Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother and sister-in-law don't make any effort to see us

162 replies

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 07:37

My brother and his wife live 1 hour 45 mins away yet they only see us around 2 or 3 times a year. In contrast her family live in France and they go to visit them in France every half term holiday (or her family come to visit them) - so every 6 weeks or so they see them. When we do see them we have a wonderful time and they tell other people they had a great time so I know it's not us! We're chilled out normal, sociable people. I think it's just a case of them prioritising where they want to spend their time and there are only 4 weekends a month so they see their friends and her family a lot and we are just way down the list - because she just prefers to see her mum which I do understand.

I was very ill in 2019 with cancer but made a recovery. I finished all my treatment in Nov 2019 and thought Xmas they would want to spend with me but they jetted off to France. I regularly suggest meeting up and our kids all get on great. This christmas they were due to see us in Nov to celebrate as they were spending Xmas in france - they cancelled as they were ill which is fine but they made no effort to suggest a new date. I reached out after xmas and suggested we meet up as I'd like to give my niece her xmas presents and to see them to make up for xmas. They replied saying yes that would be great and would let me know dates but they haven't. I always have to set up the meetups. I understand she wants to see her family lots and that's fine but I feel like they don't bother with us - they just squeeze us in when they can. To be honest if I didn't have kids I'd not bother at all trying to meet up as I don't see the point of a half hearted relationship with immediate family who don't really care. I feel sorry for my son though!! I became a single parent in 2012 and I remember they didn't make any effort with me and I felt very lonely and isolated. I've now been in a long term relationship for 8 years so I don't 'need' them now but I feel desperately let down and sad about the situation and honestly feel like not bothering at all any more. His wife never makes any contact with me at all between visits. I have tried really really hard but am fed up now... I'd be very interested to know how often people see their brothers and sisters please? And in my situation would you consider just not bothering at all with the relationship? They never see me on my birthday or my kids birthdays or invite us to there's for birthdays or new years etc. They also don't make much effort with my parents and other family so it's not just us. I have spoken to them and asked them to see them more so it's not a case of me 'talking to them about it'.

OP posts:
UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 08/02/2022 09:16

I wonder whether her parents provide the family with a lot of support and are just very easy, undemanding and/ or helpful in a way your brother and sister in law are comfortable with.

Perhaps they find your family harder work. Its not your fault you've been seriously ill and struggled as a single parent but does explain why if they also feel they've needed support themselves they've gravitated towards her parents instead.

Holly60 · 08/02/2022 09:15

I see my DB and DSIL regularly and always have. We are good friends. Could you try organising things directly with your brother rather than your sister in law?

I would just carry on making the effort to be honest. Travel to them, find things they are interested in to suggest to do, invite them to birthdays etc.

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 09:14

@SheWolfOFFrancee

Op although it’s hard to hear from all your posts it’s just sounds like for whatever reason your brother just isn’t that interested or bothered about making the effort to see his family.

Yes they’re willing to travel to see your SIL family and that could be because they just get on better with them or because your brother is lazy and just goes along with whatever she plans who knows BUT he’s showing you he’s not bothered about maintaining a close relationship with him.

I know you said your illness was from being lonely and needing close meaningful relationships but this clearly isn’t going to be one of those even if you force more contact. You should concentrate on the people on your life (however many that is) that make YOU and maintaining a relationship with you a priority. Those are the people who you want to build those meaningful relationships with. Accepting he’s just not that bothered and letting the “relationship” go will be the best thing you can do

Thank you for your response - you are absolutely correct in everything you have said - thank you.
OP posts:
justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 09:12

@Thirkettle

They probably don't want to see you because you insist on 'the woman' arranging all the visits.

Yes, your brother doesn't want to visit you. That's called adulthood. People grow apart and don't visit. His wife had no reason to want to visit you. You're not her family. I don't faff about visiting the random strangers that are my husband's siblings either, why would I? Don't know any of them.

