2 years in prison.

For those joking about big banks and caring for consumers. The banks do have an obligation to ensure consumers are protected as well as they can from scammers, phishing calls and emails and dodgy tradespeople.

I used to work in a retail branch and it's not always the old or vulnerable who fall pray to clever cons. I now work in financial fraud detection services.

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 09:38

Exchanging banknotes for gold

We publish details of a selection of requests made under the Freedom of Information Act 2000, and the information we disclose in response.
Date released: 9 April 2015

Disclosure:

Since its foundation in 1694 the Bank of England (the ‘Bank’) has issued notes promising to pay the bearer a sum of money. For much of its history the promise could be made good by the Bank paying out gold in exchange for its notes. The link with gold helped to maintain the value of the notes, although the link was sometimes suspended, for example in wartime.

The link with gold was finally broken in 1931 (see in particular The Currency and Bank Notes Act 1928 and The Gold Standard (Amendment) Act 1931) when the UK came off the gold standard, and since that time there has been no other asset into which holders have the right to convert Bank of England notes. They can only be exchanged for other Bank of England notes. Nowadays public faith in the pound is maintained in a different way - through the Bank of England's operation of monetary policy, the object of which, by statute, is price stability.

The Bank Charter Act 1844 and the Currency and Bank Notes Acts 1928 and 1954, provide for the establishment of a distinct Department within the Bank of England - the Issue Department – and for the issue of banknotes. This legislation also requires notes issued by the Bank to be backed by securities (the concept of securities was broadened by the Finance Act 1932 and is now reflected in the amended 1928 Act) held in the Issue Department and confers legal tender status on Bank of England notes.

Youngatheart00 · 09/02/2022 09:36

@AutomaticMoon I’m not disputing that or excusing banks historic conduct but what I’m saying is that even in the direst of circumstances no one lost their money.

I work in financial services and I can say it’s a very different place to 15 years ago. So much focus on financial crime prevention

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 09:32

@Youngatheart00 “A bank rescue package totalling some £500 billion (approximately $850 billion) was announced by the British government on 8 October 2008, as a response to the global financial crisis.”

This is why the money was ‘safe’ in the bank, it was all taxpayer money.

Longingforsunshine · 09/02/2022 09:31

@NumberTheory

Last time I transfered a large amount of money and got similar questions and insinuations about it obviously being dodgy I just said "That's rich coming from a banker" and raised an eyebrow.
Yes because it’s that cashier on living wage who needs to take the brunt of your ‘banker’ jokes. OP this thread is ridiculous. I have worked as a bank cashier (albeit a good while ago) and scams are very very real. Banks have a duty to try and prevent fraud and protect its customers. That’s all they are trying to do. As for taking out cash to keep at home that’s utterly ridiculous. Much safer in a bank where it’s protected
AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 09:28

@rookiemere

My DPs were prevented from transferring money to their niece in the USA and had a visit from the police to check they weren't being scammed. They had to show emails and correspondence before they were then allowed to go back to the bank and make the transfer.

I suppose it's good to protect people but it does feel a bit like age discrimination as usually the elderly who are asked the questions.

This is dictatorship level intrusion, unbelievable. I lived in a dictatorship which is why I know and still get triggered by this kind of authoritarian stuff.
godmum56 · 09/02/2022 09:28

I am 50 50 on this one. Last time I needed to draw a largeish amount from the bank the cashier asked me very quietly if anybody was making me do it which i thought was acceptable. I had also contacted my bank and told them what I was going to do as my branch (now closed) was a small one and I wanted to be sure they would have enough cash on hand. The lady i spoke to said that she would make sure that they did and that they would earmark it for me. On the other hand, when my husband died and I was in and out of the bank closing stuff out, paying bills, depositing cheques and so on and very very little of it was done with cash, I was asked about 3 times if they could give me investment advice. The first time I said no thanks and the second time (different cashier) I asked why she was asking and she said it came up on her screen that she had to so I told her that I'd like it to be noted that they shouldn't ask as i was finding it painful. She immediately apologised and said she would sort it and I wasn't asked again. The third time it was a very unpleasant acting manager who accosted me on my next visit and asked me quite publicly if the bank could give me investment advice as i had quite a large sum in my current account. Right there I lost it completely and told him it was to pay for my dead husbands funeral and to settle certain bills and that if ANYBODY asked me again i would remove my business forthwith (yes I did say forthwith!)
I mean yes I get money laundering and assisting people but there are ways and ways and limits

CharSiu · 09/02/2022 09:24

I had a friend who was a civilian police worker and worked in victim support. She said the amount of women that fell for online romance scams and sent off money was truly frightening.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 09/02/2022 09:10

@ToffeePennee

Do you understand that your money is protected up to £85K per institution?

