Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be cranky about the £150 council tax rebate

238 replies

Notcontent · 07/02/2022 23:44

I have been thinking a lot about this. I understand that the government was looking for a way to implement help with energy costs in the easiest way possible and that doing it through council tax bands seemed sensible as for the most part it does target the right people. But only for the most part. For example, in London there are lots of people who live in high value properties that are actually far from luxurious and who will miss out. For example, my elderly neighbour will miss out even though he deserves the help. He doesn’t have a lot of money - bought his house decades ago when the area was very cheap and lives very frugally. I know councils will get some extra money to distribute but that will be for only a small number of people.

These kinds of injustices really get to me, as I think when it comes to public money everyone should get equal treatment.

OP posts:
SmellinOfTroy · 09/02/2022 21:30

@LethargicActress

Sure he doesn't have a landlord to ay for his repairs, but maybe he could take it out of the rent he isn't paying?

What if, like many pensioners, his basic pension wouldn’t cover rent and if he had rent to pay it would be covered by benefits. Your attitude comes across as so small minded.

Remind me again what Cheryl, the single parent on minimum wage, who pay astronomical rent can do to mitigate the price rises?

I expect she can’t do much more than John the pensioner can do to increase her earnings for the time being. We weren’t talking about increasing earnings though, we’re talking about a council tax rebate. Assuming both Cheryl and John live in a band A-D home and pay their own council tax, they can both benefit in exactly the same was as each other. As it should be.

Small minded because I think if you have an asset you should use it.

Again, there are options for a single person with a massive asset, he can get a life time mortgage and release equity, he can move, he can get a lodger
I'll pop this here again, as you seemed to miss it when cherry picking from my post.

LoisLane66 · 09/02/2022 21:08

The highest council tax is in Rutland at 2.5 x more than Westminster but these bands were set in 1991. House prices and other factors have changed so much since then. Crime, housing, immigration, schools, policing among many other pressures, have contributed to skewed house prices and consequently, council tax. Yesterday, I sent a request via the government website to ask for a review of my council tax, as I feel the banding is wrong.
They promise to respond in 2/3 days.

LethargicActress · 09/02/2022 20:41

Sure he doesn't have a landlord to ay for his repairs, but maybe he could take it out of the rent he isn't paying?

What if, like many pensioners, his basic pension wouldn’t cover rent and if he had rent to pay it would be covered by benefits. Your attitude comes across as so small minded.

Remind me again what Cheryl, the single parent on minimum wage, who pay astronomical rent can do to mitigate the price rises?

I expect she can’t do much more than John the pensioner can do to increase her earnings for the time being. We weren’t talking about increasing earnings though, we’re talking about a council tax rebate. Assuming both Cheryl and John live in a band A-D home and pay their own council tax, they can both benefit in exactly the same was as each other. As it should be.

ancientgran · 09/02/2022 20:39

[quote rookiemere]@ancientgran it's not jealousy, its simple maths.

Coronavirus has cost the country dearly, the government has to have a cut off point for anything being handed out. Some comments are ridiculous like the government giving out free equity release .Council tax banding may not be perfect, but it's good for once to see something that acknowledges wealth that people have accumulated through property, rather than yet again basing it on income.[/quote]
There's lots of arguments about the money. That wasn't my point though. Why was it awful if elderly people in rented accommodation had to move because their benefits to help with rent was reduced but it is the thing elderly people in a house they own should do. The only difference I can see is people resent that this old man is living in a house that is worth alot of money but he is potentially just as short of money to live on as the person in rented accommodation.

If it is just fine for him to downsize (I would but my DH won't as he is older than me and can't face the disruption) why isn't it fine for someone in rented.

As I've said it doesn't affect me, I just think the difference in attitude is interesting.

It isn't a first for taking the value of property into consideration, ask any of the old people in care homes who have had to sell their home. Again I haven't got an issue with that, as someone with LPA for an elderly relative I'm happily spending over £6k a month for her care from the proceeds of her house and am glad we have the money for an excellent home but it isn't right to say that "for once" something acknowledge wealth accumulated from property.

