Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refuse to provide a reference

162 replies

ByMyName · 07/02/2022 22:35

I own a small business and we provide employment to a small team.

Last year we took on a junior member of staff through a government backed scheme. The scheme reimbursed the business the cost of employing someone who was on UC and at risk of long term unemployment. In turn we provided training and work experience. Win-win.

This particular employee is on a fixed term contract. If it was not a government backed scheme, we would not have kept her for a week.

She was working from home as most of our staff do since covid. She had no childcare provision and her children would scream during staff meeting. She is constantly late and unavailable during working hours. She also had many sick days. Her work is poor and she has shown no improvement despite training and coaching.

Her line manager has had several informal conversations with her. I asked not to push to a formal warning as it was a fixed term contract anyway.

Can I inform the employee that we will not provide her with a reference?

OP posts:
ByMyName · 09/02/2022 13:35

@Overandout1

She has some experience in this specific field of work. She came across as enthusiastic during the interview process. The interview process was less thorough as requested by the scheme.

She is paid more than minimum wage and has access to the same perks offered to all our employees. She is not paying anything for the 30 hours childcare. Of course she needs to pay extra for additional hours, but she’s just refusing to put her DCs in additional hours.

Everyone else in the business does.

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 09/02/2022 13:26

@RitaJosephina

OP was literally being paid the full cost of employing her to try to help this woman prepare for the work force. - spot on.

That's the point of these schemes, not a free labour from highly qualified and skilled person...

Our 2 actually cost us money in terms of the time we spent trying to get them to actually contribute One had never actually made a phone call before and the other suffers from such extreme anxiety they can’t make phone calls - this is a key part of the job. One of them we have managed to find things for them to do but it’s busy work to keep them from getting bored. Just because something is free it doesn’t make it any good
Hoppinggreen · 09/02/2022 13:17

Is this Kickstarter?
We took on 2, one lasted 2 weeks and one will be leaving when her 6 months is up. Pair of them are bloody pointless
If asked we would probably just provide the bare facts - x worked here under the Kickstarter scheme between (date) and (date) and no more.
Why even get into with her before she asks?

Dishwashersaurous · 09/02/2022 13:14

No one is saying its OK to work with children around. They are saying that she might need to have this spelt out to her more clearly and that it needed to be addressed

RitaJosephina · 09/02/2022 13:03

@ByMyName
I'm pretty sure people are generally aware of workplace expectations, but I'm not sure if you adjusted your expectations considering the nature of the scheme. If you truly coached and supported her than fair enough, but I'm not sure you realise that she simply might not have had enough money to cover wraparound childcare. In usual circumstances people calculate if they can afford to go to work when having small children (that's actually ridiculous, but that's the reality of current lack of support for parents). If she was made to take part in this scheme and is paid minimum wage then I'm sorry but you have to adjust your expectations.

Overandout1 · 09/02/2022 11:55

@ByMyName does she have any experience at all in the area she is working in? Or have they basically just put someone with no experience into this particular job role?

In fairness, if she's free and you wouldn't have kept her on for a week, then she must be bad!

Personally as others have said, you can just provide a basic and factual reference. However I'm largely on your side OP, if you can't get childcare/fulfill the job requirements (and it sounds like she had been supported) then she shouldn't be in the role. It's hard as a single mum and trying to work. I have been in that situation, I still have to limit my work hours more than I like because I have to balance childcare costs and work. Unfortunately it's the reality for many, many people!
Does she get paid properly for the role? I'm assuming it much more than minimum wage, however regardless of this I'm assuming the idea with the scheme is that you make an effort to build up your skills and impress your employer with a view you may be hired and then further down the line, potentially a pay increase.

Are these schemes offered to everyone? Forced? Or just offered to a select few that apply?

ByMyName · 09/02/2022 11:40

It is surprising how many people do not understand what are workplace expectations.

The scheme pays for the employee’s salary but as an employer there are more costs than only salary when we recruit someone.

We would not have been fined or anything if we terminated her contract early. I wanted to give her 6 months of good work experience. She has been trained and coached. She has been told where to
improve verbally and in writing. I did not put any formal disciplinary in place.

The main issue has been childcare. I’m surprised by how many people think it’s ok for someone to be working from home with no childcare in place.

She is not our only employee. However none of our other employees have their children at home when they are working.

OP posts:
RitaJosephina · 09/02/2022 11:16

OP was literally being paid the full cost of employing her to try to help this woman prepare for the work force. - spot on.

That's the point of these schemes, not a free labour from highly qualified and skilled person...

donquixotedelamancha · 09/02/2022 10:42

Honestly, some people will have an excuse for everything and it's rather naive to think they're all just hard done by and in need of support. Some people just don't want to be helped

OP was literally being paid the full cost of employing her to try to help this woman prepare for the work force.

