Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hypnobirthing thoughts

68 replies

Happyfeet45 · 07/02/2022 21:22

Sorry if this isn't in the right place.

I wondered if anyone has any experience with hypnobirthing? I am due in the next few weeks and have been reading up on this throughout my pregnancy. The breathing techniques and scientific parts make a lot of sense to me. The positive mantras and visualisations....not so much.

Has anyone tried it and did it genuinely help you in labour?

The idea of creating a safe, spa-like environment to give birth does sound nice but is it really going to help?

Would love to hear other peoples experiences of what worked and what was clap trap!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RedRobyn2021 · 26/03/2022 10:36

It helped me undoubtedly.

I have heard some women be quite negative about it because they didn't have the whole Homebirth with no drugs birth etc but that's not the point of it, it's about a state of mind but also educating yourself so you can make informed decisions. After your child's birth ideally you want to look back and think if it as a good experience.

Have you heard of birth-ed? They have a phenomenal course, online or in person if you are in south London

They also have a Instagram page you can follow if you do insta. Lucyflow is brilliant too she has some free online yoga classes.

I hadn't heard of them with my first, I did the course with the positive birthing company. It did help me. But there were lots of factors which helped me.

fromcitytocountry · 26/03/2022 09:54

For my first pregnancy I'd used hypnobirthing books and did an online course.
I also read a fantastic book by Milli Hill about positive birth, which explores every possibility and your rights and choices.

What I took from this was an understanding of what was happening to my body and being able to recognise each stage. I also used the positive affirmations over and over to keep my mind focused.

Did I do it all to the letter? No. Was my labour extensively long? Yes. But I used those same mantras and breathing techniques for my internal examinations, injections and other things that I didn't like, as well as my labour and in each situation it really helped.

No hypnobirthing isn't some magical wonder but it can really help give some control in situations when you could easily go into an anxious to panicked state.

I'm using the same approach with this pregnancy, whatever my birth my end up like.

GrendelsGrandma · 26/03/2022 09:47

It helps to manage fear. Not sure it helps with actual labour.

It wouldn't have helped with my first labour which had a long period with contractions that ran into each other. My second labour it helped until transition.

I think it can help with labours that aren't textbook 'natural', if you can stay calm and feel engaged with decisions etc then it helps.

AgathaTrunchbull1 · 26/03/2022 09:37

The problem with something like hypnobirthing is those who have a good birth will attribute it to the hypnobirthing. See also those who had a bad first birth - did hypnobirthing - great second birth such as @MoreHairyThanScary Whereas in reality all births are different. My SIL never did any kind of hypnobirthing - 1st birth prolonged and awful, 2nd birth wonderful calm and easy, 3rd birth emergency and stressful.

AtLeastThreeDrinks · 26/03/2022 09:33

I did the PBC course and even just learning the science of labour helped! Made my partner watch with me who was fab at reminding me to breathe during contractions.

Ended up with an EMCS but a good hypnobirthing course doesn’t strive for intervention-free, it helps you to cope with whatever happens on the day. That said, dim lights, spa music and a lot of gas and air made for a lovely environment for me! All the drs etc who ended up coming in also commented on how nice it was in there Grin

So I would recommend! It can’t hurt, and like PP I still use the breathing techniques for pain management now.

ElysianTaraHughes · 26/03/2022 09:20

I think any Hypnobirthing course that is worth its salt, includes births that involve scenarios that do occur, induction, forceps and venteuse deliveries, unplanned and planned Caesaerians. This is when the technique s you ve learned are most helpful, where remaining calm, allowing you to make informed decisions. Just because your birth is not moonbeams and rainbows, does not mean Hypnobirthing has failed, If you have pain relief, or an instrumental delivery, YOU have not failed. As long YOU feel that it was the best birth for you, that could be a Gentle Caesaerian! I cannot believe people were not invited to postnatal meet ups , its appalling!! I had 2 Hypnobirths, 1 great just with gas and air, 2 nd used it for Venteuse delivery, x

ISeeTheLight · 08/02/2022 09:30

Hole - home

ISeeTheLight · 08/02/2022 09:29

Not hypnobirthing as in a cd with visualisation techniques etc, but I did pregnancy yoga and they focused a lot on breathing techniques and positions. It was a HUGE help. I had a very fast labour and got sent hole from the hospital initially as I was only 2cm (only to turn back up less than 3 hrs later, fully dialated). Had non stop contractions and DD was back to back. In short it was pretty intense.
As I wasn't in hospital I had zero pain relief available (I'm allergic to paracetamol) apart from a heat bag and the yoga breathing techniques. I genuinely think the breathing techniques were the only reason I stayed calm and could cope with the pain.
That said I was pretty pragmatic, I had read up on c sections etc, my birth plan included that I was open to an epuridal etc. So don't go in expecting zero pain and that all will be serene.

