Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refuse to provide a reference

162 replies

ByMyName · 07/02/2022 22:35

I own a small business and we provide employment to a small team.

Last year we took on a junior member of staff through a government backed scheme. The scheme reimbursed the business the cost of employing someone who was on UC and at risk of long term unemployment. In turn we provided training and work experience. Win-win.

This particular employee is on a fixed term contract. If it was not a government backed scheme, we would not have kept her for a week.

She was working from home as most of our staff do since covid. She had no childcare provision and her children would scream during staff meeting. She is constantly late and unavailable during working hours. She also had many sick days. Her work is poor and she has shown no improvement despite training and coaching.

Her line manager has had several informal conversations with her. I asked not to push to a formal warning as it was a fixed term contract anyway.

Can I inform the employee that we will not provide her with a reference?

OP posts:
ByMyName · 11/02/2022 07:45

@RedWingBoots thank you for this. We have a policy about distractions but not dependants. This is a really good term.

@Mogwig we offered her to work only the hours when her DCs are in nursery, effectively going part time. She refused. We also offered that she works evenings when DCs are in bed. Some of our staff do this to make up hours when doing school pickups. Again, she refused.

As an employer offering above market pay, it is not my role to budget for my employees’ expenses or to assess what childcare is available where they live. To everyone suggesting this - does your employer offer this???

OP posts:
DePfeffoff · 11/02/2022 07:38

If she's 'using her free 30 hours', does that mean you have 30 hours of her time no problem, because the kids are in free child care?

Well, no, RTF OP. Despite having 30 hours a week available, she's constantly late and unavailable during working hours, has taken many sick days, and such work as she does is poor despite training, coaching and informal talks to help her improve. So OP still has several problems.

Some of the responses on this thread are ridiculous. Most single parents in this employee's position would be working their socks off to prove themselves even if they can't find child care, but this one just isn't. But the hard-of-thinking around here have decided that 'single mother' must mean put-upon saint and OP must be a Victorian villain, and/or are simply indulging in the usual nasty unthinking MN pile-on.

Mogwig · 11/02/2022 07:15

If she's 'using her free 30 hours', does that mean you have 30 hours of her time no problem, because the kids are in free child care?

So how many hours is she struggling with the kids? 5? 7?

You do presumably realise that a single mum on UC can't possibly afford nursery?

You should work with her on those hours where she has the kids. You are an employer. Even though you'll let her go in two months' time, you should still treat her decently now.

Why wouldn't you give a basic reference? I'm glad you've accepted that.

Tbh it sounds as if you dislike her a lot.

BobbleAlong · 11/02/2022 07:05

Maybe she couldn't afford childcare provision. UC isn't a big payer.

Regardless, just provide her with a dated reference like nearly every other company does now. For an activity that will take you less than 5 minutes there's a huge benefit to her. Poor woman is probably acutely aware of her unsuitability for the role hence the sickness absence, and it will be eating away at her confidence

McClary111 · 11/02/2022 06:59

Sorry posted to soon. I am not saying you have treated her badly but the gov pushes people into schemes with the threat of sanctions. It must be terrifying.

My friend had to attend a UC meeting During her working day! So 2.5 hours of work missed (works over 30 hours a week). She has never not had a job, leaving an arsehole partner meant she needed childcare help until they start school. She was so scared in the job centre she threw up. She knew that if they didn’t give her the money for childcare she couldn’t work. Her wage (though decent) is not enough to cover almost £1000 a month in childcare costs). The system is ridiculous.

McClary111 · 11/02/2022 06:52

Assuming she is working a 40 hour week and nursery is within 20 mins of her home she needs to pay for approx 13.5 hours childcare for 2 children (I’m guessing 2). This may be rounded up as some nursery’s offer am or pm sessions.

The cheap nursery near us would round up to 15 hours and is £5 per hour per child. So £150 a week, £600 to find for a 4 week month. Plus meal costs. She would have to find this two times before UC reimbursed her. This may not be possible.

Her embarrassment at being poor may be why she doesn’t want to increase nursery.
Does she know about the flexible fund for childcare? Is she confident enough to ask for it and push for it.

It’s disgusting how single parents are treated whilst absent parents can Swan off and pay fuck all.

UnexpectedItemInShaggingArea · 11/02/2022 05:54

All the Kickstarter stuff is a red herring. She's not meeting the requirements of the job and refusing to find appropriate work arounds for her childcare situation.

I think you have been more than fair OP.

