Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be cranky about the £150 council tax rebate

238 replies

Notcontent · 07/02/2022 23:44

I have been thinking a lot about this. I understand that the government was looking for a way to implement help with energy costs in the easiest way possible and that doing it through council tax bands seemed sensible as for the most part it does target the right people. But only for the most part. For example, in London there are lots of people who live in high value properties that are actually far from luxurious and who will miss out. For example, my elderly neighbour will miss out even though he deserves the help. He doesn’t have a lot of money - bought his house decades ago when the area was very cheap and lives very frugally. I know councils will get some extra money to distribute but that will be for only a small number of people.

These kinds of injustices really get to me, as I think when it comes to public money everyone should get equal treatment.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Endoftether2000 · 12/02/2022 10:20

Well said toastiessnowy

HadaVerde · 11/02/2022 19:54

@Tealightsandd

Plenty of those highest paid jobs go to people from the south west (and elsewhere in the UK) - who move to London, pricing out locals. Who then move out of London...and get described as 'rich Londoners' by the Local locals.

As well as those higher paid jobs (that still don't make up for the much higher house prices, there are also huge numbers of minimum wage jobs.

How is the employment rate in London for well qualified young graduates? Are those jobs graduate jobs or not? Do those jobs have good prospects?

I assume so - since large numbers of them move to London to take those jobs... pricing out Londoners. How does that help Londoners, please?

Not sure why you are so insistent on London being worse than anywhere else.

I acknowledged lots of places have problems. But it's a fact that the situation is worst in London. Like I said, two thirds, eg. a majority, of all England's homeless families are in London.

London is the epicentre of the public health housing and homelessness emergency.

I'm not sure why you seem so determined to deny that fact.

Like I said, it's not ok when it happens anywhere. But the problem is most acute in London.

And also, if everywhere else is allowed to have Local locals, so is London. Which means that the majority of 'rich Londoners' are not actually Londoners.

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Tealightsandd · 11/02/2022 17:27

Plenty of those highest paid jobs go to people from the south west (and elsewhere in the UK) - who move to London, pricing out locals. Who then move out of London...and get described as 'rich Londoners' by the Local locals.

As well as those higher paid jobs (that still don't make up for the much higher house prices, there are also huge numbers of minimum wage jobs.

How is the employment rate in London for well qualified young graduates? Are those jobs graduate jobs or not? Do those jobs have good prospects?

I assume so - since large numbers of them move to London to take those jobs... pricing out Londoners. How does that help Londoners, please?

Not sure why you are so insistent on London being worse than anywhere else.

I acknowledged lots of places have problems. But it's a fact that the situation is worst in London. Like I said, two thirds, eg. a majority, of all England's homeless families are in London.

London is the epicentre of the public health housing and homelessness emergency.

I'm not sure why you seem so determined to deny that fact.

Like I said, it's not ok when it happens anywhere. But the problem is most acute in London.

And also, if everywhere else is allowed to have Local locals, so is London. Which means that the majority of 'rich Londoners' are not actually Londoners.

ancientgran · 11/02/2022 12:40

@Tealightsandd

Maybe export some of the well paid jobs down here and there would be less pressure on London property and less pressure on young people to move away to the big city(ies)

London has one the highest rates of youth unemployment.

And some of the highest paid jobs. I don't suppose it is the unemployed youths who are coming down here to buy property.

How is the employment rate in London for well qualified young graduates? Are those jobs graduate jobs or not? Do those jobs have good prospects?

Bit different to down here. Not sure why you are so insistent on London being worse than anywhere else. Lots of places have problems, it isn't just London.

Tealightsandd · 11/02/2022 10:58

Maybe export some of the well paid jobs down here and there would be less pressure on London property and less pressure on young people to move away to the big city(ies)

London has one the highest rates of youth unemployment.

ancientgran · 11/02/2022 08:29

The pricing out of 'locals' has indeed started to spread to other parts of the UK. It hasn't just started here, it has been going on for decades and I can say that as someone who moved here 30 years ago. If I look round the cul de sac where I live I think there is one family where the parents are "born and bred" down here although several of us have adult children who presumably can now claim local status but ironically very few of them live here.

The main problem here is lack of opportunities for young people so they have to move away. I see a fair number of families moving down where one of the parents has kept their well paid job in London or elsewhere and work part time at home and 2 or maybe 3 days a week back in the big cities. It doesn't seem great to me but it seems to work for them.