Weonlyhavealoanofit · 09/02/2022 20:33

Targeting council tax payments is a gimmick. Local authorities have endured years and years of cuts via ever decreasing payments from central government. Coupled with this policy, the obligations on local government to provide social care services have increased. You can see where this is going? Impoverished councils will now become even more impoverished and then everyone blames ‘the bloody council’…I’m afraid this government couldn’t care less about poverty, hardship or the appalling destruction of social services, our underfunded schools and our hospitals. If they were serious about poverty Universal Credit wouldn’t have been slashed, and something would be done about VAT on fuel.

rookiemere · 09/02/2022 20:08

@ancientgran it's not jealousy, its simple maths.

Coronavirus has cost the country dearly, the government has to have a cut off point for anything being handed out. Some comments are ridiculous like the government giving out free equity release .Council tax banding may not be perfect, but it's good for once to see something that acknowledges wealth that people have accumulated through property, rather than yet again basing it on income.

HadaVerde · 09/02/2022 19:52

@Bebethany

Notcontent Are you set to gain from his 1,000,000 house?
The op said it’s not worth a million.
ancientgran · 09/02/2022 19:47

When the "bedroom tax" came in I remember lots of outrage about elderly people not being able to stay in their homes.

Now elderly people should "just move."

Is it jealousy that makes the difference. Nothing personal, my house is band E in quite a deprived area with high council tax.

Bebethany · 09/02/2022 19:46

Notcontent Are you set to gain from his 1,000,000 house?

SmellinOfTroy · 09/02/2022 19:41

@LethargicActress

YANBU OP.

I think I will benefit from this council tax discount so I’m not going to complain about about it, but reading some of the responses on here I find it sad that so many people are so small minded that they can’t find any sympathy for a single elderly man who is struggling with the cost of living just because he happens to own his house. In day to day life he’s no better off than if he lived in a council house that’s paid for by housing benefit. In fact he’s probably worse of as he doesn’t have a landlord to pay for any maintenance problems. It’s not that easy to just up and downsize, especially if you’re on a low income and don’t have help. People’s jealousy of him owning a house in London is completely misguided.

Sure he doesn't have a landlord to ay for his repairs, but maybe he could take it out of the rent he isn't paying?

Again, there are options for a single person with a massive asset, he can get a life time mortgage and release equity, he can move, he can get a lodger

Remind me again what Cheryl, the single parent on minimum wage, who pay astronomical rent can do to mitigate the price rises?

MyrtleHope · 09/02/2022 19:40

Your elderly neighbour has been fortunate that his property has appreciated so much. I think there are far too many taxes on income and not enough on assets, council tax (and anything based on it) is therefore one of the fairest in my opinion.

HadaVerde · 09/02/2022 19:38

Has the OP said this persons house is worth £1million? I thought she’d said it wasn’t.

Band E In London doesn’t mean property worth a million.

Also not everyone owns their home so ‘just sell up’ isn’t necessarily an option.

The council tax banding system is nonsense. Identical homes on the same street have different bands.

Newnamefor2022 · 09/02/2022 19:37

YANBU. Why shouldn't we have sympathy for that old chap, just because some are even worse off?

maureen17 · 09/02/2022 19:15

you are not being unreasonable. You are a kind caring person who understands.

StaplesCorner · 09/02/2022 18:57

There are so many anomalies - when I bought my 3 bed house it had a small extension, roughly 12 x 12, at the time council tax was set. That pushed it into band E, every other house in the road, band D (even though their plots were bigger than ours).

30 years on, every other house in the road has had at least one bedroom added, wrap around extensions etc., plus their larger plot, means that where my band E house might be worth £400k, my neighbours in band D could realise £500k+ if they sold. We've applied twice to be re-banded without success. I've shrugged it off for so many years but now there are many very wealthy people in this road with what are now huge houses and its really got to me; I'm already paying nearly £400 a year more in tax than my neighbours.

Bit shit really.

LethargicActress · 09/02/2022 18:55

[quote rookiemere]@Tealightsandd they don't need to move, they can do equity release on their property.[/quote]
So you think people should have to pay to be in a position to be able to pay their council tax? Equity release isn’t free, and it’s only an option towards the end of people’s lives when they’re not far off having to pay a colossal amount of of death tax anyway.

Maybe the government could offer free equity release for people in this position and that way they get to protect the amount they get when the person dies.

