Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s nobody’s business what I do with my money?

235 replies

ToffeePennee · 08/02/2022 21:29

I went in to my bank to withdraw a large amount of cash. I explained to the cashier what I wanted to do and she proceeded to ask some security questions - all fine.

One of the questions was what I wanted the cash for so I said I was having building work done. She then started saying that I should pay by bank transfer, it was tax avoidance etc. etc. When I insisted I still wanted to withdraw the money, she sighed and rolled her eyes and I felt really judged and like I’d done something wrong.

I’m glad now that I didn’t admit the real reason is in case the banking system collapses and it’s now stuffed under my mattress.

Please tell me I’m not wrong to think she had no right to judge me and if she did, she should have been professional and not passed comment?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WayneBruce · 10/02/2022 13:08

The advisors face would have been proper twisty if you'd actually given your real reason. Proper bonkers!

UsernameInTheTown · 10/02/2022 13:02

Cheap wine and loose Gentlemen would have been my answer.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 10/02/2022 12:32

Based on this thread - if I were a burglar, I'd be combing social media etc for people who are into prepping etc. Absolute goldmines, the lot of you. Grin Hope you all namechange regularly, keep a close eye on privacy settings, keep any stockpiled items out of sight of windows/visitor, and also take care who you discuss prepping with irl.

HelloFrostyMorning · 09/02/2022 22:11

@flintstonewall

I have many worries about a cashless society too, OP.

Today I was in Tesco and the contactless / phone payments had went down. It was utter chaos. Huge queues, people irate and concerned at having to leave their shopping cause they couldn't pay for it, constant announcements over the tannoys. One lady was saying how she couldn't get on a train.

Really consolidated my thoughts on how we are handing so much control to a small number of people.

For the sake of what? A tiny bit more convenience, which is negated by the inconvenience when things like today happen (not the first time I've been in a shop and that's happened either). It's not even that much more convenient! How did we ever get on before!

Agree. I don't know why the OP is getting such a hard time. There's nothing wrong with keeping some cash at home. You'd be crazy not to IMO. I wouldn't be keeping multiple 10s of 1000s in my home, but several thousand yes. Or at least 1.5 to 2 thousand minimum in case of emergencies. In case you can't access your bank/your accounts are frozen/a major countrywide banking problem causes glitches and puts everyone offline for a week.

Very unlikely to happen but not impossible, and I (like the OP and other posters) reserve the right to keep cash at home, just in case of the worst case scenario, without being mocked/laughed at/called ridiculous, and told to grow up and get over it etc...

flintstonewall · 09/02/2022 21:28

I have many worries about a cashless society too, OP.

Today I was in Tesco and the contactless / phone payments had went down. It was utter chaos. Huge queues, people irate and concerned at having to leave their shopping cause they couldn't pay for it, constant announcements over the tannoys. One lady was saying how she couldn't get on a train.

Really consolidated my thoughts on how we are handing so much control to a small number of people.

For the sake of what? A tiny bit more convenience, which is negated by the inconvenience when things like today happen (not the first time I've been in a shop and that's happened either). It's not even that much more convenient! How did we ever get on before!

drpet49 · 09/02/2022 19:45

Oh get over it OP. What. A ridiculous thing to get annoyed about.

AutomaticMoon · 09/02/2022 19:42

@flirtygirl

Do dogs drink milk?
My whippet loves it, clotted cream too. She’s an utter piglet!
flirtygirl · 09/02/2022 19:09

Do dogs drink milk?

Allmyarseandpeggymartin · 09/02/2022 17:38

@countrygirl99 - Jesus that’s awful. It happens all too often sadly.

Op please reconsider and read up on the financial services compensation scheme.

TW9resident · 09/02/2022 17:24

I used to have an online savings account with the same bank that I used to keep surplus funds in, and move back and forth to/from the current account when needed. One day I needed to make a 4 figure transfer between my accounts to pay a direct debit due to be taken the next day and the bank blocked it. They wouldn't tell me why. The only solution was to go in person to the branch in the next town (as of course ours was closed) in the middle of my working day with photo ID. In front of everyone the cashier made some comment which was basically asking if we were in financial difficulty (we weren't). I forget the absolute details now as it was a few years ago but thinking about it still increases my blood pressure. It was totally out of order and so unnecessarily stressful.

countrygirl99 · 09/02/2022 14:43

Well the chances are that if you had put it in a cash ISA you would have had a little bit more when you come to spend it 🤷‍♀️

rookiemere · 09/02/2022 14:26

@caringcarer this is a sales technique and was even being touted back in the day when I was a graduate trainee at a now defunct building society almost 30 years ago.