EezyOozy · 08/02/2022 09:28

Birthday = birth

EezyOozy · 08/02/2022 09:28

It helped me stay calm and at home for as long as possible when I was in labour with my second.

It didn't help at all with the actual birth because I had acute placental abruption / bradycardia and needed a category 1 C/section under GA and a lot of blood and fluids.

It will not determine the sort of birthday you have but it might to help keep you calm if you can breathe throughout your contractions, as well as understanding what is happening physically and avoiding a panic response (which can hinder oxytocin).

Stompythedinosaur · 08/02/2022 09:21

I found it helped me with my anxiety in the run up, but in reality, during my traumatic and lengthy labour and mid birth emergency hospital transfer, I found it of limited use.

MoonCowbag · 08/02/2022 09:10

I couldn't get on with gas and air at all, so I am very glad I had that TENS machine!!

ToykotoLosAngeles · 08/02/2022 07:33

@MoonCowbag

I hypnobirthed my way through both labours. I found it incredibly helpful.

First labour was a drip induction, second was a straightforward water birth with no intervention. I also used a TENS machine for both. The technique was immensely useful both times.

Oh yes, good point. I used a TENS alongside the deep breathing, which was brilliant, then moved to gas and air at the end. Mine was rented from eBay.
birdglasspen · 08/02/2022 07:08

It helped me, mainly the breathing and one of the recordings on repeat, the kind telling you how strong a woman you are etc. It might be hard to listen to now but during childbirth you need someone telling you how great you are!! This was a consultant led birth with two midwifes always present and monitored all the time so relaxing it wasn’t however the recording and breathing with gas and air was all I needed to keep calm and keep going till baby arrived!

MoonCowbag · 08/02/2022 07:07

I hypnobirthed my way through both labours. I found it incredibly helpful.

First labour was a drip induction, second was a straightforward water birth with no intervention. I also used a TENS machine for both. The technique was immensely useful both times.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 08/02/2022 07:06

I just did a few sessions on Spotify, but I found it helped quite a lot by giving me some breathing techniques to concentrate on. It won't help you with any medical interventions in my view (I still needed an episiotomy) but I was calmer than I would have otherwise been during a precipitate labour.

EishetChayil · 08/02/2022 07:01

The breathing techniques are great. Not a fan of twee language like "surges" though. There's a medical term for them - contractions.

89redballoons · 08/02/2022 06:59

I had private hybnobirthing sessions with DS1 and in the end I didn't find them very helpful.

One of the exercises I did involved visualising how the whole birth would go - so I imagined bouncing on a ball, watching funny films to get the oxytocin going, then getting into hospital and using the tens machine and aromatherapy and the pool and finding a comfy position to gently breathe DS out etc. Well in the end labour only took 4 hours from start to finish so I didn't have time for most of what I had planned/visualised. DS got stuck during the second phase with his heart rate dropping, so midwife had to coach my pushing during an exam on my back, and if DS hadn't been born on the push he was, they were going to call the duty obstetrician. I don't know how any amount of visualisation could have changed that.

Also (possibly because my labour was so fast) it seriously bloody hurt. It hurt MUCH more than I was expecting from hypnobirthing! I have pretty high pain tolerance and have definitely kept myself calm by breathing or meditating through pain before. With childbirth I really found that stuff didn't touch the sides. I honestly didn't feel like I ever got a break between contractions, didn't feel a noticeable "transition" after which I got more of an urge to push, it was just 4 hours of intense pain.

I felt kind of guilty afterwards that it hadn't really "worked", which was a bit ridiculous - as in fact, I had handled the pain, DS was fine, and I was just left with a 2nd degree tear which also healed up no problem. But that was how the hypnobirthing left me.

I should say I've had hypnotherapy before, for driving test nerves and weight loss, and similar techniques worked really well for both of those. I think the difference is that lots of elements of my birth were surprising or outside my control anyway.