Live your life and stop fussing about getting involved in everyone else's.

That is really harsh - I never said it was for the woman to arrange the visits!! it is for my brother to arrange not her!!

I'm not fussing and getting involved in their lives I just miss seeing them but never mind

OP posts:
MaudieandMe · 08/02/2022 09:11

We all have different expectations but yours don't match your brothers. I think you need to accept that rather than get all childish about reducing contact on your side.

From my perspective, 2 or 3 times a year is quite a lot when they don't live nearby.

I haven't seen my brother in person for about 12 years and my other brother and sister for 5 years but we chat on the phone and FaceTime inbetween calls. I live abroad from them and don't have spare cash to hop on a plane and visit on a regular basis. I still love them just as much though.

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 09:10

@BoredOfCbeebies

I think you're getting a hard time on here, I'd be very sad in your situation too. It sounds like your brother is just not that bothered, that your expectations are not the same as his. Not sure what you can do really, other than go with the flow.
Thank you - yes I felt that I was getting a hard time on here too! I think perhaps I didn't word / explain the SIL properly and some people assumed i was blaming her which I wasn't! - But It does seem that I am being unreasonable with the amount of time we spend together so I will accept that it is only 2 or 3 times a year and take a step back! Its a shame as we all have a lovely time together and my sister in law did once comment that she would like the kids to spend more time together! Maybe its just that they dont have enough time to do everything they want to do so they prioritise and we are low on the list. They are always bust seeing people
OP posts:
Mambles · 08/02/2022 09:10

I see my sisters and grandparents weekly or ever few weeks, my mother lives abroad and we have no relationship, so I haven't seen her since 2019. I've never made plans with my husband's brother and leave the arrangements for his family up to him, as he leaves mine up to me.
I think this is normal, your SIL isn't responsible for arranging your brother seeing his own family.

phoenixrosehere · 08/02/2022 09:10

I dont feel that 3 hours of an afternoon in the childs first 6 months is much at all

And said baby wouldn’t have known you were there if you had been there as long as her family.

You keep saying you don’t blame your SIL but almost every post you keep mentioning how much time her family gets. It is not a competition nor is it her fault that her and her family have a relationship where they are able to make plans together with dates and such and stick to them.

Maybe your brother is lazy, maybe he simply prefers her family more and/or has more in common. Whatever the reason, you are going to have to accept it for what it is and concentrate on building relationships with people who do or talk to your brother and tell him how you feel that you would like to see him more and set a date and time then and there and if it falls through than you know that it is a lost cause and you should move on.

Wilkolampshade · 08/02/2022 09:09

Oh dear, am I your sister in law OP? Wink 2-3 times at a distance of 2 hrs is totally normal OP. On the hot side of normal in my experience. I might see ours once a year? I think this is because when we do, it's all smiley and fine but we're not alike and as adults have very little in common. If we weren't related we wouldn't be natural friends IYSWIM, and we're all so time poor now why would anyone give up valuable time to people they have nothing really in common with? Could that be it?
I can hear this upsets you though and it's sad that the future you envisioned for your children and yourself as part of a much more involved family group hasn't come to pass. I think maybe try and think of your friends as the wider, extended family you'll be part of? The good thing about friends is you get to choose them.

billy1966 · 08/02/2022 09:06

OP,

You sound reasonable but as you accept this is on your brother completely.

He isn't pushed about his family and she is.

Make an effort with your parents and friends, detach from them as much as you can, and see them a couple of times a year.

I also think 2-3 times a year is not unreasonable.

I love my in laws very much and though they are 1-2 hours away, we only see them that often too.

We are very busy with our lives, as are they.

Focus on building up your life too.Flowers

DottyHarmer · 08/02/2022 09:05

@Cocomarine - I think there is a men/women divide, at least in British culture. I know that my gf never saw his family again after he’d married my (fierce) granny. It just wasn’t worth the aggro. My granny had never met them - she just didn’t want the bother of other people in her (or his) life. Similarly mil didn’t stop fil from seeing his family, but it was always inconvenient so he drifted away from them. Dsis refused to ever see bil’s family (and one of the reasons he gave for leaving her).

