Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to get bit annoyed that people assume I just “don’t put on weight”

141 replies

mumof2exhausted · 08/02/2022 15:18

I’m a size 10 at the moment - been 10/12 most of my life apart from when I drank too much/ate kebabs at uni and when I was pregnant. This is not because of magic genes it’s because I consistently exercise and I watch what I eat.

I have a friend who is always on a fad diet and is over weight by a few stone (she is always moaning about her weight). She says all the time to me “oh you’re alright you never have to watch your weight”. I do though!! I went on an all inclusive holiday a few months ago and I did barely any exercise and ate and drank everything in sight and I put on a stone in 2 weeks!! It’s gone now as I’m back to eating normally and exercising.

AIBU to say some overweight people genuinely seem to think slimmer people are just lucky and it’s nothing to do with the fact we move more and eat less. When my friend says it to me I just say hmmmm as I don’t want an argument with her and I know she’s unhappy with her size so it’s pointless to point out that i average 20,000 steps, I have an active job, I go to gym 4 times a week and I roughly eat 1800 calories a day

OP posts:
HunterHearstHelmsley · 08/02/2022 21:23

@phoenixrosehere

Fact is you are thinner than she is and it seems to be an issue for you. Why?

Are we reading the same posts? The issue is the constant commenting from friend that OP is thinner and the assumption that it is easy for OP to be that way.

Many people regardless of weight do get annoyed with unwarranted comments about their body.

OP has said herself she doesn’t make comments to her friend because it’s none of her business so why is it her friend’s business about hers or to comment on it?

It's like I said upthread. It's OK for someone to make repeated comments to slimmer people, but if something is said back they are the ones in wrong/with issues/bragging
NeedAHoliday2021 · 08/02/2022 21:20

I get this about running… “you’re so lucky you can run” “I wish I enjoyed running line you”

I don’t “enjoy” running, I hate it slightly less than the other options and if I didn’t run to balance out my love of food, I’d be massive. I’d much rather sit on the sofa watching Netflix while eating Ben and Jerrys. And no I don’t get any chemical boost after a run… I just feel tired and achy but glad I ran as I don’t have to feel guilty about the cake I consumed earlier in the day. Oh and 4 years ago I couldn’t/didn’t run but I saw others around me and set myself a goal of doing 10 park runs. If I still hated it by number 10 I’d stop. By number 10 I didn’t hate it, had made friends and had more confidence about not being terrible at it. I’m not fast but I do it. To some people, that makes me lucky as they think I naturally run rather than it being something I forced myself into mid 30s in an attempt not to be a lazy lump (my natural inclination is to this).

worriedatthemoment · 08/02/2022 21:13

Its a bit like how people assume all overweight people eat chips and kebabs all day and just watch tv when there are many many factors not involving that

maddening · 08/02/2022 21:10

Slim people often assume overweight people are stupid, lazy and greedy, more frequently, more openly and often laced with much more vehemence and judgement.

5128gap · 08/02/2022 21:06

No. I get the opposite. People forever telling me they wouldn't want to 'starve themselves' and life's too short and they wouldn't want to be too thin anyway. Which is excellent, because they don't envy me, and I don't envy them, and we get on with our own lives.

Goldenbear · 08/02/2022 21:00

Again, people just don't think this as they know for most it is not true. The only time I hear anyone going on about this is from a very thin, small acquaintance but there is no doubt she has issues, does the classic baking of loads of Brownies, bread, never eats any of it herself but is regularly telling anyone who will listen that she is so thin now and she is worried about eat. My friend who is is also very thin suggested she gorge on chocolate if she wants to put on weight but she said that she couldn't do that. It's a false sense of pride and think that's equally as strange as going on about how lucky someone is to be thin.

Furbulousnous · 08/02/2022 20:49

Don’t get annoyed - just say - ‘actually I have to keep on top of it and watch what I eat’.
For some People it’s not as easy as stick to 1800 calories and walk a lot but if that’s what works for you then that’s what works for you.

FatFilledTrottyPuss · 08/02/2022 20:38

YANBU. My best friend and I have been friends for 30 years and we were both always the skinny ones and had years of people commenting on how lucky we were, always in a snidey way too. It really pissed her off because she barely eats enough to keep a sparrow going, whereas I was one of the lucky naturally skinny people who ate crap. Now we’ve hit our 40s she still barely eats a thing and exercises loads and is still thin I’m still lazy and eat crap but I’ve got fat now. Nobody ever comments on my weight now but she still gets it all the time. People think she’s oh so lucky but she’s actually really bloody disciplined.

lljkk · 08/02/2022 20:36

It's annoying when people make repeated confident statements about your life that are removed from reality & don't want to hear any contradictions.

My dad does this sometimes. Not about my weight but about other stuff. He just assumes he knows how things are in my life when he knows nothing.

