Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother and sister-in-law don't make any effort to see us

162 replies

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 07:37

My brother and his wife live 1 hour 45 mins away yet they only see us around 2 or 3 times a year. In contrast her family live in France and they go to visit them in France every half term holiday (or her family come to visit them) - so every 6 weeks or so they see them. When we do see them we have a wonderful time and they tell other people they had a great time so I know it's not us! We're chilled out normal, sociable people. I think it's just a case of them prioritising where they want to spend their time and there are only 4 weekends a month so they see their friends and her family a lot and we are just way down the list - because she just prefers to see her mum which I do understand.

I was very ill in 2019 with cancer but made a recovery. I finished all my treatment in Nov 2019 and thought Xmas they would want to spend with me but they jetted off to France. I regularly suggest meeting up and our kids all get on great. This christmas they were due to see us in Nov to celebrate as they were spending Xmas in france - they cancelled as they were ill which is fine but they made no effort to suggest a new date. I reached out after xmas and suggested we meet up as I'd like to give my niece her xmas presents and to see them to make up for xmas. They replied saying yes that would be great and would let me know dates but they haven't. I always have to set up the meetups. I understand she wants to see her family lots and that's fine but I feel like they don't bother with us - they just squeeze us in when they can. To be honest if I didn't have kids I'd not bother at all trying to meet up as I don't see the point of a half hearted relationship with immediate family who don't really care. I feel sorry for my son though!! I became a single parent in 2012 and I remember they didn't make any effort with me and I felt very lonely and isolated. I've now been in a long term relationship for 8 years so I don't 'need' them now but I feel desperately let down and sad about the situation and honestly feel like not bothering at all any more. His wife never makes any contact with me at all between visits. I have tried really really hard but am fed up now... I'd be very interested to know how often people see their brothers and sisters please? And in my situation would you consider just not bothering at all with the relationship? They never see me on my birthday or my kids birthdays or invite us to there's for birthdays or new years etc. They also don't make much effort with my parents and other family so it's not just us. I have spoken to them and asked them to see them more so it's not a case of me 'talking to them about it'.

OP posts:
SeasonFinale · 08/02/2022 12:33

Why are you also involving yourself with how frequently they see your parents. That is a separate issue and between your parents and them. Perhaps one reason they don't see you is because you attempt to pressure them into doing that. Just a thought.

Rossnagoose · 08/02/2022 12:31

And I know you keep saying that you don't 'badger' your brother and SIL, but even on the basis of the things you've said on here, about telling your kids that's 'just how it is' and 'to enjoy the ten hours or whatever a year' and your brother and his family 'jetting off to France' sound very bitter, reproachful and passive-aggressive. I wonder if the reproachfulness comes through in your communications with your brother, and makes them feel 'nagged', especially if it's literally always you chasing them for more contact than they appear to want.

ittakes2 · 08/02/2022 12:31

I have a relationship with my s'n'l like this and she lives 15mins away. Perfectly nice woman, has been great for my b'n'law - but life is all about her family. We went to their wedding overseas and our children were two of about six children....the other four children being from her side of the family and these four children all had important roles in the wedding party. My two children had zilch. There was a last minute attempt to include them I think instigated by my husband and they were asked to announce the cutting of the cake.
When we meet my s'n'law I compliment her, ask her about her life. She doesn't even ask about my children ie her niece and nephew. It makes her sound mean but she's not - she is just very wrapped up in her own extended family.

Rossnagoose · 08/02/2022 12:26

I think @incognitoforthisone and @11GrumpsaGrumping's posts are good.

It's certainly understandable that your SIL makes a big effort to immerse her children in the French part of their heritage.

And in my own brother's case, he is both lazy about visiting my parents, and he also enjoys his wife's family far more. To be blunt, they are a big, united, terribly straightforward clan, all of whom live on the family farm, where DB's wife also has a small house where they spend a lot of time. To me, they're nice enough but very limited, but I think DB, who is a melancholic type, finds this soothing, certainly more soothing than our more complex family dynamics.

That's on him. I don't think his wife's job is forwarding communications with our family. If he felt strongly, he would behave differently, and that's fine.

I do think you are taking this weirdly personally, though especially the remarks about it feeling 'false' to only see one another twice a year, and that it's like an absent parent whom it's more damaging for a child to see at long intervals than not at all! It sounds as if you have a specific model for how you want the relationship to be, which is fair enough but your brother doesn't agree...

PicaK · 08/02/2022 12:15

Are you a planner? I mean how much notice do you give that you want to see them. Do you suggest dates. Have you asked if they are free on x date to celebrate your birthday?

Cocomarine · 08/02/2022 12:10

Yes, I think I'll just do this - although it just seems so false to me just meeting up twice a year. We see them and my kids then talk about them and ask after them for weeks/ months and then just as they get used to not seeing them we see them again - it's not the same I know but it's a bit like an absent parent not committing to their child - more damaging to see them occasionally than not at all (i know its not the same thing at all really!) but thats the only way i can describe it - anyway I'll just tell my kids thats just how it is and to enjoy the 10 hours a year or whatever it is they get with them! Thanks everyone!