Henlie · 08/02/2022 09:04

Can I ask @justkeeponmoving when you do meet up with your DB and SiL, do you go to their house, stay the night or come home, or meet somewhere else? And likewise what do they do when they come to you?

Pre Covid, it was a given that DHs sister and her family would come and stay with us every summer for four days or so. They live 4 hours from us. They could never reciprocate as they don’t have the room for us, so if ever we went up to see them we’d need to stay in a hotel/rent somewhere which we used to do a lot when DH’s mother was alive. Since she passed away not so much, as it gets very expensive.

I always found it hard work entertaining them all (they have two teenage sons). The amount of work involved pre, during and post their stay would often take the shine off the visit. We’ve not had them stay here for getting on for two years now, mainly due to Covid, but also I just needed a break from hosting. I’m guessing they might be feeling a bit miffed about it all. I say all this as just wondering if there’s the same ‘hosting issues/expectations’ at play in your scenario? Plus sometimes it can be the children that others find hard work….especially if there’s different parenting styles at play. We have this with some friends children (not so much family) and I just can’t have them in my house anymore as they destroy everything and the parents have little control.

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 09:01

@astroboy45

**They travel to see her parents extremely often but they dont take their kids to see my parents - so their kids see one set of grandparents who live abroad a lot more than my parents who live in the same country but thats a separate issue.

Yep it sounds as if your brother is definitely the issue here. As someone said before, SIL is prioritising seeing HER own family. If they see her parents who live overseas, more often then they see your parents who lives in the same country, it’s clear that your brother isn’t bothered enough regarding seeing his own family. It’s not up to her to arrange visits when your brother is more than capable to do so.

I stopped reaching out to DPs side and now they hardly ever care enough to come and see DD. DP just doesn’t care enough to arrange anything🤷‍♀️ As you said, db and sil also live nearly two hours away. That’s quite a long distance to me so 2/3 times a year sounds good enough to me

Thank you for your kind and sensible post! I agree with what you have said - you summarised it perfectly. I will just accept the 2 / 3 times a year (well that is when i make the effort). I will take a step back though. thank you
OP posts:
PollyPerkins87 · 08/02/2022 09:00

Sounds like there is a bit of animosity or jealousy with the SIL.

We live more than 4 hours from DH's family. I never contact SIL really as we're not close particularly and to be honest we don't really have much in common.

It sounds like you view the relationship very differently to them.

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 08:59

@Collaborate

I don’t get the negative responses to this thread.

You have made all the effort and he’s just not that interested in meeting up. If I were you I’d take a step back. Wait until they either suggest you visit them or they visit you.

My sister was like this. In 15 years we got invited to hers twice - once when she knew we were spending Christmas elsewhere anyway. She’d hardly ever ring me - once every two years as opposed to me calling her maybe twice a year, but then complain to my mum that we weren’t close as I never rang her.

She stopped speaking to me a few years ago so I no longer have this problem but I think you should try to detach yourself so that it doesn’t upset you. Get closer to your parents.

Ah thank you so much for your kind post! I will take a step back and wait for them to suggest meeting up. It is sad and you are right - I will try to detach myself so it doesn't upset me.
OP posts:
DisforDarkChocolate · 08/02/2022 08:58

I think your SIL organises contact with her family and your brother his. It may seem imbalanced but if this is what your brother is happy with its not going to change.

