Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother and sister-in-law don't make any effort to see us

162 replies

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 07:37

My brother and his wife live 1 hour 45 mins away yet they only see us around 2 or 3 times a year. In contrast her family live in France and they go to visit them in France every half term holiday (or her family come to visit them) - so every 6 weeks or so they see them. When we do see them we have a wonderful time and they tell other people they had a great time so I know it's not us! We're chilled out normal, sociable people. I think it's just a case of them prioritising where they want to spend their time and there are only 4 weekends a month so they see their friends and her family a lot and we are just way down the list - because she just prefers to see her mum which I do understand.

I was very ill in 2019 with cancer but made a recovery. I finished all my treatment in Nov 2019 and thought Xmas they would want to spend with me but they jetted off to France. I regularly suggest meeting up and our kids all get on great. This christmas they were due to see us in Nov to celebrate as they were spending Xmas in france - they cancelled as they were ill which is fine but they made no effort to suggest a new date. I reached out after xmas and suggested we meet up as I'd like to give my niece her xmas presents and to see them to make up for xmas. They replied saying yes that would be great and would let me know dates but they haven't. I always have to set up the meetups. I understand she wants to see her family lots and that's fine but I feel like they don't bother with us - they just squeeze us in when they can. To be honest if I didn't have kids I'd not bother at all trying to meet up as I don't see the point of a half hearted relationship with immediate family who don't really care. I feel sorry for my son though!! I became a single parent in 2012 and I remember they didn't make any effort with me and I felt very lonely and isolated. I've now been in a long term relationship for 8 years so I don't 'need' them now but I feel desperately let down and sad about the situation and honestly feel like not bothering at all any more. His wife never makes any contact with me at all between visits. I have tried really really hard but am fed up now... I'd be very interested to know how often people see their brothers and sisters please? And in my situation would you consider just not bothering at all with the relationship? They never see me on my birthday or my kids birthdays or invite us to there's for birthdays or new years etc. They also don't make much effort with my parents and other family so it's not just us. I have spoken to them and asked them to see them more so it's not a case of me 'talking to them about it'.

OP posts:
SartresSoul · 08/02/2022 08:40

If they lived around the corner then fair enough but a 4 hour round trip with children in tow is not ideal at all. It’s probably easier to get to France in all honesty, especially if they live fairly close to the airport Grin. I also don’t think you can compare a trip to France to visiting Aunt in a British town/city really. I think this set up sounds pretty normal, I don’t see my family often because they live 40 mins away never mind almost 2 hours.

unidentia · 08/02/2022 08:37

The trips to France will also be important to your SIL to make sure the kids grow up with frequent exposure to French language and culture.

Seema002 · 08/02/2022 08:37

It sounds as though your brother is not bothered , or doesn't want to see his family any more than twice a year. You have different ideas to this.

I can see why you're upset particularly when SILs side of the family are seeing them so much more. It does feel unfair in a way, particularly for your parents. But as others have said I think that's because the SILs family have different ideas and priorities. Good on SIL for not becoming chief organiser for your brother. It's his issue to sort.

You can either accept it and see them twice a year and enjoy it for what it is, or you can invite them for something in between your normal meet up dates. Maybe meet up half way and go somewhere.

Deliaskis · 08/02/2022 08:37

Thing is, I think it's actually not that unusual for a couple/ family to see a lot more of the woman's family and less of the man's (where there is no huge geographical disparity), simply because, sadly, arranging to see family often falls under 'wifework' and mental load etc. and a lot of men are happy to let their wife stand whatever they like as long as they don't have to put much effort in. I know NAMALT etc but I think it's one of the reasons why what you describe is quite typical.

We have Sunday roast with my family most weeks, and they come see my daughter in her riding competitions, and collect her one day a week from school. We rarely socialise with his family because he doesn't arrange it. That's his choice but it's certainly not my job.

I know I will probably get jumped on here for generalising about men and women, and as I say there are of course plenty of exceptions, but what you describe isn't unusual.

I'm sorry though, I know what you mean about your son spending time with his cousins etc. That's sad and I would wish for that too. Although.... for many their cousins are almost strangers anyway, I only ever saw mine at weddings etc. Families are all different, we have to accept what we have and learn to be happy with it, and find social outlets elsewhere I guess.

Maray1967 · 08/02/2022 08:34

If I left it up to DH to sort out seeing his brother I doubt it would be more than once a year. No issues - he’s just not good at organising anything.
My own DB - very different. He is proactive sorting out things with us and DF.
In both cases we live about 90 mins drive away. We see DBIL more as they come to in laws when we go - so probably 6-8 times a year. My DB we probably see about 4 times a year.

