Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refuse to provide a reference

162 replies

ByMyName · 07/02/2022 22:35

I own a small business and we provide employment to a small team.

Last year we took on a junior member of staff through a government backed scheme. The scheme reimbursed the business the cost of employing someone who was on UC and at risk of long term unemployment. In turn we provided training and work experience. Win-win.

This particular employee is on a fixed term contract. If it was not a government backed scheme, we would not have kept her for a week.

She was working from home as most of our staff do since covid. She had no childcare provision and her children would scream during staff meeting. She is constantly late and unavailable during working hours. She also had many sick days. Her work is poor and she has shown no improvement despite training and coaching.

Her line manager has had several informal conversations with her. I asked not to push to a formal warning as it was a fixed term contract anyway.

Can I inform the employee that we will not provide her with a reference?

OP posts:
WindyState · 08/02/2022 23:45

YABU. Just provide her with a basic reference.

TBH it sounds like you expect the moon on a stick. Cheap labour and an employee with a neat little life who fits exactly into your company.

A single mother relying on min wage and free childcare hours and you expect her to pay for wrap around care? Someone who you have clearly written off and aren't willing to coach and help through a formal process? Yeah, frankly it sounds like you are a shit employer and this person would be better off job hunting again.

Grenlei · 08/02/2022 23:42

'Teach her to problem solve...'

Jesus wept.

Honestly, some people will have an excuse for everything and it's rather naive to think they're all just hard done by and in need of support. Some people just don't want to be helped, they want an excuse not to do something. I can't say if this employee is one of those, but I suspect so. I've come across many people who do the whole 'I can't be expected to do X because...' innumerable times over the years. And even if you gave those people workable solutions to their issues, or even helped them see those solutions themselves, they'd find a reason why it wouldn't or couldn't work for them. Because they simply don't want to.

donquixotedelamancha · 08/02/2022 23:34

The main issue is she does not have childcare during all of her working hours. She uses the free 30 Hours and the rest of the time she has very young children around the house, who are very noisy. I am not sure how she manages any work with them around to be honest.

Surely that's a maximum of about 8 hours without childcare? Presumably she could make up the time when the kids are in bed? If noisy kids are the main issue that's a very poor reason for a disciplinary.

I spoke with her today and she got very emotional. She said I’m a single mother, what do you expect me to do? I explained that like every employer I expect her to have childcare arrangements during working hours.

I don't understand how, after all the comments on here, you can think that's a constructive and supportive comment. I wouldn't speak like that to anyone in tears, let alone someone the government was paying me to train back into the workforce.

Teach her to problem solve, help her figure out the best solution and set her small achieveable targets about to how improve her work. It's worth the managment time if for no other reason than it's good practice for you.

TheHateIsNotGood · 08/02/2022 23:34

Well chrissy if the employee in question is unable to obtain the prerequisite childcare then that makes her unemployable for awhile doesn't it.

But then, given that UC doesn't meet living costs, without employment this woman and her children will be propelled into a worsening cycle of poverty. I'm quite employment suitable, now,
never stopped working during the years of being an LP of a disabled child (now young adult) but had to be self-employed or unemployed.

And I can't get a job either - too fucking over the hill now.

Grenlei · 08/02/2022 23:32

Maybe the OPs employee is struggling financially.

Equally maybe she's also looking for an easy ride, or more charitably, going through the motions. Not everyone is diligent or committed. There are clearly issues with her performance generally, not just when her children are present.

Just because the OP is a business owner doesn't mean she has to bend over backwards to everyone she employs when they aren't putting any effort in themselves. It doesn't sound like the OP or other staff are unsympathetic per se, but this person simply isn't performing at any level. Not unreasonable to ensure she is well aware of those performance issues and that any reference will be no more than dates of employment, and will include sickness/ other absence, any Bradford triggers met etc.

It's not always as simple as she absolutely can't afford childcare either,; I have seen many posters on here since COVID who view working from home as an ideal opportunity to cut childcare costs by having children (babies in some cases) at home for at least part of the day. Often failing to see that the flexibility offered to parents during lockdown was an emergency measure and should not now become the norm...hence the outrage when people are asked back to the office 2 days a week and they are flapping about childcare for a full working day, when they should have continued to have this in place.

Catabogus · 08/02/2022 23:26

How many hours a week is the role? If she has 30hrs of childcare, that must cover the majority of her working hours, surely?

ChrissyPlummer · 08/02/2022 23:21

I can’t believe some of these responses! The woman is employed to do a job, as we all are. What would she do if the role was fully office based? It’s been pointed out many times on here that, barring emergencies, parents should have childcare in place while they’re working.