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 08:57

And before anyone says that when you have a new born you dont want loads of people around i understand that but even at 2 or 3 or 4 months old I dont feel that 3 hours of an afternoon in the childs first 6 months is much at all -but I will lower expectations and the expectations of my kids - I'll encourage them to focus on close friendships rather than family I think

OP posts:
justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 08:55

@Lobelia123

You may find its also the lure of France, which is a lovely place to visit, Id be there every second weekend if I had close family there :) Just relax, people have different ideas of how close they feel family relationships should be. She sounds perfectly pleasant and nice....you maybe need to build a circle of friends closer to home and who share in your current life stage...fellow moms, work colleagues and couples who are friends with you and your partner.
It's not just that they prefer france - they often cant see us in the holidays as they have her parents for the week. I feel sad that I dont get to see my neices and nephews and feel sad for my kids not seeing their cousins and aunts and uncles. When their children were born we were invited for half a day when the kids were around 3 months old. Her family stayed over for 2 weeks - i felt very sad that i only got half a day and a 2 minute cuddle with the new born! I dont care about it being 'even' - of course my sil will want her mum there with her lots when shes a new mum - thats totally normal but I felt really sad that I had so little time with the baby :-( I think Im allowed to feel sad about that
OP posts:
justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 08:52

@FloraPotts

If your sil lives in UK and her family is in France then I think it's perfectly normal for her to prioritise going back there during the holidays, for herself, and for her DC to maintain relationship with GPS, and sorry if this sounds harsh but that sounds perfectly normal to me.

And speaking as someone who lives abroad and visits UK in the holidays, it is really quite stressful trying to fit everyone in. We have stopped going to one location for Christmas and another for NY as it gets quite exhausting, and also it's hard sometimes when DC want to do something different to what you have planned, and school term times differ between countries etc.

I am sorry you feel that your brother wasn't there for you when you had cancer but tbh, I don't understand why you are blaming your sil for this.

I think as a sister, however close you were to your brother growing up, you have to make an adjustment and step back once your brother marries and has his own family. It's hard sometimes but I think that is just the way of things Flowers

I am not saying that your bil and sil shouldn't be making more of an effort with your family, because they should, but that is up to your brother to sort out!

Absolutely agree with stepping back when people have their own families and leave them to live their own lives and do their own things but I still think its important to make some effort to see each other
OP posts:
Aprilx · 08/02/2022 08:49

@justkeeponmoving

I'm angry at my brother more than my sister in law but I just mentioned my sister in law more because my brother does message me occasionally. I mention how much she sees her family simply to demonstrate that they do like to see family, just not our side
And he is your brother, so it is down to him. My sister was married for thirty years and my BIL was consequently part of my life since I was 16 years old, a huge part of my life, but I could count on one hand the number of times we messaged each other. I contact my sister, not him.

And I would repeat what someone else has said. It isn’t that “they” like to see the other side of the family. She is proactive about seeing her family and he goes with her.

You are starting to sound a bit precious.

Totalwasteofpaper · 08/02/2022 08:49

@justkeeponmoving

so it seems the consensus is 2 or 3 times a year is acceptable for siblings - what about parents - how often is reasonable?
Oh this is sad Flowers There is a misalignment here. All you can do is invite them to join any day trips halfway between you both, keep suggesting meet ups and /or tell your DB you'd love to see them more.

2-3 times would be weird for me and my brother if he lived in the UK. I see him this often and he lives in the Middle East!!
But thinking about my husband and his brother (who lived about 4 hours apart) 3 times a year is about the norm. They whats app and chat in-between mostly about football though.
And BIL also calls to verbally download his problems every 4-6 weeks (this involves no two way dialogue it is just a stream of emotional unloading Confused 🤣 )

Again, my mum is 10 mins away we see her 2-3 times a week sometimes for 15 mins sometimes 3 hours or so. My mil comes 4-6 times a year but is an emotionally demanding vortex lives 4 hours away Blush

Cocomarine · 08/02/2022 08:48

@DottyHarmer “Like it or not, it is usually women who set the social/family agenda, and if they prioritise their family and friends it is difficult to go against that, and that is why husbands often become distant from their own family - for a quiet life.“

I think this is utter bullshit!
Not the part about women (more often) setting their social agenda. But suggesting the poor menz can’t go against it, and accept it for a quiet life? 🤣
Don’t be ridiculous! The menz are not out their wishing they could see more of their sisters and too downtrodden to speak up! They simply don’t want to.

phoenixrosehere · 08/02/2022 08:48

I know it hurts OP but you have to acknowledge that you can’t make your brother do anything he doesn’t want to and as PO have said it is on him to reach out more because he is your brother. If he’s not reaching out to other members of the family again that is on him and shows you where his priorities are. Your SIL wants to see her family and has made the effort to do so and your brother looks to be happy with just going along with it for an easy life. Did he come and see you and your parents before he met SIL?