SheWolfOFFrancee · 08/02/2022 08:34

Op although it’s hard to hear from all your posts it’s just sounds like for whatever reason your brother just isn’t that interested or bothered about making the effort to see his family.

Yes they’re willing to travel to see your SIL family and that could be because they just get on better with them or because your brother is lazy and just goes along with whatever she plans who knows BUT he’s showing you he’s not bothered about maintaining a close relationship with him.

I know you said your illness was from being lonely and needing close meaningful relationships but this clearly isn’t going to be one of those even if you force more contact. You should concentrate on the people on your life (however many that is) that make YOU and maintaining a relationship with you a priority. Those are the people who you want to build those meaningful relationships with. Accepting he’s just not that bothered and letting the “relationship” go will be the best thing you can do

MintJulia · 08/02/2022 08:33

I love my four siblings, but I see most of them once a year, maybe twice.

They have full time jobs and busy lives. Their weekends are spent with friends, children or GPs. Their annual leave is precious. As is mine. I think you have a fairly normal relationship.

I'm here if they need me, if something is wrong. I'll fetch, carry, take care of DCs in an emergency (illness. accident etc) as they would for me. But I don't need to SEE them.

We have a fairly healthy on-line relationship. I very seldom message my BIL/SIL. It isn't the same.

ChippyChipsTh0 · 08/02/2022 08:32

@justkeeponmoving

I'm angry at my brother more than my sister in law but I just mentioned my sister in law more because my brother does message me occasionally. I mention how much she sees her family simply to demonstrate that they do like to see family, just not our side
I'd imagine it's actually more just a case of she arranges to see her family a lot whereas your brother, who should be the one arranging to see his family, doesn't bother.
WhatNoRaisins · 08/02/2022 08:31

Ultimately you need a healthy way to cope with your loneliness and I don't think focusing on how often your brother's family goes to France is helpful here. Focus on the good relationships you do have and don't expect your brother to meet your needs. I'm sorry if I sound harsh but I don't think there is much you can do with this

notanothertakeaway · 08/02/2022 08:29

I make the effort to keep in touch with my own family, and we see them fairly regularly

My DH makes very little effort to keep in touch with his family. When they meet up, they get on well and he does enjoy their company, but they all seem content with limited contact

It's a shame that you and your DB have different expectations / hopes, but I think you have to accept that, for whatever reason, he is content withh quite limited contact. You can't really impose your wishes on him, so better to accept and appreciate and enjoy the relationship as it is, rather than trying to change it

Thirkettle · 08/02/2022 08:24

They probably don't want to see you because you insist on 'the woman' arranging all the visits.

Yes, your brother doesn't want to visit you. That's called adulthood. People grow apart and don't visit. His wife had no reason to want to visit you. You're not her family. I don't faff about visiting the random strangers that are my husband's siblings either, why would I? Don't know any of them.

Live your life and stop fussing about getting involved in everyone else's.

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 08/02/2022 08:23

What do you do about it?
You speak to your own brother
You tell him that you feel let down and lonely and you'd like to see him more.

I really like my BIL and SIL and their family and I enjoy their company but it still doesn't mean I am going to have time to arrange meet ups with them when it's my husband's responsibility
I do put a lot of effort into seeing my own family because I see that as my responsibility

SparklingLime · 08/02/2022 08:23

The only thing you can do - for your own benefit - is to drop all expectations of them. That your brother didn’t bother with you when you were newly alone with a baby says it all. Flowers

BoredOfCbeebies · 08/02/2022 08:23

I think you're getting a hard time on here, I'd be very sad in your situation too. It sounds like your brother is just not that bothered, that your expectations are not the same as his. Not sure what you can do really, other than go with the flow.

SheWolfOFFrancee · 08/02/2022 08:22

@justkeeponmoving
“ Yes agreed - it is up to my brother to sort it but he's not bothered - so where do i go from there? Just carry on seeing them twice / three times a year and accept it as it is? ”

Sadly yes you can’t force people to see you. You can talk to him and explain why you feel you need to see him more but at the end of the day if he’s not bothered and not putting the effort in you cant do much. Even if you did make him see you more it wouldn’t be a meaningful relationship if he just isn’t bothered.

Also the point about how they don’t take the kids to see your parents again sorry that’s on your brother. His parents his arrangements to make. If he wanted to take them to see them he would he clearly just doesn’t want to make effort

ManicPixie · 08/02/2022 08:22

3 times a year sounds pretty normal to me. YABU.

roastingmichael · 08/02/2022 08:21

I don't want to be harsh here but maybe they don't see you as often because they don't want to. Maybe for them 2-3 times a year is enough.
Maybe he loves you as you're his sister but actually doesn't have a lot in common with you so doesn't feel the need to see you all the time.

