Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to get bit annoyed that people assume I just “don’t put on weight”

141 replies

mumof2exhausted · 08/02/2022 15:18

I’m a size 10 at the moment - been 10/12 most of my life apart from when I drank too much/ate kebabs at uni and when I was pregnant. This is not because of magic genes it’s because I consistently exercise and I watch what I eat.

I have a friend who is always on a fad diet and is over weight by a few stone (she is always moaning about her weight). She says all the time to me “oh you’re alright you never have to watch your weight”. I do though!! I went on an all inclusive holiday a few months ago and I did barely any exercise and ate and drank everything in sight and I put on a stone in 2 weeks!! It’s gone now as I’m back to eating normally and exercising.

AIBU to say some overweight people genuinely seem to think slimmer people are just lucky and it’s nothing to do with the fact we move more and eat less. When my friend says it to me I just say hmmmm as I don’t want an argument with her and I know she’s unhappy with her size so it’s pointless to point out that i average 20,000 steps, I have an active job, I go to gym 4 times a week and I roughly eat 1800 calories a day

OP posts:
GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 09/02/2022 09:58

I occasionally get "how do you stay so slim?!" I answer honestly - I eat low-carb and work out a lot - and their faces fall.

I suspect the thinking is that if I'm naturally slim then "it's not their fault" that they're not, they're just not as "lucky" as I am. If I'm slim because I work at it, well, then, so could they be. It takes away an excuse.

Not saying this how I think mind. I've been overweight, I know how hard it can be to lose the weight, and I don't judge people on how they look or what they weigh. But I do understand there's something comforting in thinking "she's just lucky she's so skinny!"

FabriqueBelgique · 09/02/2022 09:49

I think a lot of people genuinely can’t wrap their heads round it or don’t want to!

I literally went through my plan with someone and they said they couldn’t do all that. Then proceeded to say “lucky bitch!” as my weight fell off. So frustrating!!

phoenixrosehere · 09/02/2022 09:45

*ate

phoenixrosehere · 09/02/2022 09:44

Yes poor you, it must be terrible for you.

It is for most people when others make unsolicited comments on what they eat and their body regardless of size. I doubt you would enjoy it if someone commented on your body and food every time you are something or had food in your hand. It gets annoying really fast.

Purplewithred · 09/02/2022 09:05

It is bloody annoying to be told you are ‘lucky’ to achieve something when it’s actually involved a bit of work. Same as if you were told you were ‘lucky’ to pass an exam or ‘lucky’ never to have had any speeding points. And the implication that the other person was just ‘unlucky’ to fail that exam or ‘unlucky’ to have got caught by a speed camera.

That said, I do think people who do this are in the minority (hard stare at occasional co-worker who told me I was lucky to be able to burn off my food after I’d politely refused her offers of cake, biscuits and sweets).

rookiemere · 09/02/2022 08:58

The last time I was naturally thin was when I was 5 before we went on holiday to
America. Apparently the family history goes that I discovered McDonalds and came back fat.

So I've never really had a normal relationship with food. I found it hard the other day when I went out for lunch with my two thin friends, they both had cake for dessert- I couldn't because I was full. But then my friend said she'd have nothing for dinner, so that made sense.

Please do tell your friend about the calorie counting, exercise and ongoing vigilance. It may give her hope that a change is achievable. But also tell her not to
Comment on what you eat, as that's just rude.

Porcupineintherough · 09/02/2022 08:04

Yes poor you, it must be terrible for you.

Goldenbear · 09/02/2022 08:02

I don't really understand how anyone would come to the conclusion that an absence of food (small appetite) and a cigarette smoking habit does not help someone remain small. I was like this in my early 20s and guess what was very light indeed. I mean it's not rocket science. Who are all these people that would genuinely say, 'she hardly eats and smokes instead of snacking but it's a really quandary as to why she is so slim, she's lucky she is she can eat what she wants'Confused. Like I said, I just find the opposite is true so people say she's thinking because she has a small appetite and smokes- hardly rocket science or she is thin because she eats relatively normally and walks at 20000 steps a day in her active job! That's loads and when I have made time for that as I have a desk job the weight drops off me even if I'm eating shut cards like pizza. The problem is I don't have an active job and need to make that time to walk for 1.5hrs. Also, the lack of self discipline. I'm unsure why so many people are perplexed by this though.

user94747295 · 09/02/2022 07:49

They literally just said this on GMB. Did anyone else hear it ? "I think your one of the lucky ones Richard who can eat what they want and don't put weight on"
He said no I'm not I have to watch what I eat because my dad died of a heart attack and I'm worried about that

