Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be cranky about the £150 council tax rebate

238 replies

Notcontent · 07/02/2022 23:44

I have been thinking a lot about this. I understand that the government was looking for a way to implement help with energy costs in the easiest way possible and that doing it through council tax bands seemed sensible as for the most part it does target the right people. But only for the most part. For example, in London there are lots of people who live in high value properties that are actually far from luxurious and who will miss out. For example, my elderly neighbour will miss out even though he deserves the help. He doesn’t have a lot of money - bought his house decades ago when the area was very cheap and lives very frugally. I know councils will get some extra money to distribute but that will be for only a small number of people.

These kinds of injustices really get to me, as I think when it comes to public money everyone should get equal treatment.

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 10/02/2022 03:02

It's not just a matter of morals. It makes good economic sense.

The public health housing and homelessness emergency costs the taxpayer many many billions every year. Indirect and wide reaching indirect consequences.

Billions to house homeless families and vulnerable individuals in expensive but crappy temporary accommodation.

Billions in housing benefits for ever increasing high private rents.

And billions and billions and billions and billions on the impact of insecure or no housing.

It has (expensive) consequences affecting many public services. The NHS (including mental health), social services, criminal justice system.

People were concerned about the temporary Covid measures affecting children's education and life chances. The public health housing and homelessness emergency impacts heavily on a child's education and life opportunities.

We need to spend to save. Invest to longer term save.

We need a construction industry boosting mass social housing build and buy.

(And for those who want/are able to buy, there needs to be some relaxation of mortgage lender affordability criteria. The attention is often on deposit yet it's actually the minimum requirements that are the stumbling block for growing numbers. Of course we don't want s new subprime crisis but the pendulum has swung tok far in the other direction.)

Tealightsandd · 10/02/2022 02:47

Obviously neglecting to include sufficient accessible and smaller homes in new build developments is one cause of the scarcity of suitable downsize homes.

But of course another major culprit is the dreadful 'bedroom tax', which has seriously depleted the supply of 1 and 2 bedroom homes.

Anyway, as always gold star ⭐ to that tried and tested old favorite. Divide and rule. Works a charm everytime. Well until, eventually, the divided equally fucked over groups finally work it out and realise strength in numbers.

The real answer to the cost of living crisis - for individual family benefit and the longer term national economy? That would be tackling the public health housing and homelessness emergency.

Tealightsandd · 10/02/2022 02:39

^So yes, there may also be people living in CT band E and above properties who don't have a lot of cash but they do at least have far more valuable houses and if they can't afford the CT on them, they do at least have the option to move into somewhere cheaper.

Problem is many won't.

Many are too elderly and frail (physically or mentally) to move.

There is also the lack of accessible homes for disabled or elderly people.

And, whilst yes, social rent downsizers often get highest priority for rehousing (often above people trapped in flats in wheelchair when lifts break, and those fleeing domestic abuse.

But those in private renting it's a very different story. A far more miserable one. There's a serious shortage of landlords letting to tenants on low incomes especially benefits (other than illegal or should be illegal slum beds in sheds types).

This is, unsurprisingly, a particular problem in London, but it's a growing issue elsewhere too.

Tealightsandd · 10/02/2022 02:30

am disabled and on ESA (a legacy benefit that pre-dates UC) and PIP, as part of my weekly benefit amount, the DWP pays my Council Tax direct, so I know it gets paid but don't have to pay it from my available cash as such.

My understanding (from a couple of people I know who are on UC) is that they get their CT paid too but it's given to them to pay to the council.

@Harmonypuss A friend is on the same legacy benefits as you. She still has to pay some council tax. Her (London) council only gives a discount.

I think it varies across the country. DP has a cousin on UC, not in London and he too has to pay an amount.

I do know that both my friend and DP's cousin do feel the rebate will help them. Whilst still a drop in the ocean, paying even discounted rate of council tax when benefits can be a struggle.

Tealightsandd · 10/02/2022 02:23

council lists are 10-20 years long in some parts of London.

Yes. And many London councils won't let many people even join the list.

Now I know things are beginning to get bad in some other parts of the country as 'levelling up' happens. Manchester, for example is discovering the 'benefits' of 'investment pricing people away from families, support networks, and communities.

But there's still quite some catching up to get to London level of bad.

Tealightsandd · 10/02/2022 02:15

They rarely see them either, families spread out for employment etc is not something limited to Londoners

It's not limited to Londoners - but they've been affected the most. By far. In London it's happening on mass. In the rental as well as buying sector. Which means the most vulnerable . Including disabled people and families with disabled children - the people who most need family, community, and support networks.

It's been going on for years and years, including London councils socially cleansing vulnerable families and individuals away from family, community, and support networks.

Nowhere in the UK has suffered worse than London.

London is the epicentre of the public health housing and homelessness emergency.

Two thirds of all homeless families in England are in London. A whopping majority.

And of course a vital point that can't be dismissed, is that if your family decide to move back home, they will be welcomed as returning locals. They will not face the hate and bigotry that Londoners face when priced out. (It's very easy to find just on MN alone, if you don't believe me).

