Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be cranky about the £150 council tax rebate

238 replies

Notcontent · 07/02/2022 23:44

I have been thinking a lot about this. I understand that the government was looking for a way to implement help with energy costs in the easiest way possible and that doing it through council tax bands seemed sensible as for the most part it does target the right people. But only for the most part. For example, in London there are lots of people who live in high value properties that are actually far from luxurious and who will miss out. For example, my elderly neighbour will miss out even though he deserves the help. He doesn’t have a lot of money - bought his house decades ago when the area was very cheap and lives very frugally. I know councils will get some extra money to distribute but that will be for only a small number of people.

These kinds of injustices really get to me, as I think when it comes to public money everyone should get equal treatment.

OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 08/02/2022 09:28

Are you actually sure he’s band E OP. It will have little to with his current house value.

He does have choices though. He could sell what is almost certainly a house that is too large for him.

BoredZelda · 08/02/2022 09:26

There are lots of people like him in my area. He would not apply to the council as he is just not that sort of person - proud of being self sufficient.

We can’t design a system of benefits around people “too proud” to seek out the help they need.

OnaBegonia · 08/02/2022 09:21

Why live frugally when you have a house with a great amount of equity? Sell up, downsize and live in comfort.
Plenty people need your sympathy OP but not this man.
Also, as previously stated many older people live 'frugally' when in fact they're financially very comfortable.
My DPs GF looks and lives like a pauper, mithers over 10p but has £10,000s in bank, he's 94, live well I say.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/02/2022 09:20

..it’s the furlough/bounce back loans that is all wrong...lot of dodgy people/scammers were literally given tens of thousands and treasury has written it off

This is very true. It’s all very galling when you worked throughout the pandemic whilst trying to home school a child with undiagnosed ADHD (everything stopped due to pandemic!), now a pay freeze for public sector and tax rises. Been utterly shafted!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/02/2022 09:17

Was quite annoyed when I check and found I’m Band E!

I’m a single Mum - happen to live in London. Got a massive mortgage taking up huge amounts of my income but I’m stuck here due to ex and due to my children being settled in schools. The reality is, a smaller house wouldn’t fit us in but I could have really done with that money!

Lampshading · 08/02/2022 09:16

Comparing London to elsewhere is a bit of an anomalie as its so densely populated that for the same size catchment more people are paying (if that makes sense)- but comparing London to other bits of London highlight the ridiculousness. That said it varies by area anyway, we pay tonnes in this county and like everywhere else services are dwindling. Its a very loose yardstick, more effective than everyone paying the same though as some would gain and some would miss out, being linked to something changeable such as income wouldn't work as wouldn't be able to project with any sort of accuracy.

Jvg33 · 08/02/2022 09:12

Don't ask other people to do something that you don't want to do yourself. Do you want to give this person 150 pounds of money from your own pocket op? If not, stop asking others to do it.

Jvg33 · 08/02/2022 09:07

If someone can't afford to live in an expensive home, they need to sell up and move somewhat cheaper. I live in a cheaper area than most in England. I'm not about to feel sorry for someone who bought their now high valued realastae decades ago for a much lower price. Stop feeling sorry for the babyboomers and their parents. We are the generation who are missing out. Someone posted a thread earlier in the week about grandparents not providing childcare and were slated for it. Erm, I remember my parents gaining lots of free childcare and they hardly give anything back to their own children. Why don't you give this elderly person the 150 pounds op and stop assuming the rest of the actual tax payers to fund for it.

Enzbear · 08/02/2022 09:05

Feel sorry for an old person who owns an expensive house outright?
Behave!
Why does he need the help? Others, especially a lot of younger people are much worse off.
How do you know he doesn't have much money.
Most of my elderly relatives live/lived like paupers while having a fortune sitting in the bank. My uncle died and left over half a million this year, he always had holes in his socks!
My DM frets about having a taxi to hospital, yet has loads in the bank. They can't accept that they are well off somehow.

BarbaraofSeville · 08/02/2022 09:04

It's one of those where it costs too much to target effectively, but wouldn't another UC uplift been better as it would have then gone to those who've already gone though means testing to demonstrate that they have less money than average?

Plus maybe increase the winter fuel allowance so pensioners get it too? Doing it that way would mean that it goes more to low income people?

I'm not sure exactly who's getting what as I've seen various reports of £150 and/or £200, some being repayable, and others not, but if it's £150 of free money to lower council tax bands then we'll get it and we certainly don't need it (band A house, childfree couple with an income of around £60k but we're too lazy to move somewhere nicer and it's OK here really).

But I saw this campaign on here to donate the £150 if you don't need it and we'll be doing this.

Appleseesaw · 08/02/2022 08:59

@UndertheCedartree

I am exempt from council tax due to illness. I am on a very low income as I'm a single parent and can't work. It's a shame I will miss out on this support as I can't currently afford to put the heating on. So glad Spring is on it's way!
Contact your council about the household support fund. I hope things look up for you soon.
ilovebrie8 · 08/02/2022 08:57

I think they should give it to everyone it’s unfair ...bandings are not a great benchmark! It’s poor as £150 is woefully small ...it’s the furlough/bounce back loans that is all wrong...lot of dodgy people/scammers were literally given tens of thousands and treasury has written it off ...the figures are mind boggling ...wrong on every level ...and people arguing here over £150. There is a bigger picture it’s shocking ...