Maybe export some of the well paid jobs down here and there would be less pressure on London property and less pressure on young people to move away to the big city(ies)

ancientgran · 11/02/2022 08:24

@Tealightsandd

I'm sorry the problem of pricing out has spread to where you are *@ancientgran*

Although I'm not sure why you think the pricer outers are Londoners. A lot of the 'rich Londoners' who moved to the south west (eg. Scottish Gordon Ramsay) are not actual Londoners. Not by your definition of 'locals' - which, forgive me if I'm wrong, you mean born and bred.

The pricing out of 'locals' has indeed started to spread to other parts of the UK. But it is nothing new in London, where for years and years, 'locals' have been priced out by people coming from all over... including the south west - and to add insult to injury, having priced out London locals, when they move back to their home area of elsewhere, the Local locals call them Londoners.

Either someone is a local through born and bred (in which case, most of those 'rich Londoners' are not Londoners) or it's because of wherever they currently live (in which case, they are not Londoners if they're living n the south west).

I'm not a local, I've only lived here for nearly 30 years. Obviously I don't know everyone who has moved here from London but I know lots have moved from London. I can't vouch for how long they lived in London but either way people come here via London having sold a property and can outbid locals. It's just a fact.

Personally I find the whole "local" thing a bit ridiculous but each to their own.

PainterMummy · 11/02/2022 06:18

You do realise OP, that one reason people down size when they retire is to realise the profit on their home to help fund their retirement, moving to more affordable and smaller properties?? It is a choice that huge numbers of elderly make every year. I do have sympathy for your neighbour but if they have this asset and not use it, then there are others in greater need who do not have this asset.

Tealightsandd · 11/02/2022 01:53

Social cleansing on mass is not ok wherever it happens. But it is undeniably London that has and continues to suffer from this the most.

Two thirds of all of England's homeless families are in London.

There are more homeless people in London than the entire population of many UK towns.

Tealightsandd · 11/02/2022 01:51

I'm sorry the problem of pricing out has spread to where you are @ancientgran

Although I'm not sure why you think the pricer outers are Londoners. A lot of the 'rich Londoners' who moved to the south west (eg. Scottish Gordon Ramsay) are not actual Londoners. Not by your definition of 'locals' - which, forgive me if I'm wrong, you mean born and bred.

The pricing out of 'locals' has indeed started to spread to other parts of the UK. But it is nothing new in London, where for years and years, 'locals' have been priced out by people coming from all over... including the south west - and to add insult to injury, having priced out London locals, when they move back to their home area of elsewhere, the Local locals call them Londoners.

Either someone is a local through born and bred (in which case, most of those 'rich Londoners' are not Londoners) or it's because of wherever they currently live (in which case, they are not Londoners if they're living n the south west).

Harmonypuss · 10/02/2022 16:30

@LethargicActress

From what you’ve explained, I honestly can’t see why you’d be begrudging this from someone in a not too dissimilar situation. Your problem seems to be that those on legacy benefits aren’t getting the same as those on UC.

I don't begrudge anyone of it, I just think that if pensioners and those on UC are claiming to be 'the poorest in society' then there are others who should also be included in that group when the Govt are handing out assistance.

LethargicActress · 10/02/2022 16:16

@Harmonypuss

From what you’ve explained, I honestly can’t see why you’d be begrudging this from someone in a not too dissimilar situation. Your problem seems to be that those on legacy benefits aren’t getting the same as those on UC.

I’d assume a pensioner has finished paying off their mortgage and isn’t trying to buy a house at the same time as wanting help to pay for their council tax.

You might need to downsize because you haven’t finished paying for your house yet, but I can’t see why someone who finished paying for their house a long time ago should not be forced into the stress and upheaval of downsizing for the sake of £150

Harmonypuss · 10/02/2022 13:53

@LethargicActress

^It’s a bit hypocritical of you to flippantly say that people have the option of moving house right after saying you couldn’t possibly be expected to switch to UC because you’d end up with a loan to pay back out of your benefits. Do you really think that selling a house, buying a new one and going through all the stress of moving, especially alone and elderly, is an easier process than moving onto universal credit?

Again, it’s people who already get help from the state begrudging a much smaller amount of help to others who also need it.^

Actually, I wasn't being flippant about it, I actually own my own 3-bed house which is only worth about £110k and I'm trying to sell and downsize. As I said before, I'm disabled, I also actually live alone, so trying to move house is a big thing for me but I'm trying to do this because I can't afford to live on my pittance of an income. I have my mortgage to pay (£437/month), if I was in rented accommodation the DWP would be paying my rent but I get nothing towards the mortgage (I can't expect the state to buy my house) so trying to do this and paying all other living expenses on less than £700/month (which includes PIP payments) is almost impossible.

