Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel overwhelmed by non-binary, cancel culture, and woke society?

683 replies

FordSiesta · 08/02/2022 20:57

I've got to the stage where I feel quite apprehensive about the future. It just feels like there will be no 'men' or 'women' or 'boys' and 'girls' and everyone will need to conform to various gender identities and have to remember all the different ways people identify so as not to accidently offend anyone. I'm supportive of transgender people and understand people changing from male to female or vice versa but now there's all this non-binary stuff it's getting confusing.

All these things going on in this 'woke society' and if you aren't seen as wanting to conform with all this new stuff then the 'cancel culture' comes at you.

I just feel like I would be happy if there wasn't so much pressure placed on people to get pronouns correct if for millions of years we've used he/him and she/her and now we need to say they/them when we were taught in school they/them was plural.

I don't have kids yet but I do wonder if I did what the world would be like for them growing up.

AIBU for wanting to just continue with two genders?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
lifeturnsonadime · 10/02/2022 22:37

[quote LexMitior]@lifeturnsonadime - that sounds like a huge challenge for you and your daughter. And yes, it does look rather convenient. History shows a rather nasty litany of treatments for young women who are perceived to be different or deemed to have mental problems at the hands of the medical profession. Much of it is a kind of misogyny, because there are not easy answers.

I wish you both the best.[/quote]
Thanks Lex,

Luckily, so far, my daughter has been shielded from the social contagion.

She wears and looks and does what she wants.

I just really hope she doesn't get influenced by others to believe that the fact she doesn't conform with how society expects girls to look and behave means that she's not a girl. Girls need to be empowered to know that it is fine to be a girl and to reject make up, crop tops etc etc. Not told that this makes them non-binary or really boys with all of the potential implications of that pointed out by FOJN.

lifeturnsonadime · 10/02/2022 22:32

The growth market in trans surgery is with non binary people. Young females can now have gender affirmation surgery which involves removing their breasts and nipples. They may choose to take small doses of testosterone. Young males can have their testicles removed and the scrotum formed into a cavity (a fake vagina which is different to the penile inversion of full SRS) behind the penis or they may choose to have their penis and testicles removed to end up with a smooth profile like a desexed action figure.

This is where preferred pronouns lead to.

Monstrous.

FOJN · 10/02/2022 22:25

YABU but I'm sick of anti-trans threads like this.

It's unfortunate that you see concern for women's rights and childrens safety as anti-trans.

Women's single sex spaces are important for our participation in public life, receiving health care and to receive support recovering from trauma caused by males.

We are currently running a live experiment on children. There is an increasing body of evidence about the negative health outcomes from administering puberty blockers and cross sex hormones to children. The experiment has not been running long enough for us to have long term data. Puberty blockers are not a pause button, scientists have no idea if there is a window in which puberty must take place or it doesn't happen at all. Gathering evidence is difficult because nearly all children who are prescribed puberty blockers go on to receive cross sex hormones.

A watchful wait rather than puberty blockers approach results in about 85% of children outgrowing their dysphoria or managing it without surgery or hormones. Who in their right mind would prefer children to become lifelong medical patients if it's possible to avoid it? It has nothing to do with thinking being trans is wrong.

The growth market in trans surgery is with non binary people. Young females can now have gender affirmation surgery which involves removing their breasts and nipples. They may choose to take small doses of testosterone. Young males can have their testicles removed and the scrotum formed into a cavity (a fake vagina which is different to the penile inversion of full SRS) behind the penis or they may choose to have their penis and testicles removed to end up with a smooth profile like a desexed action figure.

LexMitior · 10/02/2022 22:24

@lifeturnsonadime - that sounds like a huge challenge for you and your daughter. And yes, it does look rather convenient. History shows a rather nasty litany of treatments for young women who are perceived to be different or deemed to have mental problems at the hands of the medical profession. Much of it is a kind of misogyny, because there are not easy answers.

I wish you both the best.

lifeturnsonadime · 10/02/2022 22:16

LexMitior

What disturbs me more, being the parent of a non gender conforming autistic daughter, is the fact that services are referring autistic girls to services like GIDS. I am sure that part of that is to do with waiting lists for general mental health and autism services.