UndertheCedartree · 08/02/2022 08:52

I am exempt from council tax due to illness. I am on a very low income as I'm a single parent and can't work. It's a shame I will miss out on this support as I can't currently afford to put the heating on. So glad Spring is on it's way!

Livelovebehappy · 08/02/2022 08:50

I think the general consensus would be that if someone lives in a Band E property, and who are probably paying the equivalent of a monthly mortgage payment for their council tax, that they are probably not going to be struggling financially. I’m glad though that this is probably also going to help those people who live modestly, but don’t get any financial help normally as they may be just outside the criteria for getting help.

Franklin12 · 08/02/2022 08:50

A relative lived in a house in London for over 50 years. Claimed for years he didn’t have any money, refused to move due to the house being in a terrible state (no money or inclination to repair it supposedly).

I was part of the team who helped him to move to a home, the house had to be cleared and put on the market. I was STAGGERED at his wealth. All those years with plenty of choices yet he CHOSE to live. Very desirable part of London. Lots of neighbours slightly younger than him making the same choices.

The point I am trying to make is that there are choices for the vast majority of us. We just choose not to take some of them and keep things as is. Much easier in my relatives case!

Notcontent · 08/02/2022 08:45

@Ponoka7 you are quite wrong about the sort of person you think I am and I also don’t think you understand the point I am making. The point I am making is that lots of the people who will be receiving the rebate don’t actually need it - but they are getting it nonetheless when people who have much less income are not going to get it.

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 08/02/2022 08:38

A family with two working age adults in the north have more chance of increasing their income than an elderly pensioner in London

But they won't be any better off if childcare and travel to work take all their extra wages.

And northern homeowners have exactly the same choice to downsize if they can’t afford life

They really don't because if your house is worth £150k you can't free up hundreds of thousands of pounds by buying in a cheaper area like you can if your property is worth £500k+.

Someone who owns a London property outright is in a pretty priviledged position even if they are cash poor, and the OPs neighbour might not even be that poor, even if he looks poor because he doesn't appear to spend any money. Many older people have good pensions and lots of savings, but won't spend it.

But in any case, he can release some of his equity if he doesn't want to move. It's nowhere near as bad a deal as it used to be and the value is just sitting there available to him to supplement his income if he needs it.

ivykaty44 · 08/02/2022 08:38

Ariela You can look on Martin Lewis website for how to challenge this situation

Ariela · 08/02/2022 08:37

We are by far the smallest house in our road - yet 4 houses pay a lower band, despite humungous extensions, and the one that's the same band is almost exactly twice as big

Bigassbeebuzzbuzz · 08/02/2022 08:36

Well the government isnt trying to help anyone they are making it look like they are.
Most of it will end up in their mates back pockets

Lolamento · 08/02/2022 08:36

But if they give it to everyone equally people would complain about the ones who do not need it.

rookiemere · 08/02/2022 08:34

The housing crisis is - to some degree- caused by people not moving to smaller properties once they no longer need a large house.

I do understand that it's hard to move once elderly, but there was the option of moving before that point. Or if he's strapped for cash he can do equity release on the property - and yes he'll get shortchanged on that but better than going cold and hungry if that's his choice.
Or he could rent out part of the property.

He has options, in a way that a person who does not own an expensive house does not. If he chooses not to take those options because he wants to leave the property as his inheritance, that's on him. If it's because he's not able to go through the necessary steps then suggest he contacts Age Concern who may be able to provide some support.

innyourhead · 08/02/2022 08:33

Just me who can always tell a @Tealightsandd post before I've looked at the poster?? 🙄

Yes, poor London. My heart bleeds for people sitting in million pound houses they couldn't possibly sell because they don't want to move (like the rest of the country has to).

You honestly think people aren't being denied services and forced out of their local areas up and down the entire country?

The only difference is they don't have million pound budgets to do it with.

ivykaty44 · 08/02/2022 08:26

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poll_tax_riots

The advent of the poll tax was due to an effort to alter the way the tax system was used to fund local government in the UK. The system in place until this time was called "rates" and had been in place in some form from the beginning of the 17th century.[1] The rates system has been described as "a levy on property, which in modern times saw each taxpayer paying a rate based on the estimated rental value of their home".[1]

The Thatcher government had long promised to replace domestic rates, which were unpopular, especially among Conservative voters. They were seen by many as an unfair way of raising revenue for local councils.[2] It was levied on houses rather than people.[2]

The proposed replacement was a flat-rate per capita Community Charge—"a head tax that saw every adult pay a fixed rate amount set by their local authority".[1] The new Charge was widely called a "poll tax" and was introduced in Scotland in 1989 and in England and Wales a year later.[3] The Charge proved extremely unpopular; while students and the registered unemployed had to pay 20%, some large families occupying relatively small houses saw their charges go up considerably, and the tax was thus accused of saving the rich money and moving the expenses onto the poor.[4]

Timeyime · 08/02/2022 08:23

Council house tenants pay council tax fgs.

No wonder councils get away with the shit they do if this thread is anything to go by: half the people on it don't understand how council tax works.

Swipe left for the next trending thread