You clearly do see it that way. You can’t say “it’s like this” then “I know it’s not”. That’s how you feel. And frankly, it’s ridiculous!

If it seems false, it’s because you don’t have much of a relationship with your brother, full stop. If you did, you could see him once every two years and still enjoy those visits, and not make silly digs about “10 hours”.

11GrumpsaGrumping · 08/02/2022 12:07

It is a bit frustrating to me reading your op, as I can well imagine my SIL writing the same thing about me, DH, and DS.

In my opinion, my family relationships are up to me to nurture, and DH's family relationships up to him. He puts in significantly less effort than I do, and so even though my family are farther away, we see and speak to them more.

Also, I am making some assumptions here, but is it possible that your brother simply enjoys his wife's family more? I know that DH does, in our circumstance- his family are from a small ish town which his sister never really left, their children don't behave and so doing things with them is exhausting and frustrating, and the impetus is always on us to travel to see them- which is tiring.

So we do see them 2-3 times a year, we do enjoy it when we do, but that's enough for us!

incognitoforthisone · 08/02/2022 12:07

Yes, I think I'll just do this - although it just seems so false to me just meeting up twice a year. We see them and my kids then talk about them and ask after them for weeks/ months and then just as they get used to not seeing them we see them again - it's not the same I know but it's a bit like an absent parent not committing to their child - more damaging to see them occasionally than not at all (i know its not the same thing at all really!) but thats the only way i can describe it - anyway I'll just tell my kids thats just how it is and to enjoy the 10 hours a year or whatever it is they get with them! Thanks everyone!

Appreciate that this is how you feel, but ... to me, this seems like a weird reaction. Your children should be more than capable of having some people in their lives that they see less frequently than others and they shouldn't be pining for them; I think you're probably projecting a lot on to your kids here.

I think you just have a very specific notion of what a sibling relationship should be, and can't accept that other people, including your own sibling, don't feel they need to adhere to those rules. Two or three times a year seems perfectly normal for family who live a couple of hours away.

If your SIL's family are French, then I can absolutely see why she wants to make sure she and her children see them a lot. If she's a French person living in England then regular visits back to France and spending time with French-speaking family is the only way she can really immerse her kids in the French half of their culture.

I love my siblings very much and we get on well when see each other. But we see each other about three times a year, I'd say. And that's fine. And don't have exchanges of messages with my SIL and BIL either; I wouldn't really expect them to message me just to say hi and if we were making arrangements about something, it would just usually be my siblings who would get in touch rather than their partners because they're closest to me.

I appreciate you feel differently about this, and you can't help the way you feel, but your brother's done nothing wrong.

Horst · 08/02/2022 11:43

Honestly most people are busy. She plans visits with her family because that involves cross country travelling.

It sounds like your brother just isn’t fussed and well men do seem to suck at organising family time tbh I’d say 2/3 times a year is pretty normal. Infact if I counted how many times dh actually organised a visit to his side it would be zero we attend because an invite has been issued.

My own brother I see him if he happens to be at my mums when I pop in. Could go a year or two without seeing him.

Rockbird · 08/02/2022 11:39

Mine don't either and they live about 4 roads away. My brother and I used to be close but I see him about 3 times a year now.

Arabellla · 08/02/2022 11:37

@justkeeponmoving

I meant to ask - in my situation would you consider just not bothering at all and let the relationship just die off?!
Yes, absolutely fine to stop running around after them.

Let them arrange or suggest the next catch-up.

Qwill · 08/02/2022 11:36

Maybe try thinking about it another way? You know those good friends you have that you don’t see for a while, but when you do it’s as if nothing has changed? Certainly nothing ‘false’ about it. People have different expectations and personally I would be happy that when you meet up you all have a good time. Maybe that’s enough for them. As you said, they are busy people and they make time to see you three times a year - I think that’s pretty good going! It seems you all like each other which is the main thing.

ExtraOnion · 08/02/2022 11:25

I see my sister in law more than my brother … we keep in touch, he just happens to be there.
On my husbands side, I see his sister more than he does, we often go out for meals, and he gives lifts

arcticgoose · 08/02/2022 11:14

Is your children close in age with their children? I do get you and as a dil/sil myself I try to be equal with both sides of the family and so does my DH. My cousins live abroad and growing up, we used to see each other once every year or two. Sometimes it's not the quantity but the quality of the relationship that sticks with the children and I have a very close relationship with my cousins still now. When your children and their children become adults, you might find that they will go to France less and stick with their own friends and cousins here in the UK and the parents would travel less and less overtime. I think I would continue seeing them 2-3 times a year and not expect anything else and let the kids have a awesome time when they do see each other.