The thing about the council tax is that if the DWP were giving me the cash to pay my CT, I would benefit by about £3/week because of the rebate (this is what UC claimants will receive) but they pay mine direct so I won't benefit from it and its not just me but all other legacy benefit claimants. When you're not on the breadline you can't understand how much £3/wk means to someone who is. With all the increases in electricity charges, even back in September I was having to choose between eating and putting the lights on, never mind heating, I've not been able to afford to put my heating on for 2 winters now.

Mummyto2rugrats · 10/02/2022 11:33

Council tax bands do need an overhaul but not based necessarily on property prices as some will have been in their house since 80s / 90s never moved but property prices have shot up and vast majority in my Borough would be on band g or h which considering we are band E and ours is £2430 per year we wouldn't manage as g is currently £3158.06. We are not well of we have just been lucky with strategic moves to enable good schools (of which is actually trust run not authority!)

Council tax is there to pay for
The Borough Council (would love to see the numerous pot holes fill as should be with the money!)
Town Council
Adult social care
Fire authority
Police services

So surely this is something that could be a set amount across the board for all as we all will use the services equally or maybe I'm being simplistic!

ancientgran · 10/02/2022 11:30

@Tealightsandd

council lists are 10-20 years long in some parts of London.

Yes. And many London councils won't let many people even join the list.

Now I know things are beginning to get bad in some other parts of the country as 'levelling up' happens. Manchester, for example is discovering the 'benefits' of 'investment pricing people away from families, support networks, and communities.

But there's still quite some catching up to get to London level of bad.

I live in the south west and it is a problem here, ironically with "rich" Londoners pricing out the locals. Obviously people can move but it is hard on local people.

The other pressure is the lack of opportunities for our young people, my 4 all went to universities and have good jobs in either their university city or in the city their partners come from. There just aren't the opportunities here. Locally the older people with children still local are in a minority among the people I know.

ancientgran · 10/02/2022 11:26

@LethargicActress

the DWP pays my Council Tax direct, so I know it gets paid but don't have to pay it from my available cash as such.

@Harmonypuss I have sympathy for your situation, but quite simply, if you don’t have to pay council tax or it’s paid for you, then you don’t need a council tax rebate.

I hope there will be other measures that you can benefit from to help with the rising cost of living, but the fact that this isn’t one of them doesn’t mean it shouldn’t exist.

It’s a bit hypocritical of you to flippantly say that people have the option of moving house right after saying you couldn’t possibly be expected to switch to UC because you’d end up with a loan to pay back out of your benefits. Do you really think that selling a house, buying a new one and going through all the stress of moving, especially alone and elderly, is an easier process than moving onto universal credit?

Again, it’s people who already get help from the state begrudging a much smaller amount of help to others who also need it.

A very good post, considering various sides to this.

I do think this govt are doing a "divide and conquer" with organising things so that people are set against each other. It is very sad.

ancientgran · 10/02/2022 11:24

@Username1951

Equity release may be suitable for your neighbour to release some funds for him to live on, only drawback is the inheritance he leaves to family, friends or charities. Yes the council tax is not the right way to calculate what should be paid, but remember the Tories got burnt last time they tried to change it...... The tax needed should be collected and distributed nationally if we rally are serious on levelling up.
I think alot of elderly people have been frightened off equity release as there were some dubious schemes a few years ago. I would like to take out a lifetime mortgage as I would feel more in control of it but my DH won't hear of it. He's older than I am, I'm late 60s and he's late 70s, and I do think that age comes into it, at my age I think the majority of pensioners are enjoying life and getting out and about, I'm still working, but ten years on I think alot of people are less able and a bit more nervous. Not sure how common that is but it is something I have observed.
ancientgran · 10/02/2022 11:21

@lonelyapple

OP, perhaps he needs to cut down on his visits to the garden centre and Waitrose? Much of the council tax bill will be spent on social care for elderly people, so he probably benefits more from council tax than young people paying huge rents/mortgages in his area anyway.
How do you know he visits garden centres and Waitrose, I can't see that in the OPs posts, have I missed it? I'm retired and I have been to a garden centre once in the last 2 years, I went to meet someone for a coffee not to shop. I never go to Waitrose, firstly as we don't have one in my town and secondly when I went to one once when we were on holiday I wasn't very impressed. Do you just assume that is what the elderly spend all their time doing?