It might actually help her in future to fully explain what the expectations are (productivity targets, % calls answered etc) and that while she is working, she is meant to be working and not looking after children.

TheHateIsNotGood · 08/02/2022 23:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Gooseberrypies · 08/02/2022 23:18

And to add, yes YABU. Hopefully she can find a employer that pays enough to cover her childcare. You don’t need to add to that difficulty when you can just give a very basic ‘yes she worked here’ and dates. Why are you trying to make this poor woman’s life even more difficult?

Gooseberrypies · 08/02/2022 23:15

@ByMyName

Let me elaborate a little more. The employee has gone through induction and extensive training at a cost to the business. We have policies in place for sick days etc. All issues have been raised with her verbally and actions have been sent to her via email. I don’t want to raise any formal disciplinary as it’s not worth management time as we have decided not to keep her at the end of her contract.

The main issue is she does not have childcare during all of her working hours. She uses the free 30
Hours and the rest of the time she has very young children around the house, who are very noisy. I am not sure how she manages any work with them around to be honest.

Lockdown was an exceptional time but we did see a
decline in productivity. We are also very flexible when parents need to have children at home when sick etc. but I expect all staff to have childcare in place during their working hours.

I spoke with her today and she got very emotional. She said I’m a single mother, what do you expect me to do? I explained that like every employer I expect her to have childcare arrangements during working hours.

My own children are nursery as are the children of other staff members…

I wonder what her salary is Hmm My first salaried job, slightly above minimum wage for my contracted hours, barely covered my round the clock childcare, never mind my other bills (bearing in mind for most people these will be higher if working from home). She is using her 30 hours so she clearly is trying, but sadly the support is not as great as it seems - even with the %of childcare costs you get back from the job centre - you have to pay it upfront and then get it reimbursed rather than them paying their bit and you paying yours, and it left me in an endless cycle of debt. I suspect she is really struggling and was told she has to apply and take on the job even if unsuitable in order to no keep her benefits (which of course in turn would cause a massive knock on effect such as losing housing and other support).
Fiddlesticky · 08/02/2022 23:12

Gosh what a nasty post. Give the poor woman a break, and a reference.

What benefit would you get if you didn't?

Oh that's right, the satisfaction of making someone who is clearly already struggling feel even lower. 👍

TheHateIsNotGood · 08/02/2022 23:04

Oh do not perturb yourself too much. As a current mature job seeker I can assure you that about 50% of the jobs advertised in my area are govt-backed schemes - Kickstart being the flavour of the moment. And 50% of the rest are for elderly carers.

Of the rest that I'm suitably qualified and experienced for, there's major hoop-jumping and a definite reliance on software and various 'online' tests to weed out, if not the 'slackers', then just about everybody else. Eg: my local District Council's Recruitment software asks for my "Social Security Number" - we're in Devon ffs, not bloody California.

After failing an online personality test for emptying bins and picking up dog poo, amongst many other test failures - if your employee passes these hoops and you're actually contacted for a reference - well, it's time for me to head back to the caves.

RitaJosephina · 08/02/2022 22:45

@ByMyName and let me guess, as it's a government scheme she only gets paid minimum wage and you expect her to be able to afford the childcare...

ByMyName · 08/02/2022 18:06

Let me elaborate a little more. The employee has gone through induction and extensive training at a cost to the business. We have policies in place for sick days etc. All issues have been raised with her verbally and actions have been sent to her via email. I don’t want to raise any formal disciplinary as it’s not worth management time as we have decided not to keep her at the end of her contract.

The main issue is she does not have childcare during all of her working hours. She uses the free 30
Hours and the rest of the time she has very young children around the house, who are very noisy. I am not sure how she manages any work with them around to be honest.

Lockdown was an exceptional time but we did see a
decline in productivity. We are also very flexible when parents need to have children at home when sick etc. but I expect all staff to have childcare in place during their working hours.

I spoke with her today and she got very emotional. She said I’m a single mother, what do you expect me to do? I explained that like every employer I expect her to have childcare arrangements during working hours.

My own children are nursery as are the children of other staff members…

OP posts:
PatsyJStone · 08/02/2022 06:51

Unless you’ve discussed the issues with her first,you shouldn’t go straight into a formal warning.
Her manager should talk to her about the problems with her performance and sickness, and disruption during meetings. You should have an absence policy you can use regarding her sick days.
Explain to her that these issues could be a problem to any future employer. If she’s been out of the workplace a long time she may not have this awareness.

Regarding the reference a basic worked from date to date is acceptable. You can answer questions about sickness absence and if you would re employ if you are asked, but you should have a policy and give all ex employees the same reference if you are approached. Don’t treat one differently to another. Don’t do the ‘give me a ring’ approach.
You aren’t doing her any favours by just saying you won’t give her a reference. She needs to be made aware of the issues with her performance etc. That is how you will be fulfilling your side of the deal getting a paid employee for six months.