CaptainThe95thRifles · 08/02/2022 23:59

Whilst it's pretty dumb to presume someone who is slim has no issues with food / weight / lifestyle to maintain their weight, the "we move more and eat less" rhetoric is equally ignorant and unkind. There are so many factors influencing weight, fitness and an individual's capacity to exercise - if you're capable of doing 20k steps a day and controlling your weight on 1800kcal, you are fairly lucky in terms of health at least. I routinely do double that - because I'm bloody lucky to have a job / lifestyle that facilitates it, and I'm currently healthy enough to do it. It means I can eat what I like, mostly. It would be cruel of me to use my privilege to make friends with physical and mental health issues and office jobs feel bad about their weight.

Skinnymimi · 08/02/2022 23:47

@latetothefisting thank you!!

OfstedOffred · 08/02/2022 23:41

It isnt all discipline though. It just isn't.

I have a friend who is very careful with diet and exercises as much as you, she's definitely not a size 10.

I by contrast, eat more and exercise less than her but am a fair bit slimmer.

I don't know why that is but you must acknowledge that some people are more prone to certain body shapes/sizes

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/02/2022 23:39

Why do you care?

Grandville · 08/02/2022 23:37

YANBU - from a bona fide ex fat lass. I used to be nearly 20st. Got down to 9st and have gained a few back during Covid but working on getting it off again.

When I was very big, I used to look at slim colleagues eating salad for lunch and wonder why when they were already small so could have had a nicer lunch. Hmm

I knew all about calories and exercise but just didn't really apply it to myself. I didn't have a clue about what a healthy weight actually was even though I knew I was bigger than I should be. Even now, when in a bad eating rut I can deliberately ignore nutrition labels on food as if that makes the calories not matter. And I am very well informed about food now compared to before.

Denial about eating and weight can be very powerful. My weight will be a battle for the rest of my life and it took me years to accept that.

pictish · 08/02/2022 22:10

I have come to love running but I’ve been at it for four years or so now. I live in close proximity to a lovely hill range and beautiful country estate and always trail run off road or in the hills. Fantastic scenery. It feeds my head and keeps me trim. Having had a couple of (inevitable) running related injuries which have forced me to lay off the runs for a few weeks, I feel pent up and frustrated when I can’t go.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/02/2022 21:59

I used to get this, OP, when I was a size 8-10 - friends used to say, ‘You’re just lucky, you can eat whatever you like’.

Actually I wasn’t working at it - I just had a very small appetite and wasn’t fond of a lot of sweet things. So no virtue on my part. But friends who were prone to putting weight on still liked to think I was stuffing cream cakes and biscuits all day and not putting an ounce on. It didn’t matter how often I told them I just didn’t eat much - they chose not to believe it.

One so-called friend even spread a rumour that I was anorexic - apparently because I declined biscuits at her house. Probably horrible custard creams, and in any case at the time I preferred a cig with my coffee. It was months before I found out what she’d been saying.

I’m a lot older now, and no longer an 8-10!

mumof2exhausted · 08/02/2022 21:55

@NeedAHoliday2021

I get this about running… “you’re so lucky you can run” “I wish I enjoyed running line you”

I don’t “enjoy” running, I hate it slightly less than the other options and if I didn’t run to balance out my love of food, I’d be massive. I’d much rather sit on the sofa watching Netflix while eating Ben and Jerrys. And no I don’t get any chemical boost after a run… I just feel tired and achy but glad I ran as I don’t have to feel guilty about the cake I consumed earlier in the day. Oh and 4 years ago I couldn’t/didn’t run but I saw others around me and set myself a goal of doing 10 park runs. If I still hated it by number 10 I’d stop. By number 10 I didn’t hate it, had made friends and had more confidence about not being terrible at it. I’m not fast but I do it. To some people, that makes me lucky as they think I naturally run rather than it being something I forced myself into mid 30s in an attempt not to be a lazy lump (my natural inclination is to this).

Ha ha I’ve had this as I joined a running club and recently did a 10k race. Hated every bloody second of it. Had a few friends say “oh I wish I could just go for a run like you…” I wanted to see if I could do it and thought it’d be good for my waistline! It was but I’m done with it. At the beginning I literally couldn’t run for 1 minute but I stuck with it.
OP posts:
mumof2exhausted · 08/02/2022 21:52

@cherrybonbons

I don't get the brag. OP is saying she's a size 10. Which is a healthy size. She's not saying she's a tiny size 6 and only lives on Mac Donald's is she. She says she watches her calorie intake, goes to the gym a lot to maintain this. Why is that a brag? Good sense tbh. I'm the same OP- I had to up my gym and swap beer for gin and slimline 😆 and say no to puddings 😭
Ha ha yep! Have to admit when I was younger and before I had kids I probably didn’t have to be as vigilant but feel like after 3 kids and turning 40 I need to keep on it. Not just for the aesthetics but because I want to be fit and healthy.

