Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refuse to provide a reference

162 replies

ByMyName · 07/02/2022 22:35

I own a small business and we provide employment to a small team.

Last year we took on a junior member of staff through a government backed scheme. The scheme reimbursed the business the cost of employing someone who was on UC and at risk of long term unemployment. In turn we provided training and work experience. Win-win.

This particular employee is on a fixed term contract. If it was not a government backed scheme, we would not have kept her for a week.

She was working from home as most of our staff do since covid. She had no childcare provision and her children would scream during staff meeting. She is constantly late and unavailable during working hours. She also had many sick days. Her work is poor and she has shown no improvement despite training and coaching.

Her line manager has had several informal conversations with her. I asked not to push to a formal warning as it was a fixed term contract anyway.

Can I inform the employee that we will not provide her with a reference?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dishwashersaurous · 11/02/2022 13:46

Agree that kick-start is a training scheme. And the op said that she provided lots of training and support.

It seems that the issue around working without childcare wasn't addressed adequately.

Op felt that everyone would understand the workplace expectations not to work with children around.

When that wasn't understood then op didn't follow through correctly.

She.should have insisted on hours being cut to only those when childcare was provided, and that they could increase if childcare was arranged.

Instead, the worker was allowed to carry on working with her children around. And because she was doing it, she probably thought that it was OK to do it.

JenniferWooley · 11/02/2022 13:27

I dont think Kickstarter is a job I think thats the main issue here, its a training scheme, a 25 hour a week training scheme to teach skills/give work experience, they are not expected to be employees, they are not expected to hit the ground running and be on a par with experienced staff, if they were there would be no point in the scheme because the people being put on it will already have no barriers to work.*

This 100%

It's an awful scheme with many employers running their hands with glee at the prospect of free labour & no thought or consideration of the actual purpose of the scheme.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 11/02/2022 12:09

Talk about drip feed!

VelvetChairGirl · 11/02/2022 12:01

@RedWingBoots

I only do it now because I got such a bollocking from a interview for co-op a few years ago, but they didnt state the hours and days on the job advert only the total number of hours a week so they had no right to bitch at me like that.

@VelvetChairGirl there is no need to tell potential employers you have children, you just need to find out the hours and if they don't suit you say they don't suit you. They are actually at fault for not telling you that they expected you to work at any time.

Even before I had a child there were employers who took the piss on how long they expected staff to work and with shift patterns.

She's probably terrified of being sanctioned, it sounds to me like she is trying and I am not surprised she didnt mention/lied about kids when she applied that in itself shows she wants to work.
She isn't trying though.

There may be good reasons why she can't make up work in the evenings when her children are asleep but she can tell her manager.

There may be good reasons why she is sometimes late e.g. dropping of children at the nursery, but she can tell her manager.

They all take the piss even the ones that want people for as little as 4 hours a week want someone who can be available at opening and closing times. I think the worst one I applied for was the local Vue, part time job but expected to be available from 9am to 3am all days of the week.

they all want the moon on a stick.

I dont think Kickstarter is a job I think thats the main issue here, its a training scheme, a 25 hour a week training scheme to teach skills/give work experience, they are not expected to be employees, they are not expected to hit the ground running and be on a par with experienced staff, if they were there would be no point in the scheme because the people being put on it will already have no barriers to work.

RedWingBoots · 11/02/2022 11:55

I only do it now because I got such a bollocking from a interview for co-op a few years ago, but they didnt state the hours and days on the job advert only the total number of hours a week so they had no right to bitch at me like that.

@VelvetChairGirl there is no need to tell potential employers you have children, you just need to find out the hours and if they don't suit you say they don't suit you. They are actually at fault for not telling you that they expected you to work at any time.

Even before I had a child there were employers who took the piss on how long they expected staff to work and with shift patterns.

She's probably terrified of being sanctioned, it sounds to me like she is trying and I am not surprised she didnt mention/lied about kids when she applied that in itself shows she wants to work.
She isn't trying though.

