Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to get bit annoyed that people assume I just “don’t put on weight”

141 replies

mumof2exhausted · 08/02/2022 15:18

I’m a size 10 at the moment - been 10/12 most of my life apart from when I drank too much/ate kebabs at uni and when I was pregnant. This is not because of magic genes it’s because I consistently exercise and I watch what I eat.

I have a friend who is always on a fad diet and is over weight by a few stone (she is always moaning about her weight). She says all the time to me “oh you’re alright you never have to watch your weight”. I do though!! I went on an all inclusive holiday a few months ago and I did barely any exercise and ate and drank everything in sight and I put on a stone in 2 weeks!! It’s gone now as I’m back to eating normally and exercising.

AIBU to say some overweight people genuinely seem to think slimmer people are just lucky and it’s nothing to do with the fact we move more and eat less. When my friend says it to me I just say hmmmm as I don’t want an argument with her and I know she’s unhappy with her size so it’s pointless to point out that i average 20,000 steps, I have an active job, I go to gym 4 times a week and I roughly eat 1800 calories a day

OP posts:
bindud · 08/02/2022 18:11

Not really, you'd have to be extremely tall (like well over 6 foot) for a size ten to be underweight,

I don't think I'm extremely tall though & I reckon I need to be 9 st to be a 10 all over. That puts me as an underweight BMi which I was when young but not now.

RestingPandaFace · 08/02/2022 18:03

Some people are just lucky though, my dad never did deliberate exercise in his life, and wasn’t generally active at all with an incredibly sedentary job. He ate like a monster, never a biscuit always a packet, a multipack of crisps, takeaways all the time, cooked breakfast with fried bread a few times a week etc. Had a 32 inch waist at 65 and considered that ‘middle aged spread’ Grin sadly I did not inherit his metabolism.

Lampshading · 08/02/2022 18:03

Yanbu, but threads about weight and people taking responsibility for their weight or for berating slim people never go well.

Mojoj · 08/02/2022 18:01

Ooh lots of jealous people on here....🤣🤣. I completely agree OP. It's easier for fat people to think that being slim is just your luck and not down to hard work and willpower. And just for the record- a size 10-12 IS slim...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Ki0612 · 08/02/2022 17:59

I really agree with you I'm very overweight and chatting with also overweight friends they seem to think people are naturally slim. I'm like they are not! They watch what they eat constantly. However I think this myth is because slim people are very often underplaying the work they put in to maintaining their weight.

Shopgirl1 · 08/02/2022 17:51

I get this now - I’m size 10 and people comment on how I’m lucky I’m so slim. It’s not luck though, I work hard at it, walking lots, running 50km a week, watching I’m not eating junk. In the past I was several stone overweight. I know how easy it can happen, it’s not down to luck, it’s ongoing vigilance- but I don’t mind it, I love fruit and healthy eating now, I think when you reduce processed sugar from your diet your tastebuds change. I’m also very focussed on running and that helps me think about eating to fuel my body correctly.

latetothefisting · 08/02/2022 17:48

[quote bindud]@latetothefisting I wouldn't say thin equals underweight. I'm 5ft 10, bmi 19 ish, size 10/12[/quote]
I thought you were responding "depends on height" in relation to the "is a healthy size" part of the sentence rather than the "thin" part.

So I was saying that a size ten is a healthy size for the majority of people regardless of their height - for it to not be a healthy size (i.e. too heavy or not heavy enough for their frame) they'd have to be at the very extreme of the height range for women. Sorry if that wasn't clear.

TheHaka · 08/02/2022 17:45

I never gained weight & ate & drank whatever I liked, I walked everywhere though. Overweight people constantly told me I didn’t deserve to be thin 🤔 I wouldn’t dream of telling anyone that they deserve to be fat, for whatever reason. My very fat (I wouldn’t normally say the F word about anyone, but I want to insult her) jealous sister was obsessed with my weight, & absolutely hated me for it. I got ill & gained weight, I hoped she would like me because of the weight gain, she didn’t. OP, if you do an AI it’s best to try & lose a stone beforehand, then you’ll be the same weight upon your return. Tell the friend to fuck off.