I'm 32 weeks pregnant again now and while I have revised some of the breathing and visualisation techniques I learned last time, that's as far as I'm going!

sarahc336 · 08/02/2022 06:39

I found the science part helpful, about staying relaxed and not to be scared of labour. Worked both times for me, only needed gas and air and had two water births. I think it's really good xx

Mylittlepixie · 08/02/2022 05:55

Oh and we had a meet up afterwards to share out birth experiences. I told them about mine and was told i probably didnt breathe right.
That made me feel pretty bad afterwards.

annlee3817 · 08/02/2022 05:55

I used the Maggie howell Natal hypnotherapy CD

annlee3817 · 08/02/2022 05:54

It helped me, the focus on my breathing kept me calm, I remember trying gas and air but it changed my breathing rhythm, which I didn't like so carried on without. I didn't visualise, or have mantras, I just focussed on the thought that each contraction bought me closer to meeting DD. It was a positive experience, despite the pain

Mylittlepixie · 08/02/2022 05:52

I took a course and read books for my first birth. In the end nothing went according to plan and the breathing techniques didnt help me at all. That birth was nothing like the romantic picture the classes built up in my head.
My second birth was different. Everything went smoothly and was over after a couple hours. I used all my knowledge from the hypnobirthing course and i felt really good during the entire birth.
I do think it would have still been a smooth experience without the hypnobirthing though. In the end every birth is different and i guess its down to luck whether it all goes smoothly or not. However, it definitely wont hurt to try it. Just dont ve disappointed if it doesnt go according to plan.

labyrinthlaziness · 08/02/2022 05:43

@eeek88

It was bullshit and made me angry. The implication that if you don’t fully sign up to hypnobirthing, you’ll end up with an induction and EMCS and it would be your fault for not having the correct mindset, made me angry on behalf of every woman in history who would have loved to breathe through it but died because of lack of medical care.

The following worked for me: an epidural, gas and air, and reading a very very funny book. Nothing went to plan and I ended up with EMCS but tbh it was fine, not a horrible experience - the strongest negative emotion was loneliness because it was mid-pandemic so I did most of it alone.

In summary, if you did hb and it worked and you didn’t require any medical intervention good for you, you didn’t need it but well done for not being in the 20% of women who would have died if they’d given birth 100 years ago. If you are in that 20% (like me) then hb cannot save you. Just follow medical advice and be glad it’s 2022.

I'm sorry you had a bad experience Flowers

HB is not for situations like yours, of course not. But that doesn't mean it isn't useful for situations without complications.

At no point was I encouraged to ignore medical advice during birth.

eeek88 · 08/02/2022 00:16

@NotTheMrMenAgain

I was worried about giving birth, so paid for a private hypnobirthing course. Ex-DH and I attended all of the sessions, I did all of the homework, read the book repeatedly, listened to the CD every day, practised my visualisations etc. I even turned up to the maternity ward with lavender oil and arnica gel, like an utter muppet. Half a house brick in a sock would have been more effective - at least ex-DH could have hit me on the head with it to knock me out for a bit! I did okay for the first 24 hours or so, but for the last 24 I was delirious with pain and exhaustion, so nothing apart from serious drugs was ever going to help. You can't repeat affirmations and visualise 'breathing the baby out' when you're so delirious you have no idea where you are or what you're doing there. Ultimately, there was never going to be a fabulous, peaceful, stress free hypnobirthing PR type of birth for me - if not for medical intervention DC and I would both have died. As previous posts have said, hypnobirthing for me just added an extra dimension of unrealistic hopes, disappointment, guilt and self-recrimination. The tone of the course, and the content of the book, was that when the techniques failed it was because the woman hadn't tried hard enough/wanted it badly enough/believed in it enough. It's a great marketing ploy, because when it doesn't work it's the customers fault for proving inadequate! It was 14 years ago, but I vividly remember a case study in the book about a woman who attended a course but then went on to have a highly medicalised delivery - it actually said that the woman secretly must have wanted that sort of birth because she enjoyed the fuss, drama and attention, so she'd subconsciously sabotaged her own efforts to successfully hypnobirth. Utter bollocks, if you ask me.
Yup this makes me incensed with rage. How dare you tell me I’ve essentially failed at birth because I didn’t try hard enough? Birth’s a lottery, get through it whichever way you can. Personally I found that going into it with very low expectations worked well because in the end I was pleasantly surprised.