There may be good reasons why she can't make up work in the evenings when her children are asleep but she can tell her manager.

There may be good reasons why she is sometimes late e.g. dropping of children at the nursery, but she can tell her manager.

Christmaswindows · 11/02/2022 11:51

I don't actually think your business is cut out to take part in this type of scheme.

LaBellina · 11/02/2022 11:50

My father deals with this issue as an employer by simply stating that they have worked in this and this job title during an X period of time. He does not provide any further information. When HR from another company calls and asks what he thinks about them as an employee/ the work they did he usually replies with ‘no comment’. He tells them this way they weren’t a good employee without actually saying it.

Branleuse · 11/02/2022 11:43

Refusing to give a reference at all is too harsh. Just give a factual reference saying that she was employed by you on a kickstart scheme for 6 months and the dates she was there till. Thats all it has to say.

Having childcare issues that affect performance during the pandemic is hardly crime of the century. Its not gross misconduct, and the government paid their wages for the 6 months so while youd have hoped it would have worked better you werent left out of pocket and you werent forced to keep them on after the 6 months.
The kickstart scheme has finished now anyway despite it being a really successful scheme for many young people. I think refusing to provide a reference at all is really petty and shitty. Your free employee wasnt as good as you hoped because of her childcare issues. Thats all

MandyCarter · 11/02/2022 11:32

Fucking hell I wish I had a boss who offered me choices like you have. She's not interested in helping herself and from the sound of it is just biding her time until she can leave
Such a shame if that's the case as there are so many people who would jump at the opportunity
But yes, I'd give her a basic reference

VelvetChairGirl · 11/02/2022 11:29

[quote ByMyName]@VelvetChairGirl

When we found out that childcare was an issue, we offered to reduce her contract hours. We gave her the option to work part-time for when she has childcare in place. It does not work out at 30 hours as she needs time to drop off / pick up. We offered to revise her contract and offered her pro-rata hours and pay. She REFUSED!

The scheme representative will be speaking with her today anyway.[/quote]
But she cant work part time the scheme is 25 hours a week thats not part time to the JCP, part time is 16 hours or less (My JCP claimant agreement is for part time), to be eligible she has to work 25 and god alone knows what the advisor has said to her half of them dont know their arses from their elbows anyway.

maybe she doesnt have 30 hours free childcare a week as I said it depends on demand maybe she can only get morning sessions.

She's probably terrified of being sanctioned, it sounds to me like she is trying and I am not surprised she didnt mention/lied about kids when she applied that in itself shows she wants to work.

I always write on cover letters I am looking to work during the school hours due to childcare commitments, but many advisors do not advice you give reasons not to be employed (i.e telling employers you have kids) I only do it now because I got such a bollocking from a interview for co-op a few years ago, but they didnt state the hours and days on the job advert only the total number of hours a week so they had no right to bitch at me like that.

my my have the interviews dried up since I stated honestly on the applications, but such is life.

TwuntyFriend · 11/02/2022 11:28

You've been an unnecessary hard time OP. I fully agree that you've done everything you can, and she's taking the biscuit a little bit.

For what it's worth, I work FT, have a DS 7 and pay for a childminder around school hours. Before he was at school he went to the CM full time so I could work. UC credit pay up to 85% of childcare costs, and on UC the more you earn the better off you are. There are too many excuses being made on here as to why she can't pay for additional childcare - there are options out there and it's entirely financially doable, she just doesn't want to.

ByMyName · 11/02/2022 11:14

@VelvetChairGirl

When we found out that childcare was an issue, we offered to reduce her contract hours. We gave her the option to work part-time for when she has childcare in place. It does not work out at 30 hours as she needs time to drop off / pick up. We offered to revise her contract and offered her pro-rata hours and pay. She REFUSED!

The scheme representative will be speaking with her today anyway.