I have worked with many on this type of scheme and some don’t last, you can end their employment as long as you do it all in the correct way. I have also worked with many successfully. You have just ended up with the wrong person, please don’t be put off.

formalineadeline · 08/02/2022 05:02

Long term unemployed to trying to start a new job fully remote is a tall order! People struggle to settle into remote roles when they have a lot of workplace experience to fall back on, nevermind with none.

You have hardly upheld your side of the bargain here by failing to manage her performance and writing her off. Formal performance management is about clearly communicating expectations and ensuring staff have the right training/support to change things - it sets out a pathway for improvement. You have denied her that.

If you only give someone vague informal chats, they rarely leave those chats realising how serious matters are or how they should change them. Most people's view is that if it was a serious problem it would have been a serious discussion.

How was she supposed to improve if you failed to communicate to her how serious her conduct was and the consequences of it?

thingymaboob · 08/02/2022 04:31

You'll put her in a shit situation if you don't provide a reference. All you need to do is confirm the dates that she worked for you and her job role. No opinions about work standard etc. Just factual.

RedWingBoots · 08/02/2022 04:21

From that you could add a final paragraph along the lines of ''if you would like further information, I (HR etc) can be contacted during business hours on (business number).

Don't do this.

I know someone who successfully sued their ex-employer for doing something like this. They managed to get notes from their prospective new employer as references aren't confidential in the UK.

Just give the dates and job title.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 08/02/2022 04:10

@ByMyName

I own a small business and we provide employment to a small team.

Last year we took on a junior member of staff through a government backed scheme. The scheme reimbursed the business the cost of employing someone who was on UC and at risk of long term unemployment. In turn we provided training and work experience. Win-win.

This particular employee is on a fixed term contract. If it was not a government backed scheme, we would not have kept her for a week.

She was working from home as most of our staff do since covid. She had no childcare provision and her children would scream during staff meeting. She is constantly late and unavailable during working hours. She also had many sick days. Her work is poor and she has shown no improvement despite training and coaching.

Her line manager has had several informal conversations with her. I asked not to push to a formal warning as it was a fixed term contract anyway.

Can I inform the employee that we will not provide her with a reference?

Its only win win for you. A free employee! Have you ever actually sat down and spoken to the woman to see if a solution could be found? Surely you knew that someone on one of these schemes may need much more support than a regular employee or did you just want 6 months free labour? Back in the 80's I was part of a company who assessed and found placements for unemployed people on training schemes. We had many employers who were fantastic. They would mentor the trainees, support them and work out problems when they cropped up. Inevitably those trainees usually went on to get jobs. The few employers who treated the trainees as cheap labour were very obvious and were very quickly weeded out and told they were not suitable.
buddylicious · 08/02/2022 04:10

You should treat her like any other employee and give her verbal or written warnings etc. Otherwise you are teaching her that it's ok to carry on like this in the workplace and she will never hold down a job in future!

Sugarplumfairy65 · 08/02/2022 03:55

It sounds like the poor woman is juggling working, keeping UC happy and lack of childcare.
She's obviously struggling. What support have you given her given that she's not costing you anything to employ her? She's on this scheme because she's been out of the workplace for a long time and needs extra support and more training than a regular employee that you actually pay for would.
Why would you kick someone when they are down?

expat101 · 08/02/2022 01:02

^^ used us as a reference as a former employee to a potentially new employer

expat101 · 08/02/2022 00:58

Firstly I would wait until she asks for a reference. She may well not.

If she does, give the most bog standard you legally have to apply. When I lived in Australia, it had to be the starting and ending date, plus job title.

From that you could add a final paragraph along the lines of ''if you would like further information, I (HR etc) can be contacted during business hours on (business number).

You can add the word confidentially in there somewhere if you wish.

That leaves all personal experiences and thoughts off the letter, employee has what she needs to account for her time, and gives the opportunity for the next employer to contact you directly where you can talk.

We had a call last week for a former employee who used us as a reference as a former employer, he worked with us for a while, but he didn't tell the interviewer he abandoned his employment with us. So we had a chat about that.

CaptainCabinets · 08/02/2022 00:33

You don’t have to sing her praises but why would you want to make it difficult for her to find future employment? Just confirm that she worked there from X to Y dates.

Ozanj · 08/02/2022 00:31

It’s mean to deny a reference for someone who is learning how to work, when you haven’t done your job properly in managing her / setting performance goals in the first place. keep it basic and factual - you only need dates of employment, role title etc

Swipe left for the next trending thread