Withdrawing thousands and thousands to keep in your home is a worrying sign.

Penners99 · 09/02/2022 09:01

What do you want the money for?

Mostly drugs and strippers, the rest I will just waste.

jgw1 · 09/02/2022 09:00

@onemorecupofcoffeefortheroad

Iam pretty sure I heard earlier this week a government minister saying that fraud was not a proper crime and does not affect people. That is why they have suddenly not included it in the statistics they like to use

He's a fool to suggest ordinary people are not affected by fraud. It's misleading and untrue.

I talk to victims of fraud every single day - and I can assure you they are very 'real', mostly ordinary people: people on benefits, pensioners, single mothers, teenagers, business people, working parents, from all backgrounds and of all ages - every single day I speak to these people. Anyone can be the victim of a scam and you are naive if you think otherwise.

It's a massive problem, scammers are getting more sophisticated - even cloning bank telephone numbers so you think you're speaking to your bank or finding out your mother's maiden name so you think they know the answers to your security questions and therefore must be who they say they are and so on ... in order to make you think they are an organisation you can trust - there should actually be much more done to raise awareness.

Government ministers are surely not fools, they are the brightest and best in the land.
LookItsMeAgain · 09/02/2022 08:53

I would have thought that the questions being asked were either due to money laundering queries, especially if you've withdrawn large sums of money from the same branch in the past.
Another reason why cashiers may start asking questions is due to financial abuse in the home, if you're withdrawing a large sum of money it could be because there is some domestic abuse going on and they are being trained now to spot this.

OnlyAFleshWound · 09/02/2022 08:49

@ToffeePennee

It’s not really under my mattress, it’s in a fireproof case Wink but yes, the ways things are right now I feel like there is real potential for things to go very wrong very quickly and so I feel safer having enough at hand in a SHTF situation. I didn’t empty my account or anything.
So you envision a world in which the entire global banking system has crashed, but in which people and businesses will be happy to accept your tenners?
Remytherat · 09/02/2022 08:41

@OfstedOffred

Lol at paper money under the bed having any value if the banking system collapses
This. If you're lucky and manage to avoid large amounts of cash not being stolen or lost in a fire or flood, then the chances of it having any value if the banks collapse is minimal. It's just paper telling you how much the banks owe you. It has no intrinsic value.
Kazzyhoward · 09/02/2022 08:34

@AutomaticMoon

Yes, and regular people have their bank accounts blocked and it would be ‘tipping-off’ to tell them what the problem is, it’s Kafkaesque.

If people are lacking capacity to manage finances, why are they not being supported with this? It’s absurd to treat all of us as lacking capacity. Many just seem to want to be nannied like this.

It's because people who DO have capacity also get scammed!
bruffin · 09/02/2022 08:33

My friend has always preferred cash and kept slot in the house. I suspect 5 I not 6 figures. They have just been burgled and it's all gone. Insurance doesn't cover it.

onemorecupofcoffeefortheroad · 09/02/2022 08:22

Iam pretty sure I heard earlier this week a government minister saying that fraud was not a proper crime and does not affect people. That is why they have suddenly not included it in the statistics they like to use

He's a fool to suggest ordinary people are not affected by fraud. It's misleading and untrue.

I talk to victims of fraud every single day - and I can assure you they are very 'real', mostly ordinary people: people on benefits, pensioners, single mothers, teenagers, business people, working parents, from all backgrounds and of all ages - every single day I speak to these people. Anyone can be the victim of a scam and you are naive if you think otherwise.

It's a massive problem, scammers are getting more sophisticated - even cloning bank telephone numbers so you think you're speaking to your bank or finding out your mother's maiden name so you think they know the answers to your security questions and therefore must be who they say they are and so on ... in order to make you think they are an organisation you can trust - there should actually be much more done to raise awareness.

Lalliella · 09/02/2022 08:22

I was in the bank with my elderly mum and we were sat down having a chat with a member of staff about various financial matters, and she was telling us about examples of common scams. An elderly man came in while we were there with exactly one of the scam letters she was telling us about Sad Luckily he thought about asking the bank first. Not everyone does though.

FourChimneys · 09/02/2022 08:19

My elderly aunt used to withdraw large sums of cash. She would look the cashier straight in the eye and say "gin" when asked what the several thousands were for.