OP posts:
JuergenSchwarzwald · 11/02/2022 11:03

I could not expect that anyone would think it’s appropriate to have 2 young children around while they are meant to be working

but you said she uses the 30 free hours? So she can only be trying to work with kids around for an hour or so a day. I wouldn't have thought that was a huge issue if she works well the rest of the time. However, it doesn't sound like she does.

Sick leave she probably can't help.

Poor work she can.

What I would say OP is please don't write off the scheme. The next person you take could be really good.

Pudmyboy · 11/02/2022 10:54

@DePfeffoff

If she's 'using her free 30 hours', does that mean you have 30 hours of her time no problem, because the kids are in free child care?

Well, no, RTF OP. Despite having 30 hours a week available, she's constantly late and unavailable during working hours, has taken many sick days, and such work as she does is poor despite training, coaching and informal talks to help her improve. So OP still has several problems.

Some of the responses on this thread are ridiculous. Most single parents in this employee's position would be working their socks off to prove themselves even if they can't find child care, but this one just isn't. But the hard-of-thinking around here have decided that 'single mother' must mean put-upon saint and OP must be a Victorian villain, and/or are simply indulging in the usual nasty unthinking MN pile-on.

^This. Sounds like you have tried, and are willing to take on board some suggestions for the future. Good luck!
VelvetChairGirl · 11/02/2022 10:35

[quote ByMyName]@VelvetChairGirl there are a lot of posts and I don't expect you to have read everything. However, it is incredibly naive to think that we made a profit from employing someone who is unskilled.

The £1,500 grant did not ever cover the total cost of equipment and initial training when we onboard a new employee. Yes, her salary was subsidised but we topped up her salary and hours. She is no different than another staff member.

No, as an employer we do not discriminate against parents. We do not ask if someone has children as this would be discrimination. However, it is up to an employee to sort out their own childcare.

So, no the scheme was not a great success for this employee.[/quote]
" 100% of the National Minimum Wage (or the National Living Wage depending on the age of the participant) for 25 hours per week for a total of 6 months
associated employer National Insurance contributions
minimum automatic enrolment pension contributions

you have a fully covered worker for 25 hours a week whom has presumably the full 30 hours a week of child care they can get altho how many hours you do get depends on area and how in demand those places are, it is your decission to treat her like every other employee and increase her hours and pay her extra, clearly that wasnt a good move because she is on a training scheme she is not like any other employee she is learning and her UC will be reduced for extra money she gets over a certain amount, as far as the JCP is concerned if they are giving her 30 hours of free childcare that covers her hours on the scheme which are25, the rest is your discussion and thus your problem.

MinnieGirl · 11/02/2022 10:03

I think you’ve bent over backwards to try and accommodate this woman, but she just doesn’t want to be helped!
She told you her mum and her partner would be available for childcare, and that doesn’t seem to be happening.
She’s refused to work just 30 hours, refused to work when the children are in bed….
Most people with young children would jump at those offers and the flexibility.
I think you are getting a hard time here, when the reality is you have been very accommodating.

I would talk to her formally as soon as possible. Make it very clear that her lack of childcare provision is not acceptable and you have offered flexibility. If she still refuses I would give her notice and let her go. She does need to know that her actions have consequences

ByMyName · 11/02/2022 09:55

@KnobJockey

Well, to be honest- she's probably aware tht she is not being kept on after 6 months, and so far she has received 100% of a full time wage, with no deduction for hours she's not working productively following company rules, and not forced to make them up later, and only using her free hours of childcare. As much as it's bad for your business, in her position why would she bother now? Im not saying she's right by any stretch, just- why would she?
100% - I agree. We also messed up as a business by not going down the disciplinary route earlier. And by the time it was properly picked up - there were only 2 months left on her contract.

However, we would 100% have kept her on if it was not for these issues.

We have another person who started on the same scheme. We have identified areas where he needs to be trained to get to the level that we need him to be. His line manager will be discussing this with him at his appraisal. Assuming he is happy to go for the training that the business is paying for anyway, we are keeping him on and putting him on a permanent contract.