It's not ok to happen to anyone or anywhere in the country but it cannot be denied that the problems is most acute in London. And has been for years.

dratsnotyouagain · 10/02/2022 00:37

Also subsidised rent just means bringing the rent down to the LHA or below which in some boroughs for a two bedroom flat can range from £1300 - £1600pcm, which is stretching it for most people, as a studio in these places can far range upwards of £1500 so is realistically the only way people can get housed as the rents are ridiculous.

Viviennemary · 10/02/2022 00:26

The point is she is already been given a house at a large discount and also UC. I cant see any issue here at all.

LoisLane66 · 10/02/2022 00:19

There will always be winners and losers. Life is never equal and we can never pit our income, outgoings, lifestyle, against others we think are in the same bracket/boat as us. There are things we will never know and the bits we do know and don't like, we have to hold our noses and suck up. No matter who's in government, there will be millions who don't agree with their policies or chosen ministers. I asked numerous times (on a certain website) 'Who and what do YOU suggest?' when posters decried the latest 'loans' and CT reductions along with other ministerial faux pas. Silence reigned. So I ask here, what do posters here think would be better, fairer or more acceptable than the 150 reduction in your CT?

dratsnotyouagain · 10/02/2022 00:16

@Viviennemary

She is saving plenty more on rent. She is extemely lucky to have the flat on half the commercial rent.
No she is not saving anything because her rent is 65% of her income and then 50% of her income goes to childcare which means she is in the hole before she even receives UC.

The only reason the mention of her rent being subsidised is to explain she is in a high council Band, she is just the same as someone else renting the same size flat in another zone. If you know anything about social housing in those overpriced fancy London high rises you would know the fixtures are cheaper with worse materials and the use of poor doors and blocked access to amenities mean those in those flats are no better off than they woould be on a traditional council estate or low income area but because of the fancy address and judgements of the building (plus higher council tax) means people assume you are not in need when you are and are ungrateful/grabby when you ask for help you are entitled to.

To preempt your question or suggestion that she go live elsewhere, she was homeless with her children and in temp accommodation for 3 years prior - you don't say no to the council when they finally house you when council lists are 10-20 years long in some parts of London. The point is she and other social tenants qualify for their housing based on the fact that they are low income tenants- the rebate is meant to help those on low incomes, using Bands to determine need is not nuanced enough as they are many people living in social low income rented housing in high band flats through no fault of their own.

Harmonypuss · 09/02/2022 23:33

I've not read all 9 pages of responses so someone may have already said this ...

I am disabled and on ESA (a legacy benefit that pre-dates UC) and PIP, as part of my weekly benefit amount, the DWP pays my Council Tax direct, so I know it gets paid but don't have to pay it from my available cash as such.

My understanding (from a couple of people I know who are on UC) is that they get their CT paid too but it's given to them to pay to the council.

Now, this £150 will be passed on to UC claimants because they'll see a reduction in what they have to pay for the 22/23 year, but those of us on legacy benefits won't see that reduction, the DWP will beneefit from it.

Also, another thorn in my side is that UC claimants last year got that temporary £20/week uplift in their payments, those of us on legacy benefits didn't and many of us actually get less than those on UC (especially as some of them are able to, and do, work). Someone on Twitter suggested that legacy claimants can apply to be moved onto UC and therefore not miss out on payments like this, I would say, who, on benefits (and maybe even those with jobs), has 5 or 6 weeks worth of cash sitting around, available to tide them over until their first UC payment comes in? Yes, they say you can have a loan but that still has to be paid back and when you've gone 5 or 6 weeks with no money how on earth can you pay back a loan?

So yes, there may also be people living in CT band E and above properties who don't have a lot of cash but they do at least have far more valuable houses and if they can't afford the CT on them, they do at least have the option to move into somewhere cheaper.

Viviennemary · 09/02/2022 23:08

She is saving plenty more on rent. She is extemely lucky to have the flat on half the commercial rent.

dratsnotyouagain · 09/02/2022 23:05

I have a friend in a Band F property in London, single mum on low income and UC. She needs the rebate but wont get it because she lives in a fancy new build high rise in a Housing Association flat for half the commercial rent rates. There are council flats in the samw building with poor doors though who are likely in the same boat as their Bands also range from D-F. Bands are not a good way to work this out.

ancientgran · 09/02/2022 22:45

@HobnobsChoice

When the "bedroom tax" came in it didn't apply to those of pension age. It still doesn't, and there have been plenty of comments on here that people in their 70s with a three or four bedroom council house should move to allow for a family to move in to it. My ex partners parents live in an ex pit village in County Durham. They can afford their home etc however their sons moved away for jobs to Yorkshire and Lancashire. They rarely see them either, families spread out for employment etc is not something limited to Londoners
I think there were alot of scared people at the time. I remember them on here and people being scandalised at the idea they'd have to move. The old man in London has as much right to be attached to his home as anyone else. Just saying, "move" is strange if that isn't what is said to renters.