Of course some people don't want to improve but they are few in number and you don't know until you try. OP doesn't seem to have engaged constructively and some of her complaints seem petty. I am suggesting that more could be done to support this employee.

sillylittleflowers · 09/02/2022 10:37

YABU either let her go or do something constructive. I like the PP idea of allowing pt so she works the hours when she has childcare. Then you can go from there and separate it's the job she can't do or genuinely the dc in the background causing the issues.

emuloc · 09/02/2022 09:55

Yabu. You sound mean.

Hankunamatata · 09/02/2022 09:47

I can see why your annoyed.

If she has 30 free hours of childcare would it not be worth discussing with her about dropping her working week to 30 hours?

Dishwashersaurous · 09/02/2022 09:30

If she's on UC, then 85% of childcare costs will be covered. It seems like her job coach has helped explain this.

Could you change her role to part time so that she only works when she does have childcare, and adjust pay accordingly

TheDogsMother · 09/02/2022 09:26

Recruiter here and it's pretty standard that companies just verify dates and job title. Many say it is their policy not to provide any other information. Just make this your policy and you protect yourself from being taken to an employment tribunal and this woman gets another chance somewhere else that might be more geared up to support her.

longwayoff · 09/02/2022 09:23

You have got a 'free' employee. She's not good enough for you, you resent her and want to further complicate her life by refusing a reference. How very Victorian. I think you should also turn her away from your door and point her towards the nearest workhouse. You know that phrase 'you get what you pay for'? Apply it to your workforce.

Brainwave89 · 09/02/2022 09:18

I would provide just the standard details as above. Even if you get a telephone call asking for further details, unless a formal HR process has been followed you should never elaborate on your perception of performance the legal risks are too high. You managed your risk by having her on a FTC. Pity her new employer.

WindyState · 09/02/2022 09:14

"we would not have kept her for a week."

That's not being kind.

That's writing someone off from the get-go.

Earlydancing · 09/02/2022 00:24

@user062648910

I must say I wouldn’t want to work at your company after reading your OP. How petty and vindictive to not give a factual reference than any other employer would. I am assuming this is a small company but your management style needs work and you should be more supportive to your employees who are trying to get into work. This is a government backed scheme ffs.
I think the company are being quite kind actually. If it were me, I'd terminate her contract early. I suspect the only reason this company isn't is because there'll be penalties under the scheme. It's a place of work not a social centre.
ambushedbywine · 09/02/2022 00:21

Was she actually paid properly? I think a temp scheme does make it hard to commit to childcare that's probably more than she could afford. Personally I'd give someone the benefit of the doubt.

Earlydancing · 09/02/2022 00:20

I wouldn't give her a reference. How is that fair to any other company who might look at employing her? And the Benefits Office need to know that in her present situation she is unsuitable for work.

user062648910 · 09/02/2022 00:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

user062648910 · 09/02/2022 00:14

I must say I wouldn’t want to work at your company after reading your OP. How petty and vindictive to not give a factual reference than any other employer would. I am assuming this is a small company but your management style needs work and you should be more supportive to your employees who are trying to get into work. This is a government backed scheme ffs.

NeverChange · 09/02/2022 00:01

Cannot believe some of the responses here.

The OP higher someone to do a job that they have not performed well.

Why on earth would they treat her any different to anyone else in the same position? Fully appreciate it's difficult to manage job and being a single mum but that's not her employers problem.

No one wants to give a false reference as I'm sure the OP wouldn't appreciate it if they hired someone on the bais of a false reference.

I would leave it non specific, X was employed under X scheme from dates Y to Z.

TheHateIsNotGood · 08/02/2022 23:58

Best get your next govt-subsidised employee from the Kickstart scheme, it's for young people aged under 25 so generally childcare shouldn't be a 'factor' to account for.

Let's face it - it's actually impossible for any LP on a low-wage to use state-subsidized childcare as their only childcare option and fulfill the expectations of most employers.

No blame, it's just a fact. It's always only been possible with 'informal' childcare available too. Not so long ago this was the only option, including the 'local woman' who took in kids at a price the working mothers could afford, completely unregulated of course.

Never mind teenagers demanding £10ph for babysitting, rather than a couple of quid for the freedom, tv and phone.

Single parents have always been around, but society as we know it now, hasn't.

Ikeptgoing · 08/02/2022 23:51

You can state she was employed through govmt backed scheme from this date to this date. We would not have continued to employ her

You Can be factual and say less is more

Really though when an employer says person employed from x to x date, l(& on a scheme) and nothing more, it speaks volumes

They can ring you for rent and you can verbally say "I can't discuss but we would not have chosen to employ afterwards"

Usually when someone is a good employer people fall over themselves today what a lovely employee...

Swipe left for the next trending thread