OP posts:
VelvetChairGirl · 11/02/2022 09:49

@N00tN00t

I don't understand why she would be forced into this by UC if her children are nursery age. Have they changed the rules? I'm sure it used to be that these rules kicked in once your youngest is in school.
Because its works from home, so the advisor would have been like "you can do that without having to worry about childcare"
KnobJockey · 11/02/2022 09:32

Well, to be honest- she's probably aware tht she is not being kept on after 6 months, and so far she has received 100% of a full time wage, with no deduction for hours she's not working productively following company rules, and not forced to make them up later, and only using her free hours of childcare. As much as it's bad for your business, in her position why would she bother now? Im not saying she's right by any stretch, just- why would she?

ByMyName · 11/02/2022 09:23

@VelvetChairGirl there are a lot of posts and I don't expect you to have read everything. However, it is incredibly naive to think that we made a profit from employing someone who is unskilled.

The £1,500 grant did not ever cover the total cost of equipment and initial training when we onboard a new employee. Yes, her salary was subsidised but we topped up her salary and hours. She is no different than another staff member.

No, as an employer we do not discriminate against parents. We do not ask if someone has children as this would be discrimination. However, it is up to an employee to sort out their own childcare.

So, no the scheme was not a great success for this employee.

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 11/02/2022 09:17

@notthemum

In all honesty I haven't read tft. However, gist of it is. You do NOT have to provide a reference if you do not want to. You are not legally allowed to provide a bad reference. So your best bet is just to say X worked here between x date and x date on a government scheme. Fixed term contract
You are legally allowed to provide a bad reference as long it is entirely factual and the facts are proveable.
VelvetChairGirl · 11/02/2022 09:02

[quote RitaJosephina]@ByMyName and let me guess, as it's a government scheme she only gets paid minimum wage and you expect her to be able to afford the childcare...[/quote]
The last time I was on a Job Centre Scheme (under Blair) all I got was was my standard JSA and and an extra £10 a week to cover bus fares and lunch (it didnt cover those things it only just covered the bus).

notthemum · 11/02/2022 08:59

In all honesty I haven't read tft.
However, gist of it is.
You do NOT have to provide a reference if you do not want to.

You are not legally allowed to provide a bad reference.
So your best bet is just to say
X worked here between x date and x date on a government scheme. Fixed term contract

SamphiretheStickerist · 11/02/2022 08:39

Did you think about reading all of OPs posts @VelvetChairGirl? There's a little blue link See All at the bottom of any of them, handy to see what has been elucidated in the 130+ posts since the initial one.

VelvetChairGirl · 11/02/2022 08:36

@ByMyName

I own a small business and we provide employment to a small team.

Last year we took on a junior member of staff through a government backed scheme. The scheme reimbursed the business the cost of employing someone who was on UC and at risk of long term unemployment. In turn we provided training and work experience. Win-win.

This particular employee is on a fixed term contract. If it was not a government backed scheme, we would not have kept her for a week.

She was working from home as most of our staff do since covid. She had no childcare provision and her children would scream during staff meeting. She is constantly late and unavailable during working hours. She also had many sick days. Her work is poor and she has shown no improvement despite training and coaching.

Her line manager has had several informal conversations with her. I asked not to push to a formal warning as it was a fixed term contract anyway.

Can I inform the employee that we will not provide her with a reference?

So you took advantage of a free employee from the kickstarter scheme plus took £1500 of tax payers money and you are not even going to give her anything to help her get a job.

I notice you didnt say she didnt work just that she struggled with juggling it with kids and that unfortunately training etc didnt help her, did you not think before enrolling in the scheme that there are reasons why a lot of people are out of work and its no fault of their own and not for want of trying many claimants are parents, many have health/mental issues, are struggling with stress etc.

gift horse and mouth springs to mind you took advantage of having a staff mamber you didnt have to pay for 6 months, the least you can do is give her a reference.

Swipe left for the next trending thread