RedWingBoots · 11/02/2022 05:13

However, we've NEVER had anyone keeping young children at home while working.

OP do you have a company policy about caring for dependants including children while working? If not you need one.

I say dependants as I was on a work call once and someone's elderly mother interrupted the call. It was quickly explained the mother had dementia. (To be fair she only did it once.)

We start at 9 and she is often late.
Clearly come back from dropping her children off.

ByMyName · 10/02/2022 10:04

@C8H10N4O2

We interviewed her in September at the office and made an offer for her to start in October. We were not aware that she had DCs or any childcare issues during the interview. After we made her an offer to start in October, she casually mentioned that she has 2 young children. We asked if she would have childcare in place in October and she said she would and in any case, her mum lives nearby and would take care of the children.

She then starts in October and mentions in passing to her line manager that she has a partner at home who is taking care of the children. During staff meetings, we could hear the children and the partner in the background. During staff meeting, the children would interrupt. Her line manager spoke with her. She said she was waiting on a nursery place and it would get better.

Eventually the children start at nursery. We do not see/hear them in the morning meetings. Other staff mention that when they are having meetings with her in the afternoon, there are children around. Her line manager also points that she is making a lot of mistakes during those times. We then find out that for some days of the week, her children come back at 12.

We start at 9 and she is often late.

I don't know about the availability or affordability of childcare for all employees obviously. We all make our own arrangements and it's never been an issue before. We've been flexible and have been offering WFH from before Covid. The concept is not new to us. However, we've NEVER had anyone keeping young children at home while working.

The problem is that her performance is impacted on the afternoons when her children are at home. It also affects the team as whole and my other staff.

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 10/02/2022 08:35

She had 2 children who are both in free 30 hours childcare

So a 3 yr old and a 4yr old, both going to childcare for 30 hours a week? In your OP you said:
She had no childcare provision and her children would scream during staff meeting. She is constantly late and unavailable during working hours which suggested to me that the kids are running around all day.

But if both children are in childcare 30 hours a week then surely most of the working hours are covered?

She would have to pay extra for additional hours and she is refusing to send them for additional hours

You didn't answer my question about availability and affordability of those hours during the last two years, however if 30 of her working hours are covered with childcare provision then is it only the other hours that work quality dips or is this nothing to do with childcare and simply a performance issue which needed to be addressed earlier?

How many of her working hours are impacted by the children being around and do you see a notable difference?

Working in the evenings instead can work fine if its a couple of hours around a school pickup but not so easily if its more than half of each day.

Having done scattered hours around the clock with small children when starting a business the only way I was able to make it work was with the help of OH.

You seem completely focused on childcare as the problem but its not clear from your descriptions just how much that is the problem. Presumably you need to feedback to the scheme when you renew/don't renew and want to be clear where the problem was rooted in childcare and where it was general skills or ability to acquire skills remotely.

ByMyName · 10/02/2022 08:17

Hi @C8H10N4O2

We suggested that she makes up the hours after the children have gone to bed. Other team members who do school pick up will often do this. We allow for this flexibility. This employee said it would not work for her.

She had 2 children who are both in free 30 hours childcare. She would have to pay extra for additional hours and she is refusing to send them for additional hours.

Many of my staff are mothers. We understand and are fully supportive if their child needs to be picked up early on the odd day or that a child has been sick and needs to be home for a couple of days. We are aware that some parents have older children at home with them during school holidays. These are all exceptional circumstances. We are more flexible than most employers. However, our policy is that you need to have childcare arrangements in place for working hours.

We should have addressed it sooner but I guess this is something new for us too. I could not expect that anyone would think it’s appropriate to have 2 young children around while they are meant to be working. But as I said, we also learned from it as a business and we are better prepared if we come across this situation again.

OP posts:
Catlover77 · 10/02/2022 08:12

I have used the kick start scheme. Discuss with your provider and then end her contract. There is no need to issue warnings, you have discussed the issues, she has not improved. She has no employment rights (the same as an employee in probation) so you can part ways if it is not working.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/02/2022 07:50

We have suggested that she works evenings but she has turned down the offer. She wants to work with her DCs around. It just doesn’t work

If she is single who then looks after the children in the evening?

You say children plural - how many hours of childcare a week would she actually need against the 30 free hours for a 3/4 yr old? Are all her children eligible for the 30 hours? Are the local nurseries taking free childcare vouchers without top ups? What reason does she give for not using paid care?