If you look at social care expenditure it is almost equal between under 65s and 65 and older. As people won't even be retired at 65 I think it is a bit of a fallacy that it is the retired who are benefiting from all the social care support.

Username1951 · 10/02/2022 11:00

Equity release may be suitable for your neighbour to release some funds for him to live on, only drawback is the inheritance he leaves to family, friends or charities. Yes the council tax is not the right way to calculate what should be paid, but remember the Tories got burnt last time they tried to change it...... The tax needed should be collected and distributed nationally if we rally are serious on levelling up.

Owl55 · 10/02/2022 10:25

My concern is if the government are giving £150 to those households the already underfunded local councils will have a shortfall in their budget and services will be reduced further for the vulnerable , Education services , social services etc 😢

lonelyapple · 10/02/2022 08:48

OP, perhaps he needs to cut down on his visits to the garden centre and Waitrose? Much of the council tax bill will be spent on social care for elderly people, so he probably benefits more from council tax than young people paying huge rents/mortgages in his area anyway.

LethargicActress · 10/02/2022 08:14

the DWP pays my Council Tax direct, so I know it gets paid but don't have to pay it from my available cash as such.

@Harmonypuss I have sympathy for your situation, but quite simply, if you don’t have to pay council tax or it’s paid for you, then you don’t need a council tax rebate.

I hope there will be other measures that you can benefit from to help with the rising cost of living, but the fact that this isn’t one of them doesn’t mean it shouldn’t exist.

It’s a bit hypocritical of you to flippantly say that people have the option of moving house right after saying you couldn’t possibly be expected to switch to UC because you’d end up with a loan to pay back out of your benefits. Do you really think that selling a house, buying a new one and going through all the stress of moving, especially alone and elderly, is an easier process than moving onto universal credit?

Again, it’s people who already get help from the state begrudging a much smaller amount of help to others who also need it.

Billandben444 · 10/02/2022 06:51

@Tealightsandd
But of course another major culprit is the dreadful 'bedroom tax', which has seriously depleted the supply of 1 and 2 bedroom homes
I don't understand how the bedroom tax affects this? Surely there are single people who would prefer a cheaper 1-bedroom home? Serious question, I'm trying to understand it all. Where I live just outside M25, we have massive home-building schemes but they are for either 3/4-storey flats (with no lifts) or family homes, no provision for the elderly wanting to downsize.

Tealightsandd · 10/02/2022 03:40

Stable affordable housing creates a more stable cohesive society. A more contented - and healthier one. Good for individuals, for families, and for the economy (and taxpayers).

I'll shut up now. (Way past bedtime but I made the mistake of caffeine whilst staying up for a chat with family in Australia Brew)

I'll sign off with something well worth remembering.

That altruism/morals was not the main reason why we created a welfare state - including social housing. It was self interest and economic good sense. Spend to save.

Huge numbers suffering increasingly desperate (physical or mental) deprivation costs the taxpayer many billions, but it can also eventually lead to dangerous instability. Or worse.

Here's to hope. Hope for a better fairer future where everybody, wherever they are in the country, can afford the essentials - housing, food, fuel, etc. - and even (gasp) some treats too...because there's a difference between existing and living. And because health is holistic - mental wellbeing affects physical health and vice versa.

Whether we'll see that as a reality, I don't know but it's a good one to dream of (and call for).

Tealightsandd · 10/02/2022 03:20

Tackling the public health housing and homelessness emergency (including increasing availability of smaller, and mobility and other accessible needs suitable homes) is not a miracle panacea. It won't magically make everything alright...but my goodness it would make an enormous difference.

I mean to the NHS - because bad, insecure, or no housing is hugely damaging to physical and mental health. It's certainly one of the reasons why an increasing number of working age people are currently too unwell to work. Hence a bigger burden of cost for the NHS.

Likewise the burden of cost on other public services. Of course there will still be need but it would be less - and therefore lower demand for certain council tax funded services...

Stable affordable housing creates a more stable cohesive society. A more contented - and healthier one. Good for individuals, for families, and for the economy (and taxpayers).

Companies particularly small ones can only increase wages by so much before going bust. And anyway those wage rises won't be able to keep up with the spiralling housing market.

If people have affordable stable housing, there's more money for other essentials including food and fuel - and also, more chance of spare money to spend on the economy... which means fewer leisure, retail, and hospitality job losses.

Swipe left for the next trending thread