Nospringchix · 08/02/2022 17:45

@HunterHearstHelmsley

YANBU

I used to be a size 6-8 and people used to make comments all the time. As though it just happened!

It's disgraceful that it's acceptable to comment on someone's weight if they're slim, but if any one says something about someone larger then its "fat shaming". I specifically remember one woman who always used to say how I needed to eat a sausage roll/doughnut/whatever, it was every day. She cried when I suggested she shouldn't and couldn't see the comparison to what she was saying to me daily.

I eat a lot. I exercise a lot. If I didn't exercise as much, I wouldn't eat as much.

Yes this! People thinking its acceptable to comment if you are slim! I had a period of awful depression and anxiety in my mid twenties and completely lost my appetite and enjoyment of eating. Size 6 clothes were too loose on me.

When people , both those I knew and complete strangers would say how lucky I was to be so skinny I used to feel like shouting at them andntelling them I would rather be bigger and not severely depressed.

PollyCreo · 08/02/2022 17:40

It's frustrating OP. I'm only within the healthy weight range because I eat healthily and exercise five days a week. I come from a long line of chubsters and if I take my eye off the ball I can gain a stone in a fortnight Angry

I have a naturally skinny friend (8 stone dripping wet) who rolls her eyes at my gym habit. Yes she's sylph-like a la 90s Kate Moss but she gets out of breath walking to her car.

TibetanTerrah · 08/02/2022 17:35

Ugh you're clearly touching a nerve with some posters OP. I hate these threads as they inevitably get sneery defensive replies.

I put on a bit of weight over lockdown when I stopped moving WFH and not going out, and snacking more. I lost it again by stopping snacking and exercising most days. Now I can 'eat what I want' and I'm sure from the outside people think I'm just 'lucky' but it does take work. You can't just sit on your arse ordering takeaways then blame 'luck' or 'genes' when you're fat fgs. Most people underestimate how much they eat and overestimate how much they burn off.

Goldenbear · 08/02/2022 17:31

YABU but only because I really don't think many people do think that I think most people think the opposite is true- that thin people work hard at being thin. I think it was UCL who did some research on 'naturally thin' people and it is a small percentage of people that are naturally thin but that i mean don't exercise excessively or purposely, eat what they like when they like and never put weight on! This is really very rare so I can't imagine thinking that it is easy or not worked at is a common thought. What is more likely is, 'it is alright for you, you are thin and you don't have to worry about one off night'

bindud · 08/02/2022 17:31

@latetothefisting I wouldn't say thin equals underweight. I'm 5ft 10, bmi 19 ish, size 10/12

givethatbabyaname · 08/02/2022 17:30

YANBU

Reminds me of people at school who used to say “you’re so lucky you get maths, wish I could be like you”. It wasn’t luck, it was hours and hour of studying after school and at the weekends.

It’s the dismissing of your effort, at the same time as moaning about their circumstances, that’s annoying. It doesn’t bother me any more, I just feel sorry for these people because they’re clearly either not capable of thinking logically or pushing themselves. Their choice 🤷‍♀️

phoenixrosehere · 08/02/2022 17:25

*most of my life

phoenixrosehere · 08/02/2022 17:23

YANBU

I have been between a U.K. 8-10 for all of my life and was actually heavier in Secondary but have never been overweight. I’ve dealt with comments on my size, weight, and even how I eat from relatives because I’m the slender one. My mother and my sister were my worst bullies. Questions like “why don’t you have a six pack at 15? Why do your clavicles jut out, are you becoming anorexics? Regardless of gain or loss, there was always comments. Even overheard my mother talking to her sister about how disappointed she was I was still slender after having my first and sighing in defeat that I was again with my second. Many of them rarely ever take into account how much thought and action it took to maintain and lose weight.

I walk everywhere and have done so for the most part since I was six. When my dad came gone from work, I was straight outside riding my bike around for hours up and down hills. I had dance classes from 10-16. I learned my triggers early after moving from my parents and going to uni. Stress is a massive trigger for my weight gain so I try to keep it down and when I do feel stressed I usually exercise, going on long walks. I partake in physical hobbies like hiking and gardening, I drink high calorie drinks as a treat once maybe 2/3 months. I eat my biggest meals in the day and light meals in the evening, intermittent fasting, being creative with swaps asking myself what I enjoy about the foods I eat, eating on smaller plates and bowls (dessert size) , not feeling I have to finish my plate, taking my vitamins and the right dosage for my body, etc..