They do it to my DPs as well. We do rather well out of it as DM goes oh yes there is too much there and transfers some to DS savings.

caringcarer · 09/02/2022 13:22

Yes, I have also found bank cahiers can be very bossy. I went to withdraw money and got 'told off' by cashier for having too large an amount in my current account and told I should put most of it into savings account or ISA. I explained it was for deposit on a house and would be needed in a few months and she called over another person, who also told me I was in the wrong.

countrygirl99 · 09/02/2022 13:20

@Allmyarseandpeggymartin

Op I think you need help, the banking system is not going to collapse and your money is much safer in the bank than under your mattress.

What will you do if you are robbed?

My parents neighbour had a gardener. Retired bloke, insisted on cash but it was only a couple of hours light gardening/mowing a week. He didn't trust banks and only had a bank account to receive his pension and tried to pay everything in cash if he could. Every week he would clear his account and everyone knew he kept all his savings at home. He lived a very frugal lifestyle and everyone assumed he only had maybe a couple of thousand there. One night a couple of burglars broke in and threatened to beat him up if he didn't tell them where the cash was. So he did, it was in the attic. £30k, his entire life savings, gone and not covered by insurance.
JesusInTheCabbageVan · 09/02/2022 13:11

@Allmyarseandpeggymartin

Op I think you need help, the banking system is not going to collapse and your money is much safer in the bank than under your mattress.

What will you do if you are robbed?

Yes. The problem is, the chances of you being robbed are about a billion times higher than the chances of global societal collapse.
Allmyarseandpeggymartin · 09/02/2022 12:58

Op I think you need help, the banking system is not going to collapse and your money is much safer in the bank than under your mattress.

What will you do if you are robbed?

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 09/02/2022 12:47

@justasking111 Shock can just imagine how this would pan out with our dog. For milk, she'd let them in and then guard the house against us when we got home.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 09/02/2022 12:40

"I rather fancy a Waitrose apricot flan. Have you seen the price of those things?"

Onlyhuman123 · 09/02/2022 12:34

Cheeky cow. As you say, nothing to do with her...she's asked her security questions, she said that it's not advisable yadda yadda, and in doing so has ticked all the boxes for anti M-L etc...so what's with the eye-rolling and sighing?! I'd have pulled her up on it tbh and caused a scene. Wink but then I'm menopausal and raging atm...

justasking111 · 09/02/2022 11:41

Talking to a wholesale jeweller once who took stock home, he had a drainpipe plastic sealed at one end a drain cover on the other end dug into his land. He said that was safer than in the house.

We were burgled the mess. They pulled back carpet corners looking for loose floor boards emptied every drawer in the bedroom, shoe boxes, bathroom cabinet, freezer, food cupboards. This was while I was doing the school run. They'd been watching the place police said. They did a number of Homes in our road. Never caught.

They even gave the dog a bowl of milk

RedToothBrush · 09/02/2022 11:19

@ToffeePennee

As I had to order the money, I’ve been back to get it and it was a much more pleasant experience. Same questions from a different cashier in a chattier tone and I was handed my money without a side helping of shame or judgement. Happy customer Smile

I appreciate the concern from PPs and the financial advice. As I mentioned, my issue was with the judgement rather than the security questions - I understand why they have to do this and I was happy to answer them. This is not my life savings, just an amount that helps me feel secure to have on hand.

A few years ago, during the whole ‘no deal’ brexit threats, I read an article about the normalcy bias, the notion that people do not see the collapse of their country coming until it’s already underway. With the way things are going, I do not trust the government or institutions and I feel they are becoming more controlling of the poor while the rich get away with more and more. I’ve been an avid Prepper since and feel this was a prudent part of my planning. I know the money will be worthless in the event of a banking crash but there will be a small window before it happens where everyone will be trying to withdraw their money so this way, I’m ahead of the curve. Obviously, I hope it never happens, it’s an insurance policy just in case.