HeyItsPickleRick · 08/02/2022 20:21

Why are some of you telling the OP she is not slim? Surely she knows. An old colleague was an Olympian but no longer competing and just very very slim. Definitely bony, any skinnier and you'd think she had an issue. She was about 5'11 and wore a size 12. I'm pretty chunky at size 10-12 as I'm 5'5 but small boned. I don't think you can really tell just based on someone's dress size.

TibetanTerrah · 08/02/2022 20:15

If anyone has ever watched Supersize vs Super Skinny they will agree, whilst it's at the extreme end of the scale, there's a huge discrepancy in the sheer quantity and types of food fat vs slim people eat. Similarly with Secret Eaters, without fail every person at the start says 'all my slim friends eat way more than me and I just can't understand why I hardly eat anything and I'm overweight'. Even the woman with PCOS lost weight on that show when she was shown the camera footage, which showed her eating far more than she admitted to in her food diary.

It's very easy to be in denial about weight, and the causes, but it's unfair to put the blame on 'slim people' for being 'lucky' and avoid personal responsiblity.

QueenCoconut · 08/02/2022 20:10

I remember the staff room conversations too. All my colleagues discussing their various dieting attempts on a daily basis, comparing their home made salads and counting calories, complaining about the unsuccessful attempts to lose weight. It was constant and everyone had to listen to it because it was the daily conversation to have , the majority trying to lose weight and encouraging each other . I was a size 6 back then and I can’t even imagine joining in to share my eating habits or compare my meals and exercise routine. I would’ve instantly been accused of bragging or being insensitive because I was ‘the skinny one’.

Double standards but it’s true that slim people can’t just state a simple fact that they eat reasonably and exercise , it’s not acceptable or seen as someone joining in a friendly conversation or even just sharing their experience with weight management. You need to be seen as unhappy with your body and never quite ‘there’ with your weight otherwise you’re just bragging.

AndTime · 08/02/2022 19:37

Mumsnet is so weird when a slim person posts anything weight related. It's like if you are slim you should just be grateful and never comment.

OP, I get it. I am slim but find it massively difficult to be so. At my smallest I was exercising for 3 hours a day and eating very little. I would have been annoyed with any "it's just luck" comments.

mumof2exhausted · 08/02/2022 19:08

@phoenixrosehere

Fact is you are thinner than she is and it seems to be an issue for you. Why?

Are we reading the same posts? The issue is the constant commenting from friend that OP is thinner and the assumption that it is easy for OP to be that way.

Many people regardless of weight do get annoyed with unwarranted comments about their body.

OP has said herself she doesn’t make comments to her friend because it’s none of her business so why is it her friend’s business about hers or to comment on it?

Thank you. This is it exactly. I’d rather never talk about weight at all. I don’t feel the need to comment on her weight but it’s fine to comment on mine as I’m only slim because of “good genes “ apparently!
OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 08/02/2022 18:57

Fact is you are thinner than she is and it seems to be an issue for you. Why?

Are we reading the same posts? The issue is the constant commenting from friend that OP is thinner and the assumption that it is easy for OP to be that way.

Many people regardless of weight do get annoyed with unwarranted comments about their body.

OP has said herself she doesn’t make comments to her friend because it’s none of her business so why is it her friend’s business about hers or to comment on it?

TheCurrywurstPrion · 08/02/2022 18:57

She probably doesn’t think it’s just luck, or not in the way you think. I recently had almost the opposite conversation with a colleague, who said she was trying to “do a bit more” which included an extra hour’s hike in the morning with her dog, and various other things. My reaction was to say, “Well that’ll be why you’re so much slimmer than me then,” (said without rancour - simple statement of fact).

That said, I do envy slim people, not because I think it’s effortless, but because they find the willpower to do all that stuff, whereas even though I want to in theory, I never have. I do think that for some people, eating is an addiction and a very difficult one to control. I admire my colleague’s effort and don’t grudge her her thinness, I just don’t know how to get myself there: theoretically yes, practically no. And that’s very hard to explain to someone who does manage it and makes it look effortless, even if it’s not.

That said, I hope your friend stops moaning about being overweight and telling you you’re lucky. Just the moaning would be deeply irritating, even without the lucky jibes.

mumof2exhausted · 08/02/2022 18:41

@pictish

It’s funny this should crop up. We had this very discussion in the (busy) staff room at work yesterday. A (nice) colleague was saying she couldn’t seem to lose weight no matter what she did, then looked over at me and said I was lucky. Another colleague (who is very slim and also a right cowbag) piped up, “When do you ever see Pictish eating crap? She’s slim because she watches what she eats and exercises. So do I. It’s not by magic!” Stunned silence. Nice colleague was scarlet. So awkward. It’s true but there was no need to say it like that. Some people are naturally slender and slight in build, others are slim because they’re not particularly interested in food. I am slim because as a dyed in the wool greedy bastard, I make eating a well balanced diet a priority. I’d soon put on weight if I didn’t. I stay fit by regular exercise (running) which contributes to maintaining my weight as well. I AM fortunate to be mobile and able. Not going to lie…I don’t eat whatever I want while I do get up at silly o’clock to run before work. It’s a conscious choice and effort. No one else is obliged to do the same but it’s the only way I’ve found to remain fit and slim that works.

