Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel overwhelmed by non-binary, cancel culture, and woke society?

683 replies

FordSiesta · 08/02/2022 20:57

I've got to the stage where I feel quite apprehensive about the future. It just feels like there will be no 'men' or 'women' or 'boys' and 'girls' and everyone will need to conform to various gender identities and have to remember all the different ways people identify so as not to accidently offend anyone. I'm supportive of transgender people and understand people changing from male to female or vice versa but now there's all this non-binary stuff it's getting confusing.

All these things going on in this 'woke society' and if you aren't seen as wanting to conform with all this new stuff then the 'cancel culture' comes at you.

I just feel like I would be happy if there wasn't so much pressure placed on people to get pronouns correct if for millions of years we've used he/him and she/her and now we need to say they/them when we were taught in school they/them was plural.

I don't have kids yet but I do wonder if I did what the world would be like for them growing up.

AIBU for wanting to just continue with two genders?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Momijin · 10/02/2022 13:54

I don't know enough about it. I know I hated puberty and getting breasts and I was also a tomboy but always felt like a girl. I wanted to look like a girl and be a girl.

I have quite a few online friends whose daughters are either non binary or identify as boys. I don't know any the other way. I know of an adult transgender woman but I don't know if she's had any operations or takes any hormones. She still looks like a man, but she's in her 60s.

If it is a phase then it would be a tragedy to support it with hormones and operations. But for those who are people born in the wrong body they must be fully supported.

And since you can get people that are born both sexes physically then it also makes sense that their brain or whatever makes them them, can also be both or the wrong one.

babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 13:46

Right, but what about those whose parents buy into this batshit ideology? Or those who get sent to therapy because they have trauma from sexual abuse or an eating disorder, mention they feel like they might be trans and then get referred on to GIDS?

Who is going to protect those kids?

Momicrone · 10/02/2022 13:36

Baby jellyfish, getting referred to a gender clinic is a massive step, that for most of these kids who are experimenting with their identity, won't happen, it's certainly not something I'd encourage

Momicrone · 10/02/2022 13:34

The keeping five, - Kids 'experimenting' with their gender, be it gender fluid, non binary etc, is not the same as changing sex. Choosing not to reject a child's inherent beliefs about themselves, however temporary or permanent, is not encouraging it.

babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 12:24

It's also worth noting that there are parents (including here on Mumsnet) who know their children are suffering from serious mental health problems, but because they have talked about being trans or non binary their parents don't feel able to get them any counselling because they have no way of checking in advance that the counsellor won't push them towards transition instead of getting to the bottom of what is really going on.

babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 12:21

@Momicrone

To reiterate my point, I do not agree with medical intervention, but most of these kids will never get that far, so to allow them to have a space to express who they think they are is generally a good thing, be it a fad, a cult, deluded nonsense, whatever you want to call it
But if they are referred to a gender clinic they will be affirmed in their gender identity and put on a path towards medicalisation.
TheKeatingFive · 10/02/2022 12:13

but most of these kids will never get that far, so to allow them to have a space to express who they think they are is generally a good thing, be it a fad, a cult, deluded nonsense, whatever you want to call it

But people don't necessary agree that it's a good thing, or not in the way that you're presenting it.

Allowing them space to explore confusion and complexity about who they are in this world, who they want to be, coming to terms with an adult body, exploring all the myriad ways you could be male and female. Sure.

Encouraging them to believe that they're a woman in a man's body or vice verse, despite no real evidence for innate gender identities outside of societal stereotypes, playing along with a fairytale that you can 'change sex' and that would be the answer, no. I think that's harmful.

Momicrone · 10/02/2022 12:06

To reiterate my point, I do not agree with medical intervention, but most of these kids will never get that far, so to allow them to have a space to express who they think they are is generally a good thing, be it a fad, a cult, deluded nonsense, whatever you want to call it

FOJN · 10/02/2022 12:01

The very fact I could be threatened with rape or murder for saying that speaks for itself.

Never doubt the patriarchy is alive, well and positively thriving.

PollyPage · 10/02/2022 10:57

If it wasn't for MNi would probably say live and let live and think it's all a bit silly. But I have learned so much from the discussions and do feel genuinely concerned that this erosion of women's rights is stealthily creeping into normal language. The very fact I could be threatened with rape or murder for saying that speaks for itself.

lifeturnsonadime · 10/02/2022 10:02

I have said this before and I will say it again, this is the ONLY reason I am glad that my autistic non gender conforming daughter whose sensory issues means that she couldn't stand the feel of make up or the clothes that are marketed for girls is not able to be in mainstream (or any) school.

She would be so very vulnerable to gender ideology, it's no wonder autistic girls are the most likely group of girls to experience sudden onset gender dysphoria.

That paired with the fact that there are next to no services available to support young autistic people means that it is very easy for the adults to say that this is a great fix for the fact that these girls don't 'fit' into to society.

It's a bloody disgrace, I don't like to dwell on it too much because it's to painful but we why is the state sanctioning the sterilisation of disabled girls?

WhoIsBernieBrown · 10/02/2022 09:49

A poster upthread mentioned that their teen identifies as non-binary as they don't fully identify with female stereotypes (sorry if I've misquoted) and this is what I keep coming back to - is it all just about gender stereotypes? Are the kids who were raised to love dolls and cars, wear whatever colour they want regardless of gender going through this too? Or is it more the girls who were forced to wear pink and not spoil their dresses who are rebelling and identifying as male?

I was a tomboy but LOVE being a woman. But being a woman isn't about getting manicures every weekend and drinking sparkling bloody rose. The insistence on labels is what I can't get my head around.