This thread has hardened my feelings on the matter and I can see why we’re sleepwalking into a cashless society with all the unforeseen consequences, where the wealth of the poor is even more tightly controlled by the rich and powerful.

Anyway, I’m off to dig a hole in my back garden Wink

If people are sleep walking into a cashless society (which i think is deeply problematic) and then there's a crash of some kind, having cash isn't necessarily going to help you.

If the supermarket no longer accepts cash, it wont suddenly switch to taking cash again. The cash you have will be worthless anyway because its only worth something if its accepted as currency.

We are more likely in a apocalyptic type scenario be seeing looting / bartering. Or if cash is accepted, the criminal targeting of anyone who looks like theyve got cash.

As its been said many times before, prepping only works if you also have the means and ability to defend yourself and your property. You are actually better cultivating good support networks and community culture for this reason.

If things go that badly tits up, working and having safety in groups works better than in an every man for himself scenario.

I think preppers tend to do the opposite.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 09/02/2022 11:06

That entire posts just screams out, "I need help."

ToffeePennee · 09/02/2022 10:55

As I had to order the money, I’ve been back to get it and it was a much more pleasant experience. Same questions from a different cashier in a chattier tone and I was handed my money without a side helping of shame or judgement. Happy customer Smile

I appreciate the concern from PPs and the financial advice. As I mentioned, my issue was with the judgement rather than the security questions - I understand why they have to do this and I was happy to answer them. This is not my life savings, just an amount that helps me feel secure to have on hand.

A few years ago, during the whole ‘no deal’ brexit threats, I read an article about the normalcy bias, the notion that people do not see the collapse of their country coming until it’s already underway. With the way things are going, I do not trust the government or institutions and I feel they are becoming more controlling of the poor while the rich get away with more and more. I’ve been an avid Prepper since and feel this was a prudent part of my planning. I know the money will be worthless in the event of a banking crash but there will be a small window before it happens where everyone will be trying to withdraw their money so this way, I’m ahead of the curve. Obviously, I hope it never happens, it’s an insurance policy just in case.

This thread has hardened my feelings on the matter and I can see why we’re sleepwalking into a cashless society with all the unforeseen consequences, where the wealth of the poor is even more tightly controlled by the rich and powerful.

Anyway, I’m off to dig a hole in my back garden Wink

OP posts:
saraclara · 09/02/2022 10:51

@onemorecupofcoffeefortheroad

Like fuck do they care if you are getting scammed by someone

Being scammed can destroy people's lives - over £300 million has been lost in scams in one year.

I work with victims of fraud - it is quite shocking 1. how clever and manipulate scammers can be and 2. how easily victims are tricked.

Most UK banks are signed up to a voluntary, banking code which means they have a duty of care to protect their customers from getting scammed and are required to detect high risk payments, identify vulnerable people and freeze payments while they investigate if they think you may be the victim of a scam.

If they don't do enough to protect their customers (are negligent) while the customer has done enough to protect themselves (are not negligent) and the bank refuse to refund the customer's money in the event they have been scammed - the matter can be taken to the Financial Ombudsman (easy to do via an online form) who will allocate an independent advisor to look into the case.

If they find the bank has been negligent while the customer did enough to protect themselves - they will order the bank to refund the lost funds. I have known banks forced to refund as much as £200k, which is a loss to them. That's why they ask the questions.

When I listen to a vulnerable person, who has handed the entirety of their bank account over to a scammer, sometimes I wish they'd do more.

Thanks for this post. I'm finding most of the responses on this thread, really quite disturbing, in that people don't seem to have a clue.

This isn't remotely about staff being nosy. Why would they care? The teller has no curiosity about you as a person, whatsoever. But they do have a job to do, and would feel some responsibility if they themselves handed over thousands to someone who they later found out had been scammed.

On the one hand people who lose money will scream that the bank should have protected them, and on the other, when the bank tries to protect them, it's "IT'S MY F*ING MONEY AND THEY CAN KEEP THEIR NOSES OUT"

VanGoghsDog · 09/02/2022 10:30

My mum has full capacity but is often on the verge of falling for scams, she's clicked on email and text links which so far have luckily not caused any issues, but one will work one day.

And she's regularly being over charged by tradespeople.

It's not that much of a stretch to see her falling for something where she loses a lot of money. I can't do anything about it. But luckily the banks do at least try to check.