Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be cranky about the £150 council tax rebate

238 replies

Notcontent · 07/02/2022 23:44

I have been thinking a lot about this. I understand that the government was looking for a way to implement help with energy costs in the easiest way possible and that doing it through council tax bands seemed sensible as for the most part it does target the right people. But only for the most part. For example, in London there are lots of people who live in high value properties that are actually far from luxurious and who will miss out. For example, my elderly neighbour will miss out even though he deserves the help. He doesn’t have a lot of money - bought his house decades ago when the area was very cheap and lives very frugally. I know councils will get some extra money to distribute but that will be for only a small number of people.

These kinds of injustices really get to me, as I think when it comes to public money everyone should get equal treatment.

OP posts:
LethargicActress · 08/02/2022 19:10

The taxpayer will get back it’s £150 and plenty more when the man dies, and they probably won’t have to wait too long either. I don’t know why people would begrudge it so much on the basis that he has an asset, when as soon as the asset is turned in to cash, the state will take 40% (above the threshold) of it anyway.

I think measures that help as many people as possible are a good thing. It’s worth ensuring the help can reach as many people as possible who are in need, even if that means that a small amount is given to people who don’t really need it.

Rhayader · 08/02/2022 19:08

It’s hard to feel sorry for someone who is unimaginably wealthy after an asset has appreciated in value by more than I will earn in my lifetime and they paid no tax on that unearned income.

CovidCorvid · 08/02/2022 19:00

I don’t know if this is still the case but a number of years ago when Tony Blair left Downing Street and moved into a £7million house in London the reported cost of his council tax bill was less than my small 3 bed semi in the Midlands. That’s what needs sorting out for sure. I pay about 2k a year i think.

CayrolBaaaskin · 08/02/2022 18:57

@Tealightsandd - we should not be paying benefits to millionaires. We are borrowing to pay for government spending as it is - we don’t raise enough tax to pay for it. If single parents, refugees, etc. are also millionaires, I’m quite happy for them not to be given council tax rebates too. They don’t need them.

CayrolBaaaskin · 08/02/2022 18:53

Why should the taxpayer pay for someone with a million pounds in assets? Even if his home is indeed suitable or he is too frail to move, he could do equity release. Why should working age people who can’t afford housing pay to give benefits to millionaires?

Tealightsandd · 08/02/2022 18:52

@cptartapp

I don't feel sorry for him. I feel sorry that heating allowance for example, is dished out freely to people like him solely on the basis of age (as with other pensioner benefits) and not actual need. Means test it. Like my child benefit which was quickly whipped away easily enough a few years back.

And if people are too frail to move, they've failed to plan for the inevitable and will live with the consequences.

Careful. Slippery slope. By your own argument, wrt child benefit you should've 'planned for the inevitable' (cost of being a parent) and will 'live with the consequences'.

I emphasise that's not my view. It is what happens when you go down the slippery slope. First the disabled, then pensioners, then single parents, then refugees, then someone else. It keeps going the slippery slope.

And again. As per the link I posted, London pensioner are the poorest in the UK. So if anything they should get more than elsewhere (if we are to do the awful regional divide thing).

cptartapp · 08/02/2022 18:45

I don't feel sorry for him. I feel sorry that heating allowance for example, is dished out freely to people like him solely on the basis of age (as with other pensioner benefits) and not actual need. Means test it. Like my child benefit which was quickly whipped away easily enough a few years back.

And if people are too frail to move, they've failed to plan for the inevitable and will live with the consequences.

Tealightsandd · 08/02/2022 18:42

Yes about London.

The capital has the UK’s highest rate of poverty for people of pensionable age. Older Londoners are as diverse as any other age group and face significant socio-economic inequalities impacting all aspects of people’s lives.

24% of Londoners of pensionable age live in poverty (a quarter of a million people). This is a 5% increase since 2017 and 7% more than the rest of England average.

www.ageuk.org.uk/london/projects-campaigns/age-friendly-campaigns/poverty-and-older-londoners-8-facts/

Eggshausted · 08/02/2022 18:36

@Inspectorslack

What about the fact that the discount is only for those in England op and that the other nations of the uk are excluded?

And if they do similar where I am, those in most rented accommodation will be excluded?

Rather than feeling sorry for your neighbour who owns his house in London outright?

The other nations of the UK get other benefits that people in England do not, regardlessif they are millionaires or on the poverty line. Free dental treatment and prescriptions, that can easily tot up to more than £150 for each person in a household. I would rather have that than the £150 council tax reductions PER household.
woohoo54 · 08/02/2022 18:24

@DaphneBasset

From the sounds of it, your neighbour's house has hugely appreciated in value. He may have little in the way of cash but it sounds like he has decent wealth. He can downsize anytime he wants. No, I don't feel sorry for him!!
This! And working people are about to be massively taxed so the elderly don't have to sell their assets to fund their care. Working people (many of whom don't have £££ houses) are being massively squeezed. So no it's not fair.
olivehater · 08/02/2022 18:23

I agree with it. Every thing should’nt be based on earnings. Sick of wage earners always being the easiest targets. Tax/benefits system is never going to be completely fair. There are always cliff edges and exceptions. But if someone is sitting in an expensive house they own they aren’t doing too badly.

Sleepdeprived42long · 08/02/2022 18:16

*assets

Sleepdeprived42long · 08/02/2022 18:16

I don’t have a huge amount of sympathy for the gent in the OP-he has assists he could choose to release if he is cash poor.