But I suppose when you are a teen with raging hormones and not much sense of who you are as a person, labels help you paint that picture.

I'm confused by the whole thing, supportive of genuine trans people but the media storm and school aged gender chaos is overshadowing the real issues. It all makes me need a lie down.

babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 09:30

@Momicrone

Yes and that's terrible, but some people experiment with drugs and go on to lead happy healthy lives, some don't.
Drugs are illegal.

Why is it illegal to take cocaine or ecstasy, or even smoke weed, which will probably not actually harm you in the long run, but legal for an 18 year old girl to take testosterone and have a double mastectomy with little if any appropriate counselling?

TheKeatingFive · 10/02/2022 09:28

Sorry I quoted the wrong post. I meant this

Yes and that's terrible, but some people experiment with drugs and go on to lead happy healthy lives, some don't.

Not state/medical/parentally sponsored they don't

TheKeatingFive · 10/02/2022 09:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Rhannion · 10/02/2022 09:16

Growing out of something is normal, people change their minds about tattoos for example, and can have them removed, which is very expensive and painful, but what about the irreversible steps?
Cutting off healthy breasts, having chunks of flesh cut from arms and thighs to create a faux penis for example. Those surgeries are not something that can be reversed.
A certain well known young person from the US has been the poster child for m to f and I remember reading that that person’s mother saying I’m paraphrasing here “ there wasn’t enough “ material“ ie flesh , to create what her child wanted.
This isn’t a child or an adult who has needed skin grafts after a terrible accident, this is a young person who has had bits of their body removed because they have mental health issues or they were indulged and/ encouraged by their parents who should know better.

Momicrone · 10/02/2022 09:15

Yes and that's terrible, but some people experiment with drugs and go on to lead happy healthy lives, some don't.

babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 09:11

@Momicrone

Thekeatingfive, it's not a terrible idea if it's something they grow out of, many will
Unfortunately some of them will be irreparably harmed before they grow out of it.
Lostinafjord · 10/02/2022 09:04

@DdraigGoch

My daughter’s friend is trans (girl to boy) and was banging on in the car how disgusting it is that toilets in school are single sex and should all be unisex… Firstly they go to a girls’ school Ok, that's beyond parody. The toilets may as well be unisex on the basis that all pupils can use all toilets.
If he now identifies as male, why is he still attending a girls' school?
TabithaHazel · 10/02/2022 08:58

@blublub

It’s just the latest fad. We’ll have real problems soon, aside from navel gazing, like if we can eat or possibly war. This will help put things in perspective for those whose lives are in a bubble in their own head.
Agree with this 100%, it is just a fad. What is inexcusable is the grown men and women jumping on the bandwagon when they are old enough to know better. It does seem to mirror a more narcissistic direction western society seems to be going in though. Honestly no-one really gives a shit about other people's 'gender identity' it's just all so self indulgent.
TheKeatingFive · 10/02/2022 08:43

it's not a terrible idea if it's something they grow out of, many will

Denying biological fact isn't a terrible idea? That's what you're saying?

Momicrone · 10/02/2022 08:39

Thekeatingfive, it's not a terrible idea if it's something they grow out of, many will

milkyaqua · 10/02/2022 08:36

I get that people find this confusing. But what isn't confusing is the genuine heartache of feeling that you're in the wrong body. The confusion in your own mind and the feeling of isolation caused by not feeling at home in your own skin.

Curious that there is an epidemic of it... Prior to social media, there were a handful of individuals (all adults) here and there who underwent a full transition, having lived as their preferred self for two years as a prerequisite, etc. I have known three in my whole life.

I think it is often down to social contagion; certainly was the case for three young girls in the same class in a small country high school that I know of - what a coincidence!

TheKeatingFive · 10/02/2022 08:29

Accepting that they're confused and accepting what they're saying as how they feel - i.e.showing compassion and supporting the individual will help them feel accepted and give them the space to discover who they are.

But this is exactly what people propose doing.

Maintaining some illusion that you can change sex, however, doesn't help anyone. In fact it has the potential to seriously fuck these children up in the longer term.

Getting used to an adult body is a tough and confusing process. We've all been through it. Attributing all this to being in a 'wrong' body or perpetuating ideas that living as a male/female is about complying to rigid stereotypes are a terrible way to handle this.

Pilgit · 10/02/2022 08:20

I get that people find this confusing. But what isn't confusing is the genuine heartache of feeling that you're in the wrong body. The confusion in your own mind and the feeling of isolation caused by not feeling at home in your own skin. Approaching those in this situation with compassion and acceptance is not confusing - it's allowing them to be as they are.

Teenagers have been going through confusing personal journey's for millenia. Whether it was seen and accepted by people or not - the confusing teenage years have always been there. What i see of girls in this society is that they see all this pressure that to be female means one thing - glamour, big boobs etc- love island wannabe (I'm using shorthand here but you get the picture) and not identifying with that image may cause confusion in them. There's lots of perceived pressure to be certain ways and lots of female centric violence highlighted.in the press. I understand the desire to reject that and if they're already feeling confused, finding a tribe that accepts them is all the sweeter.

Accepting that they're confused and accepting what they're saying as how they feel - i.e
.showing compassion and supporting the individual will help them feel accepted and give them the space to discover who they are. This is what i believe we should be doing. This doesn't mean not challenging their views and opinions but that can be done constructively and in a way to make them think analytically about their situation.

From the trans people i know it was a long journey to final acceptance of what and who they are. It was not a lifestyle choice.

And I'm yet to meet a teenager who when told that they're wrong does anything other than.dig their heels in and entrench in their position.