Stunned silence all round.

Wow your colleague was harsh! That’s kind of my point I have never said anything like that (obviously would be much kinder to my friend) but maybe by not mentioning that I do actually watch what I eat and am very active I maintain my weight she is under the impression it’s all just luck?

I’ve be friends with her for 30 years and know about health issues and there are none. She does eat a lot (which she is very aware of ) and she does no exercise and works from home. Often her steps per day are less than 5000.

BUT I am not annoyed about her weight. It’s none of my business. It’s just frustrating that she goes on ALL THE TIME about the fact I’m so lucky. Literally every time a morsel of food goes into my mouth I hear her sigh and say “oh you’re so lucky”…

OP posts:
pictish · 08/02/2022 18:26

It’s funny this should crop up. We had this very discussion in the (busy) staff room at work yesterday. A (nice) colleague was saying she couldn’t seem to lose weight no matter what she did, then looked over at me and said I was lucky. Another colleague (who is very slim and also a right cowbag) piped up, “When do you ever see Pictish eating crap? She’s slim because she watches what she eats and exercises. So do I. It’s not by magic!”
Stunned silence. Nice colleague was scarlet. So awkward. It’s true but there was no need to say it like that.
Some people are naturally slender and slight in build, others are slim because they’re not particularly interested in food. I am slim because as a dyed in the wool greedy bastard, I make eating a well balanced diet a priority. I’d soon put on weight if I didn’t.
I stay fit by regular exercise (running) which contributes to maintaining my weight as well. I AM fortunate to be mobile and able.
Not going to lie…I don’t eat whatever I want while I do get up at silly o’clock to run before work. It’s a conscious choice and effort. No one else is obliged to do the same but it’s the only way I’ve found to remain fit and slim that works.

Stunned silence all round.

Dappled · 08/02/2022 18:23

I appreciate that you work hard for your health and your body; but I don't think you're making allowances for the fact that some people seem (genetically?) prone to putting on weight very very easily and some people simply don't.
Some people seem to have to work much harder to keep weight off and it must be very easy to feel demotivated by the constant struggle. Other people have to make little to no effort - it just doesn't strike me as a level playing field and hence not very fair to make comparisons or generalisations.
I've been a size 8 all my adult life (barring two pregnancies). I eat large portions, I love food and have a big appetite. Sometimes I eat pretty healthily, sometimes less so. But I always have pudding. And cake. And biscuits. I never think twice about what, or how much, I eat.
Sometimes there are periods of time when I exercise regularly. Sometimes there are long periods of time when I do nothing. It makes no difference to how I look. The weight fell off me post pregnancy, I didn't do anything to make it happen - I certainly didn't have to "work" for it.
I half-expected to start putting on weight in middle age, to start having to watch what I eat, as everyone says you do. I'm 49 now and that doesn't seem to be happening. I remain the same clothes size (and almost the same shape, although without quite such a small waist and with slightly bigger hips) as I was in my twenties.
I'm just saying this to point out that I can take absolutely no credit for this. There is nothing virtuous that I've done to "achieve" it. It's just me. Maybe lucky genetics (and I can enjoy it now, but I spent my teens and early twenties hating being skinny and trying to eat more and weight train to - unsuccessfully - put weight on)

Whiskyinajar · 08/02/2022 18:22

What a strange post. What's the point of it? You know nothing of your friend's medical history. She could have any number of conditions which make weightloss harder. PCOS for example (as I did) or thyroid issues.

Likewise a history of dieting may well have lead her to disordered eating.

Who knows!

Fact is you are thinner than she is and it seems to be an issue for you. Why?

Your list comes across as strange and a tad smug.

Goldenbear · 08/02/2022 18:22

But people don't think that, I don't know anyone that thinks people have to not make any effort to be slim. If anything, all I hear are remarks that border on the risky about very slim peope like they must have an eating disorder or exercise loads and are pretty vain but don't care about exercising the brain! Maybe she says that in front of you to make you feel good about yourself because everybody would love to be 'naturally thin' rather than having to work at it, it is a bit insulting to say you have to work very hard indeed to look good and deny yourself food and pleasure and must be typical fairly vacuous as the way you look is all consuming!

optimistic40 · 08/02/2022 18:18

@FourTeaFallOut

The thing about being very disciplined and thin is that you really don't get enough kudos for it - is that about it, op? Sounds tough.
That's not it though is it? Say you worked hard all day cleaning your house and then someone commented how 'naturally tidy and clean' it is... I'd tell 'em I'd spent the day cleaning!
Royalbloo · 08/02/2022 18:14

I don't think this is bragging at all - it's just the truth!

bindud · 08/02/2022 18:12

ate

bindud · 08/02/2022 18:12

I was naturally skinny though & are rubbish. My dad is similar

Swipe left for the next trending thread