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 11:14

@Lunificent

You don’t get the priority because he’s male and probably leaves family organisation to his wife. If that’s the case, she’ll prioritise her family in France regardless of how much fun she has with you. I wouldn’t be bothered. Stop making the effort to reach out as it’s causing you stress. See them when they reach out to you.
Yes, I think I'll just do this - although it just seems so false to me just meeting up twice a year. We see them and my kids then talk about them and ask after them for weeks/ months and then just as they get used to not seeing them we see them again - it's not the same I know but it's a bit like an absent parent not committing to their child - more damaging to see them occasionally than not at all (i know its not the same thing at all really!) but thats the only way i can describe it - anyway I'll just tell my kids thats just how it is and to enjoy the 10 hours a year or whatever it is they get with them! Thanks everyone!
OP posts:
ThoseFestiveLights · 08/02/2022 11:05

I am in a similar position with my sibling. It’s taken me a long time to realise that the truth is, they like their in laws more! And that’s okay. We’ll always love each other but they prefer to spend time with other people. We are probably harder work than we realise! That’s okay. Just keep bumping along and be open, loving and kind and all will be okay.

Lunificent · 08/02/2022 11:01

You don’t get the priority because he’s male and probably leaves family organisation to his wife. If that’s the case, she’ll prioritise her family in France regardless of how much fun she has with you.
I wouldn’t be bothered. Stop making the effort to reach out as it’s causing you stress. See them when they reach out to you.

ethelredonagoodday · 08/02/2022 11:00

I think OP you could do worse than just be honest with your brother. Something on lines of obviously I've got a big birthday coming up and would love you all to be part of it. Can we see each other more often? Would love the kids, and us, to spend more time together.

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 10:57

It's my 40th birthday this year and they probably wont make the effort to come and I think that's why it's all been playing on my mind recently ... :-( never mind!

OP posts:
Dogmum40 · 08/02/2022 10:54

I never see my brother and sis in law! They live 20 mins away and he completely cut his entire family off when he got with her! He posts cards to my parents for their bdays, Xmas, mothers and Father’s Day! I got one delivered to their address for my big birthday last year but never have any communication with him other than that! My parents, myself and our extended family never see him! He’s a complete twat! I can’t believe we used to be so close and hang around together in our 20s! He’s in my SM and so is she and they see her family most days!

DottyHarmer · 08/02/2022 10:47

I totally get it but there is nothing you can do. We all prefer one side of the family over another. Not every family does turn and turn about for Christmas and birthdays etc, they just see the side they are closest to and feel more comfortable with.

It is not always the fault of the bil. Dh’s db sees us or dh by himself, but sil and their dcs never come or meet up. So he does make an effort, but sil absents herself. As I said in pp, there is no animosity, she is just not interested.

ethelredonagoodday · 08/02/2022 10:47

First of all, I've not read the full thread, so apologies if I've missed something.

I get on well with both my brother and SIL but I would always contact my DB to organise stuff. My SIL is extremely close to her sibling and her mum, they probably spend time together every single day. I don't get it, I'd find that claustrophobic, but absolutely accept that's how she likes to be.

I have literally no relationship with my ILs on my DH's side, other than sorting presents for the kids etc. no animosity, but we just have nothing in common at all. We are actually closer to one of DHs cousins, who we see fairly regularly.

Families are strange things. There's no right or wrong way, but if you're hurt by this situation I'd suggest you have a chat with your brother.

adoreyou · 08/02/2022 10:46

Do you have anything to lose by saying anything to DB?
Just say you would like to see them more. I think when you have family near by it's easy to take them for granted as you can see them more but you then don't prioritised. You have nothing to lose by saying something....

I'm guessing they are teachers by your comment about all holidays off.
Do they really spend every school holiday inc full 6 week summer holidays in France?

justkeeponmoving · 08/02/2022 10:37

@adoreyou

Are the kids similar ages?

Instead of arranging days for them to come to you or waiting for them to let you know dates, look for something that they or kids might like to do and send it to them to arrange a day out or something?

We've had a similar issue with by brothers sister.... basically telling us we aren't interested in her and her kids etc... but from our side, we work full time and weekends are usually pretty busy! DD has hobbies and clubs, birthday parties etc
She was expecting us to visit at least once a month which isn't possible and personally don't want to be beholden to that. We have other family and friends to also see.
It's nothing personal. It's just life with small kids!

I think they are busy people (as are we) and although their jobs mean they get all the holidays off work they both just choose to spend 95% of that time with her family. That's their choice and I respect that they enjoy doing that. They are happy to see us twice a year and I'll just leave it as is and not dwell on it. I'll encourage my kids to focus on their friends rather than family - its a shame but that is just how it is!
OP posts:
adoreyou · 08/02/2022 10:31

Are the kids similar ages?

Instead of arranging days for them to come to you or waiting for them to let you know dates, look for something that they or kids might like to do and send it to them to arrange a day out or something?

We've had a similar issue with by brothers sister.... basically telling us we aren't interested in her and her kids etc... but from our side, we work full time and weekends are usually pretty busy! DD has hobbies and clubs, birthday parties etc
She was expecting us to visit at least once a month which isn't possible and personally don't want to be beholden to that. We have other family and friends to also see.
It's nothing personal. It's just life with small kids!