It’s years of learning and picking things up along the way and not wanting to end up with the health issues that my parents, sister, and many other family members deal with. My grandmother was obese and she spent the last years of her life wheelchair-bound in agony, with two large bags of pills on top of insulin injections taken every day. That is not how I want to end up nor would wish that existence on anyone. I also have an autistic son who will one day be bigger and likely stronger than me and I will somehow have to manage that if something happens to my DH and I become a single mum.

chickenninja · 08/02/2022 17:23

Thank you @latetothefisting for the excellent definition

freesolo · 08/02/2022 17:14

For some people it is luck. I'm 44 and a size 8-10, I try to exercise 3 times a week but I often end up only going once, I probably average 2 a week. I don't watch watch what I eat at all, In fact I'm really greedy and do worry about my overall health as I should eat healthier.

latetothefisting · 08/02/2022 17:11

@bindud

I don’t think a 10 is thin, I think it’s healthy size

Depends on height surely

Not really, you'd have to be extremely tall (like well over 6 foot) for a size ten to be underweight, or very very short (significantly under 5 foot) for it to be overweight.

@chickenninja - A stealth boast and a humble brag are similar but not the same. The key difference is the "stealth" part of the stealth boast - so it can't be directly about the topic being discussed. Here OPs weight is directly relevant to the question she's raising so it can't be a stealth boast. If she had chucked in that this conversation with her friend took place in [x expensive restaurant], or that she has an active [and very well paying job] that would be a stealth boast. Think of the people who post pictures captioned "new nails," but the photo is of the nails carefully positioned holding a designed brand/on the steering wheel of their new Audi, for example.

Whereas the relevant part of the humble brag is the "humble" so the brag/boast can be very obvious as long as the poster pretends it is nothing to do with her own actions and just a lucky coincidence - so same post as this but instead of clarifying how much effort she goes into to maintain her weight she would have said "I feel sorry for [friend]I can eat anything I want and still stay the same size, guess I'm just lucky" (tinkly laugh....)

deeplyrooted · 08/02/2022 17:06

I get the passive aggressive comments at every family meal. I never judge what anyone orders, I don’t care a jot what weight you are, I just want to eat in peace.

If I order a salad that’s wrong - I eat like a rabbit. If I order a dessert - that’s wrong too.

It’s like you’ve betrayed the sisterhood if you’re not trying to lose a few pounds.

Snuggleworm · 08/02/2022 16:58

@mmgirish

Is this a humble brag or stealth boast?
I was wondering this too.
Nomorefuckstogive · 08/02/2022 16:55

I get you, OP. YANBU. Most people have to work at staying slim and everyone has to work at being fit. I feel it’s more a choice than anything else. You prioritise being fit and slim, some other people don’t. It’s very rare to do as you like and stay slim and fit.

user94747295 · 08/02/2022 16:49

I actually agree with you. I was so strict with my diet and excersize before I had kids and people thought I was naturally slim. I used to get it all the time about how lucky I was. I'm chubby now though Grin

LondonReturner · 08/02/2022 16:48

But some people don't watch what they eat and stay slim. Between the ages of about 21 and 40 I could eat whatever I wanted and not put on a pound - just like a teenage boy. Just had a ridiculously fast metabolism. Almost overnight at 40, that changed. Now if I eat more and move less than usual I can feel the weight go on.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/02/2022 16:41

If you look at an actually representative sample, you will get a mixture of people who say

  1. I'm naturally small/struggle to keep weight on/couldn't possibly eat that much/sit down
  2. I keep an eye on it but it's pretty easy
  3. It's constant vigilance and discipline
  4. I'm [enter size consistent with being in the lower half of healthy BMI] but I'm a bit of a porker/let myself go/can't control myself like very slim people do.
  5. EDs suck. It's only 'easy' because the ED makes the alternative too terrifying to contemplate.
Swipe left for the next trending thread