I talk or see my sister if she is usually with a parent but if not it would be years.

We are 6/7 years apart and have very little common other than growing up with the same parents in the same house hold. We barely look like family and if we weren’t we would be strangers and likely never met. She was the younger sister and one of my biggest aggressors growing up because not only did she know she could get away with it due to my mother treating me the same way but would do it in front of people making others uncomfortable since I hadn’t done or said anything to get her reactions. Even when I tried to bury the hatchet, and went out of my way, I rarely received a thank you or even has even gone as far as accusing me of stealing something of hers when it was mine and our mother wanted one for her and I showed her where I bought it all in the span of just seeing me next to it, no hi either. We’re cordial but I wouldn’t go out of my way to contact her and she would never contact me unless both our parents died. I’m okay with that and she doesn’t bring anything to my life or my children.

I see my parents every few years but we talk once a week, sometimes two.

My parents were emotionally and mentally abusive and are still a toxic environment (though they have gotten better) so the only way we are able to stay in contact and for my own emotional and mental health is living far away and having small doses of them. If it wasn’t for me having children it would have probably be talking to dad once a week and mother if he pressed me to.

DottyHarmer · 08/02/2022 08:43

People have been very mean to the OP. Like it or not, it is usually women who set the social/family agenda, and if they prioritise their family and friends it is difficult to go against that, and that is why husbands often become distant from their own family - for a quiet life.

We live 15 minutes from bil but see them rarely. Haven’t seen sil for about three years. I went to their house for a legal matter about five years ago and she told me to come to the “tradesman’s entrance” and I was left standing up for half an hour - no coffee or pleasantries. They see sil’s family all the time, for high days and holidays, and she has a big social group. Bil sees Dh on his own sometimes. It has made Dh sad over the years, especially when he sees their extended family holidays and birthday celebrations on FB, but he has come to terms with it. There has never been a row or anything, it’s just sil prefers her family.

When I come to think of it, my family growing up were the same - never saw some relatives of my parents - not because we didn’t like them, but we were too occupied with the other side.

DaisyMum40 · 08/02/2022 08:43

@Thirkettle

They probably don't want to see you because you insist on 'the woman' arranging all the visits.

Yes, your brother doesn't want to visit you. That's called adulthood. People grow apart and don't visit. His wife had no reason to want to visit you. You're not her family. I don't faff about visiting the random strangers that are my husband's siblings either, why would I? Don't know any of them.

Live your life and stop fussing about getting involved in everyone else's.

Sorry I think this is really mean, I don't count my in laws as random strangers and I don't think most people do either. The OP has clearly needed family support through health problems and frankly, it's a bit shit that her brother and his wife have made zero effort but can frequently visit family abroad. My SIL isn't my favourite person in the world, but if she was a single parent going through cancer treatment I'd make a lot more effort and I'd be pretty angry with my husband if he didn't bother his backside. My husband prioritised me and my family when my parents have had health problems and I've prioritised his family when the in laws have had health problems. Isn't that what normal families, who get along, do for each other?

I appreciate you can't force people to spend time with you, they either want to or not. But for a man and his wife to pretty much ignore his sister with health problems while doing everything for her family tells me that they're both as ignorant as each other.

The OP clearly cares for her brother and his family, doesn't want to lose touch and have the kids enjoy a relationship. That's not a bad thing and it's a shame to see her get so much negativity for it.