However, the council tax banding system creates an inherent unfairness-plucking a number out of thin air (ish) for what a house might have been worth in 1991 (even if the house was built years after that!) is never going to produce a fair and equitable result-for council tax charges and for any money linked to your banding.

Tealightsandd · 08/02/2022 18:15

[quote roarfeckingroarr]@Tealightsandd fair, there are expensive Tory areas too. [/quote]
@roarfeckingroarr

I don't know if it's relevant at all but they were both safe constituency seats?

Tealightsandd · 08/02/2022 18:14

@Viviennemary

No I don't feel very sorry for a person thst lives in a house worth £1m but needs a £150 rebate.
The house can be 'worth' whatever somebody wants to pay for it, but that's fuck all use to the person or family living in it, who for various reasons need to stay in their home. It's not their fault other people have made money out of an essential need - housing.

And wrt London, like I said yesterday it has a huge amount of deprivation (some of the worst in the country, as per the link I posted). And often poor public services for those in need of support.

I'm sure there's an Age UK study knocking around that found London pensioners were the poorest in the UK. I must have a look.

Low tax has consequences. The post above mentioning Kensington and Chelsea. Yes, the borough of (very poorly maintained) Grenfell.

roarfeckingroarr · 08/02/2022 18:11

@Tealightsandd fair, there are expensive Tory areas too.

danni0509 · 08/02/2022 18:11

@HobnobsChoice

The council tax band is based on property value in 1991 when London property prices were significantly less insane. I live in a Band B property in the North West and have just discovered I pay more Council tax than someone in a D property in a number of London boroughs.
I don’t understand how they work it out either.

My house is a tiny mid terrace 2 bed, no front garden. We pay £1570 a year thereabouts.

My dad lives in a bigger house (easily 3 times the size of mine) huge garden / drive etc and pays £200 a year less. Makes zero sense to me!

Tealightsandd · 08/02/2022 18:06

I've lived in both Conservative and Labour run London councils. Both high council tax. (I once nearly moved to the Wandsworth bit of Putney because of the c tax - but ended up moving elsewhere, to nearer where my boyfriend at the time was).

roarfeckingroarr · 08/02/2022 18:05

@DaphneBasset

From the sounds of it, your neighbour's house has hugely appreciated in value. He may have little in the way of cash but it sounds like he has decent wealth. He can downsize anytime he wants. No, I don't feel sorry for him!!
Funny how all these people think home owners should sell up, but thought the spare room subsidy "bedroom tax" was unfair when arguably the people in a house too big for them could've just downsized
Viviennemary · 08/02/2022 18:03

No I don't feel very sorry for a person thst lives in a house worth £1m but needs a £150 rebate.

Tealightsandd · 08/02/2022 18:02

Bedroom tax downsizers who are freeing up a larger home which was desperately needed for a family (who can't really go and get a flat share or sleep on relative's sofas like a single adult can).

Particularly once they get to a certain age, single adults need and deserve the privacy and dignity of their own home. I mean, men too, but for single women there's the added safety aspect (relevant because single women over a certain age are a minority - and therefore would face having to share with strange, potentially predatory, men).

And, it's not always so easy for single adults to get a room. Many are disabled or long term ill. Certainly a safe room isn't always easy to find for people on disability benefits (I won't include slum beds in shed type HMOs).

But also, like I said, many people needing a smaller home, including a lot of elderly, have mobility needs. There is a serious shortage of accessible homes.

roarfeckingroarr · 08/02/2022 17:57

@ToastieSnowy

If he can’t afford it then he needs to sell his expensive home and downsize/ move location just like the rest of us would have to do.

How about being in one of the most deprived wards in the country yet paying one of the most expensive council tax. There’s quite a few areas of the country who pay far far more than the expensive London boroughs. For example while those in City of London pay £1049 a year council tax (band D), Wandsworth & Westminster pay even less than that. Kensington & Chelsea is £1331.

Yet Middlesbrough pay £2104, Gateshead £2145 and County Durham with all the old pit villages about the same.

Let’s start with equality in council tax payments first eh.

Labour council = high council tax.

I live in Wandsworth and vote Conservative for a reason.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 08/02/2022 17:54

Surely banding is based on local areas so a 500k house in one area will be a different band to one in another area.

themental · 08/02/2022 17:48

Street homelessness is on the increase. One of the (various) reasons why is that 1 and 2 bedroom socially rented homes have all been taken by bedroom tax downsizers.

Bedroom tax downsizers who are freeing up a larger home which was desperately needed for a family (who can't really go and get a flat share or sleep on relative's sofas like a single adult can).

But way to change the subject.

We're not talking about the homeless, we're talking about a single man living in London who is going to struggle without £150 a year CT rebate but not to the extent he should possibly think about selling his million pound home.

With a million pound budget your argument about shortages falls flat on its face. And if they are so frail they cannot possibly move, how would they manage if they had to go into a care home? Confused Do you not think people have any responsibility to think about this? Or do we just give council tax rebates to millionaires... because? Because?

Surely every £150 going to people in million pound houses is £150 less going to those at risk of homelessness. You can't have it both ways (or are you arguing for a world where everyone can have everything?)

BarbaraofSeville · 08/02/2022 17:34

Many elderly people are too physically and/or mentally frail to move.

And also, not in every area of course, but many parts of the country have a severe shortage of smaller properties - particularly suitable for people who might have mobility needs

A family sized property isn't likely to be suitable either but if they don't want to move they also have the option of equity release via a lifetime mortgage.

Pretty bloody minded to struggle along in a large property and not put the value of use if short of cash to pay the bills.