Then of course, is it even available in her area? If you have numbers of staff with childcare arranged you will know what a nightmare it has been even for those with the money. A huge amount of provision has shut down, other providers have had to constantly close and reopen due to isolation/covid outbreaks.

If none of your other staff have had these problems and interruptions to childcare then I'm very surprised.

As for performance management - I'm sure you know this should have been addressed a lot sooner rather than drift along informally. However expecting anyone to get up to speed and fit in well after long term unemployment, especially with small children to manage, was always going to be a struggle. Presumably the 18 yr old boy doesn't have the same external challenges to manage compared to the single mother?

Roselilly36 · 10/02/2022 07:26

@TheDogsMother

Recruiter here and it's pretty standard that companies just verify dates and job title. Many say it is their policy not to provide any other information. Just make this your policy and you protect yourself from being taken to an employment tribunal and this woman gets another chance somewhere else that might be more geared up to support her.
This is good advice.
Cazziebo · 10/02/2022 07:21

The OP has a duty of care to all employees. An underperforming employee impacts on everyone and can make work unpleasant for the whole team. This employee is not more important than the others. She's been given the opportunity and she hasn't appreciated it. I don't know any companies that would tolerate working with children around unless it was exceptional circumstances (like the first lockdowns).

OP - good on you for giving her a chance.

ByMyName · 09/02/2022 19:16

@caringcarer

You should treat this employee exactly the same as any other employee. Otherwise she will not know what standard is expected in the workplace. You should feedback any issues like having young children running around to scheme she is under.
I have fed back the childcare issues to the scheme. A work coach from the scheme will be having a chat with her on Friday.
OP posts:
caringcarer · 09/02/2022 19:13

You should treat this employee exactly the same as any other employee. Otherwise she will not know what standard is expected in the workplace. You should feedback any issues like having young children running around to scheme she is under.

JenniferWooley · 09/02/2022 18:58

@SamphiretheStickerist

and only if the parent knows about it and asks? Does that little gem still stand?

You have to know that something exists and ask for it before they will tell you about it?

I remember having a stand up/sit down argument about that with my advisor - in the last century!!

I worked in the jobcentre many moons ago & the policy was if they don't ask you don't tell - basically they ask if they're eligible for JSA & they're not don't suggest they may be eligible for IS.

I used to tell everyone I know to as "what am I eligible for" as a catch all.

sonjadog · 09/02/2022 17:50

I think a date only reference is the way to go on this one. Don't write off the scheme though. There will always be people it doesn't work out for, but there will also be opportunities to gain really good employees through it.

drpet49 · 09/02/2022 17:33

I wouldn’t give her a reference either. She is a total pisstaker

ByMyName · 09/02/2022 17:28

@MissMaple82 if you read through my posts you will see that I said I would write a basic reference but it would be misleading for me to write something glowing about an employee who is refusing the most basic request that during the hours that she is employed and paid by the business, she needs to focus on work and not have the distraction of young children. I am really surprised by how out of touch some people are about basic work requirements.

OP posts:
MissMaple82 · 09/02/2022 16:43

You'd be a massive 🛎 end if you didn't provide one as everybody needs to provide references. You'd be pretty stupid if you can't articulate some positives from your staff. Nobody is that bad! Besides that, references don't even have to say anything other than confirmation and duration of employment, so you've no excuse not to really.

GreenDressRedWine · 09/02/2022 16:23

I think you've been given a really hard time on here op - I don't think people realise how draining and expensive it can be to a small business to have to deal with this kind of situation and how much it costs to recruit, train, coach etc. Hopefully everyone comes out of the scheme a bit wiser and knows what they would have done differently.

ByMyName · 09/02/2022 16:07

@elbea

I have a great employer who is 100% flexible with my hours. My daughter does nursery three days a week at a cost of £800 plus food, nappies etc… It’s only affordable to do because I can bring my daughter to work with me, work evenings and weekends. I appreciate not all jobs are appropriate for toddlers but mine is.

How do you propose a single mother afford childcare on minimum wage for more than one child doing a scheme she has likely been forced to do.

We have suggested that she works evenings but she has turned down the offer. She wants to work with her DCs around. It just doesn’t work.

She is not on minimum wage, we top up her salary.

OP posts:
SamphiretheStickerist · 09/02/2022 16:03

Elbea & Butterflaky Read all of OPs posts. Unbelievably, as an employer, OP had already thought of that. She has outlined what changes in hours were offered - all were refused.

Swipe left for the next trending thread