The child feels better because they have assumed a fashionable identity and they can be removed from the books from the mental health services because of 'acceptance without exception'. It's a bit of a winner for overwhelmed mental heath and autism services my cynical voice tells me. Great way to manage waiting lists and pass the problem down the line

No doubt there is also homophobia but this, to me is a great solution for overburdened mental health services;

Time will tell

woodhill · 10/02/2022 22:12

I think it is dangerous for teenagers to be encouraged to go down the medical route. Surely wait till they are consenting adults of 18 would be a step in the right direction

Hormones and emotions are all over the place. It's awful and it can't be reversed

LexMitior · 10/02/2022 22:07

@lifeturnsonadime - it is worrying because I can see the temptation to say well these people are the experts, but is does seem rather counterintuitive to assume that a charity has some searing insight into a complex medical condition.

Sexuality is very simple by comparison. The difficulties with it are acceptance by others who are not gay and lesbian, and do not want to give gay and lesbian people their dignity as human being - I have always felt that homophobia is really about the fear of same sex love. That gay and lesbian people can love each in other in just the same way as anyone else.

Transgenderism seems like magical thinking which is why it is very unnerving to see the medical profession embrace it. There will be some overt homophobes in this specialism I would think. Many of them working with children who are confused. Stonewall should have thought about who they might be empowering when they give this training to GPs.

nonono1 · 10/02/2022 22:00

An interview with the aforementioned Pips Bunce of Credit Suisse:

www.fnlondon.com/articles/mistranslated-i-split-my-time-as-pippa-and-philip-20171002

It’s so inspiring that he decided to openly embrace his true identity at work IMO, especially in such a corporate environment.

lifeturnsonadime · 10/02/2022 21:57

@FangsForTheMemory

YABU but I'm sick of anti-trans threads like this.

HTH.

So don't you think that women are different from males who identify as women and that there are occasions that single sex spaces are required to ensure the privacy and dignity of women as a sex class, if not please explain why?

Why is it anti trans to be concerned about women's right to safe spaces and the mutilation and sterilisation of children who identify as trans?

Do you believe in same sex orientation or do you believe that women who reject people with penises are bigoted?

lifeturnsonadime · 10/02/2022 21:52

I suppose what looks common is that also the medical profession, who would claim to be very tolerant, are to some extent prejudiced. I wonder what part is played by their treatment of children, which in part may also be about their own prejudices.

I am related to a GP, she has been 'trained' the Stonewall/ Mermaids line of thinking, that gender must be respected and the identities of children should be accepted without exception and that doing 'no harm' might mean referring to clinics that will advise puberty blockers etc. Absolutely shocking.

I'm not sure that the homophobia plays an overt part in the thinking of those who received the training given by Stonewall. They would assume the opposite given the organisation providing the training. That's the irony.

Bollindger · 10/02/2022 21:48

Stonewall was formed to fight for LGB rights and to get marriage recognised. 100% backed for legal marriage. David Cameron just turned round and said OK. So this charity with loads of money and no cause took the wrong path, and here we are.

FangsForTheMemory · 10/02/2022 21:48

YABU but I'm sick of anti-trans threads like this.

HTH.

KarmaStar · 10/02/2022 21:45

Yanbu it's gone way too far with people doing their best to get offended.
Ridiculous.

CatsArePeople · 10/02/2022 21:37

Waiting for the pendulum to swing back.

I'm afraid the backlash will be severe. It will be against gay people, against feminists, against women in general... because this madness will be seen as "their fault".

babyjellyfish · 10/02/2022 21:36

Yes, that may be but this person basically labelled all trans women as cross-dressers. How is that acceptable?

Sinead Watson, a detransitioned woman, has posted videos on YouTube describing her experiences with GIDS. According to her, "living as" the opposite sex literally just means cross dressing. Oh, and pronouns.

I mean, what else is there?

Living as a man means living in a male body. Living as a woman means living in a female body. Trans people can't "live as" the opposite sex because humans can't change sex.

So what's left, apart from cross dressing and pronouns?