It’s also worth considering that not everyone who lives in a high value property with a low income is elderly. Other people in that position are likely to be single parents who got a house out of a divorce or people who have had a significant bereavement like the premature death of a parent or spouse. Their properties are only up to band D anyway, it’s not like we’re talking about mansions. To me, it just seems nasty to begrudge people a tiny bit of help in those circumstances.

Borisisafecklesstoad · 09/02/2022 18:49

I do agree with you OP. Council tax was a stop gap after the poll tax, literally was my dad and his council pals going out in the car and rating the size of houses.
At a time when house prices werw not insane luke now. Bigger houses are more expensive to morgage and are more expensive to heat. We are fortunate to have 4 bedrooms, so band E. In this part of scotland that's over 2.8k on an average income with rising energy costs its going to be brutal for us! The whole taxation system needs overhauled...

withoutawordofalie · 09/02/2022 18:27

If I couldnt afford to pay my council tax when sitting in a million pound house I would sell it and rent a really nice place, even paying £2000 a month for a 1 bed apartment would pay the rent for 40+ years, a million pounds would be more than enough to keep you for the rest of your life when you are your 80s. And you wouldnt have to turn the heating down or eat crap food.

purplepentagram · 09/02/2022 18:04

Yet there is some of us that won’t get any help.
We firstly got left out of the covid uplift because we’re on the old system.
Now this so called energy help. That is of no help at all.
My single disabled son gets pip and esa - his council tax is covered by council tax support - his energy bills have rocketed since npower being moved to eon. No help for him, no rebate for him.
He would be severely worse off if he changed to universal credit.
My widowed elderly disabled mother in law. - yet again no help for her, no rebate.
Myself. I’m disabled, my husband a carer with 2 disabled children in the home as well. We get council tax support - so no rebate, no help.
Our council tax is going up to which I now have to find the extra to cover that, on top of everything else going up.

LlamaLucy · 09/02/2022 17:55

In regard to your elderly neighbour - he should have sold before he was too infirm to withstand the upheaval. There are 84 million empty bedrooms in the UK, 2/3 of them are owned outright by the over 65s. In the 1960s they purchase said bedrooms for 2 years wages. One person’s two years of wages!

It now takes TWO workers 10 years to build a deposit and 40 years to pay off the mortgage.

The reason old people should move out of too-large houses, is that we do not have an unlimited amount of land, or number of houses available to safely house the population. People are literally homeless, because of selfish people who refuse to downsize. I feel very sorry for them. If your house is too big for you, sell it.

The reason we have some people who own absolutely nothing, never will build any wealth, and are going to remain on the breadline for their entire lives with never a decent place to live, is partly because the over 65s are hoarding a large proportion of our wealth. It needs to trickle down far sooner than when they die at 86 - where it is split, uselessly, and far too-late, between c.40 relatives.

SpittinKitten · 09/02/2022 17:41

R4 moneybox earlier had someone from the CAB talking about the lower council tax bands, the rebate and benefit recipients.

They said people receiving council tax support (so who receive a council tax bill which is then partly or fully covered by CTS) should automatically receive the rebate. The method of payment is yet to be confirmed.

People exempt from council tax in the first place (those who receive a £0 council tax bill, so receive no CTS as there's no bill to cover- eg full time students) will have to apply for a discretionary payment via their council.

Bit less worried now if that's correct as I've been panicking about having to apply, but it looks like I fall in the first group (fortunately for me).

RitaJosephina · 09/02/2022 17:27

Not sure if anyone linked that already but from government website : On top of this discount, discretionary funding of £144 million will also be provided to support vulnerable people and individuals on low incomes that do not pay Council Tax, or that pay Council Tax for properties in Bands E-H.

Chakraleaf · 09/02/2022 16:14

@Cocomarine

🤣 I can find plenty more people to feel sorry for than those that own their house outright!
Oh yes. Me too
CayrolBaaaskin · 09/02/2022 16:06

@Tealightsandd of course his house is an asset. In London a massively expensive asset that he likely paid buttons for. If he doesn’t want to downsize for some reason he can equity release. We absolutely should not be giving tax rebates to millionaires.

Are you Helena Dove?

jcyclops · 09/02/2022 13:20

Some figures that you may find interesting:

Percentage of households in bands A-D (who will receive £150)

95 - Tyne & Wear
89 - Yorkshire & Humber
69 - London
52 - Surrey
32 - Kensington & Chelsea