I think we all need to get away from this idea of expectations and duty. Do we really want to maintain family relationships based on what is expected because it's family?

It might be that your brother is a lazy shit and your SIL is sick of organising his life as well as her own so she's left him to it.
It might be that the level of contact they have currently works for them.

What are you going to do, force or guilt trip them into being a bigger part of your life?

FusionChefGeoff · 08/02/2022 08:21

I bet this is a case of her not wanting to take on the wife work of making the arrangements for his family so she doesn't. And neither does he.

This sits squarely with your brother.

astroboy45 · 08/02/2022 08:21

**They travel to see her parents extremely often but they dont take their kids to see my parents - so their kids see one set of grandparents who live abroad a lot more than my parents who live in the same country but thats a separate issue.

Yep it sounds as if your brother is definitely the issue here. As someone said before, SIL is prioritising seeing HER own family. If they see her parents who live overseas, more often then they see your parents who lives in the same country, it’s clear that your brother isn’t bothered enough regarding seeing his own family. It’s not up to her to arrange visits when your brother is more than capable to do so.

I stopped reaching out to DPs side and now they hardly ever care enough to come and see DD. DP just doesn’t care enough to arrange anything🤷‍♀️ As you said, db and sil also live nearly two hours away. That’s quite a long distance to me so 2/3 times a year sounds good enough to me

Collaborate · 08/02/2022 08:20

I don’t get the negative responses to this thread.

You have made all the effort and he’s just not that interested in meeting up. If I were you I’d take a step back. Wait until they either suggest you visit them or they visit you.

My sister was like this. In 15 years we got invited to hers twice - once when she knew we were spending Christmas elsewhere anyway. She’d hardly ever ring me - once every two years as opposed to me calling her maybe twice a year, but then complain to my mum that we weren’t close as I never rang her.

She stopped speaking to me a few years ago so I no longer have this problem but I think you should try to detach yourself so that it doesn’t upset you. Get closer to your parents.

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 08:20

@DSGR

OP I hear you and am in the same situation. I don’t think it sounds like you’re blaming SIL, you’re just illustrating that they do make the effort with family, just not you. I’m in the same boat with a sibling and I find it very sad, I’ve got fed up of making the effort now and just accept we see each other 1-2 times a year. It’s sad as we’re missing out on each other’s children. But you can’t make people want to see you - you have to focus on your own life and your friends/parents
Oh wow! someone who gets it! Thank you and I'm sorry you are in the same boat - it's just sad! I grew up with my cousins and I feel sad for my son.

Just to re-iterate one more time I do not blame my sil - it is my brothers responsibility - If they didnt see any family or friends at all and just prefered being on their own all the time that would be easier to understand - if the didnt like socialising or seeing people! but thats not the case and i just wanted to illustrate the efforts they go to to see family. When they lived in france they never came over to see us and we just accepted that it was a lot for them to travel - now they live here though they happily hop accross every six weeks so they can travel when they want to that is all i meant - not blaming SIL

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 08/02/2022 08:19

“Yes that is exactly it - part of my illness was due to loneliness and poor relationships / lack of meaningful relationships so I need to have people in my life who I actually see regularly!“

If you’re brother isn’t bothered about this, then you could see him every weekend and it still wouldn’t be a meaningful relationship.

My closest sibling is my most distant and we see each other 2x a year. But our relationship is very meaningful.

SpiderVersed · 08/02/2022 08:19

I see my brother probably 3 times a year with similar distance. I think you are pushing for a closer relationship than he’s interested in.

Lobelia123 · 08/02/2022 08:19

You may find its also the lure of France, which is a lovely place to visit, Id be there every second weekend if I had close family there :) Just relax, people have different ideas of how close they feel family relationships should be. She sounds perfectly pleasant and nice....you maybe need to build a circle of friends closer to home and who share in your current life stage...fellow moms, work colleagues and couples who are friends with you and your partner.

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 08/02/2022 08:16

Your whole post was 'SIL doesn't....she doesn't' even if you now admit it's your own brother at fault

I arrange meet ups with my own family
It's up to DH to arrange stuff with his. Often he doesn't so we see them less. This is in no way my fault. The most I am willing to do to facilitate is to prompt a bit 'you haven't seen your dad lately. Are you going to arrange something?' That's all I will do

We both work FT, we have kids together. He is certainly no busier than I am. Why would I facilitate his family meet ups and birthdays when it's all I can do to keep track of mine?