Lookingoutside · 10/02/2022 21:19

‘How many more goady threads on this do we need? ‘Oh, I’m soooo confuuuused!’ Of course you are, love…’

So explain it too me @WomanStanleyWoman

I’m not confused about anything. I am a woman, not a body with a vagina, a bleeder or a fucking cervix owner. If I get raped in Scotland, my male rapist will be allowed to identify as female if he chooses to when he is arrested. The incel community will eventually use this bullshit to claim that women are raping and killing women.

Why? Please explain it to me.

LexMitior · 10/02/2022 21:16

@FOJN

Its not quite the same thing in the UK, but I do wonder whether homophobia places a part in the keenness to be transgender because society is not really that accepting of gay people, despite all the rainbow flags.

A whistleblower from the Tavistock Clinic reported that staff use to comment there would soon be no gay children left. Transing the gay away is a thing but it's hard to know if its parents or children who are driving it. Many of the female detransitioners are lesbians.

I suppose what looks common is that also the medical profession, who would claim to be very tolerant, are to some extent prejudiced. I wonder what part is played by their treatment of children, which in part may also be about their own prejudices.

Children are very sensitive to the expectations of adults. Doctors are powerful people and they are not saints. I am sure they too impose expectations of wider society not to be gay or lesbian.

FOJN · 10/02/2022 20:59

Yes, that may be but this person basically labelled all trans women as cross-dressers. How is that acceptable?

Pip Bounce is a director at Credit Suisse, they identify as gender fluid or non binary and wear dresses and make up on some days of the week and a business suit on others. They accepted an award for women in business. How would you describe this?

The Beaumont Society
Traditionally regarded as a secret MTF group for cross-dressers, the society has significantly evolved since these humble beginnings. It’s now open to any section of the transgender community who would like to join, MTF, FTM, bi or non gendered – even wives and partners.

It really isn't a stretch to suggest that some males may cross dress and identify as a transwoman without actually experiencing gender dysphoria which has historically been the defining characteristic of transexuals experience.

UmbrellasAndToadstools25 · 10/02/2022 20:52

Yes, it's overwhelming and let's be honest - it's all tiresome bollocks anyway.

I just have to let it roll over me for my own sanity.

FOJN · 10/02/2022 20:48

Its not quite the same thing in the UK, but I do wonder whether homophobia places a part in the keenness to be transgender because society is not really that accepting of gay people, despite all the rainbow flags.

A whistleblower from the Tavistock Clinic reported that staff use to comment there would soon be no gay children left. Transing the gay away is a thing but it's hard to know if its parents or children who are driving it. Many of the female detransitioners are lesbians.

woodhill · 10/02/2022 20:47

@LexMitior

I wonder sometimes about transgender matters and whether it seems homophobic, whether our society is really all the accepting of gay and lesbians as it now claims to be. Years ago I used to work with Iranian men who were definitely gay, but to be accepted in Iran, they either had to pretend they were heterosexual or get "gender reassignment". Then this was socially acceptable in a place where otherwise you would have faced a death sentence.

Its not quite the same thing in the UK, but I do wonder whether homophobia places a part in the keenness to be transgender because society is not really that accepting of gay people, despite all the rainbow flags.

Yes,I remember reading an article about this.
IWanderedLonely · 10/02/2022 20:42

YANBU at all. I feel exactly the same.
Waiting for the pendulum to swing back.

Eightiesfan · 10/02/2022 20:40

@Hasselhoffsheadband

Good grief, are you serious…cross-dressing, just wow.

Cross dressers come under the 'trans umbrella' according to Stonewall.

Yes, that may be but this person basically labelled all trans women as cross-dressers. How is that acceptable?
LexMitior · 10/02/2022 20:09

I wonder sometimes about transgender matters and whether it seems homophobic, whether our society is really all the accepting of gay and lesbians as it now claims to be. Years ago I used to work with Iranian men who were definitely gay, but to be accepted in Iran, they either had to pretend they were heterosexual or get "gender reassignment". Then this was socially acceptable in a place where otherwise you would have faced a death sentence.

Its not quite the same thing in the UK, but I do wonder whether homophobia places a part in the keenness to be transgender because society is not really that accepting of gay people, despite all the rainbow flags.

Buttercup54321 · 10/02/2022 20:00

I dont care. I ignore it and carry on with my life as usual. Lot of ridiculous nonsense.