Also to the runner. I bloody hate running too but I do it - in a club now so enjoy the social side but still hate the actual running!!

OP posts:
mumof2exhausted · 08/02/2022 21:50

@phoenixrosehere

Thank you. This is it exactly. I’d rather never talk about weight at all. I don’t feel the need to comment on her weight but it’s fine to comment on mine as I’m only slim because of “good genes “ apparently!

I’ve only discussed one person’s weight and that was my best friend out of concern. Her and I are both slim and we both have endured the constant talk about our size for years. It got to the point for her that she struggled to eat in front of people at times.

At that time, she wasn’t slim anymore, she was almost skeletal. Her cheeks were sunken in, I could see her bones through her chest. I couldn’t not say something and asked her if she was ok. She said that she hadn’t believed anyone about how small she had gotten because she was used to such comments so ignored them. We had known each other for about 15 years (friends for 13) and I had never once asked, commented or talked about her weight or anything close to it until then so for me to do so was pretty serious. She was under a lot of stress and was having health issues. They lessened dramatically and she gained her weight back once she divorced her ex DH and got away from her toxic mil.

This is awful. I hope your friend is ok now. I am a very healthy size 10, never been skinnier (haven’t the energy or will power or desire to be) so she’s not talking to me about it out of concern.
OP posts:
Luredbyapomegranate · 08/02/2022 21:46

You are coming across as a bit of a humble bragger OP, but you aren’t wrong - I do think some long term overweight people don’t realise that a lot of slim people work to stay that way.

HOWEVER a lot of overweight people have a emotional reliance on food (which is how they got fat), which means that just watching what you eat is a lot harder, in that you live three quarters of your life wanting to Hoover up the fridge as a stress management aid. It’s an arse.

phoenixrosehere · 08/02/2022 21:36

Thank you. This is it exactly. I’d rather never talk about weight at all. I don’t feel the need to comment on her weight but it’s fine to comment on mine as I’m only slim because of “good genes “ apparently!

I’ve only discussed one person’s weight and that was my best friend out of concern. Her and I are both slim and we both have endured the constant talk about our size for years. It got to the point for her that she struggled to eat in front of people at times.

At that time, she wasn’t slim anymore, she was almost skeletal. Her cheeks were sunken in, I could see her bones through her chest. I couldn’t not say something and asked her if she was ok. She said that she hadn’t believed anyone about how small she had gotten because she was used to such comments so ignored them. We had known each other for about 15 years (friends for 13) and I had never once asked, commented or talked about her weight or anything close to it until then so for me to do so was pretty serious. She was under a lot of stress and was having health issues. They lessened dramatically and she gained her weight back once she divorced her ex DH and got away from her toxic mil.

cherrybonbons · 08/02/2022 21:36

I don't get the brag.
OP is saying she's a size 10. Which is a healthy size. She's not saying she's a tiny size 6 and only lives on Mac Donald's is she.
She says she watches her calorie intake, goes to the gym a lot to maintain this.
Why is that a brag?
Good sense tbh.
I'm the same OP- I had to up my gym and swap beer for gin and slimline 😆 and say no to puddings 😭

BareGrylls · 08/02/2022 21:30

I'm not skinny but I am happy with my weight. I could easily eat a lot more but I don't. I eat any kind of food I want, don't count calories or avoid anything.
I think it's possible to make a choice about being happy with the size you are and stick with it.
I like food too much to survive on 1800 calories.

BurbageBrook · 08/02/2022 21:26

Why on earth do you care OP? I’m also slim & get similar comments from people. In fact like you it does take effort to stay slim, as I bloody love food. But it doesn’t bother me at all, I just smile & nod along. It sounds so petty to care.

cultkid · 08/02/2022 21:23

Yanbu

I always get told this or things along the lines of

"Oh you're so tiny you can have what you like"

No I'm tiny because I don't eat lots of food. I eat everything but in smaller portions. I do control my weight by controlling what I eat.

I'm pregnant atm and I know I've got a job on my hands once the baby is here to bring my weight down again to a place where I feel comfortable

Swipe left for the next trending thread