If it cheers you then just think of the inheritance tax when he no longer needs his home.

CouncilFuckingTax · 09/02/2022 22:44

Or, you'd have to be a special kind of mental to think there is even one person in the whole of the UK who will be facing penury/homelessness/straightened circumstances as a result of not getting a tax break on an asset they've had the benefit of owning for 41 fucking years ie almost half a century, having never previously had said tax break and done ok without it, and who is missing out because they live in a house that even in 1991 was worth more than at least 60% of the houses in their vicinity and now is likely worth around 500% more than even that.

Seriously, this entire thread is perching on cloud cuckoo land.

Do any of you even know how this shit works?

Sunsetmom · 09/02/2022 22:41

OP if your close to your neighbour try and encourage him to apply to the council for any support, even offer to assist with this if u can. Sometimes it’s about knowing what’s out there and having the gentle support of someone rather than being proud. Worth a try!

LethargicActress · 09/02/2022 22:11

Small minded because I think if you have an asset you should use it.

He is using it. It’s his home that he lives in.

Again, there are options for a single person with a massive asset, he can get a life time mortgage and release equity, he can move, he can get a lodger
I'll pop this here again, as you seemed to miss it when cherry picking from my post.

Yes, there are options. But seriously, it’s ridiculous that a pensioner should have to leave his home, buy a mortgage or equity release or be forced to live with a stranger for the sake of a £150 council tax break that many people will benefit from at at time when everyone’s living costs are rising. You have to be a special kind of tight to resent this tiny amount of help.

LethargicActress · 09/02/2022 22:05

If basic pension doesn't cover the rent the LAs have the means to award housing benefit, as long as the property is not considered too large for the number of people. Usually, a 1 bed property for a single person or couple. There are ceilings as I'm sure you're aware.

Yes, I’m aware. But as I was responding to the suggestion that a pensioner could spend money not being spent on rent, as in money that he doesn’t actually have, that bit’s not really relevant.

HobnobsChoice · 09/02/2022 22:01

When the "bedroom tax" came in it didn't apply to those of pension age. It still doesn't, and there have been plenty of comments on here that people in their 70s with a three or four bedroom council house should move to allow for a family to move in to it.
My ex partners parents live in an ex pit village in County Durham. They can afford their home etc however their sons moved away for jobs to Yorkshire and Lancashire. They rarely see them either, families spread out for employment etc is not something limited to Londoners

Tealightsandd · 09/02/2022 21:57

Meanwhile the reference upthread of (the failure to contain) SARS-COV-2 costing the economy. Well yes Long Covid will add an economic burden, but clearly there's money to be had for some things. Billions for furlough fraud and dodgy PPE, for example.

Tealightsandd · 09/02/2022 21:55

A pp misunderstood my talk of slippery slope when I mentioned it the other day. They thought I was referring simply to council tax banding/size/price of home.

What I actually meant was the lack of compassion, empathy, and understanding of physical and mental health needs (eg. the priceless benefits of living amongst family, community, and support networks).

There has been a deeply unpleasant pernicious devaluing of elderly people in recent years.

Likewise the disabled. Next up refugees, and then single mums and/or larger families. Don't be fooled into thinking the Othering will stop there.

Slippery slope.

LoisLane66 · 09/02/2022 21:47

21:30SmellinOfTroy

LethargicActress

Sure he doesn't have a landlord to ay for his repairs, but maybe he could take it out of the rent he isn't paying?

What if, like many pensioners, his basic pension wouldn’t cover rent and if he had rent to pay it would be covered by benefits. Your attitude comes across as so small minded.

If basic pension doesn't cover the rent the LAs have the means to award housing benefit, as long as the property is not considered too large for the number of people. Usually, a 1 bed property for a single person or couple. There are ceilings as I'm sure you're aware.

Tealightsandd · 09/02/2022 21:45

[quote rookiemere]@Tealightsandd they don't need to move, they can do equity release on their property.[/quote]
Equity release is a huge rip off.

But also, why should the elderly person in a cheaper housing area get to leave an inheritance (to help their children or grandchildren possibly buy a stable home) but not the one in the area blighted by social cleansing?

And before you say the expensive housing area will be a larger inheritance, well it won't make any difference - because, of course, it costs so much more to buy a stable home in the inflated prices area.

Also forget inheritance. Many elderly need to keep equity in order to pay for care (and care homes are more expensive in London and the south east).

UndertheCedartree · 09/02/2022 21:44

@Appleseesaw - thank you for the information

Tealightsandd · 09/02/2022 21:37

@MyrtleHope

Your elderly neighbour has been fortunate that his property has appreciated so much. I think there are far too many taxes on income and not enough on assets, council tax (and anything based on it) is therefore one of the fairest in my opinion.
Nope. The elderly person in a cheaper house price area is the more fortunate one. Because he gets to have something priceless.

His children and grandchildren weren't priced away from family, community, and support network. Lucky cheaper essential need (stable affordable housing) area old guy.

Like I say. Priceless.